WWE SummerSlam 2017: Best Booking Scenarios For Each Match

Sayonara, Lesnar.

SummerSlam 2017 Lads
WWE

The 30th annual SummerSlam event is just around the corner, and you can practically already hear Michael Cole dubbing it "SummerSlam's 30th Anniversary." No, WWE, it's not.

It's been a string of mediocre PPVs so far this year, so the pressure is on. The 'Biggest Party of the Summer' has been positively jam-packed with matches, with 13 listed at the time of writing. For anyone keeping track, that's also the number of matches at WrestleMania 33. It looks like we're all in for a test of endurance.

The card is positively stacked, so there's something for everyone here, with so many big stars getting a spot somewhere on the show. Unfortunately, WWE has shown in the past that they can ruin a good thing through terrible booking.

Just this past week, we as fans were subjected to a third failed Money in the Bank cash-in attempt featuring John Cena, and Finn Bálor covered in what was presumably supposed to be blood, but looked more cherry syrup. The worst parts of the creative team are out in full force, apparently.

Even with a line-up as bloated as this, WWE has the opportunity to knock their second biggest show of the year out of the park. All it will take is the correct booking.

13. Faces Win, Jobber Takes The Pin

Jason Jordan The Miz Miztourage
WWE.com

Announced as a pre-show match just days before SummerSlam, it's nice that Miz, The Hardys, and Jason Jordan all get a place on the card, even if it woefully under utilizes their talents.

Employing Curtis Axel and Bo Dallas as Miz's impromptu bodyguards could be great if used correctly, similarly to what J&J Security did for Seth Rollins. Unfortunately, they haven't be used that well. Just a few weeks ago, Miz took the pinfall when teaming with the Miztourage against Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose.

Jordan and the Hardys are the better team, and should get the win here. The endgame appears to be an Intercontinental Championship match between Jordan and Miz in the near future, which can only mean good things.

Despite losing some ground due to the whole "Kurt Angle, you ARE the father" soap opera angle, this would be a good place to let Jordan pick up some steam. The Hardys can do their thing, then Jordan picks up the victory over either Dallas or Axel, preferably while making direct eye contact with the champion.

If Survivor Series 2017 follows the same SmackDown Live vs. Raw format it did last year, then perhaps IC Champ Jason Jordan vs. US Champ Chad Gable could be on the cards. This would be a good way to get the ball rolling.


12. The New Day Squeak Past The Usos

SS 17 New Day Usos
WWE.com

The New Day and The Usos are among the best parts of WWE on either show and in any division.

It's a shame then that the rest of SmackDown Live tag team division is so shallow.

This is one feud that doesn't show any signs of slowing down - which is good news. Kofi, Xavier, and Big E are as entertaining as they've always been, and the Usos should basically be writing Roman Reigns' promos for him.

The New Day should get the win here, but only barely. There could be a distraction involved, perhaps, or other such shenanigans. Ideally, something should happen to give the Usos a real reason to demand a rematch.

Unless a Superstar Shake-Up, NXT stars, or Zayn and Dillinger forming a tandem is in the cards very soon, these two teams will probably be feuding for quite a while yet. Title changes will be inevitable in the near future, so it's best to pad out the time between each for as long as possible.

The championships only recently changed hands, so it's best to keep them with their current owners for the time being. Otherwise it will run the risk of turning this into a Charlotte/Sasha situation: a highly entertaining rivalry completely undermined by way too many title switches.


11. Tozawa Wins The Feud

Akira Tozawa Neville
WWE.com

Neville was a great champion, and had Akira Tozawa not captured the Cruiserweight Championship less than a week prior to SummerSlam, this entry may have been different.

There are a couple of reasons why Tozawa should keep the title. Under Neville's regime, face wrestlers were allowed to shine. With a good guy holding the strap, it's time for the heels to be given a chance.

Second, Tozawa will have only held the belt for six days. It's really too soon to do yet another title switch. It would render the championship match on Raw more pointless than it already was.

