WWE’s 10 Worst Title Matches Of 2017
These title matches were not Gold Standard.
Championship matches are designed to be a celebration of the top performers in their respective divisions; superstars or teams giving it their all to be recognised as the very best.
And WWE have had some great ones in 2017 - from John Cena making history against AJ Styles at the Royal Rumble in January, to August's hard-hitting fatal 4-way at SummerSlam.
The tag division has also excelled with The New Day and The Usos going to war over the SmackDown belts, only to be eclipsed by The Shield and Cesaro and Sheamus over on RAW.
While Sunday night’s SmackDown-exclusive Clash of Champions pay-per-view did not finish the year’s title programmes with a flourish, it did not deliver any stinkers either, as AJ carried Jinder Mahal to a passable main event, and The Usos and Dolph Zigger picked up big wins.
But other shows in 2017 have not escaped without a blot on their copybook. Whether it was down to nonsensical booking, sub-standard action, or a combination of both, there have been plenty of championship matches in WWE this year that have not lived up to the billing.
10. Chris Jericho (C) Vs. Kevin Owens - WrestleMania
WWE got the build-up to Chris Jericho versus Kevin Owens spot on. In fact, it was so good that a lot of fans were disappointed that their WrestleMania match was only for the United States Championship, rather than in the main event slot for the Universal Championship.
From Jericho’s list to the Festival of Friendship, the ‘best friends’ shared an unparalleled chemistry as partners on the microphone, but for some reason it didn’t work as opponents.
There was no reason why this match could not steal the show in Florida, and yet these two great storytellers failed to portray the intensity that should have been brewing following eight months of narrative. The action was pedestrian - Owens and Jericho were out of sync.
The match was by no means terrible but it fell well short of its lofty expectations. Owens’ 365 documentary on the WWE network showed Vince McMahon’s unsatisfied response and KO’s heartbreak after he and Jericho let a potential classic slip through their fingers.
9. SmackDown Women’s Championship Six Pack Challenge - WrestleMania
This is an example of where the performers were blameless for the poor end product.
In an unfortunate regression to WWE’s WrestleMania booking of the division pre-Women’s Revolution, creative threw together a Six Pack Challenge in Orlando in which Naomi submitted Alexa Bliss for a championship coronation in front of her hometown crowd.
It was a feel-good moment for the former Funkadactyl, but the response would have been stronger had it been a one-on-one match. The injury redemption narrative was there, with Bliss as the paper champion. The other four competitors were merely window dressing and the lazy multi-person format was simply because WWE had nothing for the other women.
What really killed this match though is that it was positioned between Brock Lesnar versus. Goldberg and Undertaker versus Roman Reigns at the close of a seven-hour show. The audience was fatiguted and very few people cared for what was a five-minute filler.
8. Neville (C) Vs. Enzo Amore - No Mercy
Neville’s reign as King of the Cruiserweights was superb from start to finish.
The Newcastle native had a series of proficient matches against Austin Aries and the intense style adopted following his heel turn also meshed nicely with Rich Swann and Akira Tozawa.
Enzo Amore is not nearly as good a dancing partner as those mentioned above, but that Neville lost the title at the first attempt to a low blow at No Mercy, having taken very little offence from Amore previously, made a mockery of Neville’s intelligence and fortitude.
‘The Certified G’ has since gone on to make a success of his heel turn and is attracting mainstream spotlight to the Cruiserweight division that even Neville cannot claim to have garnered during his time as champion. But the end here does not justify the means.
Neville carried the 205 Live brand for six months and rightly saw the manner of this defeat as a mark of disrespect. It was little surprise that he walked out on WWE weeks later.
7. Randy Orton (C) Vs. Jinder Mahal - Backlash
They actually did it. They actually put the WWE Championship on Jinder Mahal.
Once the shock and hilarity passed - and it did not take long for the joke to get old - those fans looking back on his Backlash match with Randy Orton would view it as the type of boring and rigid encounter that would become a staple of Jinder's six-month title reign.
Orton in 2017, particularly as a babyface, is not exactly a thrill a minute, and Mahal’s limited wrestling style made for a main event full of rest holds and shenanigans from the Singh Brothers, whose blatant interference was inconceivably ignored by referee Mike Chioda.
Jinder was not ready to be a challenger, never mind a champion and his rushed ascent to attempt to capitalise on the Indian market cheapened WWE’s most prestigious title. Had he been built up more beforehand, his whole reign may have had a different complexion.
6. Naomi (C) Vs. Lana - Money In The Bank
With the rest of Team Blue's women’s division occupied by the Money In The Bank Ladder Match, Lana was thrust into a SmackDown Women’s Championship bout on her pay-per-view singles debut. Her lack of experience showed as she looked out of place.
