WWE Cruiserweight Champions: Ranked From Worst To Best
From Rey Mysterio to Hornswoggle and everyone in between...
Excitement is building for WWE's Cruiserweight Classic series, which begins in mid-July. WWE have scoured the globe and enlisted the services of some of the best lightweight grapplers in the world for their exciting new project, and have even brought back former stars Brian Kendrick and Tajiri.
It really looks like the start of something promising, with WWE placing importance on cruiserweight wrestling once more. In the past, WWE had their Lightheavyweight Title, which had guys like Brian 'Grandmaster Sexay' Lawler and Scott Putski fight over it and quickly became an afterthought, in the late 90s/early 2000s before the introduction of the Cruiserweight Title.
The Cruiserweight Title was a carryover from WCW, which WWE bought in March of 2001. In WCW, some of the best talent in the wrestling world fought over the belt and the division was regularly the highlight of WCW programming, at least to this writer. Who wants to watch boring, barely-mobile heavyweights when you can see Eddie Guerrero, Ultimo Dragon and Dean Malenko exchanging holds and performing state-of-the-art moves at a frenetic pace?
WCW's cruiserweight division was truly great, but just how did WWE's - which ran from November 2001 to September 2007 - measure up? Any division is defined by its champion, so just who were the men (and woman) at the front of the queue?
Here are the 16 WWE Cruiserweight Champions, ranked from worst to best.
16. Jacqueline
It was about this time - the spring of 2004 - when folks really started to clock on that WWE perhaps didn't take the cruiserweights or the Cruiserweight Title quite so seriously.
Exposing the lack of depth on the Smackdown roster at the time, WWE diva Jacqueline answered an open challenge and captured the gold from Chavo Guerrero on the May 6th episode of the show. Amazingly, she successfully defended the title against Jamie Noble and Chavito on Smackdown brand house shows over the following week.
She dropped the belt back to Guerrero ten days after she won it, at Judgement Day, in a match where Chavo's arm was tied behind his back. That turned out to be her last match for the company, as they released her a couple of weeks later. Creative didn't have anything for her, apparently.
What, you mean they didn't have any more winning ideas like this one? The short reign was pointless and rumour at the time was that it was a token gesture by management to appease a group of veterans (including Bob Holly and Billy Gunn) who felt they were being overlooked by newer, more inexperienced talent.
Worst. Cruiserweight Champion. Ever.
15. Hornswoggle
It was obvious by the summer of 2007 that nobody in the company - sans maybe one or two of the wrestlers - actually cared about the Cruiserweight Title. Gregory Helms had held the belt for a year and then dropped it to Chavo Guerrero out-of-the-blue and for no real good reason.
Then Chavo had a pretty humdrum reign with the title, only defending it once on pay-per-view (against Jimmy Wang Yang at Night of Champions). Sensing that the belt didn't mean anything any more, WWE did what was akin to a mercy killing, having Hornswoggle unexpectedly win it in a scramble match at the Great American Bash.
He then went on to have a brief feud with Jamie Noble (which included Noble having a pie thrown into his face, being blasted with a large box and finally being trapped in a large box) before the belt was retired in September. Nobody cared because the belt had been devoid of meaning for a long time and the division was stale anyway.
A sad ending for a title which once had such promise.
14. Chavo Classic
Speaking of stupid...
Chavo Guerrero Sr. - a damn fine wrestler in his day - was hired by WWE to act as the manager of his son, Chavo Jr., in early 2004. The pair were a decent act, and Chavo Sr. (now dubbed Chavo Classic) was a riot whenever he was on commentary. Sometimes WWE had Eddie's brother wrestle, which was a misstep.
In their pursuit to devalue the Cruiserweight Title, WWE then put the belt on Classic after a comedy three-way match, also involving his son and Spike Dudley, on the May 20th episode of the show. Classic won the match after he accidentally fell on his son. Amazingly, Classic held the title for a month and successfully defended it on house shows.
He lost it to Rey Mysterio on the June 17th Smackdown in a very short match and was fired at the taping because he had previosuly no-showed two live events, supposedly in protest at the way his character was being portrayed (the 55-year-old Chavo didn't want to be involved in comedic segments or storylines, apparently).
