4 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE Raw (15 December - Results & Review)
Gunther, Punk salvage holiday season Raw from typical doldrums of okay matches and little happening.
WWE television around the holidays is almost always guaranteed to be “safe” programming. You’re not going to get a world title change or an nWo “third man” moment in December.
Monday’s episode of Raw fit snuggly into this category of a boilerplate program. The matches were mostly good, but immediately forgettable and fairly inconsequential. There were some good moments on the program, but they were in service of larger angles that won’t come to fruition until 2026.
Among the true highlights, Gunther predictably (and rightly) kicked off the show to nuclear heat with minimal effort. And then the crowd apparently wore itself out, because they spent the next two hours mostly sitting on their hands.
CM Punk delivered a Punk-esque promo, ditching his “Is it great to be alive in…” shtick and just dialing up the vitriol three weeks ahead of his World Heavyweight Championship defense. (Interestingly, Punk will have gone more than two months without defending the title since he won it last month.)
And WWE’s latest “masked man” mystery ended with the most obvious payoff that it would have actually been a legit shock if someone other than Austin Theory unmasked.
While not offensive, this ultimately felt like a mostly skippable show, right on par with a typical December Raw.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
5. …And Then The Bell Rang
The Maxxine Dupri training montages in the Dungeon received high praise for being slickly produced and conveying strong emotions. But the looming criticism was always there that, eventually, Dupri would need to get into the ring, and unless she had been holding back for the past six months, the house of cards was going to fall apart.
Monday night, Dupri stepped into the ring against former friend Ivy Nile to defend her Women’s Intercontinental Championship for the first time. There really was no mystery here: Nile hasn’t had a televised singles match since June and hasn’t won a TV match since October 2024. There was naught chance she was going to upset Maxxine, but that’s not entirely a criticism; you need to have those churn title defenses every now and then.
The match itself, however, was disappointing, with Dupri out of place a few times and struggling through some sequences. When she wrestled a veteran like Becky Lynch, those mistakes were minimized on the fly. It’s no knock against Nile, but it’s not fair to expect her to be able to cover up those shortcomings as well as Lynch.
Eventually, Maxxine hooked an ankle lock and kept reapplying it until Ivy finally tapped out.
While this wasn’t that good, it’s somewhat admirable that WWE is sticking with Maxxine Dupri and trying to make it work, because she’s getting a decent reaction, and her Cinderella story is a rare instance where the company is just leaning into a feel-good story and letting it ride.
4. A Hot Finish Doesn’t Redeem Tepid Tag
Once upon a time, the New Day versus the Usos was appointment viewing, a can’t-miss tag team battle between two of the most decorated duos in WWE history.
But in 2025, it was an opening match on a mid-December Raw with minimal promotion. And it wasn’t very good either.
New Day was just off their excellent tag title match against AJ Styles and Dragon Lee, so it’s clear that they still can deliver in the ring, but the newly reunited Usos have regressed as solo acts in recent years, and they don’t have any of the zip they used to as a tandem.
Large swaths of the match played out to silence – which was strange because the crowd had been white-hot for Gunther just minutes earlier – unless they were yelling “Yeet!” whenever Jey Uso did something. Things got a bit hotter toward the end with the finishers and saves, but that’s just typical WWE shortcut booking and the Pavlovian response from fans.
It’s just hard to watch Jimmy and Jey stumble about, throwing the kind of weak-looking superkicks you might have dished out to your mates at university when playing around. Jimmy’s spear looked horrible, and then he completely whiffed on his half of a 1D, rendering it a simple flapjack.
Either way, Usos won, so they’re back. Whatever.
3. "It’s Austin Theory"
Maybe if he hadn’t spent the past two years as a goof in a mid tag team, Austin Theory’s reveal as the masked man attacking wrestlers wouldn’t have felt like such a letdown.
The masked man struck again during the main event, stomping Rey Mysterio to help Logan Paul defeat the Hall of Famer. He then fled when CM Punk raced down to the ring, steel chair in hand. The attacker raced into the crowd, where he unmasked and just stared – and the crowd went mild.
Look, it’s entirely possible that WWE has a plan to finally elevate Theory that doesn’t involve him losing his first name, or jobbing to an announcer, or stealing a golden egg. But that is an incredible amount of suck to overcome.
Let’s reserve final judgment for a bit, but we’re not holding our breath.
2. Boilerplate Matches
On paper, the card for Monday Night Raw looked pretty solid: two title matches, a tag match that essentially doubled as a number one contender’s match, and a popular Hall of Famer fighting a hated member of the top heel faction on the brand.
In execution, this was a holiday season Raw if ever there was one. WWE already is loading up the first episode of 2026 with big, consequential title matches, while next week’s episode is shaping up to be more exhibition (Je’Von Evans in action, Rhea Ripley facing Asuka, and Roxanne Perez battling Bayley) than something of significance.
Monday’s show itself was “there,” with one title match ending in a double-disqualification, and the other with an obvious finish. The main event was a 15-minute match where everyone was just waiting for the last five minutes and when the run-ins would start, and maybe something interesting would happen. (If you don’t consider Austin Theory revealing himself to be the masked man, then you were disappointed.)
Stephanie Vaquer versus Raquel Rodriguez wasn’t a bad match, but once Big Mami Cool said she wanted to face the Women’s World Champion alone, it was pretty obvious that we weren’t getting a real finish.
Setting aside Gunther’s nuclear heat (which existed in a universe of its own as an extension of Saturday Night’s Main Event) and CM Punk’s fiery promo, the rest of the show felt skippable if you had anything remotely important or interesting to do.
