WWE WrestleMania 39: 20 Things That Must Happen

Cody Rhodes lives his dream, WWE books HUGE returns and more WrestleMania 39 must-haves.

WWE WrestleMania 39 Cody Rhodes
WWE

It's here and it's huge!

No, your writer isn't referring to walking skyscraper Omos. He isn't even talking about the vast crowds that'll funnel into SoFi Stadium this weekend or the pyro budget WWE will pay up on Saturday and Sunday nights. Nah, this fan is talking about WrestleMania 39 generally.

That excitement is in the air. Can you feel it? The usual, "10 Things That Must Happen" just wasn't enough for a twin-attack of 'Mania magic, so everything has been souped up and supersized to match the buzz surrounding this year's bumper weekender.

The dawn of a new era is upon us, but there's still a ton of business WWE has to take care of on the undercards before reaching those tantalising main events (and one of the matches discussed here better be night one's main event!).

Title switches aplenty, surprising heel turns that reform factions with unfinished business, colossal comebacks that light up the grandest stage and more - these are all WrestleMania 39 must-haves for WWE, and they simply must happen.

Here's how the company can make this weekend even more special.

20. Austin Theory Beats John Cena

Austin Theory John Cena
WWE

'Mania's opening match is already special to Austin Theory.

He'll stand across the ring from his childhood idol, and he'll likely come out on the winning end then walk away with a smug grin on his chops. Sh*t, wouldn't you smile from ear-to-ear if you'd been booked to beat the mighty John Cena at WrestleMania?!

Theory winning is the only outcome that makes any sense. Cena's Hollywood schedule is far too busy to nail down some sort of return match or title loss pre-SummerSlam, so Austin taking him 'A-Town Down' sounds like the right thing to do on Saturday night in Cali.

Kicking off the historic weekend with a young star of the present/future going over someone from WWE's past would be a real sign from creative that they've got big things in mind for Theory. This would be the kind of pay-per-view win he could hang his hat on for years to come.


19. Both “Showcases” Are Kept Short

Vince McMahon WrestleMania 39
WWE

Vince McMahon's long-held bid to cram as many names onto the 'Mania card as possible admittedly comes from a good place - WWE wants to give as many workers as possible a cracking payday, and it'd definitely suck to be on the roster but find yourself "Mania-less" come springtime.

Cool, but...keep these "Showcases" on the shorter side, eh?

Neither one is particularly important in the grand scheme of things (WWE hasn't even announced any kind of incentive, or if the bouts will offer a tag title shot afterwards), and everyone knows it. These are thinly-veiled substitutes for those Battle Royals that went from main card > pre-show > SmackDown.

Two four-way tag bouts will buffer between the bigger matches in SoFi on Saturday and Sunday. Hell, they might even take place on the same night. Who knows? One thing everybody knows is that they must be relatively brief and go with the AEW Trios Title blend of spots, spots, spots to stand any chance.


18. Ronda Rousey & Shayna Baszler Dominate

WWE WrestleMania 39 Showcase Liv Morgan Raquel Rodriguez Natalya Shotzi Sonya Deville Chelsea Green Ronda Rousey Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

First up, the women's situation.

Ronda Rousey and Shayna Baszler are future Women's Tag-Team Champs. Watch this space on that after Rousey's spectacular takedown of company creative, but it seems logical. After all, the writers have been on/off building the pair as division destroyers since late-last year.

Come 'Mania 39, they should rush through the (frankly weak) competition and come out on top in the first "Showcase". What's the alternative? That Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez continue doing next-to-nothing as random partners? That Natalya ditches Shotzi for Tegan Nox again, or finds her 875th tag-team pal in the last 12 months?

Surely, Ronda and Shayna are the only choice. They've got some juice as a duo, and they'd be fine challengers for Becky Lynch and Lita whenever WWE decides to break that pairing up. That, and announcing the number one contendership stakes beforehand, is the least fans can expect from any of this.