13. Nunzio
The underrated Nunzio held the Cruiserweight Title twice, but neither reign was much cop, really. His first reign began on August 5th, 2005 when he defeated Paul London for the belt on an episode of Velocity.
There's actually some interesting backstory here, as London was set for a lengthy reign until he has the gall to speak up to Vince McMahon about Vince's recent decision to ban high-flying moves like the Shooting Star Press and 450 Splash. To London, outlawing such moves took away what made the cruisers special and was adamant that Vince change his mind.
McMahon, however, was unmoved by his pleas and was actually annoyed that London would go directly to him with such a concern and challenge his decision. Hence the sudden title loss on the weekend C show. Not that Nunzio was complaining, since he was now the champion (not that it really changed his fortunes all that much).
Nunzio ended up dropping the title to Juventud Guerrera at No Mercy in October, but won it back from 'The Juice' at a Smackdown house show in Rome, Italy on November 15th. That was just a device used to pop the 'hometown' crowd, though, and The Sicilian Shooter dropped the strap once more a week later at a Smackdown taping in Sheffield, England.
Nunzio wasn't a terrible Cruiserweight Champion or anything, but he had no real standout matches and it was obvious that management didn't have much for him, with him mainly wrestling on Velocity.
12. Kid Kash
The outspoken Kid Kash joined WWE in the summer of 2005 following the original ECW One Night Stand pay-per-view. He'd been on WWE's radar for some time, but was considered too small in the past. WWE were finally ready to give him a chance, feeling he'd be a good asset for the cruiserweight division.
Kash went about his work on velocity, having impressing showings against the likes of Paul London, Brian Kendrick and Funaki. He was brought to Smackdown proper in December, defeating Super Crazy to earn a shot at his Mexicools teammate Juventud at Armageddon.
At the December PPV, Kash won the Cruiserweight Title in a technically sound but heatless match. The work was good, but the crowd didn't care and chanted 'boring' to say as much. As for the reign itself, Kash only defended the title once on television, defeating Juventud on the January 3rd, 2006 episode of Smackdown.
Kash lost the title to Gregory Helms in the opener of the 2006 Royal Rumble event and never received an official singles rematch. It was evident that WWE were at a loss as to what to do with Kash, briefly teaming him up with Jamie Noble before firing him in September.
Few remember his Cruiserweight Title reign as it was completely unexceptional.
11. Juventud Guerrera
Oh man. Where do you start with Juventud's WWE run? There was a lot going on with Juvy at this time, as he was apparently a bit of a nightmare to deal with backstage. He was obnoxious, proposed ridiculous storylines (such as a Mask versus Mask story with Rey Mysterio, despite the fact he hadn't worn a mask in about six years) and generally alienated his colleagues and co-workers.
Juvy, along with Mexicools stablemates Super Crazy and Psicosis, were brought in to help freshen up a stagnant cruiserweight division (with WWE releasing Akio, Shannon Moore, Spike Dudley and Billy Kidman to make way for them). Juvy, in his first WWE match, botched a 450 Splash on Paul London, fracturing several bones in his face, which led to Vince McMahon banning it and similar high-risk moves.
Regardless of his recklessness and backstage eccentricities, Juvy was won the Cruiserweight Title, beating champion Nunzio at the No Mercy pay-per-view. He briefly dropped it back to Nunzio on the aforementioned Rome house show, but won it back a week later.
He dropped it for real to Kid Kash at Armageddon and was apparently none too happy about it, sulking about backstage. His rematch turned out to be his last in the company, as he defied orders and performed several high-risk moves without permission, including the 450 Splash.
Juventud could have been a great Cruiserweight Champion, but he was his own worst enemy. He's only ahead of the likes of Nunzio and Kid Kash because he did have one or two good televised matches as champion and was at least halfway charismatic.
10. Funaki
Funaki, most famous for his late 80s/early 2000s Kaientai tag team with Taka Michinoku, was the perennial jobber before WWE suddenly decided to make him Cruiserweight Champion. He won an over-the-top rope battle royal on the December 9 2004 Smackdown to receive a shot at Spike Dudley's title at Armageddon.