‘The Ravishing Russian’ started off well enough, executing some aggressive offence by suplexing Naomi twice into the ropes and clocking her in the chin with a standing calf kick.
It was not her athleticism that exposed her, but her ring awareness and endurance. Once she had done her main spots, Lana's uncertainty of what to do next slowed the match down and caused it to lose energy despite Naomi’s best efforts to carry her opponent through.
This would not have been out of place on Tuesday nights, but it was way short of pay-per-view standard because Lana just wasn’t ready. There was no way that WWE were going to put the title on her, so setting her up to lose damaged her wrestling credibility from the off.
5. Jinder Mahal (C) Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura - SummerSlam
The worst crime of the Jinder reign is that it came at the expense of Shinsuke Nakamura, who arrived on SmackDown red hot from the best run of any NXT superstar to date.
Mahal rode his early days as champion on a wave of surprise and Orton apathy, but the novelty had worn thin by the time SummerSlam came around and most followers were expecting Nakamura to end the charade and take his place as WWE champion.
‘The Modern Day Maharajah’ again slowed the pace down to snoring levels and eventually went over with the help of the Singh Brothers. It was this repeated finish which made the result tough to swallow, and lost those fans who'd been patient with the Jinder experiment.
Jinder would show later in the year that he could be carried to an excellent title match with AJ Styles, but on this night his bout with Nakamura preceded a barnstorming fatal 4-way for RAW’s Universal Championship, which showed how far SmackDown had fallen in his hands.
4. Alexa Bliss (C) Vs. Bayley - Extreme Rules
Bliss and Bayley were victims of a silly Kendo Stick on a Pole stipulation at Extreme Rules, and WWE screwed the women even further by only booking them a five-minute slot.
The match was not long enough to conclude a narrative started in its early going, when the former RAW Women’s Champion showed hesitation to use the weapon against Bliss.
Things came to an abrupt end following a flurry of kendo shots and a DDT on Bayley, who did not have the time to put in a fighting performance as she succumed easily to defeat.
Bayley’s good-natured character was pushed too far here. In the months prior, she had doubted her credentials as champion, and that she was not willing to go to extreme measures, while complying with the rules, to get the title back made her look very weak.
3. Bray Wyatt (C) Vs. Randy Orton - WrestleMania
Similar to the Owens and Jericho angle, this WrestleMania programme was imaginatively booked over a long period, only to fail to deliver when it came to crunch time.
‘The Eater of Worlds’ was riding the wave of winning his first WWE championship, and as his follower, Orton had become as interesting as he had been in years. His turn on Wyatt briefly changed fan opinion on what had previously been an unpopular Royal Rumble win.
What should have been a vicious grudge match playing up the heartless disposition of both men descended into farce. The creepy projections onto the ring was the type of theatrics one might accept at a ‘B’ pay-per-view, but not during a WWE title match at WrestleMania.
The Wyatt mind games ate into what was already a short encounter at 10 minutes, and with his sudden defeat - his third in a row at ‘The Showcase of the Immortals’ - his credibility was shot once more and we were left with another Orton title reign that few people wanted.
2. Kevin Owens (C) Vs. Goldberg - Fastlane
The rapid Goldberg victory over Brock Lesnar at Survivor Series in 2016 was effective as a shocking one-off, but the similar manner of his win over Kevin Owens for the Universal Champion didn’t serve any purpose than to hide the former WCW star’s conditioning.
The hardcore fans who had hoped for Owens to hang onto the belt through Lesnar interference may have accepted defeat for their guy had it come in different circumstances, but the 22-second squash prompted some resentment towards the returning part-timer.
Owens is one of the most intelligent heels on the roster and it is unbefitting of his character that the distraction by Chris Jericho would cause him to turn his back on Goldberg.
The biggest disappointment about this match is what could have been. Short slugfests have worked wonders for the Universal Championship in 2017 and this could have been a great match had it gone six to eight minutes with both men going gung-ho from the bell.
1. Jinder Mahal (C) Vs. Randy Orton - Battleground
A sham champion, an unloved challanger and a death sentence of a stipulation created the recipe for the worst title match of 2017 at Battleground. Oh, and The Great Khali returned.
The previous two Punjabi Prison matches had been terrible and WWE had not learned their lesson with this one. Much of the 27-minute encounter was spent with the opponents isolated, slowly climbing an ugly structure which makes for a poor viewer experience.
Once again Mahal relied on the interference from the Singh Brothers to help carry him a pay-per-view main event, and although the three-on-one dynamic allowed for some exciting Orton offence, the structure was more of a hinderance than an tool in this regard.
Khali’s return was a shocking and briefly fun moment, but he immediately disappeared thereafter without Jinder ever explaining his random involvement on WWE television. If Khali is gone for good, let’s hope he has taken the dreadful Punjabi Prison concept with him.