1. Dead Crowd Kills Raw’s Energy
THE USOS ARE SO BACK ? pic.twitter.com/veJbHBnzoy
— WWE (@WWE) December 16, 2025
After the opening segment of the show, it seemed like a safe assumption that we were in store for a hot show with a fired-up crowd.
It only took 10 minutes to completely disprove that assumption, as the Hershey audience went silent for large parts of the night, resulting in the dreaded “hair dryer noise” from the crowd, a dull, monotonous murmur that served as the soundtrack for much of the evening.
The fans were quiet for large parts of the matches and even CM Punk’s in-ring promo, only coming up for some signature spots or some particularly spicy comments. The most glaring example came during the Women’s World Championship match, where fans basically sat on their hands for the entirety of the contest until it became clear that Stephanie Vaquer was about to hit the Devil’s Kiss on Raquel Rodriguez, which shows you how conditioned they’ve become.
While the fans deserve some criticism, really, the blame must be laid at WWE’s collective feet, as they’ve spent years training audiences to not treat the matches themselves as important athletic competitions where the outcomes are consequential. They’ve taught fans that what happens during the first three-quarters of a match ultimately is unimportant, and that entrances, catchphrases, signature spots, and “moments” are what’s truly important.
Conditioning fans to focus on only certain aspects of your product means that they don’t react to the other 75% of what happens during a live broadcast, so they sit there politely until it’s time to either chant “This is awesome” for a basic wrestling sequence, or to freak out because Vaquer is performing a move that makes Booker T climax.
UPS…
4. One Good Thing About Nikki Bella
Nikki Bella’s heel run has been a net negative so far, but WWE might have found its way into something useful and mildly interesting.
Bella interfered in the Women’s World Championship match between Stephanie Vaquer and Raquel Rodriguez, attacking both wrestlers and causing a double-disqualification. This came after Raquel had laid Nikki out while the Hall of Famer was trying to demand a rematch last week.
What makes this intriguing is that it seems that Rodriguez is playing a bit of a babyface (or at least less of a heel) in this situation, allowing Bella to be the heel the fans hate. If the two of them tangle, Raquel should be the default face, which then could factor into Judgment Day dynamics.
Of course, this could all be wish-casting, and all of it could be utter sh*te. But in a “glass half-full” approach, this has some decent potential with Nikki serving a purpose for the full-time wrestlers.
3. Heating Up Women’s Tag Division
The women’s tag team division has been one of the bright spots for WWE in the latter half of 2025, and they had another good night on Monday.
The Kabuki Warriors delivered a pretty decent pre-taped promo, with Asuka and Kairi Sane focusing their venom on Iyo Sky for betraying her family and refusing to apologize for siding with Rhea Ripley. Because she chose Rhea, both women would “know nothing but pain.”
Later, Rhea and Iyo made their way out to the ring, but Asuka popped up in the crowd along the barricade and misted Ripley, while Kairi dove off the barricade and dropped Sky. The Kabukis laid out both women, with Iyo covering Rhea and taking an Insane Elbow while protecting her blinded friend.
Beating up two very popular babyfaces with a no-frills, no-nonsense sneak attack? Perfectly good stuff from the heel champs, and it raises the temperature for their Women’s Tag Team Championship match in three weeks.
2. Full Of Punk And Vinegar
After Bron Breakker cut two acidic promos directed at CM Punk, the World Heavyweight Champion finally got to respond Monday night, and he didn’t waste any time in cutting into his 5 January opponent.
Punk started by calling him a “cross-eyed, Neanderthal nepo-baby” and went from there, attacking the entire Steiner family’s intellect and pointing out that Breakker only pinned him at WarGames after his entire team hit finishers on the champ. He warned Bron that Paul Heyman repeatedly gasses up the “next big thing” and then quickly moves on when they fall short of expectations.
And Punk warned Breakker that if he ever mentions AJ Lee’s name again, their feud would become personal, and he would “rip your eyes out of your head and piss on your single-digit IQ brain.” Well, that was a visual.
As promos go, Punk has cut so many great ones that the majority fall into a tier below the greats, but are still better than what 90% of the WWE roster recites most weeks. Monday’s screed had some good fire behind it and dispensed with any pleasantries, which made it feel more “vintage Punk.”
Best of all, Punk attacking Bron’s father and uncle made him guilty of the same thing he was angriest about with Breakker: making the rivalry personal by going after family. And then he paid for it an hour later when Bron speared him post-main event.
1. 52 Words
Not since Roman Reigns uttered five words (“This is my yard now!”) after defeating The Undertaker at WrestleMania 33 has an opening segment on Raw generated so much heat with so few words.
Gunther led off Raw Monday night to deafening boos and chants letting him know how the crowd felt about him. He soaked it all in, then encouraged the jeers by posing on the announce desk and turnbuckle, egging on the fans.
When he finally grabbed the microphone, he simply yelled, “I did what I said I would do. I made John Cena give up. And when he gave up, he tapped out like a little b*tch!” Gunther would go to leave but return to the ring – twice – before standing on the desk to more or less repeat himself and drive the message home to the crowd: he was reveling in the fact that he will be forever known as the man who made Cena give up.
But we weren’t done there.
Gunther walked backstage and scoffed at Alpha Academy and R-Truth before Raw GM Adam Pearce flat-out called him an a**hole and kicked him out of the arena.
Outside, Gunther ran into AJ Styles, another wrestler who has announced his retirement, and another potential victim for the Ring General. AJ said nothing, but the point was clear: Gunther is a career killer, and he’s going to enjoy adding trophies to his shelf. Styles’ last match might be 12 months out, but we’re already invited to envision who might send him off.
Start to finish, this was great stuff because they didn’t try to do too much. Gunther said next to nothing; AJ didn’t say anything at all. They let the crowd dictate the scene, and they didn’t club fans over the head about Styles being the one to silently confront Gunther.