WWE Royal Rumble 2026: 5 Nightmares That Could Come True

Flat Royal Rumble winners and a beloved babyface being booed as WWE Champion?! EEK!

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

2026 is arguably going to be the most interesting year of Cody Rhodes' career. That's saying something considering his industry-shaking jump from AEW back to WWE in 2022, but think about it: Cody has done an outstanding job of sustaining babyface status for close to 4 years now. Cracks are beginning to show in that formula and boos are starting to surface though.

They have been for a while.

This is something WWE bosses should keep in mind when they're over in Saudi Arabia for Royal Rumble. Previously, the atmosphere at these Saudi stadium shows could be politely called...less-than. Dignitaries and money men flooded the ringside area, which didn't do much for booming responses or scorching heat. Times have changed. Now, actual wrestling fans occupy those seats, and they're as vocal with their thoughts as most other audiences.

You know the deal by now - there's no room for positivity in these pages. This is a calamity-filled tour of the worst that could happen on WWE's latest PLE. There's a lot to dig into even on a 4 match card. One titular Rumble could be flat out painful to sit through, another could end with unwanted echos of 2015, a cherished career could feasibly come to a close, legends might go back on their word, and a hardworking heel may watch his dreams go up in smoke all over again.

Hopefully, none of this happens, because it'd be nightmare inducing stuff. No-one wants the Rumble to suck, but people don't always get what they want. Read this through cracks in your fingers!

5. The Women’s Rumble Is Flat Out Boring

WWE Raw Judgment Day Roxanne Perez Liv Morgan Rhiyo Rhea Ripley Iyo Sky
WWE

The women's Rumble could be pretty tame if recent rumours about Liv Morgan winning the whole thing come true. That's not meant to put Liv on blast. She's a big star and deserving of more top tier moments in WWE for sure, but the setup for her win could prove problematic if it's framed around the Women's Tag-Team Titles.

Morgan and her Judgment Day pal Roxanne Perez have been gunning for Rhea Ripley and IYO SKY lately. Come the Rumble match, that could well be Triple H's focus, and it doesn't sound great when the likes of Bianca Belair's comeback story or Tiffany Stratton returning are being dangled right in front of fan faces.

Nothing is nailed on with either Belair or Stratton, but they certainly sound like more exciting winners than Liv right now - especially Bianca. It's gonna be pretty dull if Morgan, Perez and Raquel Rodriguez patrol the ring to fend off other tags like Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss, Nia Jax and Lash Legend or the reigning champs RHIYO.

Put it this way: Liv eliminating Ripley, who hasn't been cast as a standalone threat for a while now, doesn't seem too thrilling on paper. WWE will have to come up with something else for the match or it'll be a second lame duck Royal Rumble finish for the division in quick succession.

Charlotte's triumph last time out failed to satisfy. Morgan would be better, but admittedly not by much if her tag stuff dominates the conversation come 31 January in Riyadh.


4. Gunther Does End A Phenomenal Career

AJ Styles Sad Retirement
WWE.com

ARGH! Could AJ Styles really leave WWE on such a sour note? It's inconceivable to imagine that the 'Phenomenal One' will finish up with the company he's been with since 2016 at Royal Rumble. However, there are reports doing the rounds that Styles hasn't inked any extensions on a contract that'll run out in February. February!

As in, right after WWE gets back from Saudi.

This might mean that Gunther is going over decisively at the Rumble and this is bye bye to AJ. Surely he deserves something bigger than such a hastily-booked grudge match? The story, which sees Styles snarling at the Austrian's disrespect for John Cena, is a good one. It is, but this has still been a quick turnaround from their match on Raw a few weeks back.

Admittedly, there'd be nothing stopping Styles from working his own retirement tour over in TNA or elsewhere should he leave WWE following the next PLE. Further, there's no concrete date in February to cling to. Maybe AJ would get a big celebration bash on TV before walking out the door. Or, maybe there's nothing to worry about here at all and this is just one fan fretting.

That's possible too.

It'd be so odd to see Styles close out his WWE career like this though. Gunther doesn't need to claim another legendary scalp like he's some 2005 version of Randy Orton. Beating Goldberg and Cena was enough for the ex-World Champ. Let's not add AJ to that list so suddenly without careful thought.


