How Good Was Ultimate Warrior Actually?

Measuring The Ultimate Warrior's body of work against other WWE legends is...interesting.

The Ultimate Warrior
WWE.com

Loading up the spaceship with rocket fuel for The Ultimate Warrior! Jim Hellwig is certainly one of the most instantly recognisable WWE superstars of all time, an icon of the 1980s, and one of the most popular wrestlers of WWE's golden age. He shared the limelight with Hulk Hogan and 'Macho Man' Randy Savage at the height of wrestling's most colourful and excessive era.

Does that tell the whole story, though? The Ultimate Warrior ranks as one of the most highly debated "legends" of all time. Does his work hold up to scrutiny after all these years? Does he deserve his place on the list of the greats? Also, just what the hell was he talking about in those promos?!

Strap in as we delve into every facet of what makes the Ultimate Warrior such a controversial pro wrestler - one of the most controversial to ever lace up a pair of heavily tasselled boots, in fact. From landmark achievements that will live forever, to mysterious black goo and some of the most ridiculous moments of the 20th century, this is our deep dive into discovering just how good The Ultimate Warrior was.

Shake some ropes!

Get Surfshark for the bargain price of just $1.78 per month! Valid only until April 19th!

https://get.surfshark.net/aff_c?offer_id=1030&aff_id=1691&url_id=2561

10. Presence/Look/Presentation

Ultimate Warrior
WWE.com

In the 1980s, only Hulk Hogan was more popular than Ultimate Warrior. During wrestling’s first national and international boom period, Jim Hellwig’s madcap antics were as over with fans as it was possible to be on one of the most personality-laden WWE rosters of all time. Whilst Dusty Rhodes had the gift of the gab and Ric Flair was the era’s best in-ring main eventer, The Ultimate Warrior’s presentation was second only to all-conquering red and yellow of Hulk.

His explosive entrance, however, was one area where the Warrior was second to nobody. Sprinting to the ring like Usain Bolt after a night at Tony Montana’s house, crowds would go ballistic for Warrior’s signature entrance. He'd run across the ring apron, one hand on the ropes and the other pumping like he was pulling invisible oranges from a tree. Then, he would shake the ropes like an enraged gorilla. It was absolute nonsense, but it worked like a charm. Adrenaline-filled, nitro-fueled mayhem that was perfect for hyperactive children everywhere; everything about The Ultimate Warrior was perfect (until the bell rang).

His look was memorable too. The iconic war paint on Warrior's face would change colours from week-to-week. Sometimes he'd paint his face makeup onto his entire chest area just to make sure the audience had fully grasped the point. As his stature within wrestling grew and he claimed WWE titles, he changed the colour of his belts to match. That seems like a small detail, but it made a big impact on the audience of the time and his young fans. 

Warrior would wear a long coat for PPVs with an airbrush-painted image on it, and the colours used were so striking that it looked like someone had been drinking every variety of Buzzball and thrown up on him. Again, it was cartoonish drivel on the surface, but over is over, and The Ultimate Warrior was as over as anyone (including Hogan) for a short time in the late 80s.

Perhaps an element of the Warrior’s presentation that has held up best of all is Jim Johnson’s excellent entrance theme. Sure, the chugging guitar riff and Metallica-esque cymbal crashes are also as 80’s as The Outrunners’ fashion sense, but put Lamb Of God or Malevolence’s guitar tone on Warrior’s entrance theme and it still rips ten tons of awesome by modern heavy metal standards.

If everything is judged through the lens of its era, then Ultimate Warrior embodied the 80s perfectly. Neon colored, big-haired, fist-pumping excess that the kids from Stranger Things would have loved.

8/10


9. Promos

Ultimate Warrior promo
WWE Network

This is possibly the most subjective element of The Ultimate Warrior. His promos made about as much sense as putting pineapple on a pizza, but millions of weirdos all over the world love that taste of madness.