17. Alpha Academy Get To Shine

WrestleMania 39 Men's Showcase
WWE.com

SHOOOOOOSH!

OK, so Otis has had his head turned by Maximum Male Models lately, but it'd be a bit of a clanger to give up on the fine Alpha Academy tag-team just yet. They've got chemistry on the mic, and they both complement each other well in-ring too.

Braun Strowman and Ricochet probs won't team for longer than a few more months, The Street Profits certainly don't need another tag title whirl for a while, and WWE has shown once again that they've got nothing of substance for The Viking Raiders.

So, this is Chad Gable and Otis' match for the taking.

It'd feel great to see Gable, in particular, score a win on one of the biggest cards of the year. He's rarely been taken too seriously in company circles despite being one of the best workers WWE has on its books. Hopefully, those folks calling the shots toss him an olive branch here.


16. Bobby Lashley Helps Omos

Brock Lesnar Omos
WWE

Brock Lesnar vs. Omos still sounds like the kind of exhibition that used to be the norm on 'Mania cards in the late-1980s/early-90s more than something that'd fly in 2023. However, WWE is solidly behind the towering giant, and they trust Brock to bring the best out in him this weekend.

Cue Bobby Lashley, who has sod all else to do post-Bray Wyatt, running in to help the big guy win, stick it to Lesnar one more time and reform a rejigged Hurt Business faction on Monday nights. Would it make much sense after everything Bobby has been through with MVP and Omos? Not really, but WWE has nothing else for Lashley.

Another bout vs. Brock could be on the menu post-'Mania.

Seeing the ex-WWE Champion fall in line behind new centrepiece Omos would be interesting too. Yeah, some folks will hate this. There isn't much else to do with Bobby going forwards into the summer months though.


15. Bianca Belair Retains

WWE WrestleMania 39 Bianca Belair Asuka
WWE.com

Well bloody hell, WWE's build for the Raw Women's Title match has been rubbish. Creative couldn't give less of a toss about Bianca Belair vs. Asuka, and that means fans are struggling to get invested in the feud too. This is a real drop-off for Belair at 'Mania, sadly.

She's retaining all day here.

Asuka winning would be considered a minor shock, if only 'cause Bianca's lengthy title reign deserves better than to end 'just because'. Who knows, maybe these women will produce the goods and turn some heads on the midcard this weekend. They're up against it though, and WWE only has itself to blame for that.

Personally, this guy would keep the belt on Belair for now, then figure out something higher-profile for her heading into SummerSlam. Honestly? She's rather lost in the mix due to iconic comebacks from Lita and Trish Stratus, and her match defo comes across as one of 'Mania 39's least important.


14. Miscommunication Helps Damage CTRL

WWE WrestleMania 39 Damage CTRL Trish Stratus Lita Becky Lynch
WWE.com

Damage CTRL were, somewhat tragically, seeking some damage control of their own mere months into their run together as a trio. Things have settled down into 2023, at least, but most expect them to stare at the lights for the Trish Stratus, Lita and Becky Lynch group at WrestleMania.

They shouldn't.

If anything, Bayley's faction should capitalise on some miscommunication on the babyface side and come away with a momentum-boosting win. WWE's end goal is to get to Trish vs. Becky anyway, and that's why those two (literally) butting heads and causing Lita to shake her own noggin sounds like a winning idea.

Bayley taking advantage and pinning Becky would add more fuel to the fire when it comes to a babyface breakup too. It would not sit well with Lynch if she was embarrassed by one of her biggest enemies on the grand stage, and it'd be even less tolerable if Stratus was partly responsible.


13. Trish Stratus Holds Becky Lynch's Belt Aloft

Lita Becky Lynch Trish Stratus
WWE.com

Despite losing, Lita would rally the troops and ask that they thank the fans for supporting their efforts. That's when Trish, in the most subtly heelish way possible, would grab Becky's tag title belt and hold it aloft next to Lita. Again, this wouldn't do much to foster friendship with Lynch.

