WWE WrestleMania 40: 20 Nightmares That Could Come True

Triple H and WWE wouldn't do all of THIS and ruin WrestleMania...would they?!

WWE WrestleMania 40 Cody Rhodes Roman Reigns The Rock
WWE

There's a lot WWE must do during WrestleMania 40 weekend.

People want major title changes, fabulous landmark moments, cameos to remember, and two cards that sit amongst the best 'Mania has ever produced. Can Triple H and his writers meet those expectations head on? What's more, can WWE's roster deliver the goods and double down on company momentum they've created in early 2024?

If you believe everything in this article, then no. Everything will go wrong, and WrestleMania XL will be remembered as WrestleMania XS - as in, extra small, because...well let's just roll with it. These are nightmares, and everyone knows barely anything makes sense when you're having a "scary dream" anyway.

There's scant positivity here. This is the absolute worst that could occur across the biggest weekend of WWE's year. So, instead of all those pro wrestling pressies you're surely anticipating, 'Mania 40 might have sagging performances, unwanted belt switches, and an ending flatter than someone on the receiving end of a Roman Reigns spear.

Trips could have a riot on his hands in Philly if things go this badly...

20. A Brotherly Battle Sags

WWE Raw Jey Uso Jimmy Uso
WWE

Last year, this match would've been hot sh*t and closer to the top of WWE cards. Sure, Jey vs. Jimmy in a battle of brothers is still valid, but the bloom is definitely off the rose for Bloodline stories sans Roman Reigns or (latterly) The Rock. Also, Jimmy has been cast as more of a wisecracking hanger on than a serious threat recently.

The Usos could have their work cut out for them on Saturday night.

Obviously, everyone hopes they smash it and put on a performance closer to Bret vs. Owen than Matt vs. Jeff, but there's a real concern this sibling scuffle could sag in the middle and never recover. WWE will have to be real careful with the bout, because the build has been uninspiring to say the least.

What a nightmare it'd be for Jey especially if the match sucked and Triple H lost faith in anything Bloodline-related outside the core heavy hitters. These lads created cinema before, but now they've been tasked with turning a 'B' movie into Hollywood's next blockbuster.

It could be rough.


19. Jade Cargill Has An Awkward Debut

Bianca Belair Jade Cargill Naomi
WWE.com

Nothing is certain in a pressure spot like the one Jade Cargill is about to live. Is the former AEW star determined? No doubt. Talented? You bet. However, she's also making her first proper in-ring appearance for WWE at Wrestle-freaking-Mania. That's a lot to put on someone's shoulders, so fingers crossed she comes through unscatched.

Of course, creative might fudge Jade's debut even if she's Kurt Angle out there. The writers blatantly fancy programming Cargill opposite 'Mania partner Bianca Belair at some stage, which could come into their thinking when deciding the weekend's winners and losers.

Maybe Bianca will f*ck Jade and Naomi over and cause a Damage CTRL win. That'd rule for the heel side, but it'd make Cargill's first match pretty awkward. She's someone Triple H views as a big star of the future, so it'd be counterproductive if 'The Game' gave Jade a flimsy start to life in-ring on the main roster.

Eek.


18. Chad Gable Costs Sami Zayn

WWE Raw Chad Gable Sami Zayn
WWE

It remains to be seen whether or not Chad Gable actually wants to help Sami Zayn conquer GUNTHER. After all, Sami occupies a challenger spot Gable himself wanted for the biggest show(s) of the year, so his character would logically be a wee bit peeved that he's been overlooked. There might be a swerve a-comin'!

Is Sami about to be SHOOSH-ed?

GUNTHER is probs ready to drop the Intercontinental Title and give someone else a run with the secondary strap. Zayn would be a popular choice, not least due to his meteoric rise as a babyface over the past few years. If Chad screws Sami over in Philly and prolongs GUNTHER's reign, then it'll be more of the same on TV.

No, this is the right time to end his record-breaking IC Title tenure and move Imperium's leader up the card. If Gable is going to turn on Zayn, then he should do so at a later date rather than at 'Mania when WWE has the chance to shake things up.