3. A Legend Goes Back On Retirement

WWE Survivor Series 2025 WarGames John Cena
WWE.com

Listen, the pop from Riyadh's wrestling-daft masses would be audible from the moon if none other than John Cena marched out to take his place in the 30-man Rumble. Similarly, but to a lesser extent, people would lose their minds if Bill Goldberg was involved in the bout and cracked his dome hardway on a door before heading to the ring for a short shift.

Neither return should happen. Why would they?! Realistically, Cena isn't going back on his retirement vows so soon, and Goldberg has nothing to gain from showing face himself. Not that either guy needs it, but...money talks. What if the payday Saudi's money masters put on the table is too big to resist? Cash changes pretty much everything.

Just ask Shawn Michaels.

WWE's 2025 would come crumbling down in an instant if 'Super Cena' told Stu the cameraman, "I'm back. Let's go to work" before sprinting down the aisle for some Royal Rumbling. Triple H's league spent the entirety of last year telling the tale of John's send off - it wasn't always great, and some of it was clunkier than a Viscera vs. Mark Henry match, but 2025 belonged to Cena's retirement.

On that note, what kind of message would this send to fans? Cena or Goldberg showing up in Saudi at the end of the month would nullify the story being told in Gunther’s match with AJ into the bargain, and that doesn't sound like the right thing to do. After all, AJ is steaming mad at the heel for gloating about putting legends out to pasture, so his purpose would ring hollow if one of those icons nabbed one final payday for the hell of it.


2. Cody Rhodes Gets The Roman Reigns Treatment

Cody Rhodes Jey Uso
WWE.com

Few will ever forget how miffed The Rock looked as fans rained boos down on he and Roman Reigns at the tail end of the 2015 Rumble match. Rocky, complete with jaw agape, was frankly stunned that people reacted so negatively to his endorsement of WWE's new poster child. Those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it.

Cody Rhodes has been hearing some boos himself whenever he's cutting promos on SmackDown. In fact, the former WWE Champion has even started acknowledging that heat as a regular part of his speeches, and that shows just how noticeable the boos are getting. It's surely only a matter of time before Rhodes goes full blown heel and tells the WWE audience to stick it.

The creative team aren't quite there yet, so it'd be a nightmare for them if Cody was booked to win his third Rumble (following victories in both 2023 and 2024) then heard jeers aplenty. It'd be even more maddening for the writing team if 2025 winner Jey Uso was the one raising his friend's hand in celebration and both were booed out of the building.

Unfortunately, this isn't too far-fetched. Chants of, 'We Want Roman' and, 'OTC! OTC! OTC!' could fill the night air as a puzzled Cody and Jey look on from the ring. Triple H absolutely won't want this PLE going dark with such a cloud hanging over his booking. He'd have to be a fool to think that everyone will be 100% on board with Rhodes winning yet again though.

Be careful, WWE! If Cody going full on heel isn't your plan for WrestleMania 42, then be careful.


1. Drew McIntyre’s Reign Is Shortlived

Drew McIntyre Sami Zayn
WWE

Eventually, Sami Zayn capturing either the WWE Title or the World Heavyweight Championship is on the cards. He's been setting the scene for that with promos about explaining to his son why he's never held the top prizes, and by winning then losing the United States Title. It's a rollercoaster road of ups, downs and emotions for the one time El Generico.

So, would it really be the worst if he captured the WWE Title at the Rumble? In a word, yes, but that's largely due to the guy holding it right now. Drew McIntyre has had his own peaks and troughs for years, and he's only just beaten Cody Rhodes in a '3 Stages Of Hell' match over in Germany to become the brand new champ.

Dropping the belt so soon would be hellish for McIntyre, whether it's to Sami or any of the other workers involved in a Fatal-4-Way at Saturday Night's Main Event before the Rumble. Zayn is this writer's choice to win that match and challenge the Scot over in Saudi, but he shouldn't bag the win if that's the case.

WWE should let Drew enjoy the fruits of his labour for a while, at least. Seeing him cast aside for anyone this quickly would suck, and it'd be a sure sign that Triple H plans to play hot potato with the most important strap in the industry heading through WrestleMania season.

If he wins at SNME, then Sami can stomach some disappointment. Patience is everything. He'll have his time.

What other nightmares could come true at WWE Royal Rumble 2026? For more wrestling, check out 15 MORE Incredible WWE Attitude Era Moments Nobody Ever Talks About and Every WWE Tough Enough Winner: Where Are They Now?


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.