WWE: 10 Biggest Missed Opportunities With CM Punk

Cm Punk Shock waves have been sent throughout the wrestling world this week as CM Punk, one of the biggest stars in wrestling today, allegedly quit the WWE. Speculation is still hazy but his name has been removed from house show advertising and he has sent out a cryptic tweet thanking his fans for their support. Rumours are running rampant that Punk told management that he was "going home" and that he simply picked up sticks and left. Nothing has yet been confirmed but if the reports are to be believed, CM Punk is done with the WWE and we may never see him wrestle again. Punk has been unanimously over with the fans ever since his infamous "pipe bomb" promo way back in 2011, and whilst he has had a tremendous run since then, namely a record 434-day reign as the WWE Champion, they never really used Punk to his full potential. Taking that into consideration, we have compiled the 10 Biggest Missed Opportunities With CM Punk and WWE, this includes past booking mistakes as well as things we may never get to see. Hit "Next" to continue.

10. Capitalizing On A Potential Pepsi Partnership

CM Punk is essentially a walking free advertisement for Pepsi, his Globe tattoo is one of his most notable and he's expressed openly that he's a keen drinker of the beverage. So why did WWE never use this to their advantage? Randy Savage's Slim Jim campaign is the stuff of legend and gained WWE massive exposure in the 80s, why didn't they use Punk as a mascot for Pepsi? It could have helped WWE gain more crossover popularity into the mainstream and could have made Punk a bigger star and a box office draw. WWE have always had a good working relationship with the conglomerate and have entered sponsorship deals with them in the past, it seems silly to not get Punk to at least do a commercial campaign. I hate to say the phrase but that is something that was best for business.

9. A Meaningful Feud With Daniel Bryan

Punk and Bryan have some real history going back to their ROH days. They're both from the same generation and worked their way up through the indy circuit in tandem, at one point they were simultaneously holding both of WWE's world championships, but the trigger was never properly pulled. Bryan and Punk's feud could have been handled so much more effectively, Bryan's talent at this point wasn't being correctly utilized and he was nothing more than a cowardly heel who Punk easily disposed of. Why wasn't it turned into an epic tale of their past? A story of two indy guys who weren't supposed to make it but did writes itself. With Bryan peaking in popularity recently and becoming one of the four top guys in the company, they should have struck while the iron was hot and got Punk in the mix, they tagged together briefly but the fans were begging for a match between the two. It may be catering to the internet fans, but it's hard to deny that given how over both of these guys are as performers at this level, they would put on an epic. The future now looks pretty bleak for that dream match.

8. Winning The Extreme Elimination Chamber

Eliminationchamber Commonly cited as one of the first major mistakes that WWE made with CM Punk, his showing in the Extreme Elimination Chamber match at the new ECW December to Dismember pay-per-view was Vince's way of telling him that he was the boss. Going into the match, Big Show was the ECW Champion and Paul Heyman's plan was to have Punk quickly eliminate Show with the Anaconda vise and then go on to win the title. It was a great idea, Punk was the most over guy in ECW and the people wanted to see him get a world title push. Vince saw things differently. After Punk went backstage and complained to Vince about the choice to have Bobby Lashley win the match, despite being on the WWE roster, Vince punished him by having him be the first one eliminated in the match. The fans reacted negatively and Punk's momentum was killed for a while after that. December to Dismember would go on to have the lowest buy rate in WWE history and is considered to be one of the worst wrestling pay-per-views of all time, Punk winning wouldn't have helped the buys, but it would have certainly helped lessen the critical backlash.

7. A Feud With Colt Cobana

colt cabana Why Colt Cabana still doesn't have a WWE contract will forever be a mystery to fans. He's a household name on the indy circuit and him and Punk helped make ROH what it is today. Their matches are legendary, through hundreds of bouts together they know each other inside and out, they have perfect chemistry in the ring and some of Punk's best matches are the ones he had with his best friend. WWE should have made a more conscious effort to bring Colt in, he's never had any reservations with working for them, he happily provided interviews with them for Punk's DVD and it's well-documented that they are on speaking terms with each other. Perhaps the formula just never quite clicked, WWE may have just not seen an opportunity to hire Colt, but working the relationship between he and Punk into a storyline isn't hard and Colt has the charisma and look to get over with the fans. But now it seems totally unlikely to ever happen.

6. Letting Him Drop Pipe Bombs From Day One

It wasn't until Punk's tremendous heel run in 2008 and his story with the Straight Edge Society from 2009-2011 when we saw how impeccable he was on the microphone. His worked shoot in the Summer of 2011 only solidified his status as the company's top mic guy, but why didn't they do this from the very beginning? Everyone knew that Punk's strongest asset was his way with words, just watch some old ROH promos and you'll see what I mean, the man knew how to elicit a response from the crowd just from opening his mouth at a very young age. For two whole years Punk's only identity in the company was that he was straight edge, that was literally all he had going for him, why wasn't he established straight away as a master promo cutter and a thorn in the side of authority? He didn't suddenly just get good on the mic, his most vital asset was ignored for far too long. Had they gotten his vocational skills over as soon as he debuted on the ECW brand, he could potentially have been an even bigger star than the one he became.

