WWE Extreme Rules 2018: Star Ratings For All 12 Matches

Too many cooks overbook.

Minus Four Stars
WWE

They don't like it when you compare WWE to New Japan Pro Wrestling.

To some, there is no comparison: Bigger automatically equals better, and financial success is not depressingly mutually exclusive to the creative process but somehow a commendation of it. To others, there is no comparison. New Japan's in-ring product is everything WWE's isn't: coherent, exciting, meaningful, eclectic, electric.

I can’t not draw the comparison here.

WWE promoted Extreme Rules ’18 in parallel with the beginning of the G1 Climax tournament. Your writer, pressed for time, was forced to make a choice: either sleep for a meagre four hours, watch Extreme Rules in its entirety and catch the top two G1 Night Two bouts, or sleep for longer and miss New Japan altogether. Given that a near-guaranteed five-star classic awaited, the former option was taken. The main event - Kenny Omega vs. Tetsuya Naito - was incandescent; bewitched by a ten minute final third of absurdly-paced, dynamite action, the Tokyo crowd, to a man, reacted like Vince McMahon did when Titus O’Neil botched at the Greatest Royal Rumble.

Kota Ibushi vs. Zack Sabre Jr. was a gruesome technical feast so expertly-worked that you felt Ibushi’s searing pain. After that, to miss the rest of the show - the content comes first, and WWE gets the hits, somehow - was deeply annoying.

Tired and already predisposed to hating this show, any attempt to actively try to care was almost immediately deflated.

If WWE don’t care, why should I?

12. KICKOFF: Sin Cara Vs. Andrade “Cien” Almas

Sin Cara Andrade Almas
WWE.com

Much too often even for a match between an awesome talent with no ceiling whatsoever versus an undercard job guy with a ceiling bearing down on his masked head, this was, nonetheless, worthwhile for a Kickoff attraction.

After a sprightly opening exchange, Almas discovered an excellent counter to the profoundly overexposed dive. He simply and seamlessly grabbed the back of Cara’s head and smeared his face against the barricade. If that didn’t knock his head off, his how-does-that-not-hurt spinning back elbow nearly did the job. A commercial break-enforced rest-hold spot both dragged and revealed the artifice, but the match recovered as it entered the finishing sequence. An entertaining and wince-inducing fusion of the beautiful and the beastly, boasting a blinding top rope hurricanrana spot, the future fate of Almas was still difficult to shake.

As great as Zelina Vega is in her role, it should be redundant in a match against Sin Cara. Were it not for her interference, the implication was that Cara may have won with his frog splash.

That was a bad narrative choice, but the match itself was comprised of not bad at all lucha things.

Star Rating: **3/4


11. KICKOFF: SAnitY Vs. The New Day - Tables Match

Killian Dain
WWE.com

More “Extreme” than much of the main card proper, this was also so much more fun than much of the main card proper.

Suitably chaotic, WWE went some way towards righting the wrong of a delayed and unflattering push on behalf of Eric Young et al. Using the inherent suspense of the stipulation well enough, Young and Wolfe narrowly avoided an early fall before Killian Dain assumed control for his faction with the sort of stupendous. eye-catching dive with which he became the star of it.

Crammed full of pop-worthy tandem spots, the match may have benefited from a Royal Rumble 2000-esque stipulation, in which every member of the losing team had to eat wood. Something more violent and destructive lay beneath the surface. It would not be the first match of the night not to exploit the full potential of its stipulation.

Also: why was Dain wearing a t-shirt? He’s a beast of a wrestler. His preposterously hairy back accentuates that.

But, given the disrespectful crowd, he at least avoided “Shave your back” chants…

Star Rating: **3/4


10. The B-Team Vs. Deleter Of Worlds - RAW Tag Team Title Match

Bray Wyatt Bo Dallas
WWE.com

A curious (read: totally moronic) choice of an opener to the main card proper, this proved, if nothing else, that WWE is struggling to even play the hits in 2018.

