Bret Hart Vs. Shawn Michaels Complete History | Wrestling Timelines

The best WWE feud there ever was - outside of the ring, anyway.

survivor series 1997 bret hart shawn michaels
WWE.com

In the mid-to-late 1980s, WWE broke big as a cultural phenomenon.

The juiced-up, toyetic megastars were impossibly proportioned, cartoonishly charismatic. Mirroring in-vogue action cinema in the live arena, the likes of Hulk Hogan, ‘Hacksaw’ Jim Duggan, and ‘Macho Man’ Randy Savage grabbed the zeitgeist of Reagan’s ‘80s, with its values of American superiority. Hogan, especially, was emblematic of this glossy new super-power era of Americana.

This Golden Age would not last. The stars of the World Wrestling Federation were not, in reality, upstanding tough guys who you could depend upon. Many, if not most, were using anabolic steroids to create the illusion of strength and power. All, of course, were workers in an illegitimate pseudo-sport.

This era was brought crashing down by two major factors.

The first was external. By the early ‘90s, in another echo of the political landscape, the American dream had receded. The party was over; bad vibes were “in”. Vince McMahon no-sold the atmosphere; his WWF felt charmless, ancient, even more fake.

Vince was then indicted for distributing steroids. He would escape imprisonment, but the family-friendly image of his promotion was in tatters. Goodwill, marketable stars, the novelty: all was lost. In its wake, a fearful McMahon implemented drug testing and abandoned, for a time, his policy of pushing giants. He was still size-obsessed. Where he couldn’t push wrestlers with inflated physiques, his workaround was height (Diesel) and mass (Yokozuna). He still needed a man with a pure, athletic look to symbolise the clean-up operation.

It was the technically immaculate Bret Hart who was chosen to spearhead this new era as WWE champion. There was another guy, though, who didn’t resemble a muscle monster. This man, Shawn Michaels, also wanted the spot.

They became intertwined forever, altering the fate and future of the business.


August 29, 1984 - Bret Debuts

Bret Hart 80s
WWE

Bret makes his first appearance for the World Wrestling Federation. Vince McMahon takes a look at him as part of the deal with which he buys the Stampede territory from Bret’s father Stu. Basically, to sweeten the offer, Vince assures Stu that Bret, Dynamite Kid, Davey Boy Smith, and eventually Jim Neidhart, will receive steady work.

There’s one bit of good news on what is a terrible night for Bret: the understated, precocious craftsman goes simply by ‘Bret Hart’, and not ‘Buddy the Heartthrob' - a compromise of a gimmick he thinks is the way “in” to New York’s broad theatre.

Bret’s knee is shot, but he can’t not do the gig. He knows the WWF is taking over; he’s one of the most savvy minds to ever enter the business. He spends the day in a state of anxiety. He’s slighter than most and passable at best cutting promos, and listens on as the polished, gargantuan pros hype up upcoming events to the TV cameras backstage.

Bret, injured, messes up virtually everything when he makes it to the ring, to the annoyance of Dynamite, his tag partner and brother-in-law, in a quick squash win over Iron Mike Sharpe and Troy Alexander.

He meets Vince for the first time. Vince says little about the match, complimenting only Dynamite’s performance and thick, muscular look. A cold Vince turns to Bret, and advises him that he likes his wrestlers to spend a lot of time in the gym. Bret knows what Vince is getting at with this hardly complex code, but it’s very ironic; years later, Bret’s modest physique is what will, in part, catapult him to the top. But not before a more glittering tag run with a different partner.

It’s not the best first impression - but it’s better than Shawn’s.


June 3, 1987 - Shawn Debuts

The Rockers Shawn Michaels Marty Jannetty
WWE

Shawn Michaels, per Cagematch, makes his debut for Vince McMahon. Alongside Midnight Rockers tag team partner Marty Jannetty, he goes over Jose Estrada and Jimmy Jack Funk in a dark match.

This run won’t last even two days; this is the only match. Both Shawn and Marty are almost immediately fired when, according to Shawn, he is teased that he doesn’t know how to party after the show. He smashes a bottle over his own head in a juvenile stunt designed to prove otherwise. This displeases Vince McMahon. Is Shawn downplaying the incident - in 1987, it’s surely impossible to get fired for a wild night out - or is this the sort of stuff only top, money-drawing stars get away with?

In either event, it’s an appropriate start to life, almost mythical, knowing what will happen years later. In a premonition of 1997, Shawn’s behavior is wildly unprofessional.

Later, Bret will freely admit to recreational drug use and extra-marital affairs. Bret was no angel; very few in pro wrestling were. Michaels, though, was destructive, out-of-control, unable to leave the party when the sun came up.