5. Winning The Royal Rumble

Royal Rumble A Royal Rumble win is a very nice feather for a wrestler's cap, looking through the list of Rumble winners we see many all-time greats occupying it, Austin, Hart, Michaels, Hogan, Taker etc. So why has Punk, one of the biggest guys in the company, never won the match? Some may argue that the timing wasn't right, I say that the 2011 Rumble was the perfect opportunity, instead they went with Alberto Del Rio who is nowhere near the level that Punk ascended to. A Rumble win isn't essential for a star's credibility, but it's certainly one for the record books. Punk's accolades seem somewhat incomplete without it, Cena's won two, Batista's won two and Orton won in 2009, Punk has reached their level of star power so what gives? Punk will go down in history and is a guaranteed Hall of Famer nonetheless, but his lack of a Rumble win will always be noticeable as this year's Rumble seemed like his last realistic chance.

4. Headlining WrestleMania

Undertaker Vs Cm Punk Being in the final match at the biggest wrestling pay-per-view in history is something special, it's a moment that every wrestler dreams of but that very few can attain. It's something that Punk's peers at the top level have all done, Cena, Orton, Batista, Triple H, it's something that will beef up your career immeasurably. So why has Punk never gotten the same treatment? If it's to do with his box office appeal then how come people like Benoit, Michaels and Hart have done it? Unless my facts are wrong they are among the lowest-drawing world champions in history. There was speculation that the main event for WrestleMania 29 would be a triple threat match between John Cena, The Rock and CM Punk, but this never came to be. Instead there was a rematch between Rock and Cena which received a mixed response and a match between Punk and The Undertaker that was praised as one of the best matches of the year. Punk has proven that he can deliver an epic match at Mania and doesn't let the pressure of the big stage get to him. Now he might become one of the most successful superstars of all-time to never headline WrestleMania.

3. Beating John Cena Clean

John Cena vs CM Punk NOC 12 John Cena rarely loses clean, and there's nothing wrong with that, Hogan and Austin were no different when they were at their peaks, but there's a huge benefit to having an invincible superstar, you can make someone a major player by beating them clean. Punk's win at Money in the Bank 2011 was a special moment, but it's still worth noting that Punk won because Cena was distracted by Vince and Big Johnny. Fast-forward to SummerSlam that year and special guest referee Triple H missed the fact that Cena's foot was on the rope when Punk got the pin. CM Punk has never beaten John Cena clean, why not? That was the ultimate way to turn him into a megastar, if he's capable of beating John Cena fair and square then Cena fans will buy into him. I appreciate that Cena carries the company but this could have put Punk right up there with him permanently, they could have been the Austin and Rock of their time, with one guy firmly on top but another not far behind at all. Cena losing cleanly is a rare occurrence that is reserved for superstars who are going places, which Punk clearly was, WWE really should have gone all the way with it.

2. The Summer Of Punk

CM-Punk-Best As fondly as we like to remember it, let's face facts, "The Summer of Punk", as it's become known was a flop. Sure, it got Punk over for the rest of his career and made him a big star, but it could have done so much more for his character. Let's start with the first thing they did wrong, after kayfabe leaving the company, Punk returned to WWE television a week later to confront John Cena. Why? He should have been gone for at least a month or two, making his return feel more special. Then the WWE committed a cardinal sin by having Punk lose to Triple H at Night of Champions 2011, killing all of his momentum and ultimately focusing the spotlight on Triple H and Kevin Nash, a storyline that no one remembers or cared about at the time. This was the perfect set-up to forever cement Punk as an all-time great, all that was needed was to keep him off television for a while and to beat Triple H, just two things that were painfully obvious. Punk's 434-day title reign should have kick-started after Money in the Bank 2011, instead we had to wait for Punk to beat Alberto Del Rio at Survivor Series four months later. WWE dropped the ball on this big time.

1. A Match With Stone Cold Steve Austin

Stone Cold This is the match that has been on everyone's mind ever since Punk's hilarious confrontation with Austin on the June 13 edition of Monday Night Raw in 2011. People were clamoring for it even more after Cena vs Rock as the comparisons between Punk and Austin had been made on numerous occasions. They both had anti-authoritarian characters and a smash mouth, no-nonsense attitude. Austin has expressed his admiration for Punk as a performer and Punk has cited Austin as one of his favourites, a match between these two would have been something incredibly special and a match more than worthy of top-billing. Regardless of Punk's drawing power, Austin alone in the main event at something like, say, WrestleMania 30 would aid the event in possibly becoming the highest-grossing wrestling pay-per-view of all-time. It seems that this is one of the greatest matches that will never happen. And that was an example of ten times where WWE missed an opportunity with CM Punk, what examples can you think of? Sound off in the comments and follow us on Twitter @WhatCultureWWE and you can follow me on Twitter @TBroomey.

In this post: 
CM Punk
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling fan and film buff who consumes far too much caffeine. Currently working on a comic book and learning how to cook the perfect fried egg. Both of which are an ongoing process.