WWE WrestleMania 38: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best
Breaking down the wildest, most entertaining WrestleMania in years.
The very best WrestleManias manage to be both a genuine showcase of the WWE's most talented superstars and offer a stage for over-the-top shenanigans that fans won't ever forget.
This year's show did a mostly stellar job of splitting the difference: Night 1 offered more in the way of genuinely great wrestling, while Night 2 doubled down on absolute absurdity.
It's yet further vindication for WWE's two-night format, giving both the live and at-home audiences a breather compared to the traditional - and exhausting! - single-night show.
While certainly not one of the best WrestleManias of all time by virtue of pure wrestling quality, in terms of entertainment value it's absolutely one of the strongest in many years.
WWE understood the assignment in terms of firing up the crowd and making the most of the various gimmicks and part-time athletes on the card.
There was only one outright dud among the entire 16-match card, which is practically a miracle, while there were two genuinely great bouts that fans will be talking about for a long time.
The worst WrestleManias just come and go without anyone remembering them, but that certainly won't be true of WrestleMania 38...
16. The New Day Vs. Sheamus & Ridge Holland
Result: Sheamus destroys Kofi with a Brogue Kick for the win (1:40).
Rating: This was definitely a match that happened, and probably should've just been cut from the card entirely given what little it did for everyone involved.
The match was only really here to put over Sheamus and Ridge, but it scarcely left much of an impression at all, beyond the New Day wearing Big E's attire in tribute to him of course.
This felt like a bad sketch of a TV-caliber match: nobody will remember much of it within a week or less, and it could've been left off the card without bothering anyone. If time constraints were the reason for its brevity, why not send it to the kickoff show instead? 3/10
15. Pat McAfee Vs. Mr. McMahon
Result: Vince pins McAfee after punting a football into his chest (3:45).
Rating: Did anyone have this on their WrestleMania bingo card? Obviously a 76-year-old Vince McMahon wasn't going to do much here, and so Austin Theory basically did all the heavy lifting for him.
How do you even rate this? It probably could've been a minute long but dragged on a little more. It was hilarious, stupid, and while uniformly terrible as a wrestling match, was absolutely successful as campy theatre.
The real highlight of course came post-match: Austin Theory and Vince giving the best and worst Stone Cold Stunner sells of all time within two minutes of each other. 4/10
14. Omos Vs. Bobby Lashley
Result: Lashley puts Omos away with a Spear for the win (6:35).
Rating: Few were expecting much from this, but really all it had to be was a good old-fashioned hoss fight, and in that respect it was fine enough.
There wasn't anything particularly creative or interesting on display here, and Lashley deserves so much more for a Mania match, but it smartly wrapped up quickly while accomplishing its story goals - namely putting Lashley over while not burying Omos.
It was fine, and at least not the Omos squash many were expecting - it was a short, sweet, blunt instrument of a match. Omos is still incredibly rough around the edges but Lashley did well to carry him. 5/10
13. Winner Takes All: Roman Reigns Vs. Brock Lesnar
Result: Roman wins the unified straps after putting Brock down with one of many Spears (12:20).
Rating: For the supposed "Biggest WrestleMania Match of All Time," this sure as hell didn't feel like it. It was basically 12 minutes of two guys spamming their marquee moves at one another until one finally stayed down.
While it was a relief that this thing didn't drag on for a whole half-hour, it was still an underwhelming anti-climax on which to end a weekend of (mostly) quality wrestling.
Roman's win didn't surprise many and absolutely made sense all things considered, but you'd hope that such a heavily hyped match might do something beyond playing the hits and running the most basic beats.
And please, no more Roman/Brock Mania matches. We've had our fill for one lifetime. 5/10
12. SmackDown Tag Titles: The Usos (c) Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura & Rick Boogs
Result: The Usos put Nakamura away with the 1D to retain the titles (6:55).
Rating: This was a decent way to kick off Saturday night - it got off to a hot start, yet was unfortunately stopped short by Boogs' quad tear.
Up until then, the four men worked through the typical tag opener beats in well-paced fashion, ensuring everyone got their time to shine. It wasn't a particularly memorable Mania opener but certainly solid.