Just listening to a Warrior promo is enough to make the audience fail a drugs test. With his veins bulging like power cables, Warrior would literally snarl like a beast, whisper like a serial killer and roar like a grizzly bear in the space of 10 seconds. His words would fly at the speed of Andre 3000.

Sure, his promos made next to no sense, but they always felt captivating anyway. He was anti-cinema in the Roman Reigns sense of drama and storytelling, but totally box office as he demanded that we load up the spaceship with "the rocket fuel" and give our skeletons to sacrifice to the gods of combat for reasons only known to him.

One of his famous promos (on the road to his career-defining match with Hulk at WrestleMania VI) suggested that Hogan commit an act of terrorism by commandeering an aircraft, sacrificing the pilots in the cockpit, and putting the plane into a nose-dive.

Put on literally any promo he ever delivered, and his level of intensity made even the likes of Randy Savage and Hulk sound like a quaint Great British Bake Off contestant. This brings us back around to the point that Jim Hellwig’s promo style was/is an entirely acquired taste.

If there's a Warrior promo that demands a level of seriousness, it is his final words in a wrestling ring on the 7 April 2014 episode of Raw. Even at 54, he barked with the ferocity of a rabid dog after donning a mask with his face paint on to talk in character. His final words included this monologue: “Every man's heart one day beats its final beat, his lungs breathe their final breath; and if what that man did in his life makes the blood pulse through the bodies of others and makes them believe deeper in something larger than life, then his essence, his spirit, will be immortalised”.

For all of the laughs that can be had at Warrior’s insane promos, these words came 24 hours before he passed. They carry weight and should inspire anyone into believing they can overcome life’s insurmountable odds by becoming something larger than themselves. Is the Warrior a maniac or a genius? That is truly in the eyes and ears of the beholder.

7/10


8. In-Ring Ability

Randy Savage Ultimate Warrior WrestleMania VII
WWE.com

Ultimate Warrior was famously clunky and inadequate in the ring. Understanding his presentation and promos is critical to comprehending his success, because if you go back and watch Warrior’s in-ring performances then his popularity will make no sense whatsoever.

Hogan’s matches may have been formulaic, but he at least understood in-ring psychology and how to feel an audience. The Ultimate Warrior had the most limited set of skills it's possible to have, and he didn’t seem to care about his opponent or the sanctity of wrestling. Much like the approach WCW adopted with Goldberg, Warrior’s first few years involved matches less than 5 minutes because that was how you got the most out of him.

As his popularity grew, it was largely the responsibility of his opponent to carry the match itself when he had to be put in longer matches.

At the very base level of being a wrestler, the aim is to make fans buy into the choreographed combat playing out in front of them. That was impossible to do with Ultimate Warrior. His art of...not selling his opponent’s offence was insulting to the audience as well as his opponents. Watching the Warrior run on the spot whilst Randy Savage laid a top rope double-ax handle into him, or popping up to his feet to emphatically bench press thin air after Hulk hit him with a scoop slam in the main event of WrestleMania? Childish nonsense.

Most egregious of all, his no-sell of Triple H’s Pedigree at WrestleMania XII was so abysmal that it made a mockery of wrestling itself.

Bill Goldberg was a questionable in-ring performer, but at least his spear and Jackhammer are impressive to see. Warrior's Gorilla Press and Ultimate Splash were the pits. There is literally not a single thing about The Ultimate Warrior’s in-ring performance that warrants praise.

1/10


7. Time’s Test

Ultimate Warrior Yellow2
WWE.com

Warrior’s body of work has aged like Cyndi Lauper’s wardrobe. To see any merit in it, you have to view it as a relic of the 80’s, because it is nearly impossible to imagine a scenario in which Ultimate Warrior would work in today’s wrestling climate (or any other for that matter).