To unglue the crowd, the opening match, ideally, should see two acts perform a brisk, evenly-matched affair designed to create - but not exhaust - a surge of drama. This is elementary stuff.

This wasn’t a brisk, evenly-matched affair; performing as if no cameras were trained on them, Matt Hardy and Bray Wyatt walked through their signature spots at house show speed to convey to the crowd that the B Team were out of their depth. There was very little going on. The comedic B Team were hapless, but not ha-ha hapless. They - your new RAW Tag Team Champions! - simply eked out a win having done little but rely on a miscommunication. Teasing a meta meeting between Wyatt and Bo Dallas was very optimistic.

Teasing dissension between Wyatt and Hardy was frankly terrifying, given how lacklustre their first feud was.

Star Rating: * (That rating incorporates Curtis Axel’s endearingly stupid post-match promo).


9. Finn Bálor Vs. Baron Corbin

Baron Corbin Finn Balor
WWE.com

One didn’t need the power of prescience to see the finish to this match encroaching, tediously, on the horizon.

Such a finish was all but foreshadowed the second Finn Bálor and “Constable” Corbin were programmed together; the former is well-protected by the standards of the meandering modern midcard act, and the latter is in the midst of a new role and a renewed push. Neither could afford to lose and so, in peak WWE fashion, both were portrayed as losers.

The finish was telegraphed as the action unfurled.

Corbin mounted obscenely disproportionate offence throughout the first five minutes. It was an elongated squash match; he controlled to such an extent that he choked the life out of it and his opponent alike. Bálor only fought back at the death, accurately enough, and scored a fluke roll-up pin at the 8:20 mark. This depicted him as lucky, and depicted Corbin as utterly feckless. He lost his Money in the Bank briefcase with similar, greenhorn behaviour. Shouldn’t that result haunt him? Why does he still lose with the frequency and inattention of a 2010 era Diva? This was a match that did nothing for anybody, not least of which the fandom. It was barely a match, but rather an awful travel brochure to the stars of the independent circuit:

Don’t come. You’re shorter than and thus weaker than mediocre-at-best in-house Performance Center graduates.

Star Rating: *1/2


8. Carmella Vs. Asuka - SmackDown Women’s Title Match

James Ellsworth Extreme Rules
WWE.com

Another complete joke in which Asuka was the punchline, this “match” was worse than a farce. It was a crime scene.

Referees are stupid. The guy in the shark cage always has something hidden up his sleeve. They always have more than one item hidden up their sleeve. So, when Asuka caught the chain, it was perhaps incumbent on the referee to keep one eye up above. Not that any of this mattered. Asuka was the real idiot.

When you think about it - but don’t, it f*cking hurts - the stupidity was endless. Knowing all this, why didn’t anybody in a management capacity pat Ellsworth down before he entered the cage? He was forced into it precisely because he deals in these shenanigans. He didn’t just possess the odd weapon or two. He held the key to the cage. Who was tasked with protecting it? One of the dipsh*t babyfaces backstage?

Asuka is stupid. She focused all of her attention on Ellsworth when he was trapped. If she wasn’t stupid, she’d have simply beaten Carmella, reclaiming her title, before serving the reckoning.

Asuka did not, because she is stupid.

Asuka. The same performer with that legendary streak.

Asuka.

Star Rating: -****


7. Jeff Hardy Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura - United States Title Match

Jeff Hardy Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Tempting as it was to award minus points to this angle, on account of a referee stupid even by WWE’s standards, it wasn’t really a match.

Nakamura struck Hardy with a low blow before the opening bell.

“And the referee didn’t see a thing!” said Corey Graves on commentary.

He did, is the thing. He turned around well before Hardy crumpled to the mat. He looked nonplussed. What could Nakamura possibly have done to hurt Hardy? Could it possibly be the same illegal tactic he does on every episode of SmackDown?

