10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2004

Hey, remember when Kurt Angle shot Big Show and The Rock bored everyone senseless?

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE

Think of 2004 and you'll instantly be transported back to the highs of WrestleMania XX. John Cena opened the night by beating Big Show to win the United States Title, there was a memorable Chris Jericho, Christian and Trish Stratus angle, The Undertaker returned as a supernatural gimmick, Chris Benoit and Eddie Guerrero celebrated to close out the show. Everything seemed rosy.

Advertisement

Obviously, events afterwards would forever change public opinion on Benoit, but he did produce several of 2004's best moments. Of course, 'Mania XX also had some some of the dirt worst to offer too, and all of that is included here. WWE brought the pain via Diva Search monotony, cement crypts, miscarriage angles so foul they should never have happened, and Kurt Angle even had a bloody dart gun at one point.

Yep, the company was running out of ideas. They were struggling to push on from the 'Attitude Era' and properly find their footing without mega-stars like The Rock and Steve Austin as full-timers. Then, both Brock Lesnar and Goldberg bolted from a thinning roster, so it's perhaps no wonder Vince McMahon and his staff went into panic mode.

That anxiety doesn't excuse some of their decision-making though. If you thought Katie Vick in 2002 and the race baiting of 2003 would act as lessons WWE might learn from, then think again. By 2004, the company used sexual assault, more race-fuelled characterisation and even implied murder on pay-per-view as tools to draw ratings/buys.

Here's the worst of what '04 had to offer. Not even Rock's TV comeback could save the day. That's when you know it's bad!

10. Tough Enough Goes Wrong!

The fourth season of faux-reality show Tough Enough was still ongoing when rookie Daniel Puder took Olympic gold winner Kurt Angle down and almost broke his arm on the 4 November 2004 SmackDown. WWE had tasked the cast with running steps at Savvis Center in St. Louis for most of the day before the show was taped, and they'd also been put through their paces with regular in-ring training too.

Advertisement

None of that mattered when Puder got the eye of the tiger and accepted Kurt's challenge to enter the ring in a bid to take the WWE stalwart down. Dan took Angle to the mat with a Kimura Lock, and he might've snapped the pro's arm like a twig had officials not thought to quickly count Puder's shoulders for a 3 count. This was a legitimate bit of shooting from the rookie, one that likely didn't sit well behind the scenes.

On camera, a visibly embarrassed Kurt warned Daniel not to be "stupid", then grabbed the mic and chewed the rest of the Tough Enough entrants out anyway. This was supposed to be easy pickings for Angle. He was working, but Puder certainly wasn't. Whilst fascinating to viewers at home, it'd be hard to call this anything but one of 2004's worst moments in execution.

After all, things weren't supposed to play out that way, and it wasn't a great look for an ex-WWE Champ when he was almost tapped out by Puder. Kurt knew he couldn't tap/submit though, because that would've looked even worse for him and WWE.

To top it all off, fans around ringside chanted "UFC! UFC! UFC!" throughout. That wouldn't bother TKO now, but the landscape was different 21 years ago.

9. The Miz’s “Dixie Dog Fight” PPV Debut

A fresh faced Mike Mizanin was one of the cast members of that aforementioned fourth Tough Enough season too. He made no bones about the fact he planned to be 'the next coming of The Rock'. Speaking in third person, The Miz irritated the hell out of absolutely everybody during his first forays into the pro wrestling biz. That was true both behind the curtain and in front of it - nobody liked the poor guy.

Advertisement

Not one living soul could dispute his toughness though. At Armageddon 2004 in December, WWE plonked Miz in an awkwardly titled "Dixie Dog Fight' vs. Daniel Puder. For the record, they didn't have Kurt Angle rush out to slap Puder around and put him in an ankle lock. Maybe installing Kurt as a special guest referee for the boxing bout would've livened it up, because...it was dull.

The whole thing amounted to 3 rounds lasting 60 seconds apiece, but those 3 minutes felt like an eternity for those who just wanted Mizanin and Puder to get out of the ring so they could see actual wrestling matches. Then, The Bashams vs. Hardcore Holly and Charlie Haas changed their minds. Jokes!

