WWE SummerSlam 2017: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best
All over the place.
This year's SummerSlam was... not exactly one for the ages, that's for sure. Bogged down by booking that made no sense and was essentially insulting to the wrestlers involved, to a match that had to take place in a virtually empty arena, there were a ton of bizarre mishaps which kept this year's show from being anything more than a wildly mixed bag.
It wasn't all bad, at least, with a handful of average-to-good matches and, yes, two genuinely great bouts in their own right. Still, the terrible matches bog down a show that absolutely did not need to run six hours and pump out a ludicrous thirteen (!) matches. It's just too much.
It'll be interesting to see where the various title changes and shake-ups lead, but in many cases it's hard to be optimistic, especially as SummerSlam was so thoroughly outdone by NXT TakeOver yet again. Biggest party of the summer? Not quite...
13. Randy Orton Vs. Rusev
Result: Orton murders Rusev with an RKO as soon as the bell rings (0:10).
Rating: While on one hand it was hilarious to see Orton score such a nonchalant victory after suffering a pre-match assault from Rusev, it was ultimately an incredibly weird and undeserved burial that was really more embarrassing and sad than anything.
Rusev totally didn't need or deserve this and it's a shame to see him put in such a spot despite his clear talent, while Orton continues to do little of mention or importance, which is also pretty depressing.
An insult to anyone who paid to watch the show, really. It gets one point because you might laugh. 1/10
12. Big Show Vs. Big Cass
Result: Cass lands the Empire Elbow for the win (10:30).
Rating: Firstly, there's no way this match needed to last over ten minutes, even with the Enzo cage shenanigans, and secondly, who even remotely cared about it?
The cage stipulation is immensely lame and has been way too recurrent lately to be at all interesting, though Enzo oiling himself out of the cage was slightly amusing... even if a whole lot of nothing came of it (other than a Big Boot, of course).
Something could've been done with Big Show's hand psychology-wise beyond his fine selling, but nope, this was basically a total damp squib, to be polite. 3/10
11. WWE Title: Jinder Mahal (c) Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura
Result: With a little help from the Singh Bros., Jinder is able to nail a (botched) Khallas to retain the strap (11:25).
Rating: For long stretches this was actually a relatively OK, watchable match, but was then irredeemably derailed by a head-smackingly terrible ending, with the predictable chump distraction that was compounded by Jinder's atrocious-looking Khallas.
Nakamura didn't look like the world-class talent fans know he is nor did Jinder look like the champ beloved by a nation that WWE wants everyone to think he is. Nak losing in such lame fashion after just going over Cena clean was an asinine booking call, and ensured this was basically a dud. 4/10
10. The Hardyz & Jason Jordan Vs. The Miz, Curtis Axel & Bo Dallas
Result: Miz blind-tags into the ring and sneaks up on Jordan with a Skull-Crushing Finale for the win (11:20).
Rating: You had to feel bad for these six guys having to wrestle in a mostly empty arena: it can't be good for morale and makes it so much harder to craft a compelling in-ring story.
The fact the match was only the fourth-worst of the show is impressive given the circumstances, with most of the six superstars getting a little time to shine, and Miz delivering a smart heel ending that was genuinely intelligent and not merely cheap.
It was fine, though it probably would've made more sense for Matt or Jeff to eat the pin here. 5/10
9. John Cena Vs. Baron Corbin
Result: Cena blasts Corbin with the AA for the victory (10:15).
Rating: An interesting choice for an opener that had sure potential, but ultimately wasn't up to too much of interest, with both Cena and Corbin waltzing through their typical routines without much variation or energy.
It's clear from the ludicrous result that WWE has no confidence in Corbin now, with Cena's victory doing nothing for either man. Corbin didn't even look good in defeat and the match totally lacked the PPV feel you expect from Cena.
By this show's standards, it's pretty much mid-tier fare, but Corbin really should've won. 5/10
8. Smackdown Women's Title: Naomi (c) Vs. Natalya
Result: Nattie makes Naomi tap to the Sharpshooter (11:10).
Rating: A solid effort that saw the two ladies trying their damn hardest to make the crowd care, and they absolutely deserve points for that. It didn't outstay its welcome, the closing submission spot was great, and Naomi's post-match heartbreak felt incredibly real.
Teasing the Carmella cash-in was a rather poor attempt to make the match more interesting, as it basically confirmed it wasn't going to happen, but the standard of the wrestling was good enough that it didn't need anything fancy tacked on.
Natalya may not be the most compelling champ moving forward, but it's unlikely she'll be anything more than a transitional title holder moving forward anyway, so it's fine. 6/10
7. Raw Women's Title: Alexa Bliss (c) Vs. Sasha Banks
Result: Sasha makes Bliss tap to the Bank Statement to win the gold (13:10).
