7 Ups & 4 Downs from WWE Raw (5 May - Results & Review)

Babyfaces come together to challenge heel stable, Lyra stands tall, more average wrestling.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE

The world of post-WrestleMania 41 WWE Raw is certainly a strange one. Following a lackluster signature event, the company has turned in efforts that have ranged from pretty good to excellent.

Advertisement

Monday’s program trended toward the middle of that spectrum, with Raw continuing to lay the groundwork for future weeks and months ahead, not just the upcoming Backlash PLE or Saturday Night’s Main Event at the end of May.

Raw featured a really strong promo from Paul Heyman that almost match him into a sympathetic figure. Almost. It also gave some spotlight to Lyra Valkyria as she continues to step out from the shadow of Beck Lynch. It also saw Rusev return to a WWE ring for the first time since February 2020.

However, Raw also saw more perfectly average wrestling, a main event that used cheat codes, and a stat easily disproved.

Overall, Raw continued its streak of positive developments. Backlash itself looks mostly skippable, but the red brand seems to be setting things up for the long haul, establishing a heel stable and a collection of babyfaces to stand against them. That could provide plenty of fodder for the coming months.

Let’s get to it…

DOWNS…

4. Cole Flubs Another Stat

WWE

Let’s not throw this entirely at Michael Cole’s feet. It’s entirely possible someone fed him a bad factoid Monday night.

As the main event got underway, Cole mentioned that Jey Uso was the fifth member of the Anoa’i family to hold “the World Heavyweight Championship,” which he clearly meant to mean any world title in WWE since only five men have held Jey’s specific world title.

Here’s the problem: Unless there’s a mystery member of the famed Samoan family or a previously unknown blood brother, there have only been four members of the Anoa’i family to hold a WWE world title. Count them: Yokozuna, The Rock, Roman Reigns, and Jey.

Even factoring in extended “branches” such as Jimmy “Superfly” Snuka and Haku and their children doesn’t yield a fifth world titleholder.

Whoever is generating these stats – before WrestleMania 41, Raw ran a graphic stating that Roman would be competing in his 11th Mania main event, when it was his 10th – needs to do better.

3. Part Of The Furniture

WWE

When Penta debuted in January, he felt special. Different.

Fast-forward four months and Penta has become normalized and part of the weekly WWE churn.

Monday night, Penta had a decent match against JD McDonagh, seeking revenge for the Judgment Day man costing him his Intercontinental Championship two weeks earlier (with Penta returning the favor by interfering in a Judgment Day tag match last week). The match was fine, but it was a fair amount of back and forth with copious outside interference from Finn Balor, Carlito and Chad Gable. That seemed like an awful lot for a match between a guy lauded as a major star and an undercard wrestler who hasn’t won a televised singles match since February… 2024.

Penta has been feuding in some fashion with the Judgment Day since well before WrestleMania. He lost at Mania when Dominik Mysterio won the IC title, then lost a title match on Raw. Now he wins a bout against the low man on the Judgment Day totem pole and gets another Intercontinental Championship match at Backlash.

It’s starting to feel like Penta is little more than a featured player in the mid-card rather than a major force. And honestly, that’s fine, but WWE and some of its fans have been insisting otherwise for months, and things are playing out exactly how many figured.

2. Hot Ending, But…

WWE

Hang tight for some praise for the main event, but it wasn’t all smooth sailing for Seth Rollins versus Jey Uso on Monday night.

The Raw main event was mostly a plodding, punch-heavy bout with Rollins moving at three-quarter speed to not outpace Jey, who at times looked like he was wrestling underwater. Things picked up in the latter third, but even then, a lot of the drama revolved around shortcuts of interference, run-ins and outside shenanigans rather than the match itself – which ended in yet another disqualification.

Worse, this was (as Michael Cole noted) the first World Heavyweight Championship title match on Raw in seven months, and it ended in a DQ. (The lesson for WWE here is to not book a bunch of disqualifications in less significant matches; you’ll get a lot more grace when it’s done in moderation.)

You have to listen to and acknowledge the noise in the building, plus give credit to the babyface forces forming. But you also can’t ignore the first 12-15 minutes of the main event segment because the final five was really good.

1. A Perfect Encapsulation

WWE

Raw post-WrestleMania 41 has been an interesting case study. The show has improved from the lead-up to the big show and the actual event itself, with some new directions giving fans hope for a better outlook.

But there are always going to be blind spots and bumps in the road, some of which aren’t outright negatives, but are more a symptom of being inadequately adequate.