Jey Uso is derided for gassing during his matches, but he’s like a triathlon athlete compared to the Warrior. Jim Hellwig would be unemployable as an in-ring performer in today’s landscape. This isn’t insulting him because he isn’t AJ Styles, this is saying that Warrior is very literally below the standards of anything you will see at your local wrestling event, let alone the bright lights of WWE or AEW.

Take an act like FTR. Their look, style, and entrance music owes much to the past, be it Smoky Mountain Wrestling, The Steiner Brothers or The Brain Busters, but they are exemplary performers who would be an asset to any wrestling company in any era. Retro but contemporary. There is nothing about the Warrior that would work in any era but his period of dominance in the 80s. Even by the time he returned to WCW in 1998, he felt like selling a cassette Walkman to the iPod generation.

As for mic work, imagine Ultimate Warrior being faced with MJF or Paul Heyman. Imagine trying to convince the IWC that you were raised on the smell of combat, or the concept of your “Little Warriors”. Picture him having to put on a match after Konosuke Takeshita or Je’von Evans had been in the ring. There isn’t a single scenario in which the Warrior could thrive in today’s world, or in which his body of work stands up to scrutiny.

1/10


6. Cultural Significance

Ultimate Warrior WMVI
WWE

The Ultimate Warrior is culturally significant in the same way the movie Footloose or the yo-yo is. It is impossible to think about the 1980s without them coming to mind, but they are antiques of their era that belong in a time capsule and have almost no cultural footprint in the modern world.

His 'Ultimate Challenge match' with Hulk at WrestleMania VI defined wrestling for a lot of people who grew up with The Karate Kid as their favourite movie. It is at least as responsible as Hogan vs Andre in establishing WrestleMania’s main event as the marquee match of the year. The pair's double-clothesline in that match is the only thing about the Warrior that has had a lasting impact on the wrestling world, as this spot has been replicated by everyone from Ricochet and Logan Paul’s high-flying stunt in the 2024 Royal Rumble to the trio of finishers hit by Seth Rollins, CM Punk and Roman Reigns in the main event of 'Mania 41.

A slice of dramatic athleticism in a high-profile match that leads to everyone being laid out on the mat and the audience in raptures owes a debt of gratitude to Hogan and Warrior colliding like monster trucks.

Nevertheless, it’s hard to make a case for Ultimate Warrior having significance in the broader picture of wrestling. Think of an act like The Ascension, who took influence from the Warrior. They adopted face paint and had a presentation that was all about drawing their power from mystical forces. They had a fine 15 mins of fame in NXT, but were treated as a joke when they got to WWE’s main roster. Some things belong in the past, and that’s OK. People can still enjoy Weird Science or Motley Crue even if it didn’t really mean anything outside of its 1980s bubble.

4/10


5. Rivalries

Hulk Hogan Ultimate Warrior
WWE

It's fairly easy to undermine The Ultimate Warrior, but he did have 2 of his generation’s greatest feuds. One that is criminally underrated, and another that ended in one of the biggest matches of the 1980s.

‘Ravishing’ Rick Rude was a generational talent who was way ahead of his time. Everyone from Eddie Guerrero to Dominik Mysterio carries a little Rick Rude in their cocky personas. Rude was a fabulous worker, but his true masterpiece was being able to make Ultimate Warrior look like a competent wrestler during their matches across 1989 and 1990.

That duo traded the Intercontinental Title back and forth, with Rude causing a shock upset by dethroning the Warrior at WrestleMania V due to an assist from Bobby Heenan, before the Warrior regained the title at SummerSlam '89. Rude would also be entrusted to carry the Warrior in his first feud with the WWE Title, culminating in a thrilling steel cage match that headlined SummerSlam 1990.