Tazz brought up Brawl For All on commentary, and that was telling. This "Dixie Dog Fight" was like an even worse version of the iconically bad idea from the late-90s. Miz and Puder went to a ref’s decision following the third round, then Puder was handed the victory on points.

It's safe to say this won't be something The Miz will look back on fondly or mention during his WWE Hall Of Fame speech someday.

8. Kurt Angle’s Dart Gun

Knowing Vince McMahon's propensity for toilet humour, it's genuinely shocking that WWE didn't have Big Show crap his pants during this zany skit on the 23 September 2004 SmackDown. During an interference-heavy bout between Show and Kurt Angle (him again!), Kurt grabbed a tranquilliser gun from behind the Spanish announce desk, set it up and then pinged a dart right into Paul Wight's back.

Advertisement

Not content with his evening's work, Angle then shaved a helpless Show's head as his heavies like Luther Reigns and Mark Jindrak watched on. Somewhere, a single tear rolled down the cheek of Edge as he reminisced about his 'Hair vs. Hair' match vs. Kurt from 2002. That was a happy memory. This was anything but. In fact, it was one of 2004's worst bits of booking.

Show and Angle had been feuding heading into the No Mercy pay-per-view. After being literally shot in the back with a tranquilliser dart and subsequently shaved bald, ol' BS decided that the best way to avenge this heinous ambush was by beating Kurt in a straight up match with rules on the next pay-per-view. Huh?

The whole thing was just so far-fetched and over the top, and it was also hard to take seriously. People joke about all manner of weird things found underneath wrestling rings, but here was Kurt pulling a rifle out from behind the commentary tables. Did nobody notice that 47 from Hitman-style gun case sitting back there during the rest of the show?

At least Angle managed to set the gun up properly, because this could've gone south in a hurry. Y'know, even further south than it was already heading before the dart was fired.

7. The Rock’s Diva Search Snore

Initially, the entire 2004 Diva Search was going to go here. After all, a 'Lingerie Pillow Fight' between Christy Hemme and Carmella (not that one) at Taboo Tuesday in October could be considered one of the worst WWE PPV/PLE matches of all time. Thankfully, it was short. The same cannot be said for events on the 23 August '04 edition of flagship show Raw.

Advertisement

Brevity was not on the menu that night.

The Rock returned to WWE and interrupted Coach’s Diva Search segment. An awful lot of innuendo followed, then Rocky introduced a “Pie Eating Contest” for the remaining contestants. Rather infamously, an enthusiastic Hemme said that her behind was hungry before thumping pie against her butt and dishing out stinkfaces. What a sentence that is. 

The interminable skit ended with a beatdown on La Resitance and Coach, but not before both Tajiri and Rhyno also bizarrely got involved. For the record, this was Rock’s last proper appearance until 2011. What a waste. It hoovered up approx 20 minutes on a 2-hour show and achieved nothing other than making 'The Great One' look like a horny mess (he even hit on ring announcer Lilian Garcia here).

Remember, this was engineered to make people care about the Diva Search winner. Surely they could've wrapped it up in less than 10 minutes. Instead, The Rock bored himself senseless on the mic, and people continued to yawn their way through the titillation on offer.

You know it's bad when even Rock appearing for the first time in months can't save your segment.

6. Heidenreich Pins Michael Cole To A Wall

Oh no.

Advertisement

Every wrestling writer is cursed to talk about this moment every so often. It's one longstanding announce great Michael Cole would really rather people forgot, but that's not going to happen. Sorry, Mikey - your panicked facial expressions shall live on for the rest of time and that's that. Honestly? It'd be for the best had none of this been penned for the 16 September 2004 SmackDown in the first place.

Scary brute Heidenreich pinned Cole to a wall backstage and began reciting poetry. Then, the future Legion Of Doom member implied that he might well sexually assault SmackDown's play-by-plan man. The entire thing was unsettling, to say the least. It's puzzling too. What was any of this supposed to accomplish? Did WWE want Cole to slap on an orange singlet earlier than planned for a one-on-one bout vs. Heidenreich?