17. Nobody Cares About This Tag

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL Rey Mysterio Dragon Lee Santos Escobar Dominik Mysterio
WWE.com

Do you care about this match at all going in?

Apologies if that sounds harsh and like some internet writer just wants to lambast WWE booking for the sake of it, but...this tag doesn't feel 'Mania worthy. Rey Mysterio and Dragon Lee vs. Santos Escobar and Dominik comes across as something people would expect to see on SmackDown, not on April's spectacular.

Hell, it'd barely fit onto a 'B' level PLE. This is a TV match dressed up to give some folks a nice WrestleMania payday. That's cool and all, but the worry is that fans in Philadelphia use Rey and Dom's latest father vs. son chapter to go check out merch or visit the bathrooms. What a bummer that'd be.

Rey likely doesn't have too many 'Mania appearances left in him, so it doesn't sit well to picture thousands of disinterested punters strolling around the stadium glancing at the ring in between conversations with stewards about where the nearest restroom is.


16. Nobody Cares About The Street Fight

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL Final Testament The Pride
WWE.com

The Pride vs. Final Testament could suffer from the same problems.

WWE has tried to give this bout some juice by tacking on a localised "Philadelphia Street Fight" tag. They're trying to appeal to old school ECW fans there, and doing everything in their power to make sure people don't go for a whizz during this one too. It's just as well this and the aforementioned tag are on different nights!

Sunday's brawl should be a vehicle for Karrion Kross to get over as a stable-leading badass who has more menace than Bobby Lashley or The Street Profits. If not, then it'll be a total waste and Kross will be right back to square one as a heel who says mean things but can never back them up.

One simply can't shake the image of fans sitting on their hands as six guys stiff one another with weapon shots and sweat buckets to entertain. That'd be pretty depressing for all involved, 'cause they really need this feud to peak properly soon.


15. WWE Misses The Boat On LA Knight

LA Knight AJ Styles
WWE.com

AJ Styles has got himself into superb physical condition and definitely has at least one more WWE main event run in the tank before winding down. The man's one of the best to ever pull on a pair of boots, but he shouldn't get the nod on Sunday. This night belongs to none other than LA Knight.

He's gone from Max Dupri to super-over babyface, for crying out loud. Knight even headlined vs. Roman Reigns over in Saudi Arabia, and there's clearly way more to come from the electrifying promo artist in 2024. To keep burning brightly, LA will need to come out on top vs. Styles and gut it out.

That's a must.

Triple H would be doing himself a disservice by stepping on Knight for no good reason. WWE generally does a top job of protecting stars who need to be protected, and that's where LA is right now. He needs a bit of faith from the folks penning this stuff.


14. That Grudge Match Is Far Too Tame

AJ Styles LA Knight Police
WWE

Don't forget that Knight invaded AJ's house, and Styles also travelled all the way over to Australia just to screw LA out of his Elimination Chamber dreams. In other words, these rivals have gone to extreme lengths when trying to both professionally sink and physically wreck one another. That intensity must crescendo at 'Mania.

The crappy thought for this one is that WWE believes a straight up pro wrestling match (with rules!) is the way to go about things. Yeah, rope breaks, count outs and disqualifications won't cut it for a feud that's had the babyface act as a home invading psychopath. More is needed than chain wrestling, people.

A tame encounter would be hellish.

The easiest way to remedy this is to add a last-minute stipulation to the match. Triple H could appear on camera backstage during the pre-show and say officials found LA and AJ scrapping backstage. 'So, they'll settle everything once and for all No Holds Barred'.

Simple, eh?


13. Night 2 Gets Another Unnecessary Match

Bronson Reed
WWE.com

A few midcard names are conspicuous by their absence from both nights at WrestleMania.

There's no room on either card for Ricochet, Bronson Reed, Ivar, Shinsuke Nakamura and the like, for example. Then, on the women's side, everyone from Nia Jax and Natalya to Liv Morgan and Tiffany Stratton will be posted missing. That is, of course, unless WWE runs one of those dreaded Battle Royals for the sake of it.

