WWE Payback 2017: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best
The horror, the horror.
The first post-WrestleMania PPV often struggles to entice fans, as it can end up feeling like a warmed-over rehash of the year's biggest event, yet with Payback, WWE actually delivered a thoroughly entertaining show for the most part...with one major exception.
Thanks to smart, expectation-defying booking and a ton of rock solid in-ring work, this was far from the low-effort late April PPV many fans have come to expect. Simply, #CancelWWENetwork wasn't trending last night, which is always a good sign.
It wasn't perfect by any means, and there weren't any Match of the Year candidates in the mix, but as far as WWE shows go, this was uncommonly consistent.
8. House Of Horrors: Randy Orton Vs. Bray Wyatt
Result: With the help of Jinder Mahal, Wyatt nails the Sister Abigail to score the victory.
Rating: Well, this definitely happened. You can knock at least one point off the score straight away because the match took place at night despite it being broad daylight in San Jose.
It was also impossible to take the pre-taped segment seriously as a live fight because of the overly-cinematic editing and camerawork (not to mention the dramatic musical score and obviously dubbed insect chirping).
The first part of this match was a weirdly compelling, cheesy trainwreck in its own way, but you had to feel for the in-arena audience, who essentially had to watch almost 15 minutes of the show on a video screen.
It went on way, way too long, people stopped caring long before the match resumed in the arena, and Jinder's involvement was super lame.
An absolute flop and a clear (failed) attempt to cash-in on the Hardyz' recent TNA shenanigans, but at least it was memorably bad. After all, who is ever going to forget that damn fridge? 3/10
7. Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson Vs. Enzo Amore & Big Cass
Result: With some assistance from Cass, Enzo rolls up Gallows for the win (6:35).
Rating: This was a decent enough TV-caliber sprint as everyone pretty much expects from the pre-show, even if nobody'll be remembering it a few days from now.
It ran rather short and a commercial being shoved in the middle of the match did it no favours, but both teams put on solid performances, even if seeing The Club eat another pin, on the pre-show no less, isn't particularly heartening.
Then again, there were highly valid reasons for both teams winning, so the booking team were caught in something of a bind. Still, isn't everyone kinda over seeing these teams wrestle each other by now? 5/10
6. Samoa Joe Vs. Seth Rollins
Result: Rollins rolls up Joe for the win (15:55).
Rating: You kinda have to feel for both Joe and Rollins, as the House of Horrors insanity kinda sucked the air out of the arena for a while, even though neither of these two exactly brought their A-game to a match that settled for being barely average.
Joe and Rollins don't have much natural chemistry in the ring, so it was hard to be that into what they were putting out here, and the knee angle is getting tiresome, not to mention it ultimately made Joe look like a chump all things considered.
It was definitely acceptable, but you want it to be so much more than that given how ridiculously talented the pair are. 6/10
5. Cruiserweight Title: Neville (c) Vs. Austin Aries
Result: Neville is disqualified after putting his hands on the referee (11:20).
Rating: Despite a low-energy start and the over-use of rest holds throughout, this was a characteristically entertaining cruiser match, with both men selling their desperate need to win.
Sadly it was all tainted by a terribly predictable, boring heel bulls*** finish, which only serves to elongate the feud for another rematch, even if it did totally suit Neville's character.
Still, the referees always come off like clueless stooges with results like this, because they're effectively rewarding the heel's cowardly behaviour and punishing the challenger. Otherwise, this was very good, and few are going to complain about seeing another match between the two. 6/10
4. Raw Women's Title: Bayley (c) Vs. Alexa Bliss
Result: Alexa nails a DDT to win the title (11:15).
Rating: Though there was some occasionally sloppy work here (Alexa getting stunned on the ropes and then rolling inside the ring looked really silly), overall it was a totally solid title bout that benefited from its surprise ending, especially considering Bayley's hometown advantage. One suspects at this point that Vince straight-up gets off on making hometown heroes lose.
Both competitors played their parts well, and the red-hot crowd absolutely helped. While Alexa still has room for improvement, this clearly proved WWE has a ton of faith in her moving forward, and for the most part it's easy to see why. 6/10
3. Roman Reigns Vs. Braun Strowman
Result: Braun kills Roman with two Running Powerslams for the win (11:50).
Rating: This is certainly Roman Reigns' best-booked PPV match in quite some time, not only because he lost but because it made sense for him to lose, getting to play up the gutsy heroic defeat angle while making Braun look like an absolute beast.
It wasn't a technical classic but was exactly what it needed to be: a physically intense brawl that gave Braun a clean victory but set up Roman's eventual rematch victory down the line.
For all of the things they screw up on a weekly basis, WWE are doing fantastic things with Braun right now, and this only further solidified that. As for Roman, his detractors might want to savour this beatdown, because he'll be back to Superman mode before you know it. 7/10
2. Raw Tag Titles: The Hardy Boyz (c) Vs. Cesaro & Sheamus
Result: Jeff kills Sheamus with a Swanton Bomb to retain the titles (12:45).
Rating: Accept the never-in-doubt end result and this was a really enjoyable sit, taking a classic tag match formula and injecting some welcome roughness into the mix.
The unintended highlight was Jeff seemingly getting legit stunned by Sheamus' Brogue Kick to the point that he nearly screwed up the finish by standing in the wrong corner (and having to be corrected by the referee).
However, the real story here isn't the rock solid match itself, but rather the excellent post-match heel turn by Cesaro and Sheamus, which will hopefully pay off with a stipulation rematch in the near-future. Overall, great pacing, performances and booking. 7/10
1. United States Title: Kevin Owens (c) Vs. Chris Jericho
Result: Jericho makes Owens tap with the Walls of Jericho to win the title (17:55).
Rating: This was a Hell of a way to open the show: a hard-fought battle that defied the obvious result in an entertaining way, even if some fans are understandably miffed how it might stifle Owens' momentum moving forward.
The easy highlights here were Jericho hilariously targeting Owens' hand after he pulled out the finger trick once again, and the terrific closing sequence, which refreshingly actually saw someone tap out to the Walls for the first time in what feels like forever.
This set the PPV off on the right foot for sure, even if it also hit a peak that the rest of the card never managed to match. 7/10
What did you think of WWE Payback? Shout it out in the comments!