WWE WrestleMania 36: Every Match Star Ratings (Night 1)

"This is what you wanted, right?"

According to noted wrestling journalist and the man behind the Wrestling Observer, anyone who does star ratings for a pre-taped show where the talent are able to rework segments they're not entirely happy with is an idiot.

Anyway with that in mind, hello everybody and welcome to some star ratings.

Now, far be it from me to question the wisdom of a man who still doesn't know where the normal reply button is on twitter, but since the Academy Awards aren't reserved purely for one-take performances inside a theatre, it seems strange to punish pro-wrestling for taking advantage of the same production benefits that help make cinema what it is.

And, well, in the circumstances, who could really blame WWE? This unprecedented time of global isolation has almost rendered the industry redundant but, somehow, someway, they have pulled together something resembling a WrestleMania card. It's been split across two evenings, taped in advance, and expectation levels are surely as low as they have ever been for the Show of Shows.

Still though, WWE has an improbable knack of pulling off great shows when its back is against the wall. Simply taking their hands off the wheel and allowing the creativity of the talent to steer them home. Could they do that on the most high-profile platform possible? Or will this year's pirate-themed spectacle sink without a trace? Let's find out...


8. WWE Women's Tag Team Championship: The Kabuki Warriors vs. Alexa Bliss & Nikki Cross

Alexa Bliss
WWE.com

Arguably the least enviable spot of the entire weekend, whoever opened Night 1 of the show was going to have to do something special to distract fans from the sudden reality of the situation. The state of things outside the ring could very easily have taken the focus off that was going on inside it but, credit where it's due, all four women here did an outstanding job in dragging your attention away from the empty seats.

The Kabuki Warriors have been (when WWE remembers they exist) so important to the WWE Women's Tag Team Titles, and they regularly overdeliver in regards to both the time and opponents they're given to work with. Bliss and Cross, to their credit also, looked like a great choice of opponent here as the pair regularly exchanged taunts that both filled the silence and helped progress the match.

Asuka, in particular, is brilliant at this.

In the end, Cross and Bliss outmaneuvered their opponents to set Sane up for a Twisted Bliss and take a relatively surprising win to kick off the show. I don't want to use the phrase "under the circumstances" too much but, if anybody gets extra points for it, it's these four as opening the show was a hell of an ask. In an admittedly uncrowded field, one of the better matches we've seen for these belt.

Result: Alexa Bliss & Nikki Cross defeated The Kabuki Warriors via pinfall (15:05)

Star Rating: ⭐⭐⭐


7. Elias vs. King Corbin

Baron Corbin Elias
WWE.com

What can possibly be said about this match beyond simply the fact that it happened?

Absolutely nothing, sadly. A confusing feud that will only roll on further after 10 minutes devoid of consequence ended with Elias grabbing the tights in a roll-up.

Result: Elias defeated King Corbin via pinfall (9:00)

Star Rating: ⭐


6. WWE Raw Women's Championship: Becky Lynch (c) vs. Shayna Baslzer

Becky Lynch Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

Arguably the only predictable match on the entire card, Becky Lynch finally defended her championship against Shayna Baszler in a match where the result was as necessary as it was foreseeable. WWE, as ever though, hate it when you've figured stuff out ahead of time so went the exact opposite way.

A surprisingly even contest saw Lynch routinely battle back from Shayna's positions of physical dominance. Brawls to the outside, heads smacked off tables, the pair did their best to paint this as a hard-hitter within the confines of a conventional wrestling match. Inevitably though, this became about both women trying to get their submission hold on.

Just as Shayna finally looked to have locked in the Kirifuda Cluth, Lynch managed to roll through and score the pinfall in a manner utilized by both Kairi Sane and Ember Moon back in NXT. Questions about this being the "wrong" result are for another article but, in the context of this match, it cut the legs out just as it was starting to get seriously interesting. For this to get less time that the match it followed was a travesty.

Result: Becky Lynch defeated Shayna Baszler via pinfall (8:30)

Star Rating: ⭐⭐3/4


5. WWE Intercontinental Championship: Sami Zayn (c) vs. Daniel Bryan

Bryan Zayn
WWE.com

It's a testament to the sheer scope of the quality WWE has at its disposal that this hastily cobbled together Intercontinental Championship match was on everyone's potential Match of the Night lists despite almost zero build. The fact it contained two of pro-wrestling's all-time best in-ring performers (with another 3 at ringside just for good measure) didn't hurt either.

In short, Daniel Bryan absolutely beat the piss out of Sami Zayn here, and it was a glorious sight to behold. The opening exchanges were stilted by constant interference from Cesaro and Nakamura, building up to Bryan finally getting his hands on Zayn but, when he did, my god the brutality. This is a rivalry that has come absolutely out of nowhere, shattered the teeth of those watching, and will hopefully continue whenever the company can get back to a sense of normality.

In the end, Gulak took out Sami's buddies, Bryan came off the top rope to be met by a modified Helluvakick. These men never disappoint, but with the constraints of time and having to invent a story between them almost on the fly it didn't reach the heights it was capable of. An outstanding, inventive encounter nonetheless, but one that leaves you wondering what they're really capable of together.

Result: Sami Zayn defeated Daniel Bryan via pinfall (9:20)

Star Rating: ⭐⭐⭐1/2


4. WWE SmackDown Tag Team Championship Ladder Match: John Morrison (c) vs. Jimmy Uso vs. Kofi Kingston

WrestleMania 36 Ladder Match
WWE.com

For well over an hour last night, WrestleMania belonged to these three men. Arguably the most bizarre match on an evening of bizarre matches that made up a weekend-long bizarre card, a triple-threat singles match to determine the tag-team championships will have been a new on to virtually every single fan watching.

