WWE Royal Rumble 2020: 10 Former Stars Who Should Return Tonight!

The comebacks that matter most.

Eva Marie Royal Rumble
WWE

As exciting as the Royal Rumble pay-per-view is, it's safe to say most fans look forward to the event for the Rumble matches themselves and the surprises they have in store. This year's installments should be no exception.

NXT involvement in this year's Rumble matches is virtually guaranteed. Matt Riddle and a handful of women from NXT are expected to enter their respective Rumbles, along with a wrestler or two from NXT UK or 205 Live.

John Cena technically remains on the active roster but hasn't competed in over a year. A Rumble return for him is very possible, along with anyone else who has been inactive for the better part of the past year (Ronda Rousey, Nia Jax, Naomi, Jeff Hardy, etc).

However, the list of former WWE Superstars who could return in the Rumble is much smaller. Almost anyone who fans have wanted to come back to WWE have resurfaced at one point or another over the last decade or so. However, that hasn't stopped stars such as Rey Mysterio, The Hurricane and Jeff Jarrett from popping up and making their presence felt in the annual Battle Royal.

The focus should be on the future, but a nostalgia pop here and there doesn't hurt and only adds to the unpredictability of the bout.

Of everyone who could realistically return at the Rumble this year, these 10 would be the most satisfying to see.

10. CM Punk

Cm Punk
WWE.com

No Royal Rumble return wish list is complete without CM Punk, but because we're still a ways off from him getting back inside the squared circle, he ranks at the very bottom.

Punk's last WWE match was actually the 2014 Rumble. After lasting almost the entire bout, he was unceremoniously eliminated by Corporate Kane, never to be seen by the WWE Universe again... or at least until he resurfaced on WWE Backstage late last year.

There had been rumblings for months about him potentially joining the show as an analyst, but few fans thought much of it until it actually happened in early November. Whether he's truly "changed the culture" as promised is arguable, but he has certainly been a breath of fresh air on the program thus far.

As soon as Punk popped on Backstage, fans started to speculate whether a return in the Rumble was in the cards. From a storyline standpoint, the timing couldn't be better, but Punk has expressed zero interest in wrestling again at this time.

Considering he wasn't even advertised by the company for this week's Backstage ahead of time, there's clearly a lot that needs to be done for that relationship to be rebuilt.

Then again, Punk coming back to win the match he never could and going on to rekindle his rivalry with WWE champion Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 36 would be one heck of a story, wouldn't it?


9. Eva Marie

Eva Marie
WWE.com

This won't be a popular pick, but it would undeniably lead to deafening heel heat, similar to when Vickie Guerrero returned in the inaugural women's Royal Rumble match two years ago.

Eva Marie was last seen on WWE TV in August 2016 and was in the midst of a storyline where she found ways to delay her in-ring return each week. It actually caught on quite well, but she was suspended for violating the WWE Wellness Policy and subsequently left the promotion before the angle could continue.

While the former 'Total Divas' star will never be mistaken for being a tremendous technical wrestler, she did have a presence that helped her stand out as a star. She could have very well been successful had she not quit to pursue other endeavors.

Eva has since teased returning to WWE, and even if WWE isn't interested in bringing her back full-time (nor should they considering all the women under contract they already aren't doing anything with), a one-time return in the Rumble would make for a fun moment.

It would be worth it for the reaction she'd receive from the rowdy crowd in Houston. In fact, she could be eliminated as soon as she enters, ensuring fans wouldn't be subjected to seeing her wrestle. It'd be a harmless conclusion to a story that started years ago but was never given a proper payoff.


8. Santino Marella

Santino Marella Tattoo
WWE.com

Santino Marella was one of those wrestlers who didn't receive a grand sendoff after quietly retiring from the ring in the summer of 2014. It was a neck injury that forced him to hang up the boots, though he remained under contract and appeared sporadically for the company until receiving his release in May 2016.

The Milan Miracle has stayed busy since his departure, primarily with his wrestling school Battle Arts Academy and has even wrestled on a handful of occasions. If he's healthy enough to compete in full-length matches again, surely he'd be able to make a quick cameo in the 2020 Royal Rumble.

Lest we forget, he was the runner-up in the 2011 Royal Rumble after almost tossing out Alberto Del Rio to win the whole thing. Unfortunately, it didn't work out in his favor, but it was moments like that that made Marella such an entertaining and wacky character.