Or did they simply want to present him as a rampaging monster who also doubled up as a possible sex pest as he schemed wicked thoughts for the rest of the announce team? No-one will ever know, but that thumbnail you see above has been posted endlessly on social media since apps like Twitter/X, Facebook and Instagram were created. 

People can't get enough of reminding others about how foul some of WWE's fare was a generation or so ago. It's probs a sneaky positive that Heidenreich didn't go on to become some rip-roaring success, because no-one would ever let him live this moment down either.

No amount of top matches or WWE Title wins could overcome implied Cole mining.

5. Paul Bearer’s Cement Crypt

'Noooooooo! Please, Undertaker! Pleeeeeeeease! Noooooooo!'.

Advertisement

That was the sort of shrill screaming Paul Bearer did towards the end of a critically-panned Great American Bash pay-per-view back in the summer of 2004. The stipulation heading into the show said that the glass prison Bearer was standing in would be filled with cement if The Undertaker lost to the Dudley Boyz. ’Taker actually won the handicap match, but flipped a switch to encase his manager anyway.

WWE claimed afterwards that Bearer had survived (somehow), but he wasn’t spotted for years after the angle. It was a thoroughly miserable set piece, and a decidedly naff way to end the pay-per-view. Bringing back an old WCW PPV was one thing, but WWE didn’t need to go WCW style with the blow off moment! Nitro, Thunder or events like Halloween Havoc and Starrcade would've been proud of this nonsense in 2000.

Footage was filmed earlier that WWE used to splice in with the live feed. In other words, Paul Bearer wasn't physically present for the cement-inspired suffocation ritual they'd decided to put in the main event slot. It's pretty wild that JBL vs. Eddie Guerrero was bumped lower down the card for this, to be honest.

Creative backed themselves into an unnecessary corner with the stip. They didn't want Undertaker to lose, but still wanted to give folks the payoff of seeing Bearer get flooded. So, they nonsensically had 'Taker do the honours even though he'd beaten both Bubba Ray and D-Von in a crumbling 2-on-1 headliner.

This was Goldberg vs. Kronik levels of rubbish. Again, WWE showed itself up as a latter day WCW wannabe with this sort of storytelling.

4. MSG Rebels Against Brock Lesnar & Goldberg

It's amazing how fan reactions change depending on what's going on behind the scenes. For example, this very same match was greeted warmly by WWE audiences in both 2016 and 2017 despite flopping back in 2004. Heading into WrestleMania XX, the fanbase caught wind that Goldberg and Brock Lesnar would be leaving imminently, and they decided to give both men a piece of their collective minds.

Advertisement

Brock and Bill were cooked once news leaked out that they'd be goners post-'Mania. Madison Square Garden, long known as a loyal hotbed for the WWF/WWE product, booed both guys out of the building and refused to acknowledge their match as anything more than a contractual obligation. The only person who received any kind of positive response was guest ref Steve Austin.

'Stone Cold' seemed to find that rather funny. He struggled to hide a smile as Lesnar and Goldberg exchanged awkward glances and phoned in physicality. One of the biggest matches WWE could've placed on the midcard turned into a farce as soon as the bell sounded, and everyone inside the ring was powerless to stop the tidal wave of hate winging their way.

Privately, Brock had grown weary of the relentless WWE schedule and wanted out. Meanwhile, former WCW phenomenon Goldberg hadn't enjoyed his first year in the promotion and fancied going home too. MSG gave these soon-to-be-former WWE stars both barrels from the off.

It makes for a unique watch nowadays, but the first Brock vs. Bill bout from 2004 was roundly (and rightly) considered a total disaster at the time. The only thing that could've possibly made it even worse? A match-halting injury to either guy. New York probably would've cheered for that, come to think of it.

3. Muhammad Hassan Debuts

Wrestling has learned the hard way to stay away from certain topics. The industry has never been able to handle subjects like mental illness, racism or sexuality sensitively. Everything has always been cloaked in a clumsiness that feeds stereotypes and can even do more harm than good. Then, in retrospect, WWE has occasionally rewritten history to claim they were misjudged or people took things the wrong way.

