8 Amazing Wrestlers That Flopped In WCW
Some of wrestling's biggest superstars failed to make a mark in WCW. Here's why!
WCW's braintrust didn't always make it easy.
Anyone coming over from the WWF side who thought they'd clean up in Atlanta found that out the hard way. Even titans of the industry like Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior struggled to varying degrees. Hogan obviously figured things out, turned heel to form the nWo and was off to the races after that, but Warrior felt like he'd leapt straight out of 1990 when he showed up to drone on and on (and on and on) in 1998.
Being fair, Warrior wouldn't have been a fit for this list anyway. He was never what anyone would consider an "amazing wrestler". The guy had his appeal, but he couldn't really get it done inside the ring and lacked the veteran savvy of others with his tenure in the biz. Others? Well, others who could be considered amazing did their fair share of struggling instead!
There's a lot of variety here despite the "amazing wrestlers" tag. As anyone who follows the medium closely could tell you, that covers an awful lot of ground. Not everyone included was a technical wizard (some definitely were), but they'd been turning heads rather nicely before flopping in WCW.
For more range, consider this: WCW management, as ludicrous as they could be at times, weren't always to blame for these failures. Sometimes, things just didn't work out and there was nothing anybody could really do about it. Or, backstage politics got in the way of things. C'est la vie, as the saying goes.
Some huge names toiled on WCW's watch when they'd ruled elsewhere.
8. 2 Cold Scorpio
How Good He Was: Scorpio had a rare combination of power and speed/agility in his prime. He could match up against most top workers in WCW without it looking odd (or like a lower card guy was about to do a quick, easy job), but Scorp could also fly around the place like he was tearing it up in the Cruiserweight division.
He'd debuted as a partner for Ron Simmons, wrestled Barry Windham in an NWA World Title bout, then teamed with Marcus Alexander (Buff) Bagwell before leaving WCW in 1994.
Why He Flopped: It was a combination of failed drug tests and WCW's usual nonsense on the booking side of things. Firstly, putting 2 Cold Scorpio with Marcus Bagwell held the former down more than helping the latter. It was clear to anyone watching the product that Scorpio could've been a bigger deal on the roster, but management wanted him to develop Buff instead.
Second, opportunities were too thin on the ground for 2 Cold after an initial flurry. That's something he'd suffer from once again when he joined the WWF in 1996. Their 'cartoon pimp' character Flash Funk was never going to ascend above midcard, no matter how fittingly flashy his matches and moves were.
Scorpio had far more potential and skill than he was ever allowed to show on WCW's side of things. He really should've achieved more than one solitary tag title reign with Bagwell. Even that only lasted a day on television by the time their title win aired!
7. Marty Jannetty
How Good He Was: It's a crying shame that Marty Jannetty is often used to describe a wrestler who fades into the background and flops whilst his tag-team partner goes on to bigger and better things. In-ring, Marty was every bit as good as Shawn Michaels when the pair ruled together as The Rockers, but he'd never translate that into singles success.
Substance abuse issues gripped Jannetty and wrecked his momentum any time it looked like things were on the up for him. That's his own doing, but few could deny how slick he was as a worker on his day. When sober/focused, Marty was a real asset to whichever promotion he happened to be working for.
Why He Flopped: 1998 was far too late in the day for Jannetty to succeed on WCW TV. He could still offer something between the ropes, but he was only hired to pad out the roster across various matches on Nitro, new show Thunder and established nostalgia-fest Saturday Night. Realistically, the bloom was off the rose for the former Intercontinental Champion by the time he signed on the dotted line.
A shoulder injury also held him back, and WCW quietly released Jannetty mid-recovery. That had to come as a hammer blow, because he must've been banking on a career reprieve following immense disappointments over in the WWF.
Had Marty signed a WCW deal in say...1994, things might've been different for him. Ultimately though, he just couldn't be trusted to steer clear of trouble. It followed him around like a black cloud, and thus his WCW run was nothing to get hyped about.