Stratus wants to cost her a WrestleMania win then celebrate with her title?! That just won't do. Suddenly, 'Big Time Becks' would show off some of her old fire as 'The Man', grab her strap, eyeball Trish and storm off. Lita's moment would be ruined, and it'd be all Stratus' fault for disrespecting Becky.

Ooh, the drama.

Going the heel route with Trish in 2023 is fairly risky due to her legacy role, but it's hardly impossible. Snatching Lynch's title and kinda/sorta acting like she's part of the Women's Tag-Team Champs too would be a neat way to get to Stratus vs. Lynch long-term.


12. GUNTHER Shows His IC Strength

WWE WrestleMania 39 GUNTHER Drew McIntyre Sheamus
WWE.com

When was the last time people were this excited for an Intercontinental Title showdown at WrestleMania? The much-loved belt was last defended at 'Mania when Apollo Crews and Big E met in a "Nigerian Drum Fight" two years ago, but spotlight has become a rarity for the IC strap.

GUNTHER vs. Drew McIntyre vs. Sheamus changes that. Fans are right up for seeing these three workhorses chop the living p*ss out of each other, and hopes are high that this will become an instant Intercontinental classic which makes up for years of championship neglect on the biggest WWE stage.

Prediction: GUNTHER pins Sheamus again, and heads for a one-on-one match vs. Drew somewhere down the road. Then, assuming WWE ends his long stint as champion, the Austrian can move up a level to challenge for the Undisputed/WWE/Universal/World Title.

You just know creative will want to run GUNTHER vs. Cody Rhodes back at some point.


11. Randy Orton RKO's The Miz

Randy Orton WWE WrestleMania 39
WWE

Surprise!

The Miz drew WWE's short straw when he was announced as the guest host for 'Mania 39. That's...a spot on the show, but hardly a great one. The best Miz can hope for is to be involved in Randy Orton's return - he'd bump big style for the first RKO peeps have witnessed for a while.

Of course, this all depends on Randy's health. He's been going through hell with serious back injuries recently, and the rumour mill has even wondered if he'll ever return at all. Fingers crossed on that one, and fingers crossed on a token RKO to The Miz on Sunday night.

That'd get a sizeable pop from the live crowd in attendance. Best of all, there'd be no pressure on Orton to launch headfirst into a full-on schedule again. He wouldn't need to actually work a match for months. Just seeing him smash someone with the odd RKO would be enough in the interim.


10. Seth Rollins Shows Respect To Logan Paul

Seth Rollins Logan Paul
WWE

Haters be damned: Logan Paul has shown an astonishing affinity for top-tier WWE matches since making his debut way back at WrestleMania 38. Singles bouts vs. The Miz and Roman Reigns have both been smash hits, and there's no reason to expect anything other than another scorcher vs. Seth Rollins.

Rollins, who still seems to have a bit of a chip on his shoulder even though he's one of the best wrestlers on the roster, will be out to prove a point to WWE. There's no way he'll walk out of SoFi until he and LP dazzle the masses, so this could be some match.

It's one Seth should win, but the real story would happen after the bell; Rollins would acknowledge how impressive Paul was, and extend the hand of respect. That'd get the live crowd on side, and such respect would be reciprocated by Logan in front of a packed house.

Then...


9. Who Then Cheapshots Him

WWE Raw Seth Rollins Logan Paul
WWE.com

...that dirty, no good bastard!

The scenario you see pictured above from a past episode of Raw will repeat at 'Mania. Rollins, triumphant in victory and willing to let bygones be bygones, would extend a hand towards Logan Paul. At first, the celeb would accept, but then boot Seth in the stones just because he could.

There's no way this feud ends this weekend, put it that way. It's been a fun trip thus far, and hearing Logan snipe at Seth for being 'a typical, handshake-spamming stupid wrestler' could take things up a gear heading into Backlash and beyond over the coming months.