The sole appearance Marella has made on WWE TV in recent years was at the Raw Reunion show last summer in a non-wrestling role. He'd had have no shot at coming out on top in the Rumble, mind you, but the return of the dreaded Cobra would give the match some much-needed comic relief.


7. Victoria

Victoria WWE
WWE.com

A third of the participants in the first-ever women's Royal Rumble match two years ago were WWE Hall of Famers and women's champions of the past, all of whom helped pave the path to where the women are today.

Victoria's absence from the bout did not go unnoticed by fans.

After almost a decade-long stint with WWE that included two Women's Championship reigns, Victoria left the company on amicable terms in early 2009. She signed with TNA soon after and was a cornerstone of their Knockouts division for the next four years, proving that WWE didn't do nearly enough with her.

Victoria received her release from TNA in July 2013 and was open to returning to WWE but never got the phone call. Aside from appearing in the crowd at Hall of Fame ceremonies, she has yet to formally return to WWE TV and has revealed in various interviews that she is no longer allowed backstage at the shows.

WWE ignoring her existence has yet to be explained, but it's high time they moved on from whatever their issue with her is and invited her back home. Although she formally retired from active competition last September, it'd be nice to see her career come full circle with one last match under the WWE banner at the Rumble.


6. Eve Torres

eve torres
WWE.com

Before the "Women's Evolution," there was the Divas division, and Eve Torres played as important a role as anyone in making women's wrestling matter for the six years she was around.

Eve appeared to be just another pretty face upon winning the 2007 Diva Search but quickly proved she was determined to hone her skills and elevate the division to the best of her ability. Sure enough, she captured the Divas Championship within two years of her main roster debut and went on to hold it another two times in the remainder of her WWE career.

Her heel work at the tail end of her run was especially excellent and earned her a prominent position on Raw for the entirety of 2012. She departed WWE at the onset of 2013 before she could enjoy the fruits of her labor and work with any of the up-and-coming talent down in NXT.

Between the 2013 Slammy Awards and the Evolution pre-show, Eve has made a number of televised appearances for WWE over the last seven years in an ambassador role but has yet to lace up the boots again. The least WWE could do is feature her in a women's Royal Rumble, assuming she'd be up for it.

Considering she's married to Rener Gracie, it's safe to assume she's kept in great shape since leaving wrestling and would be able to hold her own in a Rumble.


5. Carilto

Carlito WWE
WWE.com

A majority of the fan base was aware in the mid-2000s that not everyone was going to be a world champion, and Carlito was one of those guys who was perfectly positioned as a midcarder for the better of his career.

Despite never coming close to clinching the WWE Championship, Carlito did find success in the singles and tag team ranks as a former Intercontinental, United States, World Tag Team, and WWE Tag Team champion over the span of six years.

Carlito's WWE tenure came to an abrupt end in May 2010 when he refused to go to a rehabilitation facility upon failing the WWE Wellness Policy and was subsequently released, meaning it's been nearly a decade since he last competed for the company. His one-off appearance at the 2014 Hall of Fame (where he inducted his dad into the hallowed hall alongside Primo and Epico) was well-received and left fans wanting more of Carlito Caribbean Cool.

Even though Primo and Epico haven't been regulars on WWE TV in some time, talk of a potential return to the company for Carlito has been brought up on multiple occasions since 2016. It's hard to imagine he'd be utilized any better than Shelton Benjamin has been in recent years, but a one-off return in the Royal Rumble would be cool, if nothing else.


4. Kaitlyn

kaitlyn divas champion
WWE.com

Kaitlyn accomplished far more than what was initially expected of her and then some after her NXT Season 3 victory that earned her a spot on the SmackDown roster.

Her in-ring ability was nothing to write home about at that point, but much like Eve Torres, she prided herself on improving and learned a lot through teaming with AJ Lee from 2011 to 2012. Following their split, she unintentionally broke out as a babyface and worked her way up the card before finally securing her first and only Divas Championship in January 2013.

The rest of her run could have been handled better, but she and AJ deserve credit for crafting one of the best stories the Divas division had featured in years. Their series of matches over the championship was the first step in legitimizing the title and ushering in a new era for the women where they were looked at as more than just a bathroom break.

