WWE: 12 Most Controversial WrestleMania Moments Ever

The biggest shocks and storms in the history of WWE's main event.

This week finally sees the biggest event on the WWE calendar, as the hottest bill of the year kicks off at WrestleMania XXX. The card is locked, promising personal battles of epic proportions for Daniel Bryan, Triple H, The Undertaker and Brock Lesnar, and a multi-entrant event in the shape of the Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal that is likely to be a talking point well beyond the end of the event. With only a couple of days to go until the doors open on Vince McMahon's crowning event, hype has built to a critical level, with fans clamouring for as much new information as possible, and any hints of what to expect. One thing that is certain is that we can all expects the typical thrills and spills that come with the main event billing, with resolutions (or at least moments of temporary vengeance) for the storylines currently dominating the company. Could there also be controversy and shocks? The history of the event would suggest there's a good possibility, and any event that has any input at all from Vince McMahon is invariably going to come with the potential for wide open eyes and jaws. The following notorious incidents are the most divisive, shocking and debate-starting moments in the history of the main event: from infamous heel turns to unwarranted victories, with expectations high that this year's event promises more entries when it kicks off on Sunday night...

12. Rey Mysterio Wins The Heavyweight Championship, Despite Not Being Heavy - WrestleMania 22

Surely something as simple as defining weight classes should be heeded at a big event as illustrious as WrestleMania? Well, not at WrestleMania 22, which ended with the WWE Cruiserweight Champion being heavier than the Heavyweight Champion. Despite the fact that the Triple Threat Heavyweight match was hugely entertaining, there were only ever two men considered possible victors, and neither of them was called Rey Mysterio. The comparatively diminutive high-flyer was expected to merely take up space in the ring opposite Randy Orton and Kurt Angle - the latter of who had the best of the match until the end - but he shrugged off a surprisingly heated audience reaction (with about half of the audience roundly booing him) to emerge victorious. At the time the result felt like no more than a continuation of the sentimentalism that had been creeping into creative decisions, giving an unthinkable underdog an unsuspected victory, and it was hard to take the result as the fitting end to cumulative storylines, not to mention the fact that it has been suggested that Mysterio's victory devalued the belt entirely. In hindsight, the victory feels like it was no more than the opportunity to set up two ridiculous matches between Mysterio and Mark Henry first and then the Great Kahli as part of his feud with JBL. As the final indication of what the WWE really felt about the event, Mysterio's celebration was basically rushed to get to the Pillow Fight that came next on the bill.

11. Hogan Lifts Andre The Heel- WrestleMania III

It might not be controversial in terms of some of the wilder and darker things that have happened in the history of wrestling, but the historic victory of Hulk Hogan over Andre The Giant qualifies for this list simply on the strength of the pop it received around the world, and for what it represented to Andre's career. With Andre heading into the match undefeated, having just turned heel for the first time in his career, the stage was set for an almighty face-off between himself and the supremely babyfaced Hogan, and the match delivered more than anyone could ever have hoped. In a match that will forever be considered one of the most significant moments in the history of the WWE main event, the two big men traded massive blows, before Hogan eventually put the bigger man down. That was impressive enough, but the next step was unthinkable; the Hulkster picking Andre's prone body up and slamming him down, to leave jaws flapping around the ring, and leg dropping his way to victory and Andre's first defeat. The controversial elements continue in the match's reception: Meltzer scored it a negative four, and it was named the "Worst Worked Match of the Year." Indeed, the response to the match, and its historical importance ignores the fact that the match between Ricky Steamboat and Randy Savage on the same bill was a far superior spectacle.

10. Sheamus Beats Daniel Bryan In Less Time Than It Takes To Sculpt His Hair - WrestleMania XXVIII

In one of WW's most notoriously baffling decisions to date, the company decided to turn what should have been an auspicious event between Sheamus and fan favourite Daniel Bryan into a ridiculous spectacle for entirely the wrong reasons. The event should be reserved for only the best matches, but WrestleManis XXVIII - which was scheduled to last four hours - started with the ludicrously short bout between the two that probably took significantly less time than it took either of the wrestlers to groom themselves before making their entrances. In what fans could probably only assume was a morality tale about the dangers of taking your eyes off the prize (and sexual promiscuity,) Bryan received a good luck kiss from "girlfriend" AJ before being immediately surprised by a brogue kick from Sheamus, that knocked him flat and allowed the Irishman the quickest ever victory in WWE history. The company ignored the need for a stage-setter, and the fact that fans had paid considerable sums to get access to the PPV, and wanted to see an end to Sheamus' unreasonable status as basically a superhero.