Neville was rescued from relative obscurity to swoop in and save the Cruiserweight Division. He entered as a generic face that could perform impressive feats of acrobatics in the ring. If Neville leaves, he will exit the division as easily among the top five heels currently working in the WWE. The Universal Championship is a little crowded at the moment, but a trade to SmackDown Live pending a possible second Superstar Shake-Up could do wonders for his career.

Based on the fact that this match was given away on free television, it will probably be on the shorter side. If that's the case, let's keep the Titus O'Neil shenanigans to a minimum, ok?


10. Styles Keeps The Title

AJ Styles Kevin Owens Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Fast title switches don't necessarily devalue a title. In this case, it's two phenomenal wrestlers constantly one-upping each other. But that doesn't mean we couldn't use some stability.

While AJ would be best used in the main event, giving him the strap for an extended amount of time could up the value. On the flip side, SmackDown Live desperately needs an injection of top level heels, with the recent failures of both Jinder Mahal and Baron Corbin.

The big question mark lies in SDL Commissioner and special guest referee Shane McMahon. The prodigal son having a say in the end result of the match isn't necessarily a bad thing. If McMahon screws Owens out of the title, it only gives the 'Prizefighter' more ammunition for some truly epic promos. It might also provide Owens a reason to be launched into the WWE Championship conversation.

The important thing here is that Shane doesn't feel the need to look like the toughest guy in the ring. He fancies himself a wrestler at the level of the men competing in the match, but when you throw punches with all the force of a butterfly landing on a flower, it's definitely not the case.

This has easily been one of the better feuds heading into SummerSlam, but it's time to end it now lest it become stale.


9. Cass Destroys Show

SS 17 Show Cass
WWE.com

How much explaining does this one actually need?

Enzo Amore will be suspended in a cage above the ring, which makes this the third time that's happened in a PPV match in 2017. Is it really so difficult to just ban people from ringside?

At this point in his career, Big Show is not at a stage where he should even have a singles bout on a PPV, let alone win one. Regardless of your feelings of Big Cass, picking him as the winner here is extremely easy.

Given how often we've seen the two giants interact in recent weeks, this is an easy contender for a five minute (or less) match. Cass hits a few big boots, gets the pin, then throws Enzo through an announce table or something. And then everyone involved, including the audience, moves on from this rivalry forever.

WWE, we know how much you like to give your favorite giant random pushes for no reason. We remember all those times you let Big Show bury Cesaro, or at Fastlane 2017 when Rusev got jobbed out. Resist the temptation, book the logical choice, and just let Cass get an easy win here.


8. Naomi Handily Retains

SS 17 Naomi Natalya
WWE.com

Was this even a feud?

Natalya won a five-way elimination match at Battleground, but the interaction between champion and challenger has been pretty minimal since that point.

There's no way Natalya should win here. She's by no means a real threat. That's especially unfortunate because she is easily one of the best women's wrestlers in the company, but has been treated as a joke for years (Thanks, Vince).

Both of these women are more than capable of putting on a great match, however. If they're given enough time and breathing room, it might be enough to give the SmackDown Live women's division an injection of legitimacy it so desperately needs.

What would the absolute best case here be? Naomi planting the seeds of a heel turn. She always seemed more natural in that role, and SDL has a lack of mega-heels among the women. If WWE is sticking with their guns with Charlotte Flair in a face role, then Naomi could be the villain that opposes her. Or perhaps the winner of the Mae Young Classic could become a contender instead.

Also, with the Baron Corbin debacle being so fresh in everyone's minds, Carmella cashing in her briefcase really doesn't need to happen here quite yet.


7. Shesaro Moves Through An Imploding Shield

SS 17 Cesaro Sheamus Shield
WWE.com

If Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins win the Raw Tag Team Championships from Sheamus and Cesaro on Sunday, then tag team wrestling is dead.

Was that a hyperbolic statement? Probably. But it would be quite insulting to the litany of tag team wrestlers. A cohesive tag team should always overcome two individual wrestlers that can't seem to be around each other for longer than 30 seconds without coming to blows.