Trouble was, Armageddon was just three days later, leading them with no time to build a proper storyline and get fans invested. His battle royal will had also come from out of nowhere, and fans didn't really know how to react to it. There had been no real chase or struggle. It just reeked of desperation/lazy booking.
Funaki beat Spike at Armageddon in an overly-long match that played before long periods of silence. Funaki's shock win was supposed to be a big, feelgood moment but the only one who really popped was Funaki himself. He went on to defend the belt against Akio, Nunzio and Spike on Smackdown.
The highlight of his 70-day reign was a successful defense against Chavo Guerrero in the Saitima Super Arena in Japan. Funaki lost the belt in a six-man gauntlet-style match at No Way Out 2005, the first to be eliminated after less than 90 seconds of action. Indeed.
9. Spike Dudley
The man Funaki won the belt from, Spike Dudley, had a marginally more exciting reign that lasted almost twice as long as the Japanese star's did. The littlest Dudley was drafted to Smackdown in the March 2004 draft and began competing in the cruiserweight division.
He entered into a friendly rivalry with sometimes tag partner Rey Mysterio, eventually downing the masked man for the gold when the Dudley Boys interfered on his behalf. This set Spike up as the 'boss' of the Dudleys, as he would use them for protection and order them to beat up challengers for his title, such as Paul London and Billy Kidman (and Rey Rey).
After so long playing the underdog babyface on Raw, it was nice to see the gutsy Spike given a new role. Although he wasn't always present defending the title on Smackdown and PPV, Spike did well with the role and looked reinvigorated. He had decent defences at No Mercy (Nunzio) and Survivor Series (Mysterio, Kidman and Chavo Guerrero).
Not the best champion, but he was certainly something different and a nice change of pace.
8. Matt Hardy
After floundering for a while on Smackdown, Matt Hardy (Version 1.0, of course) was finally given something to sink his teeth into February of 2003. He was, with the help of his MFer (Mattitude Follower) Shannon Moore desperately trying to cut weight so he could make the under 220lb weight limit and face Billy Kidman for the title at No Way Out.
After much exercise wearing what looked like a skin-tight bin bag and many, many glasses of banana juice, Hardy managed to make weight and faced Kidman for the title as planned. Hardy won a decent match and then went about trying to stay below 220 while entering into a feud with Rey Mysterio.
The two men kicked off WrestleMania XIX in style, with Hardy retaining thanks to some help from Moore. That was, unfortunately, his only PPV title defence but he still had entertaining TV matches and formed a fun tag team with Moore, going against teams such as Rey Mysterio & Brian Kendrick and Los Guerreros.
Hardy lost the title in style, too, dropping it to Rey Mysterio in the main event of the June 5th episode of Smackdown. It was the first time that a Cruiserweight Title match had main evented the blue show and both Mysterio and Hardy did a great job, contesting a dramatic, back-and-forth match.
Some tend to forget about Matt Hardy V1's Cruiserweight Title reign but it produced some good television and showed his versatility.
7. Billy Kidman
Billy Kidman held the WCW Cruiserweight Title on five separate occasions but only got his hands on WWE's version of the belt (once it was unified with the Lightheavyweight Title) twice. The first time, Kidman held the strap for a paltry 19 days, winning it from Tajiri on Raw before losing it back to him in a great match at Backlash.
He'd have to wait another seven months before it would be in his possession once more, winning it from Jamie 'by God' Noble at the Survivor Series in another decent match. He'd lose it to Matt Hardy at No Way Out and was from then on pretty much always hovering around the division whenever he wasn't tagging wit Rey Mysterio or Paul London.
Thing with Kidman's WWE reigns is that they weren't nearly as fruitful as his WCW ones. Kidman, who never really learned how to cut a decent promo, was someone who could be relied on to go out there and have a decent, competitive 8-15 minute match, which he did regularly.
There's really not much more to say about Kidman. He was a good, cruiserweight style wrestler who went out and did his job well. A little personality wouldn't have hurt but what can you do?
6. Jamie Noble
The Redneck Messiah's contract was acquired by WWE when they bought WCW in March 2001 but Noble spent the next fifteen months not partaking in the Invasion, but rather wrestling in WWE developmental territory Heartland Wrestling Association, where he won the HWA Cruiserweight Championship.