In what was the overarching theme of the night, Hardy was depicted as an idiot, too. As a babyface, he had to show that his balls weren’t entirely destroyed. But, through trademark sports entertainment contrivance, he also had to agree to the match knowing full well he was going to lose.

This is what WWE’s sports entertainment storytelling does: where Shinsuke Nakamura turns testicles into mush, Creative performs a similar procedure on the brain.

Star Rating: N/A


6. Braun Strowman Vs. Kevin Owens - Steel Cage Match

Kevin Owens Braun Strowman
WWE.com

In which both man and monster were portrayed as absolute idiots.

This played out as expected. Kevin Owens, more chickensh*t than flesh, attempted to escape the cage immediately. Braun Strowman pulled him down from the walls and beat him up. As he is prone to do - in every match - the Monster missed a move, allowing Owens an opening. Owens used it to sprint through his signature offence… all of which was rendered impotent as Strowman shrugged it off.

Strowman is strong, but also very stupid, Strowman missed once more, allowing Owens to handcuff Strowman to the ropes. Owens, another idiot in a roster full of them, did not immediately escape. It’s not as if he wasn’t well-practised, having ran away from Strowman for weeks and suffered the very painful (nominal) consequences of failing to do so. He mugged for the cameras like the mug he is. Strowman - again, he is very strong - broke free from the cuffs, before he - again, he is very stupid - lost the match by hurtling Owens from the top of the cage and through an announce table in a jaw-dropping spot.

Jaw-dropping is the word; this looked incredible, there is no denying that, but it was so tonally wrong. This was an abysmal comedy feud Owens suffered for. Strowman meanwhile willingly lost a match purely to maim an absurdly outmatched opponent. Some babyface.

We have referred to him twice as stupid, but he knows that wins and losses don’t mean a thing in WWE, at least.

Star Rating: **


5. The Bludgeon Brothers Vs. Team Hell No - SmackDown Tag Team Title Match

Bludgeon Brothers Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

Daniel Bryan is an underdog. A man boasting the richest and most layered character arc in WWE is presented by that company as a one-dimensional underdog.

We get it.

To tell another unnecessary chapter of a story spun to death, the Bludgeon Brothers attacked Team Hell No before the bell, injuring Kane’s leg in the process. This begat a handicap match in which Bryan’s performance was paradoxically uplifting and depressing. He used his maverick storytelling ability and explosive athleticism, to work a mini-match opposite two behemoths that was somehow believable. As fun as it was to watch Bryan unglue a dead crowd, the subtext was borderline depressing.

Bryan is the guy. Bryan is the guy to wrestle the excellent, important singles matches that might save these overlong pay-per-views from eating themselves. Bryan can wrestle awesome, different matches. Bryan can play it seriously, he can work technically, he can fly.

But no: Bryan is an underdog, and, on this evidence, a loser. Kane was injured, but Bryan took the fall. He was protected somewhat, but why is he losing to a team in which Rowan is a member months after mounting the greatest comeback story of all time?

Did Shawn Michaels lose to Spike Dudley in 2002?

Star Rating: **


4. Bobby Lashley Vs. Roman Reigns

Bobby Lashley Roman Reigns
WWE.com

1) Roman Reigns

2) Chinlocks

3) ????????

4) Roman Gets Over As A Babyface

Mercifully, WWE abandoned this formula at least, although Reigns did apply a brief chinlock to Bobby Lashley in a tentative opening phase naturally bereft of heat. Fans, deeply disenchanted by anything to do with Roman, were reluctant to be drawn into the action. That they eventually were is a testament to a match and a pair of performances bone-rattling (if basic) at their best.

Elsewhere, this represented something of a return to form for the Big Dog. A babyface opponent likely helped stave off total heat spot/comeback purgatory; when it got going, it got good. Both men showcased their impressive power games in an evenly-contested and bruising match low on substance but high on impact. Lashley, in particular, absorbed a hellish bump on the outside.

