WWE WrestleMania 39: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True

Dreamlike new beginning for WWE, or nightmare-inducing WrestleMania that makes fans angry?

WWE WrestleMania 39 Cody Rhodes
WWE

WWE has a lot to get right at WrestleMania 39.

This is it - the season finale, if you like. It's expected to be a weekender packed with big title changes, feud-ending moments, huge surprises, and enough great matches that company announcers can call it "the greatest WrestleMania ever" with a straight face.

What if it isn't though? What if 'Mania 39 turns into a nightmare that Triple H, Vince McMahon and their crack crew of writers just can't wake up from? Oh yes, it's that time again. There's no room for stupid positivity here. This is the absolute worst that could happen on Saturday and Sunday nights in Hollywood.

Hey, a nearby film studio might end up making a horror flick about it. If so, directors would surely focus on the time family members showed an embarrassing lack of in-ring chemistry, Vinnie Mac's distaste for someone literally everyone else loves shone through, "Super Cena" ruined everything, swerves were booked for the sake of it, and WWE crowds rained boos down on the company for multiple reasons.

Start getting worried, because some (or all!) of this stuff might be waiting around the corner...

10. The Mysterios Don’t Have Chemistry

Rey Dominik Mysterio
WWE.com

...as opponents.

Rey and his boy Dominik definitely had more chemistry than some were willing to give them credit for as a tag-team, but actually working against one another in-ring could be a different story. Both father and son could be in for a rude awakening on the biggest stage possible.

Fan expectancy will be high when the bell rings. This is a Rey Mysterio match at WrestleMania, and there's a lot of chatter doing the rounds that he doesn't have too many of those left. Further, he'll be in there vs. his own flesh and blood, so Rey-Rey will be desperate to make Dom look as good as he can.

Imagine disaster struck and, just a few short minutes into their clash, daddy dearest stared at his rebellious son with a face that screamed, "Sh*t - we don't match up well at all as rivals". That'd be horrible for the whole family, and for the live crowd too.


9. Logan Paul Has A Stinker

Logan Paul WWE WrestleMania 38
Twitter @LoganPaul

Celeb YouTuber-turned-remarkably-accomplished-wrestler Logan Paul could be another who's on the outs with WWE after 'Mania 39. His contract is ticking down, so the weekend's showing vs. Seth Rollins might be one of LP's last for a while. If so, then he'll surely want to go out on a high with a bout that gets everyone talking.

It could, albeit for the wrong reasons.

Paul has been sensational across all four of his in-ring WWE appearances to date. It'd be awful then if...the mighty Seth Rollins couldn't bring more from him, and the pair wound up working a tepid showing that didn't reflect their hate-filled build.

Logan must be wary of overextending himself here. Necessary confidence could give way to unwanted arrogance, causing the celebrity to try some things out there that he didn't rehearse properly beforehand. Nobody wants to botch on WWE telly, and especially not when the world is watching at WrestleMania.


8. Vince McMahon Buries GUNTHER

Drew McIntyre Sheamus
WWE.com

Most generally agree that Vince McMahon wouldn't have handled GUNTHER's phenomenal Intercontinental Title reign with the grace Triple H has to date. Reports post-Vince retirement suggested McMahon actually planned to demote the Austrian (maybe even back down to NXT) at some point in late-2022, and even wondered aloud who the hell he was to others backstage.

Want to read something concerning? The Vin-man is back, and he might decree that GUNTHER has to go this weekend. That may well mean that full focus is on Drew McIntyre and Sheamus during the IC Title three-way, and that poor GUNTHER becomes an afterthought immediately following the pay-per-view.

Bummer.

Worse, McMahon might be tempted to go one step further and overrule Trips when it comes to the big guy too. It'd suck hard if GUNTHER went from final two of the Royal Rumble and long-running IC Champ to right back where he started on NXT shows.


7. Steve Austin = Diminishing Returns

WWE WrestleMania 38 Steve Austin
WWE.com

Glass shatters -> crowd pops -> Stunners -> beer drinking -> merriment.

That's typically how it goes whenever Steve Austin is in town, but last year's 'Mania win over Kevin Owens felt like a watershed moment for 'Stone Cold'. The question must be asked: Will wrestling fans be content to see him show up and run through his usual cameo stuff after that? Or, will they demand more?

Pre-'Mania, Austin was rumoured for bouts vs. everyone from Roman Reigns and Brock Lesnar to even LA Knight. There's still time for WWE to wheel the legend out last-minute, have him run over someone who doesn't have a spot elsewhere on the weekender (like Knight, actually), then book some beer-drinking fun.

A random/impromptu match like that wouldn't live up to the KO business last year, and it could smack of diminishing returns for the legend. Granted, Austin himself has said he's done in-ring, so this one is unlikely but...don't rule it out completely.


6. Austin Theory Gets Squashed

WWE Raw Austin Theory John Cena
WWE.com

Nobody needs to see this.

Would John Cena winning get a cheer? Absolutely. Are there those out there who'd love to see him win the United States Title and work some open challenge segments again? No doubt. Does 'Big Match John' have time for that due to his Hollywood schedule? Nah, not really.