He could be described as a degenerate.


September 11, 1989 - First Interaction

Bret Hart Shawn Michaels 1989
WWE

The first in-ring meeting between Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels unfolds when the Hart Foundation of Bret and Jim Neidhart take on the Rockers, who were rehired in May ‘88, on Prime Time Wrestling.

There’s a very interesting moment early on, before Bret ties up with Marty Jannetty. As Bret circles the ring, he refuses to break eye contact with Shawn, who is stationed on the apron. It’s as if Bret knows who the real threat is - that, or he’s slyly expressing his joy at the prospect of grappling with a like-minded workhorse in whom he sees a bit of himself.

The match is good, an awkward Rockers double hip-toss spot aside. It ends when the Rougeaus run in to attack the Rockers, necessitating a disqualification.

The two teams will reach a higher peak.

November 25, 1989 - Better

Marty Jannetty Jim Neidhart
WWE

The fledgling rivalry makes its way to the discerning, taste-making spiritual home of Madison Square Garden - and the fans love it.

The match drags, almost by design - it goes to a 20:00 time limit draw - but it smashes every other thing on the card. The structure will become familiar. Bret partners up with Marty as Neidhart then does spots with Michaels. The idea is to create anticipation for the best pairing, who are tasked with building the match to a scintillating peak - and that pairing is not Neidhart and Jannetty.

Away from the rest holds, there’s a gorgeous cut-off when Shawn practically teleports into Bret’s high boot in the corner. Shawn sells it like a knock-out blow; Hart doesn’t leave so much as a blush on Shawn’s cheek. It’s a captivating glimpse into what they may achieve together in a singles match - but will they ever truly get there?


February 11, 1990 - A Challenge

Bret Hart Shawn Michawels 1990
WWE

Not at the very first attempt, anyway.

Bret Vs. Shawn I gets thrown out when their respective partners hit the ring to tease a big upcoming TV tag match. For how long it lasts - roughly five minutes - it’s solid. Incredibly basic, but solid, highlighted by a wicked Bret combo. Bret strikes Shawn with an atomic drop, which Shawn sells like his entire nervous system is on fire, before Bret wallops him with a snug lariat.

It’s only the briefest glimpse, but the match nonetheless explores the height of the dynamic. It’s infinitely better when Hart is playing the aggressor.

April 23, 1990 - A Tag Team Thriller

Rockers Hart Foundation
WWE

The Hart Foundation and the Rockers do battle once again on Saturday Night’s Main Event.

By the standards of the time, it’s a blistering effort. The objective of the match is to dazzle the crowd with athletic prowess displayed at a rollicking pace. This informs the range of WWF cards, often headlined by basic, lumbering main events powered by megastar charisma. This is true, but there’s a determination here to go all out.

This is fought at warp speed. Michaels and Hart battle with their primary weapons - aerial ability and technical intelligence, respectively - and this is explored in a great sequence. Shawn attempts to floor Bret with a high cross-body block, but Bret is clever enough to anticipate it. In one seamless motion, Bret catches Shawn and executes a backwards roll into a pin attempt. The relentless, seesawing drama is wonderful, and escalates beautifully. The Rockers demonstrate that they can get it done without taking to the skies with a double Russian leg sweep, from which they each kip-up. The match is brief, a typically abbreviated SNME special, and the double disqualification finish is a let-down. Still, this is the sort of pulsating action that makes lifelong devotees of the viewers who stick around after the fad.

Considered one of the very best tag team matches held under the WWF banner at the time, nowadays, you’d watch it and forecast stardom for Hart and Michaels in particular - but it’s 1990. This is not how it works.

It will take nothing short of a profound cultural paradigm shift for that to happen.


October 30, 1990 - Phantom Title Change

the rockers tag
WWE.com

The Rockers defeat the Hart Foundation in a Two out of Three Falls match for the WWF Tag Team titles. Only, this never “officially” happens.

Vince wants to push Bret, now one of the best wrestlers in the world, as a singles star; the Ultimate Warrior, Hulk Hogan’s replacement, isn’t delivering great numbers at the box office. Bret isn’t primed to take that spot yet, but Vince is grooming him over the long-term: Bret is a perfect Intercontinental champion years before he wears it. The tag title change happens, but is immediately retconned.

This is a knotty story, and it changes depending on who tells it. Bret goes with the “top rope” story - one that will take on a life of its own. The imagined scene, of the Hart Foundation and the Rockers working a match with only the bottom and middle ropes intact, is exactly that: imagined. The top rope is however in a precarious enough state that it limits the planned action, resulting in a tentative, awkward, hurriedly improvised contest. Bret is furious; the match isn’t live, but the referee, Freddie Sparta, won’t halt it temporarily.

