WWE 2K25 Superstar Ratings: 10 Biggest Surprises & Snubs

Another recent release, another unfairly low rating.

2K Studios's rating for Carmella is particularly unfortunate after the now-former WWE superstar revealed the shoddy way the company handled her departure. It was a poor way to end Carmella's twelve year tenure with the company, and a baffling one when you consider her accomplishments.

Carmella will forever go down in history as the first ever winner of the Women's Money in the Bank, and her eventual cash-in on Charlotte Flair was a rare highlight in a fallow period for Smackdown. Even after her title reign ended Carmella proved to be a valuable utility player for the WWE over the years, forming a sorely under-rated comic partnership with R-Truth and acting as a worthy heel for Bianca Belair's first championship run. Heck, she even played the unenviable role of being the bait in SummerSlam 2021's famous bait-and-switch, swallowing her ego to ensure Becky Lynch's return was as F-A-B-U-L-O-U-S as possible.

Carmella accomplished a lot during her twelve-year WWE career, and hopefully her future appearances in WWE 2K - as either a legend or returning superstar - will give her a rating that accurately reflects her achievements.