Sheamus and Cesaro have been phenomenal so far as a tag team, ironically also starting out in a very similar situation to the one that Ambrose and Rollins find themselves in. With the sheer skill of Rollins and Cesaro especially, this is an easy contender for match of the night.

The former Shield brethren absolutely should not capture the gold. At least not in the position that they're in at the moment.

The best argument for Rollins and Ambrose to win is that it would give the pair something to do. A situation like that has never failed to damage the championship in question.

If the two get their act together, then they could easily be legitimate contenders at a later date. As it stands right now, however, they shouldn't stand a snowball's chance in hell.


6. Rusev Crushes The Viper

Randy Orton Rusev
WWE.com

It feels a little weird to say it, but Randy Orton hasn't won a PPV match since WrestleMania. First was the House of Horrors match against Bray Wyatt that we have all attempted to scrub from our respective memories. Then there was three straight jobs to Jinder Mahal.

Meanwhile, Rusev hasn't won a PPV match by pinfall or submission since 24 July 2016. It's been a while, managing only a count-out victory over Big Cass at Roadblock: End of the Line.

This feud doesn't make much sense, and seems more like an excuse to get both men on the card. For all of Orton's detractors, he's pretty much Teflon at this point when it comes to wins and losses. There's very little Randy could do to change his perception as a genuine star of the company. Gaining a submission victory over him would still be a pretty major accomplishment.

As of right now, Rusev is definitely not legitimate enough to be a qualified contender for the WWE Championship. A win over a 13 time world champion would, at the very least, slot him in for contention for the United States Championship. A feud between a self-proclaimed redneck in AJ Styles and someone that hates America could make for superbly entertaining television.


5. The Boss Reigns Supreme

SS 17 Alexa Bliss Sasha Banks
WWE.com

Alexa Bliss has been an absolute revelation for the women's division ever since she was called up from NXT. With that being said, Sasha Banks has yet to have any kind of substantial reign with the championship.

The money match has been at the edge of WWE's fingertips for months now, and it is finally time to pull the trigger: Sasha vs. Bayley.

The story has already been built. Sasha couldn't win the title from her best friend. So when Bayley goes down with an injury, Banks pounces at the opportunity and benefits from her friend's misfortune, taking the championship away from the women that Bayley wasn't extreme enough to beat.

Sasha's heel turn has been demanded for months. Despite being extremely over with the crowd, her personality is better suited for the woman she was down in NXT, the same woman that stole a headband from Bayley's biggest fan.

As for Bliss, she's so talented on a microphone that she can easily find a place for herself even without the championship. After all, Alexa could be the person most linked to manipulating tension between Sasha and Bayley. Watching her play puppetmaster from the sidelines could make her the biggest heel in the company.

All that's left now is the first step. Sasha wins Sunday, and gets the entire show on the road.


4. Mahal Escapes With The Title

SS 17 Mahal Nakamura
WWE.com

Put down the pitchforks and torches, internet.

Let it be known that this should in no way be a clean victory. Or even a victory at all. The best case scenario here is the champion getting himself purposefully disqualified in order to avoid a Kinshasa.

There are a number of reasons for this. First of all, there has been minimal build-up for this. As much as we'd all like to see Mahal relieved of his championship, the payoff could be so much better.

Also, there is a 0% chance that this will be the main event. Shinsuke's coronation should be for a PPV where it can be the biggest news of the night.

From a business standpoint, Jinder needs to not be hindered for a little while longer. WWE's India tour is fast approaching, and taking the title off of your Indian champion right before that happens is a bad sales move. Mahal touring with the WWE title could bring in some sorely needed revenue for the company.

WWE needs to be careful not to rush Nakamura into a title reign too quickly. Even the most popular wrestlers launched immediately to the front of the line can face backlash. Remember how popular Roman Reigns was during the Shield days? Remember how hated Kurt Angle was after he became WWE Champion?