But good god, did it deliver.

All three men, to their absolute credit, went into this match with the intention of treating it like a proper WrestleMania ladder match. Given the circumstances and capacity for creative editing you'd have forgiven them for trying to protect their bodies rather than delivering high-risk spots, but this contest will rightly rank up there with the best in this PPV's storied history.

The initial exchanges were blink-and-you'll-miss-it in-ring work, before the trio gradually introduced the unforgiving apparatus into the equation. After a slightly ropey segment where the silence in the arena really did the wrestling trope of slowly climbing the things zero favours, the three managed to recover it with a few enormous spots. Jimmy taking a ladder flush in the face while walking a barricade, and Kofi managing to catch Morrison in a hurrincanrana from halfway one.

The ending was slightly convoluted, with all three men getting their hands on the prize before a falling Morrison managed to (somehow) take both belts with him. However, that doesn't detract from the overall quality of the contest.

Result: John Morrison defeated Jimmy Uso and Kofi Kingston by climbing the ladder... sort of (18:30)

Star Rating: ⭐⭐⭐3/4


3. No Disqualification: Seth Rollins vs. Kevin Owens

Owens Mania 36
WWE.com

In a bizarre way, while Kevin Owens vs Seth Rollins will undoubtedly have been hurt by not having a crowd there to react to the ending, it also benefitted from them not being exhausted after the ladder match. We've seen many examples of great matches failing to get the crowd behind them after a spot-fest, and that could very easily have been the case here under normal circumstances.

It wasn't though, and arguably WrestleMania's longest-running feud finally got a payoff that justified that seemingly never-ending run of Monday Night Raw multi-man matches. Free of all distractions, free of all interference, Rollins vs Owens belatedly became a story worth telling. Albeit it at the second attempt.

A fairly by-the-numbers encounter was cut off from being another underwhelming chapter in this story when Rollins clocked Owens with the ring bell to cause a DQ. After challenging him to get back in the ring and restart the match with no disqualification or count-out, the two finally came to blows in a suitably satisfying way.

A falcon arrow to the apron induced a wince, but nothing compared to Owens' closing spot of diving from the WrestleMania sign onto a prone Rollins. This was, if nothing else, the customary high-spot that will likely define this year's event, but the story the pair managed to tell was more impressive than the fall.

Result: Kevin Owens defeated Seth Rollins via pinfall (17:20)

Star Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐


2. Universal Championship: Goldberg (c) vs. Braun Strowman

Braun Strowman Goldberg
WWE.com

Bill Goldberg is a 53-year-old man who walks very slowly down to the ring, repeatedly tackles men in the stomach, and then fails to get them over for a suplex. We have known this for a year now, and yet it was still all WWE could think to book here.

That's not to say The Goldberg Match isn't an entertaining proposition. It lit up WrestleMania 33 and produced one of the most shocking moments in the company a few months prior to that, but the problem is that we've just seen it all before at this point. To go through everything we did with the Fiend, just to have a rinse and repeat match a mere 6 weeks later, feels like a waste of all 3 men involved in this equation.

While it's easy to get suckered into some positivity purely for Braun's sake (this result is long overdue and a fitting reward for some of his previously unacknowledged work in the company) the match itself was not something he'll look back on with too much fondness. A quick flurry of spears from the champion, followed by a not-as-quick-but-equally-flurried succession of powerslams from the challenger, and that was it.

A predictable blast of adrenaline, but one that no longer has the power to take us by surprise.

Result: Braun Strowman defeated Goldberg via pinfall (2:10)

Star Rating: ⭐1/2


1. Boneyard Match: AJ Styles vs. The Undertaker

WrestleMania Undertaker AJ Styles
WWE Network

This feels like it should be an article in itself but, before I start, keep in mind that I'm of the belief that of all the things you need to judge pro-wrestling matches on, nothing is more important than simply how enjoyable it was in the moment. Build, story, athleticism, invention, history, innovation, endurance, legacy, all of them worthy considerations that count for nothing if you don't get a kick out of watching the thing.

Heading into this event, virtually everyone had dismissed this as a confusing, convoluted accident-waiting-to-happen. Coming out, it's the biggest talking point in pro-wrestling and has performers reaching across the yawning chasm of the brand divide to heap praise on those who put it together. This wasn't pro-wrestling as theatre, it was pro-wrestling as cinema.

To boil it down, this was a buried alive match conceived and filmed in the Matt Hardy-pioneered style most notably associated with the Final Deletion in TNA. We've seen others like it in WWE before, with its spiritual sequel the Ultimate Deletion, the House of Horrors match, even Halftime Heat back in '99, but this elevated the format to new heights.

Arriving with his older Biker persona (mercifully not "Booger Red") Taker and Styles brawled viciously across an abandoned facility, using all available structures and implements to hurt each other. A match virtually devoid of any "wrestling moves" Styles was helped by Gallows, Anderson, and a smattering of druids as he looked to have beaten his opponent down.

Confident he had the Undertaker in the hole, he headed to the dump truck to finally complete the burial, only for a blinding light to appear behind him as The Dead Man channeled his supernatural abilities to stage a comeback. From there, things escalated to a rooftop, where first Styles associates, then the man himself, were dispatched. Taker buried his opponent, his hand reaching through the soil, before driving off into the night.

The response across social media was overwhelming, and both men can be delighted that they've pulled off something this unique and entertaining from such a seemingly underwhelming program.

Result: The Undertaker defeated AJ Styles via burial (35:00)

Star Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐1/2


Managing Editor
Managing Editor

WhatCulture's Managing Editor and Chief Reporter | Previously seen in Vice, Esquire, FourFourTwo, Sabotage Times, Loaded, The Set Pieces, and Mundial Magazine