SmackDown has the usual Andre The Giant Memorial again this year, but there's no female Battle Royal to speak of. Will Trips cave there and make sure loads of others get a slice of the big 'Mania money pie? Don't rule it out. Last-minute additions certainly aren't out of the question.

The other solution would be an exhibition like Ricochet vs. Reed or Stratton vs. Natalya. Neither of those sound worthy of the WrestleMania name though, and neither night can support too many lesser bouts. A couple are already on thin ice with fans as it is.


12. Co-United States Champs?!

Kevin Owens Randy Orton
WWE.com

Good lord, the build towards Logan Paul's latest United States Title defence has been utter b*llocks. Kevin Owens and Randy Orton have actually worked more like tag-team partners than opponents, and everything just has this peripheral vibe to it. You can almost picture creative palming the story off during crunch meetings.

They've got bigger stories to focus on.

The way Orton and KO have been getting along leads to another question: Could the babyface duo pin LP at the same time somehow and end 'Mania as co-US Champs? WWE tried that many moons ago with the IC belt and the on/off Chris Jericho and Chyna partnership, but it's been a while since the co-champs thing has happened.

Paul dropping the midcard prize would be puzzling regardless, but to do so because Randy and Kev want to share the spoils? Nah, that'd be unacceptable. Keeping the belt exactly where it is sounds like the best course of action. No co-champs, please.


11. Surprise! It’s The Hardy Boyz (Again)!

The Hardys AEW
AEW

OK, so this is just a bit of fun and only here 'cause Matt Hardy talked about it during a recent interview with Chris Van Vliet. The interviewer wanted to know what Matt thought about fans fantasy booking a Hardy Boyz return at WrestleMania 40. Their tip off? The fact WWE has booked a multi-team ladder bout.

Hardy's AEW future is still up in the air, but he has revealed that a new contract with Tony Khan's company is in the works. There's also doubts over whether or not he and Jeff's deals expired around the same time. Basically, there's a lot going against this idea, but Matt himself added: "Never say never".

So, why would The Hardys at 'Mania 40 be a nightmare? Well, there's a 'been there, done that' feel to them returning this way. Matt and Jeff popped the place back at 'Mania 33 in 2017, but a lot has changed since then. AEW performances have exposed how limited they are in-ring nowadays, and another comeback under similar circumstances to the last would surely lead to diminishing returns.

Again, it's highly unlikely anyway.


10. Rhea Ripley Gets Shortchanged

Becky Lynch Rhea Ripley
WWE

Becky Lynch has a book to promote and would defo enjoy holding the Women's World Title when out on the beat selling it. 'The Man' has won oodles of gold over the years, but Rhea Ripley's belt would be a fresh addition to her trophy cabinet (unless you're content to continue lineage on from the old SmackDown Women's Title).

It'd be a downer for Ripley fans though.

Rhea is clearly the present and future of WWE's female ranks. She, Jade Cargill, Tiffany Stratton and a few others represent the new wave of women supplanting Becky, Charlotte Flair and pals long-term. Further, Ripley hasn't actually achieved everything she presumably hoped to with the title since winning it - she's been more of a non-wrestling character on TV over the past year.

It'd be a little sh*tty if WWE pulled the rug out from underneath 'Mami' when she's visibly coming into her own as a tour de force on programming. Becky is great, but she honestly doesn't need this title win to cement her legacy. That's already set in stone, so her winning would only scuff Rhea's lustre.


9. Bianca Belair Screws Bayley

Bayley Bianca Belair
WWE.com

To be clear, this fan wants Bianca Belair to turn heel soon. However, he doesn't want the 'EST' do so at the expense of someone like Bayley. There's always a chance WWE will book an out for reigning Women's Champ and new Damage CTRL leader IYO SKY though. Belair rushing out to ruin Bayley's moment would make some sense within the context of current storylines.

Seeing Bayley look all Cody Rhodes circa 2023 rejected would also be lame.

She's riding the crest of a wave as a reborn babyface these days, and seems like an improvement (in terms of a viable character, at least) over IYO for the title. Having Belair run down the ramp to cause a Philly screwjob would be pretty cheap, and it can't happen on Sunday.