Rating: This was a brutal and hard-fought match with a fired-up crowd, but it also lacked that extra something to take it to the next level, never really feeling like more than a very solid TV bout. As a result, Sasha's title win didn't have have the uproarious quality you would hope for.
As was a habit on this show, it really just felt like both superstars pulling from their well-worn playbook rather than doing much of interest, but they kept the fighting fairly stiff and it certainly didn't suffer from the awful booking of some of the aforementioned matches. 6/10
6. Cruiserweight Title: Akira Tozawa (c) Vs. Neville
Result: Neville kills Tozawa with the Red Arrow to win the strap (11:45).
Rating: This was well laid-out and probably deserved to be on the main PPV, even if it was lacking a little of the ferocity that would've made it truly great.
It's hard to ignore the weirdness of disrupting Neville's reign only to return the title to him mere days later: it's yet more questionable booking seemingly done solely for shock value rather than because it has any storytelling or character merit whatsoever.
Still, both men looked good and it was a fun, frantic match. 6/10
5. Bray Wyatt Vs. Finn Bálor
Result: Bálor lands the Coup de Grace for the win (10:40).
Rating: This was surprisingly short, but it was a relief to see Bray not get buried and actually put on his strongest PPV showing in quite some time (which perhaps isn't saying much).
Plus, Demon Bálor is always a hoot and he meshed well with Bray's zany antics but considering how the feud has been building, you'd be right for expecting a little more intensity and brutality. If any match on the show would've benefited from a stipulation (and no, not a shark cage), it was surely this one.
Still, it was perfectly fine and did what it needed to, which was give Bálor a victory. 6/10
4. U.S. Title: AJ Styles (c) Vs. Kevin Owens
Result: Styles blasts Owens with the Styles Clash to retain the strap (17:20).
Rating: Shane McMahon didn't really need to be involved here as a special referee, but he at least added a little more interest to yet another AJ/Owens match, even if the excessive knockout spots seemed pretty silly, clumsy and forced at times.
Still, Owens constantly hand-wringing about McMahon's officiating was absolutely hilarious, and the pace remained intense throughout. Not anywhere near their best work together by any means, and Shane bumped way too much to not be distracting, but by this PPV's standards it was really, really solid work all around. 7/10
3. Raw Tag Titles: Cesaro & Sheamus (c) Vs. Dean Ambrose & Seth Rollins
Result: Ambrose kills Sheamus with the Dirty Deeds to win the titles (18:35).
Rating: This was a ton of fun, in large part thanks to a lenient ref who let a lot of multi-man shenanigans go on, enhancing the match's overall intensity significantly.
It'd be remiss not to mention the hilarious spot where Cesaro ripped up a beach ball that was being passed around the crowd, and overall the match towed the line between being fun and white-knuckle perfectly. It had hope spots, near-falls, desperation and was basically just an incredibly tight tag match.
Ambrose and Rollins as tag champs is an interesting move for this stage of the careers, and hopefully it won't be blown in the blink of an eye (which, looking at the state of this PPV, is quite possible). 7/10
2. Smackdown Tag Titles: The New Day (c) Vs. The Usos
Result: The Usos kill Xavier with dual top-rope splashes to win the titles (19:20).
Rating: This was an insanely riveting tag match and easily one of the best that the main roster has put out in a long time. It ran long, the crowd loved every second of it, and it just got more scrappy and surprising as it went along.
This honestly might be the best kickoff match in WWE history, and it's hard to remember anything in recent memory that came anywhere close to this. It's a travesty that it wasn't on the main PPV, and was a great reminder of just how well these two teams work together.
Hopefully the Usos will keep the straps for a while and get to mix things up with a bunch of other teams on the PPV stage, because they really brought their A-game here and thoroughly deserved the win. 8/10
1. Universal Title: Brock Lesnar (c) Vs. Braun Strowman Vs. Roman Reigns Vs. Samoa Joe
Result: Brock scoops up Roman's Spear attempt and slaughters him with an F-5 to retain the belt (20:45).
Rating: This was one Hell of a main event, and in the eyes of some may have even redeemed the show (but surely not entirely). It wasn't finessed at all, but instead focused on the monstrous physicality of these four men, which is exactly what it needed to do.
There were multiple potential satisfying winners here, especially Strowman, who really shined with his destruction of Brock in the early going, but Brock winning also worked incredibly well, especially with Roman surprisingly being the one to eat the pin.
This avoided most of the multi-man pitfalls that drag these matches down and achieved the palpable chaos you'd want from these superstars. Say what you want about the show on the whole, but it at least ended strong. 8/10
-
What did you think of this year's SummerSlam? Shout it out in the comments!