Nak had a great kickout spot near the end even if the finish was very clearly thrown together on the fly in a rush. Boogs' injury caused this one to hit a hard stop, but there wasn't much else that could be done. What we got was still pretty good. 6/10
11. Happy Corbin Vs. Drew McIntyre
Result: Drew kills Corbin with a Claymore for the win (8:38).
Rating: Nobody was expecting anything other than a Drew win, but it was a rock solid match overall. It didn't last too long, Corbin and Madcap Moss' shenanigans were a good laugh, and McIntyre's powerhouse athleticism entertained accordingly.
To be completely fair to Corbin they actually made him look competitive here, especially with that End of Days, even if Drew kicked out of it - which, at least, got a fantastic reaction from the crowd.
This was booked to its strengths and wrapped up within a sensible timeframe. A best case scenario for a match few were particularly excited for. Let's face it, though, Drew cutting the ropes with a sword was the easy highlight. 6/10
10. Women's Tag Titles: Naomi/Sasha Vs. Liv/Rhea Vs. Shayna/Natalya Vs. Zelina & Carmella (c)
Result: Sasha and Naomi kill Carmella with a double-team knee strike to win the titles (11:20).
Rating: Fatal-4-Way tag matches are always at their most enjoyable when shamelessly indulging in the chaotic demolition derby aspect, and that this did from start to finish.
But the real story here was that Sasha Banks finally won her first ever WrestleMania match, and scooped a title at that. You can argue that Liv and Rhea were more deserving winners, but seeing Sasha's Mania curse be broken sure was satisfying.
This match knew to move fast and just throw everything at the audience all at once. It was entertaining mayhem that verged on sloppiness at times, but wrapped up with a brutal finish. 6/10
9. Austin Theory Vs. Pat McAfee
Result: McAfee rolls up Theory for the win (9:40).
Rating: Somehow the Mania celebrity matches all turned out surprisingly well. While not a great bout this was moderately enjoyable, largely because McAfee's got such a larger-than-life ring presence and the crowd ate it up.
However nothing here was more over than McAfee's entrance theme, The White Stripes' "Seven Nation Army", which the crowd lovingly chanted numerous times throughout the match.
You knew where it was going and there weren't many surprises along the way - apart from McAfee's Moonsault, perhaps - but it did what it needed to and we all moved on.
There were some great near-falls, and the right guy won for a fun Mania moment that the crowd went wild for. Any mild frustration about Theory losing evaporated once it became clear what was coming next. 6/10
8. Rey & Dominik Mysterio Vs. The Miz & Logan Paul
Result: Miz puts Rey down with the Skull-Crushing Finale for the win (11:15).
Rating: Expectations are always sensibly low for WrestleMania's customary celebrity matches, though love or hate him, Logan Paul clearly put in the work to deliver an impressive in-ring performance.
Paul seemed totally credible opposite the Mysterios and played the heel part perfectly. The match as a whole was pretty standard fare, but never devolved into the embarrassing, headline-chasing silliness that the Mania celeb matches often do.
It was just long enough to let everyone get their licks in, and who among us didn't love seeing Logan Paul get hit with a Skull-Crushing Finale afterwards? Dare one say it, seeing Logan Paul in a WWE ring again wouldn't be the worst thing ever. Shocking. 6/10
7. Anything Goes: Sami Zayn Vs. Johnny Knoxville
Result: Knoxville rolls Sami up for the win (14:25).
Rating: The second celebrity match of the weekend was pure carny nonsense as you'd both expect and hope for given Johnny Knoxville's involvement.
It was all about the silly extras - Chris Pontius' Party Boy cameo, Wee Man body slamming Sami, the weaponised pyro, the bowling ball, and of course, the giant mouse trap.
Much as it's easy to say that Sami is wasted in this program, he sure seems like he's having fun out there so it's tough to feel too bad for him.
It probably ran a few minutes too long all things considered, but was fun for what it was, with Knoxville's goofy buffoonery colliding entertainingly with Sami's game commitment.
As comedy matches go, this was a blast. An appearance by Steve-O would've topped it off, though. 6/10
6. SmackDown Women's Title: Charlotte Flair (c) Vs. Ronda Rousey
Result: Charlotte boots Ronda in the face to retain the title (18:30).