Case in point, Sheamus versus Austin Theory Monday night was little more than a welcome back match for the Celtic Warrior that went on for too long and generated strange reactions from the fans. The crowd couldn’t care less about Theory or his never-ending falling-out with tag partner Grayson Waller, going silent whenever Austin was on offense. The match itself was pretty standard fare for Sheamus – which is a solid, workmanlike effort – and yet elicited a “This is awesome” chant despite fans sitting on their hands for parts of it and nothing really rising to that level.

Technically speaking, there wasn’t anything to point to that would prompt a negative, but regardless of the fans’ chant, this wasn’t anything anyone will remember by the time NXT airs. It probably was forgotten before the Raw main event concluded.

Here’s the issue: How do you give a decent match a “down”? Sheamus returning is always a net positive. Doing anything with Theory and Waller has to be better than having them sit in catering. But it’s all just average, forgettable churn, content that fills time and evaporates as soon as it’s in the past.

One or two of these segments a week is understandable, but too many of them and they will start to pull the overall product down.

UPS…

7. Dominik A Lost Lamb

WWE

Poor Dominik Mysterio.

The kid wins his first main roster singles title and thinks he will just ride high off that glory for a while and immediately has his universe close in on him. Penta and AJ Styles are gunning for his Intercontinental Championship, and his girlfriend Liv Morgan is off shooting a movie for the next month-plus.

Dirty Dom lamented his lot after AJ visited the clubhouse, turning to Finn Balor for help, as if the Prince isn’t also eyeing the IC title. Sure, Balor agreed to “handle” Styles and will wrestle him next week (sidebar: Remember when AJ versus Finn would have been a major match, and now it’s a pretext for an IC title match against Rey Mysterio’s son?).

Mysterio as an oblivious champion not realizing that being a champ is hard work and not recognizing that Balor has designs on his title could be really entertaining if it’s played properly. They might even successfully babyface Dominik in the process if they play it right.

6. Can We Just Promote Roxanne And Giulia?

WWE

There is a cynical argument that could be made that having Roxanne Perez lose to Iyo Sky does little to help the NXT upstart, but that would ignore that Sky is the reigning Women’s World Champion and should win a one-on-one matchup.

In reality, Perez hanging with Iyo and keeping the champ off-balance throughout their match was a good showing that put Roxanne on the map for WWE fans. It’s clear she and Giulia are on their way to the main roster – and really, WWE just needs to make it official rather than having them straddle the brands – so matches like Monday’s are good opportunities to introduce them to the audience.

Roxanne earned Iyo’s respect, which immediately was followed by Giulia attacking Sky and Perez joining in. This served to set up a tag match with Rhea Ripley joining Iyo to take on the NXT invaders. It’s borderline criminal that this will take place on Raw next week, but these four women could steal the show and elevate the two newcomers in one fell swoop.

Perez did good work here, and her and Giulia’s promotions are justified. WWE just needs to get on this rather than continuing this “both worlds” method.

5. Rusev Crush

WWE

Rusev’s return to action in WWE for the first time in five years was very likely going to follow a predictable route: brutalize Otis for much of the match but take just enough offense to convey that the big man isn’t a pushover, then crush him before submitting him in the Accolade.

True to form, that’s exactly how Rusev picked up the win Monday night. He then murked Akira Tozawa and slaughtered Otis afterward until referees and officials ran down to forcefully separate the two.

There isn’t much more to ask from Rusev in his first Raw match since February 2020 (yes, pre-pandemic). It was plainly obvious that a good segment of the audience either didn’t recognize him or simply didn’t immediately care given the lack of reaction as he walked down the aisle. But Rusev won them over, especially with his post-match beatdown on a beloved figure like Otis.

Good stuff here for a first match back. Hopefully, Rusev doesn’t end up part of the furniture in two or three months like Penta.

4. McAfee Talks A Good Game

WWE

It really is a shame that Pat McAfee can cut a really good promo. Or more accurately, it sucks that he’s an unbearable color commentator rather than a regular wrestler, manager or talking head with less exposure.

Had he been any of the latter, McAfee would be more universally welcomed as a brash, outspoken sometimes-wrestler. Instead, it’s easy to dismiss him for being a detriment to the product on commentary.

Monday night, McAfee went face-to-face with Gunther ahead of their Backlash match. The former football star spent a good chunk of his opening putting over Michael Cole and noting that Cole’s longevity afforded him the right to have an opinion on the action, and Gunther was way in the wrong to attack a 60-year-old announcer.

