WWE Evolution: 10 Things WWE Got Right

Women's. Wrestling.

Becky Lynch Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

The wrong match main-evented the show, the Nassau Coliseum didn't look sold out and there was an ever-looming threat of self-congratulation running throughout the entire thing, but WWE got an awful lot of things right at Evolution.

This is an experiment worth repeating; WWE can be rightly proud of what they achieved on Sunday, and that party-like ending to the show (kayfabe be damned) showed the close-knit collection of female wrestlers they have at their disposal. Note the word 'wrestlers'. That's what we saw at Evolution.

Exactly none of the seven matches broadcast failed to accomplish what they set out to do, and even two that seemed totally throwaway before the show managed to get an enthusiastic live crowd in New York pumped. When is the last time anybody has been able to say such a thing about a three-hour plus card's entirety?

The women of WWE may take time to show their full potential, but there was enough here to prove the days of gravy bowl matches, bikini contests and general titillation are consigned to history for good. That, above all else, is Evolution's crowning achievement.

One sign in the crowd said it best: "Women's Wrestling: Then, Now, Forever"...


10. The Emphasis On Childhood Dreams Coming True

Sasha Banks Bayley Natalya
WWE.com

Everyone from Bayley, Sasha Banks and Carmella to Molly Holly, Trish Stratus and Beth Phoenix had a childlike wonder in their eyes at Evolution. Critics will always have their say (that's just the way it is), but the fact is this show meant the world to these women. They're fully entitled to enjoy that.

For their part, WWE decided to take a backwards step and refrain from shining the spotlight of praise on themselves. From the off, the Kickoff show was crammed with a feeling of happiness and excitement for the performers who had made this happen, and Phoenix added a nice touch by thanking men like Fit Finlay who had always stood up for women in the company.

That was unexpected, and nicer for the surprise.

Throughout the night, some talking head segments added to the occasion by revealing how much of a landmark this was. Four years ago, WWE wouldn't have put on a card of female matches, so the tears of Banks and others were real. They know how far they've come.


9. Opening With That Legends Tag Match

Lita Trish Stratus Mickie James
WWE.com

Trish Stratus and Lita may have spent a fair chunk of their heyday squeezing into tight tops and pulling a thong as high as it would go, but they're female wrestling icons to a younger audience, including many who wrestled alongside them at Evolution. They, during an era that barely encouraged it, were able to break down some barriers.

It was great to see that recognised and even better to see both come through the curtain first.

Nobody was expecting a brilliant match from this, especially when Alexa Bliss was forced to pull out and leave it firmly in the exhibition category. As much as Alicia Fox tried, she wasn't a straight up replacement for Bliss' star power, and yet the match didn't really suffer. It was what it needed to be.

Seeing Mickie James tangle with old foes again was the main meat of the match, and fans popped big style for Trish and Lita running through some of their old routines. That's all the opener needed; it was a wonderful trip down memory lane.


8. Giving Trish Stratus & Lita The Win

Lita Trish Stratus
WWE.com

And it was a trip down memory lane that had the correct result.

Watching Trish and Lita raise one another's arms aloft in celebration had a sense of finality to it. This was as much their moment as the younger generation's, and it was a reward for sticking through some booking that'd probably make WWE blush nowadays. T&A, live sex celebrations and all that.

Once Alexa Bliss pulled out of the match, there was no other ending that made sense. Before that, it seemed logical that Bliss would pull a fast one on her elders and they'd symbolically pass the torch to her. With Alicia Fox in her stead, Alexa could watch on (smiling inwardly, no doubt) as her childhood heroines had one last hurrah.

Giving Trish and Lita a crowd-pleasing win was the absolute best way to start off Evolution. That was a pressure spot too, and it's one both legends lapped up as their careers came full circle. Sometimes, it's good when wrestling is happy, uncomplicated and appreciative.


7. Including That Fun Battle Royal

WWE Evolution Battle Royal
WWE.com

'Uncomplicated' isn't the right word to describe the previously-useless Battle Royal WWE had penned in for Evolution. There was a lot going on here, and it combined a head-spinning amount of booking layout with some nostalgic blasts from the past. Ivory, Kelly Kelly, Michelle McCool, Alundra Blayze and pals looks ace.

Pre-Evolution, this curmudgeonly old sod opined that the match would flat out suck. It was rather pointless time filler, he cried, forgetting that the multi-member format has been a staple of women's wrestling in WWE since the dawn of time. And, in fairness, they nailed it here. A full 16 minutes whizzed by.

It'd be hard to recall a more entertaining bell-to-bell Battle Royal than this under the WWE banner. There was a funny start, complete with The IIconics being put in their place, some fiery retro shenanigans, the standard 'Monster vs. Monster' face off and a popular ending.

That both Ember Moon and Nia Jax were being cheered at the end shows how much of a success this one turned out to be. There you go then, sometimes us wrestling writers know nothing.


6. The Card Placement For That Mae Young Classic Final

Toni Storm Io Shirai
WWE.com

For an example of the importance this Mae Young Classic tournament holds in WWE, look at the card placement of Toni Storm vs. Io Shirai.

They were on third, coming after the opening nostalgia kick of seeing Trish Stratus and Lita do their thing and the spot-heavy Battle Royal. In that sense then, Storm and Shirai had the spotlight all to themselves as the first one-on-one match Evolution had. That, my friends, is one hell of a show of confidence from the decision-makers.