“That was one of the roughest landings I’ve seen in a long, long time,” observed Corey Graves on commentary, completely forgetting about KO’s suicidal bump less than an hour prior. The ending made sense, even if the commentary didn’t; that Lashley overcame Roman with the spear was a neat touch.

It was his move first, just like it was his yard first.

Star Rating: ***1/4


3. Alexa Bliss Vs. Nia Jax - RAW Women’s Title Extreme Rules Match

Nia Jax Can T Aim
WWE.com

The worst entry in an already insipid feud, as a match, this was rotten. As an attraction, it was helped enormously by yet another transcendent Ronda Rousey performance.

Nia Jax, as we know by now, is irredeemable. She can’t even aim correctly, missing the first of two bin-compacting spots. Still, this match barely happened, thank Christ. Alexa is better, but very inconsistent between the ropes. She failed to wedge a chair between turnbuckle pads the first time ‘round. Forced to do it again, this made Nia look foolish for falling for a less-than-tricky ruse. A match of so many literally moving parts requires pros to hold it together. This train wreck brought into focus just how many poor performers WWE are intent on pushing.

It was left to the so-called amateur to bring the professionalism. Ronda attacked Mickie James like she’d framed her for murder, and was intent on enacting vigilante justice. Jax and Bliss are meant to hate one another in real life, and they still couldn’t come close to approaching Ronda’s manufactured motivation.

The difference in quality is beyond stark.

Star Rating: *1/4


2. AJ Styles Vs. Rusev - WWE Heavyweight Title Match

AJ Styles Rusev
WWE.com

Ultimately, the match told a good story, in which AJ Styles was presented as that elusive clever babyface for weakening his heel opponent and his most powerful weapon. Styles wrestled with the intelligence of a chess player - but also, for long stretches, with a similar pace.

Rusev entered a good performance, but this proved that he is woefully miscast. He is a natural babyface. In a show crammed to its detriment with heat spot after heat spot after heat spot, his heat spot was virtually indistinguishable. AJ Styles was good in his intelligent and gutsy babyface role, though he hasn’t yet rediscovered the kinetic energy with which he lit up the scene in 2016 and 2017. This match, though good to very good by the finish, retained the strange, almost methodical quality that rendered his series with Shinsuke Nakamura something of a disappointment.

Is this a company-wide directive, or the first sign of AJ’s descent into the twilight of his career?

Good is the word; this was a good WWE Title match just about deserving of the pay-per-view stage. Rusev’s excellent selling really helped immerse the otherwise unenthused crowd into the match, and elevate this beyond the TV realm.

Star Rating: ***3/4


1. Seth Rollins Vs. Dolph Ziggler - Intercontinental Title Iron Man Match

Dolph Ziggler Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Opponent.

Stipulation.

Preceding undercard dross.

The main event slot.

Dolph Ziggler has never been better positioned to live the gimmick, show the world that he is a main event talent, and steal the show - and he still didn't do it, rendering his next “frustrated” promo even less effective than those he has cut for the last six bloody years or so.

Rollins scored two early, contrived falls of the sort that never conclude a traditional singles match. This was overthought before Drew McIntyre’s interference, and so devoid of genuine build that it’s little wonder the Pittsburgh crowd amused themselves by counting down alongside the clock. Ziggler and Rollins worked hard, accounting for the rating, but not for the first five minutes. Virtually nothing happened, and the producer still contrived to insert two falls. Designed to convince the audience to get behind Rollins, a man they were already behind, this ploy did not work.

The action heated up in the final third, but for what? Yet another screwy heel win at the close of a match ordinarily calibrated to extract the most emotion following an uplifting babyface win?

A match that required genuine imagination to take the crowd for a long ride possessed barely any of it, this was an overbooked and monumental disappointment.

Fire every last road agent. They contribute nothing and too much.

Star Rating: **3/4


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!