Shawn says Vince came to terms with Neidhart to stay on as a talent. Vince felt he needed Neidhart to do commentary to in effect repay his legal fees Vince footed (Jim was exonerated and then successfully counter-sued after he was charged with assaulting a USAir flight attendant). If the match lived up to the prior series, the timeline might change slightly here, but it doesn’t. It isn’t deemed good enough to air, and the titles are left on the Foundation.

Bret won’t be confined to the tag division much longer, however…


March 30, 1991 - We Head East

The Rockers Tag Team
WWE.com

The Hart Foundation, set to imminently disband, defeat the Rockers in the Tokyo Dome. It’s not rated six stars but rather ***¼ by the Wrestling Observer Newsletter's Dave Meltzer. The show, WrestleFest, is promoted in conjunction with the short-lived, moneyed Super World of Sports promotion of Japan.

The match follows the familiar template, but, performed in front of a different audience, is slightly more snug when Hart senses the Japanese crowd won’t put up with their typical high spot-stuffed match. Hart puts real snap on a sublime backbreaker, which Shawn sells brilliantly, his face twisted in anguish. It will become a signature of his.

In a premonition of the future, Hart and Michaels are less interesting the longer they go; this is good, but the lean, punchy SNME match is superior.

June 2, 1992 - Tape Machines Are Rolling

Bret Hart Shawn Michaels
WWE.com

In the second televised singles encounter, taped for the ‘Rampage’ Coliseum Video release, Bret successfully defends the Intercontinental title. McMahon is true to his word; the push is happening. Shawn's singles career as a heel is just beginning.

The match is good, not great. Shawn is precocious, but has yet to develop into a best in the world-tier talent - as evidenced by a jumping knee that misses by a conspicuous distance. It’s an attritional match with many, many sleeper attempts. It’s as if Shawn is very faithfully reproducing how to play a Vince McMahon heel, forgetting how to get his personality across in the process. This is wrestled before he debuts the super-kick as his finish; Shawn is trying and failing to get the teardrop suplex over. Bret, meanwhile, is so great that he nonetheless develops some cracking pin escapes from Shawn’s experimental misfire of a finisher.

The finish is good - Hart dives out of the way as Shawn inadvertently wipes his valet Sensational Sherri off the apron - but the match is a strange one. It’s interesting, though, because structurally, it echoes the stylistic transition period that the promotion itself is undergoing.

It’s still a bit methodical and boring - but the sparks of workrate and technique will soon catch fire.


July 20, 1992 - All-Star Tag Action

Bret Hart Randy Savage
WWE.com

Dream teams collide as Bret Hart and Randy Savage take on Ric Flair and Shawn Michaels for a Superstars taping.

It’s a teaser for the big Savage Vs. Flair rematch, set for SummerSlam ‘92. It’s not quite as amazing as the match graphic would indicate, but watching Shawn study the dark arts under Flair is a hoot, and it’s a sensible decision to bring the heat segment to Bret; this allows an impassioned Randy Savage to go apoplectic remonstrating with the referee. Shawn showcases real personality here. Mostly. Bret’s job is to sell lying down, basically, but he’s far better at that than most.

On offence, Shawn is still cinching in headlocks far too late in the match like his life depends on it - but he is very, very close to discovering the genre with which he’ll (eventually) grasp how to stop the show…

July 21, 1992 - A First

Bret Hart Shawn Michaels Ladder
WWE

In the very first Ladder match in WWE history, Bret Hart successfully defends his Intercontinental title against Shawn Michaels. The match - likely because it is an experimental demo - does not take place on pay-per-view. It is however taped, and later released on the charmingly-titled ‘Smack ‘Em Whack ‘Em’ home video. Vince doesn’t see the match; in a rare event, he isn’t present in the building. This means he doesn’t see the finish, and is unaware of who came up with it.

The ladder - there’s only one - makes its first appearance in the second third of a match that, prior to it, is solid and thoroughly normal. As you’d expect with a Bret Hart match, the use of the ladder is savvy. Shawn repeatedly drives it into Bret’s gut, until Bret finds the resolve to move away from the corner of the ring. The ladder is already stationed where it needs to be, and where it “should” be, when Bret uses it as a substitute for the turnbuckle when performing his signature chest-first bump after a last-millisecond Irish whip reversal. The cause and effect is sound, not in the least bit contrived.