Being humiliated when he was trying to be gracious would tip Rollins over the edge and give him motivation to pursue some sort of gimmick bout vs. Paul. That'd gift fans another in-ring epic, and it'd let LP keep honing his chops between the ropes.

Oh, and it'll also ensure the hate for him kept on pouring in.


8. Rey Mysterio Puts His Boy Over

WWE WrestleMania 39 Rey Dominik Mysterio
WWE.com

It's hard to imagine Rey Mysterio agreeing to beat Dominik.

Daddy dearest will want his boy to be as successful as possible, and he'll also view putting him over at 'Mania as a real honour. Keep in mind, Rey is also being inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame this weekend, so it's gonna be an emotional one for him anyway.

Going from that to giving his son a leg up on the biggest show(s) of 2023 sounds like a sweet and sentimental weekend for Rey-Rey. It's hardly like WWE wouldn't be able to get to some sort of rematch with a heel win - Dom will rub his win in everyone's faces relentlessly on TV.

His victory would reflect another member of Judgment Day's success, and it'd be a real love-in backstage for the Mysterio clan overall. They've been waiting on this sort of moment for a long time, and it's almost here.


7. Rhea Ripley Avenges ‘Mania 36

WWE WrestleMania 39 Charlotte Flair Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

Expect to see signs like, "If Rhea Ripley Loses, We Riot!" on show in SoFi Stadium. Some 'Mania match results seem like a given going in, and Royal Rumble winner Rhea dethroning unlikeable babyface Charlotte Flair is one of them. It better happen.

The Rumble's sense of purpose will be lost in an instant if it doesn't.

Ripley leading the way as SmackDown Women's Champion on Fridays sounds way more of a laugh than Flair's unacceptably-poor string of face promos that somehow come across as the most condescending speeches ever. Charlotte is a natural heel, so she must return to that role immediately after WrestleMania 39.

Think of this as Rhea's revenge for what happened back at 'Mania 36 in 2020. Three years have passed since then, and she's ready to take her rightful place atop the women's division again. WWE won't f*ck it up this time - they can't afford to stick by Flair as a duff face champ.


6. Edge Goes Brood Style

The Brood
WWE.com

Major sources say Gangrel will return to WWE at 'Mania 39. Nobody really knows what kind of part he'll play on the show, but it'd make sense if he was there for Edge's entrance pre-Hell In A Cell bout. After all, Finn Bálor will assume his 'Demon' guise again, so a Brood reunion seems plausible to counteract that.

You also know what that means: BUCKETS OF BLOOD.

WWE won't have Edge or Finn bleed (unless it's hardway and "accidental") inside the cage, but they could circumvent that by bringing stage plasma aplenty to the party. Even if they don't, and blood doesn't play a major role in the Cell match, then simply having Edge/Gangrel (sans Christian, obviously) go Brood style would be enough.

This could be Edge's final hurrah on the biggest stage of WWE's year, and he'll want to go out with a bang. Paying homage to his humble beginnings in the promotion would be a fitting way to cap off an unbelievable career.


5. A Legend's Final WrestleMania Win?

WWE WrestleMania 39 Edge Finn Balor
WWE.com

He should win it as well.

Again, this could end up being Edge's last major singles bout at WrestleMania. The legend has been openly speaking about winding down this second WWE run on his own terms. Nobody wants to see him go, but everyone would respect that he retired through choice this time.

Finn Bálor would feel blessed to do the job for Edge at 'Mania. This Hell In A Cell match is also the endpoint for Mr. 'Rated-R's' story with Judgment Day, and that stretches back an entire calendar year - it's time to close the book on that, and there's no better way to do it than with an Edge win.

One can picture an exhausted icon basking in the afterglow of the moment as WWE's cage lifts back up into the heavens. He could really take his time with that celebration, and enjoy the spoils of another 'Mania classic.