6. Mike Awesome
How Good He Was: Technically, Mike Awesome was no Curt Hennig, but he had an intoxicating range of power moves that looked brutal and grabbed eyeballs. As ECW Champion, Awesome had worked fabulous fare against everyone from Spike Dudley to Masato Tanaka. His matches with Tanaka, in particular, became firm favourites for extreme fans.
Hopes were high when WCW signed Mike in April 2000. His changeover from Paul Heyman's league to Atlanta was messy and resulted in a WCW contracted worker wrestling the WWF's Tazz on an ECW show (work that one out!), but that didn't need to stop him from becoming one of Nitro's new breed and a shining light for the company heading into a fresh millennium.
Why He Flopped: Vince Russo had some of the downright worst ideas possible for Awesome. He stood no chance.
Rather than continuing to showcase what made Mike so special on ECW pay-per-view, Russo reimagined him as 'The Fat Chick Thriller'. Yes, his gimmick was that he could make overweight women happy in bed. That was it. Then, when WCW realised that was failing, they turned him into 'That 70s Guy' to try and capitalise on That 70s Show.
It was all brutally bad TV. As if that wasn't enough pain, Awesome (who was from Tampa, Florida) joined Lance Storm's Team Canada for some reason. He'd show up in the WWF during the invasion angle and even win the Hardcore Title on Raw, but the damage was done. He'd never be the same again, and the rot started in WCW.
5. The British Bulldog
How Good He Was: It's still incredible that Bret Hart was able to carry a frankly knackered and completely lost Davey Boy Smith through one of the greatest pay-per-view headliners ever at SummerSlam 1992. Just imagine how good that match could've been had The British Bulldog been with it - we might be talking 'Top 5 Match Ever' territory there.
At his best, Smith was a muscle man who could shift. Even at his biggest, the Brit could still move around the ring with ease, and it was that combo of power and zippiness that surely had WCW licking their chops when the Bulldog arrived in 1993. Further, the company reasoned that they could use Smith's star power to make inroads in the UK.
Why He Flopped: Davey's union with Sting against top heels Sid Vicious and Big Van Vader resulted in some passable matches, but they didn't perform as well as expected on pay-per-view. As a whole, Bulldog's 1993 run was too short to really count for much of anything, but he'd be back in the promotion following the 'Montreal Screwjob'.
Following Bret Hart over from the WWF, Smith re-debuted as a WCW star in late-1997, but he lacked the oomph he'd had previously. Being honest, the WCW roster was far too stacked for Davey to stand out, so he was relegated to the lower card in a nothing tag-team with fellow Hart Foundation member Jim Neidhart.
That's when the injuries began to pile up, thus accelerating Smith towards an untimely demise just a few years later. It's a sad story.
4. Jeff Jarrett
How Good He Was: Take a gander at Jeff Jarrett's match vs. Shawn Michaels from In Your House 2 if you want to see ol' 'Double J' at his finest. Other than that, Jarrett worked admirably against others like Razor Ramon on the WWF side, but he arguably had a ceiling. It was a ceiling that Vince Russo would ignore when he snagged Jeff for WCW in 1999.
In total, Jarrett had 2 spells in WCW. One was more successful than the other in terms of pure gold. Generally, 'Double J' is respected as a rock solid hand who can cut decent promos, but he's another who was probably always going to find it hard to step out from the daunting shadows of a packed WCW top line mix between 1996-1997 and again between 1999-2001.
Why He Flopped: It's been touched on above, but Jeff felt very, very forced as a multi-time World Champion from '99 onwards. It obviously isn't strictly his fault that WCW went down the tubes the way it did, but let's not ignore facts: TV audiences, pay-per-view buyrates and house show attendances dwindled partly because people just didn't view Jarrett as a major player, and they didn't want to see him headline the same way they had Ric Flair, Sting, Hogan etc.
Russo had more faith in Jeff than Vince McMahon, that's for sure. The WWF boss kept Jarrett in the upper midcard without letting him tangle with blockbuster names like Steve Austin or The Rock. Meanwhile, WCW treated him like he was on par with those superstars.
