WWE Backlash 2018: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best

Who booked this garbage?

WWE Backlash 2018 Nakamura AJ Styles
WWE.com

Well, that sure was a PPV alright. Though there was certainly on-paper potential for this year's Backlash to deliver a solid night of wrestling even in spite of its inevitable predictability, WWE once again settled for mostly bland, uninteresting in-ring action, alongside two matches that were legitimately rather bad.

There was only a single match on the nine-bout card that was anything beyond decent, which given the talent involved is just embarrassing. As usual, nonsensical booking is the main culprit, though a number of the show's strongest talents were clearly phoning their work in - presumably because they didn't much care for the booking either - which certainly didn't help.

Nobody was expecting Backlash to set the WWE Universe on fire, but was this lazy, low-effort filler fare really the best they could come up with? While there have certainly been worse PPVs over the years, there are few in recent memory that have seen WWE acting so aggressively against both their own interests and also basic logic...


9. WWE Smackdown Women's Title: Carmella (c) Vs. Charlotte Flair

WWE Backlash 2018 Carmella Charlotte
WWE.com

Result: Carmella kicks out Charlotte's knee and rolls her up for the win (9:00).

Rating: This was a mostly boring match derailed entirely by its atrocious ending, because in what world does it make sense to have Charlotte beat Asuka's streak, only for Charlotte to lose clean to Carmella the next month?

The rest holds made this fairly short match feel stamina-drainingly long, Carmella's trash talk was total Cringe City, and even the generally reliable Charlotte put on a totally lethargic performance (seemingly catching the same whiff of bulls*** fans did).

It'd be hilariously awful if it wasn't such a depressingly braindead way to book talent. Where is the consideration for the basic tenets of storytelling? It made no sense and practically everyone hated it. 3/10


8. Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn Vs. Braun Strowman & Bobby Lashley

WWE Backlash 2018 Strowman Lashley Zayn
WWE.com

Result: Lashley annihilates Owens with a Hanging Suplex for the win (8:40).

Rating: This match mostly stunk and served only to hint at the impending Owens-Zayn feud. It's both hilarious and embarrassing how fast Lashley has become a total non-entity since returning, and him being a bland face does him no favours at all. Also, winning a match with a suplex is never going to get the crowd on-side.

Nobody benefited from this, and it would've made far more sense to have Strowman score the win instead. Typical generic cool-down fare. 4/10


7. Bayley Vs. Ruby Riott

WWE Backlash 2018 Ruby Riott Bayley
WWE.com

Result: Riott nails the Riott Kick for the win (10:10).

Rating: The fact that Bayley's career has made it to the point where she's in the pre-show match on a Backlash PPV made this an inherently ho-hum bout. The actual match itself? Not so hot either.

Bayley came off especially rough here, even a shadow of her best self, and it was Riott who carried the match to watchability, to her absolute credit.

At least the match did something useful, in further building up Riott, and the women were given sufficient time to get things done, but like most pre-show matches, neither athlete bothered pushing things to the next level. 5/10


6. WWE Raw Women's Title: Nia Jax (c) Vs. Alexa Bliss

WWE Backlash 2018 Alexa Bliss Nia Jax
WWE.com

Result: Jax lands the Samoan Drop to retain the title (10:20).

Rating: Nia Jax's booking continues to be weird and offputting - that forced post-match anti-bullying speech sure didn't help - but at least they got the result right here, as predictable and foregone as it was.

Jax and Bliss just don't have much of a spark in the ring together, so this never rose above watchable mediocrity. There's no world where this needed to last 10 minutes, and a quasi-squash that ran half that length would've been far more effective at selling Nia as the tenacious champ.

It was a match that happened...and that's it. 5/10


5. Daniel Bryan Vs. Big Cass

WWE Backlash 2018 Daniel Bryan Cass
WWE.com

Result: Bryan makes Cass tap to the Yes Lock (7:45).

Rating: Nobody really cared about this beyond the appeal of seeing D-Bry in the ring, and to his credit, he carried the match and made Cass look not-awful, turning in one of his better PPV bouts in the process.

By any usual standard it was forgettable stuff, but they got the result right - never a sure thing with WWE - even if Cass' attempt to fight the Yes Lock was so pathetic it was almost non-existent. Oof.

The post-match beat-down from Cass made it clear the feud will probably keep going, for the benefit of basically nobody. 5/10


4. WWE United States Title: Jeff Hardy (c) Vs. Randy Orton

WWE Backlash 2018 Jeff Hardy Randy Orton
WWE.com

Result: Hardy nails the Swanton Bomb to retain the title (12:00).

Rating: This was TV-caliber fare through and through: neither bad nor especially good. Anyone who's ever called Orton "Blandy Boreton" got further justification tonight, because Randy just couldn't even pretend to sell that he was remotely interested in this contest, as is so often his problem.

Hardy's looking pretty great right now even if he had to deal with a totally unfussed Orton. The match could've easily lost a few minutes and delivered the same level of quality, but that's pretty much par the course with Orton these days. 5/10


3. Roman Reigns Vs. Samoa Joe

WWE Backlash 2018 Roman Reigns Samoa Joe
WWE.com

Result: Reigns drills Joe with the Spear for the win (18:10).

Rating: There have been many worse PPV main events than this, but how many of them had fans leaving the arena in droves before it was over, not to mention chanting "Beat the traffic"?

This match should've just been a 10-minute demolition derby with tons of outside extras, but instead it was an overlong, bloated, interminable bore, full of dull rest holds and played in front of a crowd who couldn't care much less.

Joe was trying, as he almost always does, but Roman just went through his usual motions ahead of a woefully predictable finish. This benefited nobody, really. 5/10


2. WWE Title - No DQ: AJ Styles (c) Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura

WWE Backlash 2018 Nakamura AJ Styles
WWE.com

Result: The match ends in a double countout after both men kick each other in the balls (21:05).

Rating: Well, this was certainly the best of their three WWE matches, with solid use of the stipulation even if the pair absolutely could've taken it further.

The match was still nowhere near the standard these two should be battling at, capped by a totally insulting ending that head-scratchingly contradicts the whole "no DQ" stipulation.

The booking is beyond idiotic and just blows off a concrete result for the sake of a fourth match that'll probably fail to deliver on expectations once again. Christ.

And above all else, why the hell is AJ not wearing a cup by this point? It just makes him look like a moron. 6/10


1. WWE Intercontinental Title: Seth Rollins (c) Vs. The Miz

WWE Backlash 2018 Seth Rollins The Miz
WWE.com

Result: Rollins murders Miz with the Curb Stomp to retain the strap (20:30).

Rating: Once again, WWE blew its load early with the single great match of the night opening the main show. Rollins was totally on fire throughout, while The Miz turned in one of his best singles performances ever - perhaps his best - and the crowd was red-hot for all the fantastic near-falls.

This match had everything an opener needed: excellent pacing, a high-impact back and forth - including one of the most disturbing DDTs you'll probably see all year - and the genuine belief that either man could've won. This was an absolute cracker of an opener and the rest of the PPV didn't deserve it. 8/10

What did you think of Backlash? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.