4. KO & Sami Zayn Become Tag Champs

Sami Zayn Kevin Owens
WWE.com

No surprises here.

The Usos have been Raw Tag Champs for over 300 days, and SmackDown Tag Champs for well over 600 days. They've (rightly) dominated the doubles scene in WWE, but Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn are worthy replacements for Jimmy and Jey heading through the rest of 2023.

KO and Sami received one of the biggest pops in modern WWE history when they hugged it out in front of fans. They're no stranger to big reactions - both have produced some of the hardest-hitting moments as rivals and as best friends. In short, they're absolute gold together. Note the key word there!

Gold is exactly what Owens and Zayn will have after WrestleMania 39. Then, WWE can either decide to break the Raw and SmackDown belts up over the summer, or bring them together as standard WWE Tag-Team belts again. Choices, choices, choices.

The only thing that isn't a choice? Read on to find out.


3. And That Match Headlines Night One

WWE WrestleMania 39 The Usos Kevin Owens Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Rumours have been flying around all over the place for months that WWE plans to headline 'Mania 39's opening night with Charlotte Flair vs. Rhea Ripley. In truth, that'd be a disaster. Their match doesn't feel worthy of that spot, and the build has been rather uninspired all-round.

The Undisputed Tag Title match is a better pick.

Flair vs. Ripley has the makings of a flat ending to the first card, being brutally honest. Meanwhile, Kevin Owens teaming with old pal Sami Zayn to beat The Usos will play before huge interest from the live crowd and everyone watching around the globe. There's no contest.

The Undisputed Tag match has to main event night one. Christ, Charlotte vs. Rhea wouldn't even rank as anyone's second choice for the headline berth - Edge vs. Finn Bálor and even the Intercontinental Title three-way rank well above it in terms of consumer interest.

Give it to KO, Sami and The Usos. Reward them for brilliant Bloodline storytelling.


2. Roman Reigns Accidentally Drops Jey Uso

Roman Reigns Jey Uso
WWE

It seems Roman Reigns will take some time away from the WWE spotlight for a while after 'Mania 39. That could be for the best, because he's been on top for years now, but a three-four month break doesn't mean the company shouldn't set something up for his eventual return.

His opponent at SummerSlam? Jey Uso.

There's been a lot of simmering tension between Roman and Jey, and that goes all the way back to their initial feud in 2020. Now, after everything that's been happening in The Bloodline, Uso is struggling to convince anyone that he properly trusts Reigns' leadership.

Jey's doubts would skyrocket if Roman accidentally smashed him with a spear, or something, during the weekend's main event vs. Cody Rhodes. Then, when Reigns does stroll back into view after a holiday, he'd be primed and ready to watch The Bloodline empire crumble for good opposite his very own flesh and blood.


1. Cody Rhodes Lives His Dream

WWE WrestleMania 39 Roman Reigns Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

The time has come for someone else to carry WWE's product.

Roman has more than done his bit, and this Cody Rhodes story is far too precious to scupper. Watching him stare skyward and say something like, "I did it, dad" after winning the twin WWE/Universal Titles at 'Mania 39 would be a moment in time that'd live forever.

Originally, people had The Rock earmarked to end Roman's dominance. They could still meet on pay-per-view in the future, but Cody has roared into view as the best man for the job of tearing Reigns' championship empire apart. He's even survived the threat of beloved babyface Sami Zayn scooping up his glory, and did so unscathed.

Rhodes deserves to become Undisputed WWE Universal Champ, then roll out on Raw wearing a brand new version of the WWE belt that's been rumoured. This is his destiny, and his promise to Dusty. Sometimes, the outcome everyone can see coming is the right way to go.

What else do you think must happen at WWE WrestleMania 39? For more wrestling, check out 10 WWE Stars Who HATED Their Own WrestleMania Matches and Ranking All Of Goldberg’s WWE Return Matches From Worst To Best!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.