WWE might've formatted both major women's matches the way they have for a reason. Then, after Rhea retains and maintains the status quo on Raw, Bayley can offer something fresh and exciting on SmackDown by beating SKY. No Bianca interference required.


8. Drew McIntyre’s Dream Collapses

Drew McIntyre Angry
WWE

WWE announced that the next Clash At The Castle will take place close to Drew McIntyre's hometown of Ayr in Glasgow, Scotland this coming June. It isn't a stadium show like the one in Wales, but that should be a momentous occasion for the big Scot...or not. What if his World Title dreams crumble at 'Mania?

As his countrymen and women say, that'd be "baws".

McIntyre has never been more ready to seize the day and win a World Title. Yes, he was raring to go back in 2020 before COVID scooped his glory slightly, but that was during the babyface hero days. In 2024, McIntyre is one of the finest heels going, and he'd be an excellent choice to replace Seth Rollins in the hot seat on Mondays.

There's a simple reason why WWE's writers would toss Drew to one side and focus on others. Perhaps they're content to look past him. Y'know, look past him towards a feud that was actually creative's original plan in the first place...


7. Because WWE Looks Past Him

Seth Rollins CM Punk
WWE.com

...this!

CM Punk will be around ringside as a guest commentator for the World Title showdown between defending champ Seth and undignified challenger Drew on Sunday night. Many expect he's only there to get involved in the finish somehow. That could be it, but what if this is bigger than that?

WWE won't have given up on the thought of booking Punk vs. Rollins once CM recovers from injury. Naturally, Seth has had some injury woes of his own to contend with, but it's only a matter of time before this mega-match hits company rings and spikes serious interest on PLE. It'd be rotten if McIntyre's challenge was a makeweight for more build towards that.

We're not quite finished with the nightmare-inducing thought of WWE pushing number one troll heel Drew to the side for the rest of 2024 mind. Not by a long shot. There's also the not so small matter of somebody else and a contractually-guaranteed opportunity.


6. Damian Priest Cashes In MITB

Damian Priest WWE Money In The Bank
WWE.com

Money In The Bank could do with a rest.

The idea has been fun for decades, but Damian Priest's current plight sums up why the briefcase gimmick should go on the shelf for a while. WWE doesn't know whether to stick or twist with the Judgment Day man. He doesn't fit into any World Title scenario neatly heading into WrestleMania, but they're running out of time to cash in.

That could cause panic behind the scenes and force Hunter to pen a hasty cash in moment for Priest that ends badly for everyone. Drew McIntyre's moment would vanish, Seth would taste some of his own medicine from 'Mania 31 in 2015 against someone he's hardly been paying attention to, and Raw's writing team would have a lesser-feeling World Champion on their hands in Damian.

That's not necessarily his fault. He was hotter last year than he is currently, chiefly 'cause creative has shone a spotlight on other characters more than Priest. WWE is in a strange position of not wanting to make JD's heavy hitter look weak but also probs not wanting to put gold on him.

Yikes!


5. This Is It For Paul Heyman

WWE Crown Jewel Roman Reigns Paul Heyman
WWE.com

Is that a wrap on the iconic career of Paul Heyman?

ECW's old 'mad scientist' will be a WWE Hall Of Famer by the time he carries the Undisputed Title down the ramp for Roman Reigns in Philly this weekend. That'll be a special moment for someone who has been a maverick trailblazer since the moment he caught Dusty Rhodes' eye by being brash and enthusiastic about all things pro wrestling.

Here's the thing: WWE doesn't have a non-wrestling character as skilled on the mic as Heyman. His promos, whilst definitely formulaic over the past few years, have their place and help keep stories motoring along even when the actual wrestlers themselves are absent. He's one of the most useful tools in the entire company, in other words.

Paul E still has a ton to give both in front of the camera and behind the curtain too. He's one of wrestling's most savvy minds, so it'd be a shame to see him bow out suddenly just because Roman's 'Tribal Chief' dominance is coming to an end.

If it is coming to an end.