Then there’s the Warrior’s career-defining rivalry with Hulk Hogan (or “Howk Ho-Gin” as the Warrior would always pronounce his adversary’s name). They met once in the squared circle for WWE, but Warrior was the only performer who got close to Hogan’s globe-conquering success. Vince McMahon would sell “The UUUUUUULTIMATE WARRIOR” excellently on commentary, and believed in him enough to have Warrior pin Hogan and hand him his first ever 'Mania defeat. We’ll cover how that panned out later in this piece, but Hogan and Warrior’s legacies became intertwined from this moment on.

The pair tried to revive their rivalry in 1998 for WCW, but this was a disaster. Hogan had reinvented himself as Hollywood Hogan alongside the nWo, whilst Warrior was still the same old Warrior. Essentially, the match felt like a way for Hogan to avenge the past, so he defeated Warrior at Halloween Havoc (in one of the most notoriously awful encounters in history) to square off their rivalry.

Vince McMahon attempted to create rivalries for the Warrior with Randy Savage, Sgt. Slaughter, The Undertaker, Jake Roberts and Ted DiBiase, but Jim Hellwig was notoriously difficult to do business with. Hulk gained a reputation for always going into business for himself, but his vast popularity meant he was able to get away with it. Warrior tried the same political coups, but with far less success.

Maybe this was because Hogan was able to make money out of rivalries with his opponents, but Warrior was too self-serving to realise that one man can’t do business by himself, and it showed in his lack of historic rivalries.

4/10


4. Moments

Ultimate Warrior Hulk Hogan Mirror Wcw
WWE

The Ultimate Warrior had an immense rise in WWE. He made his PPV debut at WrestleMania IV, beating Hercules in under 5 minutes, and then ended the longest reign in Intercontinental Title history (at least until Gunther's reign) in just his second PPV. Watch the crowd at Madison Square Garden raise the roof as the Warrior hits the ring after being revealed as The Honky Tonk Man’s mystery opponent at SummerSlam ’88 before ending his 454-day run in just 31 seconds.

It's lightning in a bottle stuff. 

Becoming the first wrestler to hold both the WWF and Intercontinental Titles at the same time is also one of the biggest achievements in company history. The Warrior felt like the heir to Hogan’s throne as he celebrated with both titles at the end of 'Mania VI, but things would plateau in this moment and he'd never reach those heights again. Just 2 and a half years later, Warrior was gone from the WWE entirely.

The Warrior has some awful moments to draw upon when things started going awry, too. His entire feud with Papa Shango is one of the most laughably bad wrestling angles of all time. Shango put a voodoo curse on the Warrior, causing black liquid to seep from the Warrior’s head in promos and him to throw up on WWE medical staff. Hearing Gene Okerlund talk about “black magic” in an attempt to sell the feud is truly dire stuff.

His entire run in WCW was a disaster, as aforementioned, but Hulk seeing Warrior gurning at him as a ghost in a mirror whilst Eric Bischoff stood by obliviously ranks as one of WCW's worst moments. This supernatural BS was a world away from the gritty content the nWo had been pioneering just a few years earlier.

Warrior's payoff match with Hogan also involved Hulk failing miserably to hit him in the face with a fireball, Hellwig having about 40% less intensity than he had in his prime, and a match that makes their 'Mania VI encounter look like Kenny Omega vs. Will Ospreay from AEW's Forbidden Door.

4/10


3. Range

Ultimate Warrior
WWE

At his best, Ultimate Warrior was unpredictable and volatile, but he was ultimately (ahem) a one-trick pony. That's why he shone so brightly for his first 2 years as a top name then struggled for much of the rest of his career. There wasn't much to be found beyond a flashy arrival, a kick-ass entrance theme, and a hyperactive squash match style.

Asking the Warrior to tell a nuanced and elaborate story was virtually impossible. His gibberish promos did a lot to sell the Warrior as a force of nature, but it’s very difficult to build storylines around a man dedicated to talking absolute nonsense at every given opportunity.