By June 2002 he was deemed ready to join the main roster proper, adopting a trailer trash gimmick and aligning himself with on-screen girlfriend Nidia. The two were a great double act and had natural chemistry together. Just a few weeks after making his debut, Noble won the Cruiserweight Title at King of the Ring by beating The Hurricane.
Successful defences at Vengeance (Kidman) and No Mercy (Tajiri) followed, but he was upended by Kidman at Survivor Series. The PPV matches were good, but Noble really shined on Smackdown, where he was often wrestling the likes of Rey Mysterio or tagging with Nidia.
Noble only had the one 147-day reign, but it was certainly one of the more memorable WWE Cruiserweight Title runs. His work was tight and he was producing good matches regularly. He really should have had one or two more runs after he changed up his gimmick and look from 2004 onwards, but he was fired in November of that year when his doctor provided WWE with written proof that he was using anabolic steroids after he suffered a staph infection.
Yes, even cruiserweights hit the gas! Regardless, Noble's reign was sweet, if not a little too short.
5. Paul London
When Paul London was released from his WWE contract in 2008, many wrestling fans bemoaned the fact that he hadn't been used 'properly' and was 'held back'. While that may be true to an extent, those same fans forget that he and Brian Kendrick had a record-setting WWE Tag Team Title reign and London himself had a decent Cruiserweight Title reign that was only cut short because of his own actions.
London nabbed the gold on the March 31st, 2005 episode of Smackdown when he won a battle royal. It was during this time that London changed up his image and act, springing to the ring and wearing Ultimate Warrior-esque tassels on his boots. WWE had, by all accounts, planned to give him a decent push as champion as they were impressed with his work.
Things got off to a decent enough start with London defending the title against Chavo Guerrero in a good match at Judgement Day. Unfortunately, most of his title defences took place on Smackdown, which is a shame because they were invariably good. London was genuinely exciting and worked a faster, more athletic and high-risk style than many of the others in the division (who basically wrestled like smaller heavyweights).
As discussed during an earlier entry, London's confronting Vince McMahon over the banning of certain moves is what did him in, with the chairman then ordering London to drop the belt to Nunzio on Velocity and cut a series of whiny promos in the following weeks, momentarily turning him heel.
Given a little longer and with a few more high-profile defences, London's reign could have been one of the best ever. As it is, at least he temporarily reinvigorated a stagnating division and provided genuine excitement.
4. Chavo Guerrero
Oooooooh, Chavo!
Eddie's nephew was always overshadowed by his more famous uncle, but Chavo was a talented performer in his own right and was a pretty damn good Cruiserweight Champion, too. Chavito won his first Cruiserweight Title from Rey Mysterio at No Way Out 2004, thanks to some interference by Chavo Classic.
Regrettably, this reign would come to a rather silly end when he lost it to Classic in a triple threat match (also involving Spike Dudley). Just before that went down, Chavo had to go through the whole Jacqueline programme, which didn't exactly do him any favours.
He got another shot as Cruiserweight Champion in 2005, winning the title once again at No Way Out (although he didn't get to defend it at WrestleMania as he had the year before). He dropped it to the promising Paul London on the March 31st episode of Smackdown in, of all things, a throwaway battle royal.
He won the title once more in 2007 at - you guessed it - No Way Out, winning an 8-man cruiserweight open. Once again, no PPV title defences were forthcoming, although he had some quality television matches and formed a decent team with Gregory Helms. He infamously dropped the title to Hornswoggle, but we covered that farce earlier...
Chavo had some damn fine Cruiserweight Title matches during his WWE career, but he wasn't always champ and didn't always leave with the belt. Still, he was a respectable division-header and rarely put in a poor performance. His matches with Rey Mysterio were particularly good.
3. The Hurricane/Gregory Helms
Gregory Helms is the longest-reigning WWE Cruiserweight Champion ever, his combined three reigns lasting a whopping 532 days. He won his first CW title at Greed, WCW's final pay-per-view before they were purchased by Vince McMahon and the WWF. His first WWE Cruiserweight Title reign would come over a year later, only this time it wouldn't be as Shane Helms.