4. Expected Cameos Don’t Happen

Stone Cold Steve Austin
WWE

Social media has been abuzz about the thought of seeing legends like Steve Austin and John Cena hit the ring to help Cody Rhodes in his quest to "finish the story" for weeks now. Raw's production truck Easter egg got people talking for the right reasons, and most predict that 'Stone Cold' and 'Super Cena' will be on tap for 'Mania.

Nothing is certain.

WWE might've been playing with the internet fanbase during The Rock's beatdown skit. There's a chance neither Austin or Cena will be in the house for WrestleMania's main event. Alternatively, if they're in attendance at all, then the company may prefer them to work a cameo elsewhere without leaving fingerprints on the weekend's blowoff bout.

That'd leave many disappointed, and it'd be another missed opportunity for 'Mania. Having Austin and Cena roll out to stop Rocky and Roman Reigns from continuing to monopolise the product sounds like a hoot. Their respective entrance themes alone would play before booming pops.


3. The Rock Struggles To Keep Pace

The Rock WWE 2024
WWE.com

Cast your minds back to WrestleMania XXVIII and 29 (this roman numerals stuff has always been a bone of contention, apparently) in 2012 and 2013. At the latter, The Rock put John Cena over before bowing back out of WWE for the time being. In total, they worked just short of 24 minutes in-ring.

Rocky was quite clearly blowing out of the people's butt less than halfway through.

In fairness, any pro wrestler will tell you that all the gym cardio or weights in the world won't prepare someone for working a full match. That could be why WWE elected to shove Rock in a tag at 'Mania, but some will still be keeping a beady eye on his gas tank to see if it's running on empty regardless.

It'd be a shocker for The Rock if he was knackered, turned into The Ultimate Warrior from 1996, and could barely keep pace with Reigns, Cody Rhodes and Seth Rollins. Those three are all finely-tuned road warriors compared to Dwayne (Roman's part time schedule notwithstanding).


2. Cody Rhodes Eats A Stupid Pin

WWE WrestleMania 39 Roman Reigns Cody Rhodes Spear
WWE.com

The result of the opening night's main event tag is very, very important. Win, and the babyfaces will ensure The Bloodline is barred from ringside for Cody's rematch with Roman. Lose, and Rhodes will have to work "Bloodline Rules". Putting Rocky and Reigns over is fine, but...

...having them literally pin Cody on night 1 sure wouldn't be.

Sorry to any Seth Rollins fans out there, but it's he who has to take the fall for this one. WWE can protect Seth somewhat by having Drew McIntyre stick his beak in, or maybe a Damian Priest attempted MITB cash in can distract him long enough for a Rock Bottom or Superman Punch finish.

It'd be totally senseless of Triple H if he had Rhodes stare at the lights though. That's avoidable, and it'd be daft to see the big babyface hope crumble before he steps into the ring one-on-one with Roman for the second 'Mania running. Keep Cody safe, Trips! Your night 2 main event depends on it.


1. Roman Reigns Beats Cody Rhodes Twice

Cody Rhodes is sad
WWE

What an awful thought this is.

Last year, the air was sucked right out of SoFi Stadium in California when Roman Reigns defeated Cody Rhodes and retained his spot atop the WWE mountain. Fans couldn't believe it, but the risk paid off by leading us to this rematch in Philadelphia. Cody maintained his popularity, but he wouldn't survive another failure on that scale.

It'd be one of the most disheartening moments in promotional history if WWE had Rhodes fail in his quest a second time. Instantly, all that babyface support would start to evaporate faster than fans around 'American Hero' Lex Luger back in 1993-1994. There's only so long creative can hold out on Cody's win.

WrestleMania 40 cannot close with another disconsolate babyface wondering what might've been. This year's version demands celebratory fireworks, tears for the right reasons and Cody staring up at the night sky mouthing, 'I did it for you, dad'. That'd give everyone goosebumps.

Attention, WWE. Do not spurn this chance.

What other nightmares could come true at WWE WrestleMania 40? For more wrestling, check out 10 Fascinating WWE Backstage Facts About The Undertaker and WWE WrestleMania 40: 20 Things That Must Happen! 


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.