9. Tyson Floors Michaels - WrestleMania XIV

Following the grand tradition of introducing celebrity guests at the main event, pugilist and notorious ear-biter Mike Tyson was lined up as the ring enforcer, after initially being announced as the guest referee. Some handbags with Stone Cold Steve Austin put paid to that, before Shawn Michaels also offered the former boxing champion out for a fight in a promo that ended with Tyson revealing his allegiance with DX. The match itself was entertaining but unspectacular, but the ending added a controversial full-stop that still gets talked about as one of the most entertaining deception turns in main event history. With Austin seemingly about to be defeated, he caught an attempted Sweet Chin Music that he turned brilliantly into a Stunner, and dropped Michaels to the mat, though probably not for long enough to get a legitimate three count. But legitimate wasn't the order of the day as Tyson turned on his DX allies and delivered a super fast three count in place of unconscious ref Mike Chioda. Austin was crowned and Michaels furiously remonstrated with Tyson over his deception, only to be met with a punch that neither he nor the crowd expected and which completely laid him out.

8. Lesnar Suffers A Concussion - WrestleMania XIX

In the main event match between hulking Brock Lesnar and Kurt Angle, the defending champ, Angle was saddled with a stipulation that would see him stripped of his title if counted out or disqualified, but with Lesnar basically guaranteed the victory, he almost lost his chance on his own ridiculous terms. There's a reason monsters don't tend to do too much aerial work - Undertaker famously found out that even a ring dive can almost end up with a broken neck and a broken cameraman - and at XIX, Lesnar reiterated just why that was the case. Perched on the top rope, Lesnar set himself up to do something truly astonishing - attempting a shooting star press - which would surely have caused considerable damage to Angle's attempted defence. Unfortunately, Lesnar messed up the landing, and took the force of gravity pretty much entirely on his head, suffering a concussion that somehow didn't stop him completing - and winning - the match. Hopefully Lesnar will have ironed out the errors in his work by now, making him, ideally, a better opponent than who Undertaker faced way back at WrestleMania 9...

7. 'Taker Is Almost Beaten By An Entirely Unworthy Opponent - Wrestlemania IX

The WrestleMania IX match between 'Taker and the former Argentinian basketball player is not only the ugliest of all of the Dead Man's streak victories, it also has to be considered one of the most underwhelming matches in the history of the main event. In April 1993, 'Taker faced off against monster Giant Gonzalez at Caesar's Palace, and suffered a genuine threat of defeat thanks to his opponent's ridiculous hulking size. The fight wasn't pretty at all, with Gonzalez too large to be really mobile, though that didn't stop the creative angle being that he was to out-muscle 'Taker, despite not being able to carry off even the simplest of moves. 'Taker struggled to pull a good match out of his opponent, and it ended in ridiculous fashion with Gonzalez resorting to chloroform, before 'Taker's inevitably revival, and the giant's disqualification. Considering the manner of the rest of 'Taker's victories, and the prestige of the streak, this blemish looks more and more like a gigantic misstep as each year passes.

6. Yokozuna Steals The Win, And Then Hulk Does - WrestleMania IX

After winning the 1993 Royal Rumble, Yokozuna earned his shot at the WWF Championship against Bret The Hitman Hart, who had taken the belt from Ric Flair, at the main event, and it almost ended very badly for the giant sumo. Taking advantage of Yokozuna's traditional pre-match ritual, Hart landed an early kick, but saw his efforts to grab the big man result in him being knocked out of the league. Over the course of the fight, the pair went back and forth, including the Hitman trapping his sizeable opponent in the ropes to even the weight advantage out by taking away any mobility, but it looked like Yokozuna was heading to victory a couple of times, and particularly when he laid out Hart with a massive leg drop. That didn't end the match however, and the big man missed a splash in the corner, letting Hart regain the upper hand, dropping his opponent and locking him into the sharpshooter, which should have ensured victory. But then, controversially, Yokozuna's manager Mr. Fuji, threw a handful of salt into Bret's eyes, blinding him and incapacitating him enough to allow his opponent to gain the pin, and win the WWF Championship, to fans' amazement. That isn't where it ended however, as moments later Hulk Hogan appeared to tell the referee about Fuji's misdemeanour, which fell on deaf ears. For some reason, rather than simply accepting his client's victory, Fuji issued a challenge that Yokozuna would put his newly-won title if Hogan would accept a fight; Hart gave his blessing, and Hulk went after the belt. He got in trouble immediately as Yokozuna held him and looked to set up Fuji to blind him again with salt, but Hogan ducked and Yokozuna took the salt in his face in a not unexpected twist of fate, allowing Hulk to clothesline him and finish off with a leg drop and a cover, ending the match in just 30 seconds. Hart and Hogan would subsequently develop a rivalry away from the ring as the former felt the new champion was dodging him and had refused to drop the belt to him, even though a deal existed that Hogan would drop it to the top heel at the time.