Besides, Austin Theory is the future of this company (or at least a big part of it). He doesn't deserve to get squashed flat by somebody who's only really been brought in to help elevate him. Surely that's WWE's thinking here - they wouldn't cut Theory off at the knees or make him look like a 1980s jobber at 'Mania, would they?!

It'd be a nightmare if the match started, Austin went for a punch, Cena ducked, and then the icon sprinted through his usual signature offensive moves before scoring the win. 90 seconds later, Theory would be dead in the water as an ongoing concern.


5. The Wrong Match Main Events Night One

Charlotte Flair Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

People will not stop chewing fingernails over this until Saturday night rolls around, and with good reason. Build for Charlotte Flair vs. Rhea Ripley has been lacklustre. It certainly doesn't scream "WrestleMania main event"; not even apologists for the writers could claim they've done a bang-up job with the SmackDown Women's Title story.

It's a midcard attraction at best.

WWE might disagree, and the fact there's even discussion about Flair vs. Ripley going on last for night one is very, very worrying. Everyone knows that Kevin Owens teaming with Sami Zayn vs. The Usos is the right headliner for Saturday night. That isn't even really up for credible debate at this point.

If creative think babyface Charlotte vs. cool-as-f*ck Judgment Day "Mami" (and popular Royal Rumble winner) Rhea Ripley is going to play before cheers for Flair and boos for Rhea, then they're simply deluded. Please, please, please make the right call, guys.


4. WWE Stick With Babyface Charlotte Flair

Charlotte Flair 2023
WWE.com

Welcome to part two of this nightmare.

Babyface Charlotte Flair has been one of the dirt worst things about WWE's product since she launched back into that smiling facade right before the new year. Her good guy promos come across as so insincere, and the promotion has had to pipe in obviously-fake positivity for her segments on SmackDown.

This writer gets shivers when he thinks about this, but WWE could see 'Mania as the ideal time to give Charlotte a main event win on the grandest stage and pretty much complete her career. That'd leave poor Rhea Ripley staring into the night skies and directionless all over again.

Let's be crystal clear about something. If Triple H and Vince McMahon want WrestleMania 39's opening night to echo the jeers that rained down on Roman Reigns back at 32, then they'll book Flair to go over Ripley in the headline spot.

That wouldn't sit well with anyone.


3. Kevin Owens Swerves Sami Zayn

Kevin Owens Sami Zayn
WWE.com

F*cking hell, this would be ghastly!

Kevin Owens is going to turn on Sami Zayn at some point, or vice versa. They didn't get to this stage in their careers by being all nicey-nice with one another for good, and yet another feud between the old pals/rivals is coming later in 2023. What if WWE jumpstarts that at 'Mania though?

To get there, they'd need KO to swerve Sami by booting him in the face before walking out and leaving him helpless against The Usos. Jimmy or Jey would then pin Zayn, end his "WrestleZAYNia" hopes, and march on as Undisputed Tag-Team Champs as Owens later remarks that he wasn't sure he could trust Sami.

It'd make zero sense to do this, but more illogical swerves have happened in pro wrestling history. Hopefully, if any writers do come up with this outcome, they're told to sit down and shut up during last-minute creative meetings.


2. Cody Rhodes Loses/Cuts A "Sorry" Promo

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

WWE would've agonised over the result of Roman Reigns vs. Cody Rhodes for months. On one hand, Roman has been such a success as the biz's top heel. On the other, Cody has roared back onto this roster with passion, popularity and a genuine World Champ-ready aura.

His story, one obsessed with winning a belt to honour the memory of his late father Dusty, is real and impactful. So, it'd be a bit sh*tty if WWE poured cold water all over that just to keep Reigns ticking into the summer months. Hell, the 'Tribal Chief' deserves a break from carrying the company on his back anyway.

It's Cody's turn. Or is it?

Tears would be shed if he lost then cut a mournful promo about letting his family down when it mattered most. Heartbreak can be a useful tool in wrestling, but fans are ready to see Rhodes ascend the mountain and leave with the title.

If he doesn't, then there will be a lot of disillusioned faces in LA.


1. Fans Think A New Belt “Looks Stupid”

WWE title belts
WWE

Triple H probably plans to introduce a brand new World Title look on the Raw after 'Mania 39. Alternatively, 'The Game' could bust out WWE's new belt(s) right at the tail end of the pay-per-view on Sunday, and let either Roman Reigns or Cody Rhodes parade around with them.

Remember SummerSlam 2016 and the negative response to that new Universal strap? Fans spent much of Seth Rollins vs. Finn Bàlor dissing the belt's aesthetic, so WWE might wait until after Roman vs. Cody to show it off. Sadly, that wouldn't protect them from hate if people thought it looked rubbish.

"That looks stupid" chants at the end of 'Mania? Ooft.

It'd be an odd low point for Roman's otherwise-outstanding run as a heel if fans hijacked his latest supershow win to lob insults at WWE's Hunter-approved championship. Fingers crossed this weekend's showcase doesn't end with an unruly audience.

What other WWE WrestleMania 39 nightmares could come true? For more content, check out 10 WWE Stars Who HATED Their Own WrestleMania Matches and WWE WrestleMania 39: 20 Things That Must Happen!


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.