From there, McAfee put over Omaha (where Raw emanated from Monday night), segueing to talking about how he and Gunther both dreamed of becoming involved in the wrestling business. The difference was that Gunther had become jaded and treats it as a job, while Pat is “jacked’ to come to work and loves all of the content. He said Gunther’s overconfidence and not “wanting it” would be his downfall at Backlash.

This fired up Gunther, who told McAfee that he now had his “full and undivided attention. The bell will ring Saturday and the Ring General will maul the commentator, choking him out until he hits the mat “like a wet towel.”

The match might surprise on the night, but it could also be a total trainwreck. Still, you have to give a bit of credit to McAfee here.

3. Lyra Continues To Shine

WWE

Whether Becky Lynch sprinkled some pixie dust on Lyra Valkyria or not, things have been looking up for the Women’s Intercontinental Champion since The Man returned at WrestleMania 41.

Lynch came out Monday night to pick a fight with the fans for booing her, claiming that all she did was take out the garbage – Bayley – prior to Mania and took her place, and no one cared about the Role Model. After calling Bayley garbage a half-dozen times, Becky compared Lyra to recycling – less offensive but still useless.

That’s when Valkyria made her way to the ring to suggest that Lynch has been recycling the same wrestling moves and “tired old act” for years. Sick burn. Lyra cut into Becky by noting that everyone in the women’s division got better during Lynch’s absence, and that she’s defended the IC title more than The Man has come around to WWE this year.

When Lynch tried to tout her legacy, Valkyria cut her off and recited Becky’s Wikipedia page, only to observe that she is the first Women’s Intercontinental Champion, a distinction that must stick in Lynch’s craw. This triggered Becky to try to attack, but Lyra was ready and overpowered her, planting The Man with a Nightwing.

The past two weeks, Valkyria has looked really good against Becky, and if the match at Backlash delivers, they could very well elevate Lyra to that next level. She just needs to continue to take advantage of these opportunities.

2. A Justified Heel

WWE

The best heels are able to articulate justifications for their actions, to come across not as ranting and raving lunatics, but to use sound but slightly skewed logic to explain themselves.

Paul Heyman did a masterful job of this Monday night in the show-opening in-ring promo segment. Interrupting World Heavyweight Champion Jey Uso, Heyman went on a lengthy rant about CM Punk and Roman Reigns, dissecting how each of them wronged him.

The Wise Man pointed out that his best friend Punk put him in an impossible position heading into WrestleMania 41 by forcing him into Punk’s corner, guaranteeing that his relationship with Reigns would be sabotaged.

But Heyman saved most of his venom for Jey’s cousin. He said that he came across “a stray Big Dog on the Island of Irrelevancy” and built Roman up to become the Tribal Chief of WWE, taking credit for Reigns’ epic run as Undisputed WWE Universal Champion. Heyman blamed Roman for blowing it at WrestleMania 40 and then leaving him to get attacked by the new Bloodline.

And when Reigns finally returned to WWE, it wasn’t to avenge Heyman, but to recover his Ula Fala, which angered Paul E.

Just masterful stuff from Heyman here, grounding his rationale in WWE canon and providing fans with an explanation that make sense rather than some ridiculous story. He’s still a scumbag – despite his protestations – but at least there’s a basis for Heyman betraying his Tribal Chief and his best friend at Mania.

1. Babyfaces, Unite!

WWE

Creating a new, top heel stable immediately after WrestleMania was a bold move that has potential to drive storylines for the next year-plus on Raw, but it only works if there are effective counterweights challenging them regularly.

Sami Zayn became the first person to stand against the Seth Rollins-led faction last week, and by the end of Raw Monday night, two more joined the fray. World Heavyweight Champion Jey Uso is a natural choice since he has a target on his back due to the title, and Rollins and Paul Heyman took aim at that target.

Those factors were baked into the conclusion of the main event, with Bron Breakker and Zayn getting involved in the world title match before a returning CM Punk ran down to ringside with a steel chair to wreak havoc. The closing shot on Raw featured Jey, Sami and Punk in the ring staring down Rollins, Breakker and Heyman in the aisle.

Immediately, your mind races to various matches: a Punk and Sami versus Seth and Bron tag could feature prominently on Saturday Night’s Main Event later this month; and Punk/Breakker would be a hell of an interesting match. But that staredown also pointed to an imbalance between heels and faces, leading you to wonder who might join forces with Rollins’ group to even the numbers.

Things are still in the very early stages, so WWE should be afforded some leeway as they continue to set the table for what projects to be its major storyline for the year. But given that they’ve already got some interesting combinations and some open-ended questions forming, that’s a good sign.

Advertisement