Fans in Uniondale were right up for the kind of back-and-forth efforts the MYC has become known for over the past two years. Although Storm vs. Shirai ended up being rather short at a touch over 10 minutes, it ticked every box, and it was clear both women could easily work twice as long without losing any match momentum.

This was a featured spot for Storm (in particular). Despite being the star of the segment however, WWE subtly shone a deserved light on Mae Young's legacy. It was only right that she'd have a stiff match to honour her own ruggedness.


5. Sasha Banks Picking Up The Pin For Her Team

Sasha Banks Bayley Natalya
WWE.com

WWE have done a dreadful job of capitalising on the star power Sasha Banks had coming out of her career-defining feud with Charlotte Flair on Raw in 2016. Since then, she's been a background figure and even played before fan silence at her worst moments. Evolution then was a shot at redemption for the 'Legit Boss'.

Achievement unlocked.

Banks looked in her element as she performer a tribute nod to childhood fave Eddie Guerrero and won the match with a Frog Splash. Credit must go to her partners Bayley and Natalya, as well as The Riott Squad, too for refusing to let their six-woman tag become a p*ss break for fans.

They knocked lumps out of each other in pursuit of some headlines. Now, post-Evolution, it's time WWE started treating Sasha properly again. Natalya, as an older head, and Bayley, who has just about survived her own problems, will take care of themselves, but Sasha needs a little more recuperation.


4. Shayna Baszler Making History

Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

Hyper-critical admission time: this guy had forgotten all about the idea that Shayna Baszler would be making NXT history by becoming the brand's first ever two-time Women's Champ. In fairness, WWE themselves didn't make a lot of noise about it, and it seemed more likely that the cute-as-a-button Kairi Sane would retain.

She didn't, and Baszler is now the only woman in brand history to hold that belt twice.

On a list including names like Charlotte Flair, Paige, Asuka and Sasha Banks, that's impressive. Maybe this two-time champion deal will do more for Shayna than a quick shunt upwards to the main roster would. Now, she's finely poised to dominate NXT again and might even bring her Four Horsewomen pals along for the ride.

Much like Toni Storm's MYC win, the pacing of Baszler's title victory was well done. Her win happened straight after the six-woman tag and right before the important 'Last Woman Standing' match for the SmackDown Women's Title. That was another great spot for someone who has emerged from MMA's shadow and turned into a super-comfortable worker.


3. Not Killing Time With A Pointless Back-Patting Promo

Toni Storm Triple H Stephanie McMahon
WWE.com

The only time fans saw Stephanie McMahon and Triple H at Evolution was in some pre-taped promo skits and when they were bestowing the trophy upon MYC winner Toni Storm. That was for the best. Any more, and fans on social media would have had their usual meltdown about Steph hogging the glory.

Some of that is warranted, and yet it's important to remember how big a deal McMahon is behind the scenes in WWE. Wheeling her out with flowers for Storm and getting her to pose for a few photos didn't eat up unnecessary time, and it in fact left a huge cheesy grin on Toni's face.

No needless back-patting, zero spotlight hogging and no lengthy speeches about what the night meant. Nah, Steph and Hunter just let the women get on with things and only popped up to make the Mae Young Classic seem like a bigger deal. That was the best use of their celebrity on the night.

It should also provide everyone backstage with some food for thought going forward.


2. Keeping The Raw Women's Title On Ronda Rousey

Ronda Rousey
WWE.com

Ronda Rousey hasn't been able to match her extraordinary performance at WrestleMania 34 since. That's not to say that singles efforts against Alexa Bliss, Nia Jax and Nikki Bella on pay-per-view have been bad, but they haven't been on the same level. It'll take more than a year in the biz before she's doing that on a consistent basis.

Regardless of her rookie status in pro wrestling, Rousey is the best choice as Raw Women's Champion right now. She's a genuine mainstream star, one WWE can rely on to represent their organisation with aplomb, and her matches share some things in common with the visceral blasts of Brock Lesnar in the men's division.

She had to beat Bella at Evolution.

Nikki's warning post-match that "this isn't over" seems to suggest a rematch is incoming, possibly at Survivor Series or (if WWE are quick) at Crown Jewel. That'll need a little more sizzle than this headliner had though, that's for sure. At least the right woman won.


1. Leaving Weapons To The 'Last Woman Standing' Match

Becky Lynch Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Becky Lynch vs. Charlotte Flair in a 'Last Woman Standing' match should have been Evolution's main event.

Their 28-minute epic was the most enticing going into the show, and it was one million times more dramatic than Ronda Rousey vs. Nikki Bella ever had any hope to be. As much as it's true WWE got that wrong, they got something else right: weapons, including kendo sticks, steel chairs, ladders and tables, were left almost exclusively to the real-life best friends.

Even when Sasha Banks, Bayley and Natalya vs. The Riott Squad got violent, they resisted the temptation to belt one another recklessly with weapon shots. That's because Charlotte and Becky needed those props to sell their own heated feud, and sell it they did.

This was another leap forwards for women's wrestling in WWE. It was a brawl to rival the best men can manage, and that'll hopefully convince the McMahon family that performers like Flair and Lynch are capable of doing anything the boys can.

What else do you think WWE got right at Evolution? Let us know your revolutionary opinions down below!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.