Take Warrior’s feud in early-1991 with Sgt Slaughter for the WWF Title, for example. Slaughter was telling a controversial story involving Saddam Hussein, a pair of boots that had been gifted courtesy of the Saudi Arabian war criminal, and building heat around himself as an Iraqi sympathiser during the height of the Gulf War (albeit being offset by calling his adversary “Ultimate Puke”).

All Warrior could add to this Royal Rumble build was blabbering about sand and adding military innuendos about minefields, foxholes and different army ranks to his usual inane ramblings.

1/10


2. Drawing Power

Randy Savage The Ultimate Warrior
WWE.com

Warrior’s ability to draw money is very much a tale of 2 halves. For his first few years in the WWF, the Warrior was a phenom. Making crowds go crazy and parting with their cash, Warrior is the only wrestler of the 1980s who got close to drawing money on the same level as Hulk Hogan.

You can’t blame Vince McMahon for wanting to try pushing Warrior to the moon as the 90s dawned, especially when his tried and trusted red and yellow formula started to wane. Ultimately, he just didn’t have the skillset to take WWE to the heights of Hulkamania. Worse than that, Jim Hellwig got ideas way above his station and began to make obscene financial demands.

He famously (and retrospectively) demanded $550,000 for his WrestleMania VII match vs. Randy Savage, and he wanted financial parity with Hogan for all appearances and merchandise moving forward. Further, Warrior threatened to pull out of the SummerSlam '91 main event (in which he’d team with Hulk vs. Sgt. Slaughter, General Adnan, and Colonel Mustafa) if his demands weren't met, and nobody threatens Vince McMahon and gets away with it.

After failing to ignite the same level of excitement and interest around the WWF Title during his first and only title reign as the company's leading man, it was an outrageous demand for Warrior to make. Fueled by real-life jealousy of Hogan’s fame and fortune, Hellwig would be granted his request, only for Vince to suspend him indefinitely directly after coming back through the curtain following his SummerSlam match.

The Ultimate Warrior only headlined 2 WWE PPVs in his whole career. His return to WCW was a nostalgia-tinted disaster at a time when the company would've been better served by elevating the likes of Rey Mysterio, Eddie Guerrero and Chris Jericho. He's rightfully considered a wrestling icon of the 1980s, but the reality is that his run at the top lasted less time than Goldberg’s streak.

3/10


1. Conclusion

Ultimate Warrior
WWE.com

The Ultimate Warrior is one of the most recognisable WWE superstars from their golden period, but is more revered by casual observers than lifelong fans of the business. His whole schtick was so comedically over-the-top and cut off from reality that it has become something of a joke over time.

Warrior had one trick that was right for the 80s when the product was at its most cartoonish. The Undertaker debuted with a gimmick that is also easy to ridicule during Warrior's only title reign, but he was able to transition from the walking undead to becoming a tough-as-nails biker and a John Wayne-style outlaw in his later years.

Meanwhile, Warrior wasn't able to find another gear. He was limited back then, hence only being popular for a very small window of time, and it's completely unfathomable that a gimmick so absurd could conquer the wrestling world during any other time period.

In certain ways, it can even be argued that Warrior was a detriment to wrestling itself. Performing in an era in which Dusty Rhodes’ aspirational “hard times” speech and Roddy Piper’s passionate delivery remain everlasting examples of how emotionally transcendent wrestling can be, Warrior’s nutty rantings and freakish physique put wrestling into an unflattering box that drew scorn and ridicule from detractors.

The idea that wrestling is a knuckle-dragger’s art form is a dated outlook that persists among outsiders of our fandom to this day, largely due to being perpetuated by characters like The Ultimate Warrior. 

Nostalgia will always mean that the Warrior will have a place in wrestling folklore. Fans who were the right age to be "Little Warriors" can always look back fondly on the brief period in which Warrior rocked the wrestling world. Take off those rose-tinted glasses, however, and Ultimate Warrior leaves a largely unflattering legacy in his wake.

3/10


Contributor

Terry Bezer hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.