5. Floyd Mayweather Fights Dirty - WrestleMania XXIV

When the WWE set up the fight between Big Show and boxing champion Floyd Mayweather, few could have expected that the diminutive fighter would actually follow in the footsteps of Mike Tyson and apepar at the main event, but he duly shocked when he turned up for his fight. Mayweather had been involved in a storyline beef with Big Show after the boxer interrupted an altercation between Big Show and Rey Mysterio at No Way Out to help the little man out. As the admittedly unpopular babyface, MAyweather attacked Big Show, and unwittingly broke his nose after failing to pull a punch, and running away comically in fear. In the aftermath on Raw, Big Show challenged Mayweather to a one-on-one No Disqualification match at WrestleMania XXIV, which he accepted, and not only did the boxer shock everyone by turning up, he also unthinkably won the match by knocking his opponent out with a set of brass knuckles. Typically classy, Mayweather claims he was paid $20m for his appearance, though that has subsequently been proven as a falacy.

4. Goldberg & Brock Lesnar Sleepwalk Through Their Final Fights - WrestleMania XX

What was billed a fitting full-stop for two closing WWE careers ended up being a notorious disappointment as neither Lesnar, who was leaving to take up American football, and Goldberg who wouldn't be renewing his contract, showed anything like the commitment demanded of them. That defied early expectations, as it was deemed a potentially massive bout, given the status of both fighters, but it took almost three minutes for anything like a real lock-up, despite guest referee Steve Austin's best efforts. The crowd duly responded with heat, openly mocking the pair, jeering about selling out and shouting for both Austin and Hulk Hogan, partly in response to the stars' departures, and partly thanks to their lack of effort. It was a truly disappointing match, and a terrible end to both careers (albeit temporarily for Lesnar,) which brought controversial response from the audience.

3. Vinnie Turns On Rocky - WrestleMania 2000

In an extremely entertaining fatal four-way elimination match for the WWF Championship, that pitted Triple H, Big Show, Mick Foley and The Rock against one another, each with a member of the McMahon family in their corners. The champion, Hunter, was with Stephanie McMahon, Big Show had Shane McMahon, Foley had Linda, and The Rock was with longtime ally, Vince McMahon. All three competitors attacked Show, which lead to The Rock eliminating him, and then Foley was pinned by Hunter thanks to a Pedigree onto a steel chair, setting up a brawl between Triple H and The Rock that had no obvious advantage taken by either. The game changer came when Vince McMahon turned on his own man, hitting The Rock with a steel chair twice, turning himself heel and allowing Hunter to win, followed by some ceremonial vengeance by Rocky on the majority of the McMahon clan, though the damage had, controversially, already been done.

2. Stone Cold Turns Heel At Home - WrestleMania X-7

Given that WrestleMania X-7 was hosted in Texas, it was already likely that Stone Cold Steve Austin was going to play a major part, but the revelation wasn't quite what fans might have expected. Austin took on The Rock for the WWF Championship in one of the most enduring rivalry in industry history, the pair putting on an entertaining match that ended in controversy when the Rattlesnake turned heel in his own backyard. Somewhat inevitably, Vince McMahon appeared and was attacked by The Rock, before unbelievably handing a steel chair to Austin, and building a bridge between the two fiercest rivals of the era, turning Austin heel, and hitting The Rock with 16 bruising chair shots for good measure. So what could possibly beat Austin's turn as the most controversial moment in WrestleMania history?

1. Bret Hart Goes Bad - WrestleMania 13

It could only be one moment. When WrestleMania 13 kicked off, Bret Hart was the biggest face int he company, universally loved - adored even - and on a level of stardom and popularity that few wrestlers had managed before, or have managed since. The match pitted Hart against Stone Cold Steve Austin in a submission match with Ken Shamrock as the special guest referee, who was forced to award the match to Hart after Austin passed out from blood loss. At that point, Hart remained a face, but not for long, as he refused to stop attacking Austin after the bell, incensing the crowd, and eliciting boos for Hart, and cheers for the prone Rattlesnake. Hart's was the ultimate shocking heel turn, and one that was beyond unthinkable, while it also turned Austin babyface in a brilliantly executed moment. And to do at on the biggest stage of all! Which controversial WrestleMania moments do you think deserve to be on this list? Share your picks below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.