3. The Great Muta
How Good He Was: The name Keiji Muto commands instant respect from those who closely follow and adore the Japanese wrestling scene. Whether as Muto or The Great Muta, he's someone who became highly regarded for working a stiff, uncompromising style that paved the way for Puro respect throughout the 1980s and 90s.
Muta had several excursions in WCW: He wrestled there between 1989-1990, again in 1991 and 1992, once more in 1994, then made several cameo appearances between 1995-1998. After that, Keiji returned to Japan before an unexpected WCW reprise reared into view come 2000. Yes, he was part of that chaotic year.
Why He Flopped: Initially, WCW fans were intrigued by this mysterious figure from Japan when he worked celebrated bouts vs. Ric Flair, Sting and others, but the 2000 run was supposed to be a proper stab at making waves in North America for someone who had conquered the scene in his homeland.
It fell flat. Like, seriously flat.
Muta was part of the dreary 'Dark Carvival' stable alongside Vampiro, but he was tasked with staring at the lights for everyone from Mike Awesome (who had already lost steam by July 2000) and Tank Abbot to Ernest Miller and even KroniK in tag action. Put it this way: This was not the Muta that people who watched New Japan knew and appreciated.
His matches were either too short to really matter or found themselves stifled by workers who weren't on Keiji's level. In hindsight, the only good thing 2000 WCW did for Muta was put some cash in his pockets. There was nothing creatively fulfilling.
2. Jake Roberts
How Good He Was: Few understand pro wrestling psychology as well as Jake 'The Snake' Roberts. His hushed promo delivery style seldom exploded, which helped him stand out from ranting legends like Hulk Hogan, Warrior, Randy Savage etc. Inside the ring, Roberts knew the value of teasing his biggest moves, and he sold like a man possessed whether he was heel or babyface.
It should've been a massive loss to the WWF when Jake left in 1992 and turned up in WCW.
Why He Flopped: Sadly, it wasn't much of a loss to Vince McMahon at all. It certainly wasn't a huge get for WCW once Roberts turned out to huff and puff his way through a bitterly disappointing feud with main man Sting. If anything, resetting Jake's babyface status and letting him organically win over the WCW audience would've been for the best.
Nope, he was gonna have that darn 'Coal Miners Glove' match with the Stinger at Halloween Havoc '92 and that was that. That turned out to be Jake's only pay-per-view match for the company, which really sums up just how miserable a flop his run with WCW was.
Roberts was gone by early-1993, meaning his Atlanta run amounted to a sagging rivalry with Sting and not much more. To say he didn't show his best under the company banner would be a gross understatement. The glory days of this particular 'Snake' had clearly come and gone. It sucks to even type that when he's so beloved by millions of fans, but it's true.
WCW wasn't a neat fit for him.
1. Bret Hart
How Good He Was: Best there was, is and ever will be. Seriously though, that easy layup aside, Bret Hart has always been considered one of pro wrestling's finest stars. A super worker if there ever was one, he was an ultra-reliable workhorse for the WWF between 1984-1997. Nobody can look back on the body of work the 'Hitman' can - he was superb with everybody.
The 'Screwjob' at Survivor Series 1997 clearly damaged him, but people genuinely believed that Bret would take WCW by storm when he jumped over. His natural talent combined with the fact he badly wanted to stick it to Vince McMahon? Yeah, he couldn't fail even if he tried to.
Why He Flopped: He did. That's the sad truth of it.
Eric Bischoff has to shoulder some of the blame for the way he booked Hart as soon as he had him. Putting him out there as little more than a special guest referee for Starrcade 1997 was poor. You've got one of the greatest in-ring technicians ever on the your books and that's what you do with his first PPV performance?!
However, Bret himself needed to look in the mirror too. He often looked totally demotivated and out of place on WCW programming. His matches still ranged between decent-excellent, but the fire in his belly had been doused. Being fair, things took an even more hellish personal turn following his brother Owen's tragic passing in 1999.
Overall, Hart in WCW was a struggle when it shouldn't have been.
What other great wrestlers flopped in WCW? For more wrestling, check out 7 Behind The Scenes ECW Stories That’ll Shock You and 10 Times Backstage Politics Ruined WCW!