Instead it was The Hurricane, Helms' relatively new superhero gimmick, that would hold the gold. Hurricane beat Tajiri and Billy Kidman in a triple threat match on the May 16th, 2002 episode of Smackdown. His reign would end up being a short one, however, as he was bested by the incoming Jamie Noble at King of the Ring just 40 days later.
Helms would have to wait three-and-a-half years to regain the title - though he did enjoy two World Tag Team Title reigns in the interim. Ditching the mask and cape and now going by Gregory Helms, he moved over from Raw to Smackdown and shockingly won the belt in a cruiserweight open at the 2006 Royal Rumble.
That was the beginning of a 385-day-long run that saw Helms defend the title on pay-per-view against everyone from Jimmy Wang Yang to Super Crazy. He also fought in a couple of Champion Vs. Champion bouts opposite World Heavyweight Champ Rey Mysterio and US Title man Chris Benoit.
Helms and his 8,000 neckbreaker variations made for a good champion, even if it would have been nice to see him get a little bit more creative direction than just 'go out there and have a match and make it good'. He's the longest-reigning Cruiserweight Champ ever, regardless, and most of his matches from that time were good.
2. Tajiri
Maybe I'm biased, since The Japanese Buzzsaw is one of my favourite WWE wrestlers ever (seriously), but I really enjoyed his second reign as Cruiserweight Champion. Tajiri was actually the first 'WWF Cruiserweight Champion', since he was in possession of the WCW Cruiserweight Title when the WWF won the Invasion after defeating The Alliance at the 2001 Survivor Series.
The mist-sprayer lost the title to Billy Kidman on the April 4th, 2002 edition of Smackdown but won it back 19 days later in a hot opener at Backlash. The game of hot potato continued, with The Hurricane winning the title three weeks later on Smackdown in a decent triple threat featuring Tajiir and former champ Kidman.
Tajiri would challenge for the Cruiserweight Title many times after that, but always came up short. That is until he downed Rey Mysterio in a tidy affair on the September 25 2003 Smackdown. From there, he'd feud with Mysterio and have many more solid matches, including the curtain-jerker of No Mercy.
Tajiri, who was now a heel with two henchman (Akio and Sakoda), would also defeat Jamie Noble at Survivor Series (the match was bumped from the main card to Sunday Night Heat). Tajiri was looking good and looked set for a length rain but fell to Mysterio in a really good match on Smackdown (which aired on New Year's Day).
The Cruiserweight Classic competitor is placed so high due to his series of stunners with Mysterio as well as the fact that I think he's great and this is my list so sue me.
1. Rey Mysterio
You know how people always intermittently mention how someone is going to be the 'next Rey Mysterio'? 'Mistico is coming in from Mexico, he's super talented and is sure to take over from Rey Mysterio'...'Oh Kalisto, yeah he's really good and wears a mask. He's the next Rey Mysterio'. Et cetera, et cetera...
Well, it's all nonsense, because there really is only one Rey Mysterio and try as WWE might to replace him, it just ain't gonna happen. Rey is genuinely one of the best in-ring performers ever and one of the best to take a cruiserweight style and make it fit WWE.
He is also, for my money, the best WWE Cruiserweight Champion ever. It took Rey a year of being in WWE to win the thing, beating Matt Hardy in an awesome main event match on Smackdown. He'd hold the title for 112 days, defending against any and all comers, before being displaced by Tajiri thanks to a little help from the dreaded red mist.
It would be the man from the Land of the Rising Sun that Mysterio would beat to reclaim his title, doing so on the Jan 1st, 2004 Smackdown. His reign wouldn't be a long one, though, as he'd lose it to Chavo Guerrero following a long match at No Way Out (although Mysterio managed to squeeze in a couple of defences against Jamie Noble in the interim).
His final Cruiserweight Title reign came later in the year when he beat Chavo Classic on Smackdown. He went on to have some good matches with Chavo Guerrero, including an underrated outing at the Great American Bash PPV.
His reigns may not have been as legendary as they were in WCW, but Rey was the best WWE Cruiserweight Champion. The belt just looked like it belonged on him and he always brought it in the ring, having cracking matches with one and all.