Kaitlyn quit WWE in January 2014 before she could hit her stride again but returned to the ring without missing a beat as part of the second-annual Mae Young Classic in 2018. She later appeared in a blink-and-you-missed-it backstage segment at Raw Reunion last summer.

If there's one thing left for her to do in WWE before officially calling it a career, it's competing in the women's Royal Rumble.


3. Goldberg

Bill Goldberg
WWE.com

While not technically a "former" star (seeing as how he wrestled as recently as SummerSlam 2019), Goldberg is no longer a member of the active roster. Thus, an appearance in the 2020 Royal Rumble match would be as much of a surprise as anyone else on this list.

After having a sweet send-off at WrestleMania 33, Goldberg decided to ruin his retirement by coming back to wrestle The Undertaker at Super ShowDown 2019 in what turned out to be a complete disaster. He was set on redeeming himself from his poor performance that night, and sure enough, he looked like the Goldberg of old (as opposed to "Oldberg") when he squashed Dolph Ziggler in a matter of minutes at SummerSlam.

Goldberg has no business winning the Rumble, mind you, but he would be the perfect person to oppose Brock Lesnar at No. 2 given their extensive history. In fact, they've played a part in eliminating each other from the Rumble in years past (2004, 2017), so it would make sense for that rivalry to be revisited at some point or another during the bout, if not at the very beginning.

As glorious as his decimation of Ziggler was back in August, that can't be his final match. Returning in the Rumble could kick off one final run for him heading into WrestleMania 36.


2. AJ Lee

aj lee
WWE.com

CM Punk has made it quite clear that he isn't ready to lace up his boots again just yet (if at all), but that doesn't mean the door is necessarily closed on AJ Lee ever returning to the ring.

Much like her husband, AJ has also gone on the record in saying she isn't eyeing an in-ring return, but she has never seemed to be as vehemently against the idea as Punk. After all, she grew up a massive wrestling fan and the business will always be in her blood no matter what she does.

From writing a best-selling autobiography to speaking out against mental illness, the former Divas champion has carved out an entirely new career for herself outside of wrestling. There really isn't any reason for her to return aside from giving fans what they want to see one last time.

AJ got to mix it up with Paige before leaving WWE in 2015 but missed out on the "Women's Evolution" and everything that followed. With three Divas Championship reigns and many memorable matches and segments to her credit, she will go down as the one of the most prominent and popular women's wrestlers of all-time to never compete in a women's Royal Rumble if she remains retired.

A CM Punk comeback may be out of the realm of possibility (for now), but a Rumble return for AJ Lee could be even better.


1. Edge

Edge WrestleMania sign
WWE

Edge returning to the ring would have been unfathomable even one year ago, but there has been enough talk about it happening after all these years that it could very well be a possibility at the 2020 Royal Rumble.

Where there's smoke, there's fire, and where there's fire, there's Edge.

Although Edge's in-ring retirement was abrupt in April 2011, he went out on the highest note possible as the World Heavyweight champion having wrestled his last match at WrestleMania. It doesn't get much better than that, but it's also hard to argue that it'd be awesome to see him step inside the squared circle one more time.

Regardless of whether he has one more run left in him or not, a one-off return in the Rumble for Edge is absolutely plausible.

Daniel Bryan, for one, defied the odds and got cleared by doctors despite being told he'd never wrestle again. Of course, Edge's issue was with his neck and not concussions, but it's strange he was given the green light to get physical with Elias at SummerSlam 2019 after not delivering a single Spear in over eight years.

On the 10 year anniversary of when The Rated-R Superstar last returned in the Rumble and won the whole thing, don't be surprised if you hear "You think you know me" on Sunday and the raucous reaction that'd surely follow.


Contributor
Contributor

Since 2008, Graham has been a diehard pro wrestling fan and, in 2010, he combined his passions for WWE and writing when he joined Bleacher Report. Equipped with a master's in journalism, Graham has contributed to WhatCulture, FanSided's Daily DDT, Sports Betting Dime, and GateHouse Media. Along the way, he has conducted interviews with wrestling superstars like Chris Jericho, Edge, Goldberg, Christian, Diamond Dallas Page, Jim Ross, Adam Cole, Tessa Blanchard, Ryback, and Nick Aldis among others.