Rating: Following up two absolute banger matches on Saturday night didn't do this one any favours at all, but Charlotte and Ronda mostly held their own, up until that dud ending.
It probably ran a bit longer than it needed to, but there were some killer submission spots - especially Ronda escaping the Figure 8 - and it truly felt like either woman could win.
The ending really harmed it, though: ref knockdown spots almost always come off as lazy, and that Big Boot finish was a total damp squib.
It fell far short of Becky/Bianca from earlier in the night, but was a respectably entertaining bout for the most part. 6/10
5. Raw Tag Titles: RK-Bro (c) Vs. The Street Profits Vs. Alpha Academy
Result: Orton RKO's Gable to retain the titles (11:30).
Rating: Sunday night's opener was what Saturday night's should've been - a fun, fast-paced thrill ride energised by an absolutely electric crowd.
RK-Bro were just insanely over from start to finish while everybody worked through the usual triple-tag formula, though there were a few inspired spots too - particularly the Street Profits' top-rope Blockbuster to Gable.
This did everything an opener should do - get in and out in a pacy fashion while firing the audience up for the bigger matches to come.
It just might be one of the most purely entertaining WrestleMania openers in recent memory, honestly, even if some were understandably disappointed that there wasn't a title change. Given the response to RK-Bro, though, it made sense. 7/10
4. AJ Styles Vs. Edge
Result: Edge puts AJ down with a Spear for the win (24:05).
Rating: This was absolutely gruelling both for better and worse. It felt incredibly physical with both men doing a fantastic job of selling how personal this match was to them, but it also dragged due to the glacial pacing.
The downtime between marquee moves definitely harmed the overall flow, but when it got into gear, it was great.
There were some fantastic near-falls here - especially Edge barely surviving a Styles Clash - though it's a shame things ultimately ended in such flat fashion.
While it's a relief that Damian Priest didn't get actively involved in the match, having AJ lose because of a momentary distraction felt like such an unfulfilling anti-climax. AJ's a pro - he should know better. 7/10
3. No Holds Barred: Kevin Owens Vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin
Result: Austin puts Owens down with the Stunner for the win (13:55).
Rating: Nobody was expecting anything from this but a demolition derby in which Stone Cold played the hits while K.O. bumped his ass off, and that's pretty much what we got, albeit with a little more physicality from Austin than anticipated.
It goes without saying that Stone Cold is miles past his physical prime, so the stipulation and Owens being the workhorse absolutely worked in the match's favour.
Austin didn't become yet another beloved superstar going out with an embarrassingly low-energy final fight, though: he acquitted himself well and went out respectably, even taking a few hard bumps in the process.
Not a great match in any conventional, technical sense, but it 100% delivered what everyone wanted to see, bringing an entertaining first night to a fittingly raucous conclusion in the process. 7/10
2. Seth Rollins Vs. Cody Rhodes
Result: Cody puts Seth down after a third Cross Rhodes (21:40).
Rating: No surprises here for Seth's mystery opponent, of course, and it was so great to see these two going at it, the result of which largely lived up to the hype.
The pacing was excellent, and there were some extremely gnarly bumps - especially the suplex over the top rope - ensuring that they quickly had the crowd eating out of the palms of their hands.
A Cody win was never in doubt, but the pair certainly made a Seth victory feel possible, especially after that Pedigree. Yet this was Cody's match to win and what an absolutely spectacular debut/return it was.
It was weird as hell to see Cody in a WWE ring, but in the best way possible. 8/10
1. Raw Women's Title: Becky Lynch (c) Vs. Bianca Belair
Result: Bianca finally puts Becky down with the KOD to win the strap (19:10).
Rating: This was ferociously intense right out of the gate and all the better for it. Becky and Bianca both played their parts perfectly - the dominant aggressor and plucky underdog respectively.
There were some absolutely killer near-falls throughout this dynamic, physically gruelling battle, which best of all was allowed to go long and show each woman pushed to the brink of exhaustion.
Either Becky or Bianca winning would've been satisfying, but a Bianca win was clearly the more crowd-pleasing outcome, and it was great to see her get another rapturous WrestleMania moment.
This might be one of the greatest women's matches in Mania history. In a just world it would've been Saturday's main event. 8/10