Advertisement

Muhammad Hassan was an awful concept from the moment Jim Cornette received a phone call down in OVW about promising star Marc Copani's new role on the main roster. Cornette couldn't believe what Vince McMahon had in mind for his developmental rookie, but WWE ploughed ahead with Hassan. Then, on the 13 December 2004 Raw, Muhammad and his handler Daivari debuted opposite Mick Foley in a trash segment that acted as a warning of things to come.

Hassan introduced himself as a wrestler who wanted to bite back at prejudice he’d faced since the 9/11 terror attacks in 2001. That, predictably given the political climate, was booed. Mick was incensed by Muhammad's words about America, and a not-so-thrilling debate about the United States army ensued.

Somehow, things would get even worse for the character heading into 2005, but this was a rough start.

WWE should've known long before 2004 that they couldn't be trusted to tackle such a sensitive subject as racism. Toss terrorism into the mix and it was a recipe for calamity. Internally, Copani knew that his new character was going to turn heads for all the wrong reasons, but he also wanted to please his employer and make a name for himself.

Dude ended up with an entire 'Dark Side Of The Ring' episode on VICE, so...congrats?

2. Kane Forcibly Impregnates Lita

The next couple of entries are appalling. Simply appalling. Sure, some of the stuff you've just been reading about should cause heads to hang in shame amongst WWE writers of the time, but things hadn't exactly peaked on the Muhammad Hassan front in 2004. Unfortunately, they'd come to a head with Lita and Kane in one of the most grotesque storylines ever printed on headed paper and handed to wrestlers.

Advertisement

Lita revealed she was pregnant on the 26 July 2004 Raw. At first, her boyfriend Matt Hardy was over the moon, but then things soured once Kane claimed he was the father of the child. That, naturally, led to a blood feud with Matt. Kane beat Hardy in a ’Till Death Do Us Part’ match at SummerSlam, and it seemed like he was indeed the dad after all.

WWE set up a mock wedding between the "happy couple", but Lita was painfully detached throughout the whole episode. On commentary, the announcers openly discussed how Kane had forcibly impregnated his spawn into the female star in a bid to create his own mini-demon. How lovely. Imagine explaining that story to pals at school or work who weren't wrestling fans?!

Unthinkably, things would get even more offensive as the weeks and months ticked by. WWE's writing team didn't stop short at Kane implying that he'd raped Lita so she could give birth to his child. They could've, but they didn't. That wasn't nearly enough OTT soap opera-style chaos for the company.

You won't believe what they did next...

1. WWE Then Tries To Turn Kane Babyface

Seriously, what the hell were they even thinking here?

Advertisement

Future foot enthusiast Gene Snitsky hit Kane with a chair on the 13 September 2004 Raw and caused the 'Big Red Machine' to fall on Lita. As a knock on effect, that caused her to miscarry the baby. Subsequent skits showing Kane crying at Lita’s bedside as she disassociated from the whole thing were torturous to sit through. Why on earth did they think trying to put sympathy on Kane was the way to go?!

OK, so WWE didn't go full pelt towards the 'cheer for Kane' prompts, but they not-so-gently nudged viewers into sympathising with him as a grieving would-be father who'd just lost his kid. Good lord - producing a miscarriage story on wrestling telly would've been challenging enough without adding in the fact that Kane had forced himself onto Lita in the first place and laughed maniacally about the suffering he'd caused for months.

Hopping from that towards the idea that he was the one people needed to feel sorry for was a wretched stretch that everybody involved should feel ashamed about. Lita was caught in no man's land between being relieved that she wouldn't birth Kane's demonic spawn and being distraught about losing a child she'd been carrying.

It's understandable when the industry attempts to tell broader stories than just 'Wrestler A wants Wrestler B's title so they're gonna fight about it', but this was awful stuff from WWE. Depicting an implied rapist as someone worthy of the sympathy vote (even temporarily) is so offensive it's almost impossible to think this ever aired on episodes of Raw at all.

What other WWE moments from 2004 belong here? For more wrestling, check out 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2003 and 10 WWE Fates Worse Than Death!

Advertisement