The objective of the match is never lost. The ladder is used not as a weapon, a means of facilitating a stunt, but rather the risky consequence of the pursuit of victory. Shawn attempts to climb as the match closes in on the final third. Bret pulls on Shawn’s tights, sending him plummeting to the mat; the ladder crashes on top of Shawn, who hopelessly attempts to kick it away.

It’s another attritional match that loops in a constant climb/shove/fall back-and-forth structure. It remains impressive, how Bret and Shawn grasp the potential of the weapon, as a way of elevating familiar spots, at the first attempt. At the finish, Bret again shoves Shawn off the ladder mid-climb. Shawn is crotched on the ropes as the match builds to a cathartic crescendo. Bret was always amazing at peaking his matches at the finish; even this curio is evidence of that.

This was Bret’s idea. The ladder was an old hit promoted by his father Stu’s Stampede territory; Bret had worked an early foray into the genre with the Dynamite Kid in Regina, Canada in 1981. And yet, it’s Shawn who immortalises it at WrestleMania X against Razor Ramon.

The rivalry has yet to truly begin, but there’s a sense, already, that Vince loves the Boy Toy more than Bret and - even on the night built around Bret’s rehabilitation as the top guy - affords Shawn Michaels preferential treatment.


November 25, 1992 - Survivor Series

Bret Hart Shawn Michaels Survivor Series
WWE.com

At Survivor Series, Bret Hart retains the winged eagle at the expense of Shawn Michaels, who displays the obnoxious charisma, bad boy looks and sublime in-ring skill to star in this new, enforced era of superior action. Bret is already there, shocking even himself.

The match is rated ****½ by the Wrestling Observer Newsletter’s Dave Meltzer. This would suggest that it’s not too far away from one of the best WWE matches ever. It isn’t. The technique on display is beautiful, and, informing the rating perhaps, massively stands out in this era of the World Wrestling Federation. The slow pacing early is necessary, since the match nears 27 minutes at a time when stateside WWF fans haven’t yet adjusted to it - but also quite dreary. Despite what is to come, Bret and Shawn never lose sight of their profound mutual professional respect. This manifests, in the Richfield Coliseum, in an almost indulgent collaboration in the opening act. It’s as if they simply enjoy the pure thrill of wrestling one another before the fans get to join them.

As slick and at times ferocious as the exchanges are towards and during the finishing stretch, the match won’t stand the test of time. It won’t be immortalised, like the rare treat workrate Federation classics of the era. It’s no Bret Vs. Mr. Perfect at King of the Ring 1993. It’s no Shawn Michaels Vs. Jeff Jarrett at In Your House: The Lumberjacks.

It’s an early tell that the Bret Vs. Shawn rivalry is far more captivating outside of the ring than between the ropes.


November 24, 1993 - We Meet Again

Shawn Michaels Knights Survivor Series '93
WWE

Almost a year to the day later, Bret and Shawn meet again at the annual Survivor Series pay-per-view - to considerably less critical acclaim.

Much has changed across 365 days. Bret has won, and lost, the WWF Heavyweight title; when it becomes clear that the fans don’t buy into Lex Luger doing Hulk Hogan, he’ll get it back. Shawn is the current Intercontinental champion - which, in 1993, is often code for future Heavyweight champion. Nobody under Vince’s employ can look like they’re on the juice, for obvious optics reasons. Bret and Hawn best represent a purer, athletic - and enforced - future. Bret isn’t remotely close to Hogan, in terms of star power and box office, but his in-ring catalogue, already, is the best in Federation history. It’s taking longer for Shawn to get there, although he’s more than capable of entering some sublime performances on occasion. His 1993 PPV record - Vs. Marty Jannetty, Tatanka, Mr. Perfect - underwhelms.

Bret teams with his brothers Owen, Bruce and Keith to defeat Shawn and “his” “Knights”: Black (Jeff Gaylord), Blue (Greg Valentine) and Red (Barry Horowitz).

This poor eight-man tag is not the originally scheduled match. Bret’s excellent feud with Jerry Lawler is meant to segue into an incredibly textured war against Owen, but Lawler misses the show after he is indicted on charges of sodomy and statutory rape.

It might have been better, since Terry Funk is meant to be involved but pulls out at the last minute, but it’s bad. Weirdly, the WWF plays it as if Michaels had been tormenting and insulting the Hart Family all along. This isn’t the case, and the fans, who know it, cannot bring themselves to care - especially since this goes for 30 tedious minutes. The Bret and Owen interaction is compelling, but that’s about it.

This is excusably bad, and while Shawn’s bumping is great towards the finish, he really could do with a breakthrough performance, if Bret’s on-again, off-again top guy role is to be challenged over the long-term.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!