Nakamura's time will come, but in the words of Juba from the movie Gladiator: "Not yet."


3. Bálor Beats Wyatt (With No Supernatural Shenanigans)

Finn Balor Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

Oh, how the mighty have fallen.

One year ago, Finn Bálor defeated Seth Rollins to become the inaugural WWE Universal Champion. It was a fantastic match effectively ruined by one of the worst crowds in recent memory.

Now, he's getting strawberry jam dumped on him by a man that tried to use projections to win a match at WrestleMania.

This is basically a question of who needs the win more, and, surprisingly, the answer is not Bray Wyatt. At Great Balls of Fire, 'The Eater of Worlds' beat Seth Rollins, while Bálor wasn't even on the show. At Extreme Rules, Bálor was ultimately the person that submitted in order to give Samoa Joe the win.

This Sunday promises the return of Finn's demon persona. The combination of the two's mystical gimmicks brings with it a potential for random occurrences, such as being hypnotized by Wyatt's crab walk, smoke appearing in the ring, or the return of those projected images.

Please. No.

Just let the two fight it out. This match was already given away for free on Raw, with Bray picking up the win. As much as 50/50 booking doesn't benefit anyone, Bálor is in a must-win situation right now. If being locked in a pointless feud with Elias Samson wasn't enough to drop Finn's standings, then a loss here definitely would.


2. Corbin Gets His Revenge

SS 17 Cena Corbin
WWE.com

Before SmackDown Live, the winner here was a much greater toss-up. Baron Corbin held the Money in the Bank briefcase, John Cena's career was winding down. Either could have used a win, but it wasn't completely necessary.

But now, Corbin must win - or his career prospects will be down the drain quicker than you can say "Damien Sandow."

As unlikely as it would be, a callback to SummerSlam 2014, in which Cena was systematically destroyed by Brock Lesnar, is the best call here if WWE is even slightly serious about keeping Corbin elevated.

Under most other circumstances, 'The Lone Wolf' dominating and either losing to a roll-up or a disqualification would be acceptable, if not ideal. However, as was already said, that finish is best used for Mahal vs. Nakamura. Relegating cheap finishes to both SmackDown Live's biggest matches would just damage the brand as a whole.

Corbin's only salvation is to be an unstoppable wrecking ball, hell bent on revenge against the man that cost him the WWE Championship. Anything less, and Baron can expect to headline the pre-show against Aiden English within a year.

There are many legitimate criticisms that one can level against Baron Corbin. Does any one of them justify being prevented from ever getting a chance to prove himself in the main event? Surely he couldn't be any worse than Jinder Mahal.


1. Literally Anyone Else Wins The Universal Championship

Brock Lesnar Braun Strowman Roman Reigns Samoa Joe
WWE.com

Paul Heyman stated that if Brock Lesnar does not walk out of SummerSlam with the Universal Championship, both will exit the WWE.

Good. Don't let the door hit you on your way out.

Of all the entries on this list, this is the least likely to happen. Lesnar is currently booked for a multitude of events after SummerSlam. It's really too bad that he doesn't deserve his paycheck.

There was a time when Lesnar was a legitimate draw, and facing him was nearly tantamount to a match against Undertaker at WrestleMania. That time is long gone. He has been reduced to sheer laziness. Brock's schtick of "arrive, bury a full-time wrestler that actually cares about WWE, leave" hasn't been appealing in years.

Keeping the belt on Lesnar is harmful to the entire product. It informs every wrestler that puts their life on the line week after week that their spot is being given away to someone that doesn't bother to look like he cares. The Universal Championship is barely defended and is treated like an afterthought instead of a great honor.

Backstage news says that Paul Heyman is strongly pulling for Samoa Joe to become champion soon. And despite being the least likely person to win the match, Roman Reigns would also be a better champion, a sentence which has probably never been written before.

End the madness, WWE. A Fatal 4 Way means that Lesnar doesn't even have to be the one to take the fall.


Contributor

I'm that millennial that's been destroying every industry. I also once placed fourth in a spelling bee.