25 Crazy WCW Facts (That Get Progressively More Ridiculous)
Where The Big Boys Play - and where it gets more ridiculous than losing a No DQ match by DQ…
It’s easy to be reductive and say that WCW as stupid. That’s because WCW, as an entity, as an idea, was stupid.
This is the promotion that installed Kevin Nash as booker, after which Kevin Nash thought it would be a great idea if Kevin Nash defeated the undefeated Bill Goldberg. So this actually wasn’t a great idea. Goldberg had to lose eventually, and it was probably too soon, but hey: heat’s good, isn’t it? All the old heads will tell you that you make money by drawing heat. What did Kevin Nash do with all that heat, which is as valuable as the Salvator Mundi?
He laid down for Hollywood Hulk Hogan within weeks, and reformed the New World Order, because WCW had one good idea and lacked the ability to do literally anything else.
Then, when that did not go well, Kevin Nash on his last day in the post decided to do commentary on Thunder and completely ridicule every single aspect of the company, treating its imminent death, in which he was instrumental, like a big joke. With the most smug grin he could muster, Nash undermined everything. Nash treated WCW as if he was your non-fan mate taking the piss out of you for enjoying it. Jim Duggan went over in one match. The idea is that you were meant to think he was as good once as he ever was. Nash literally could not stop himself from pissing himself with laughter when Mike Tenay called Duggan’s ‘Old Glory’ leg drop. What are you on about with this utter 1980s sh*t?, is what Nash was basically getting at.
Nash knew WWE was never going to let the lead slip. His response, as the man responsible for trying to catch up, was to distance himself from WCW in order to protect his beloved cool guy image.
WCW was stupid. You might not know the sheer extent of it…
25. The Referees Won’t Call For DQs!
When people say that Vince Russo booked a parody of pro wrestling, they use the term as an insult - but, genuinely, was this his actual plan?
WCW was so nonsensical that he had to have done this sort of thing on purpose. It is the only remotely possible exclamation. It is surely impossible for anybody to be that stupid.
If you can stomach it, and revisit the WCW product of 2000, the commentary team was up in arms about Russo’s BS. Tony Schiavone was as exasperated as the viewer at home. 2000 WCW is impossible to make sense of because people insist upon viewing it through the lens of a traditional wrestling product. It wasn’t. Russo deliberately wrote something else entirely, but to what end is a mystery. Was Russo simply trolling? Consider the events of the April 17, 2000 episode of Nitro.
Ahead of the much-hyped new era, Tony Schiavone insisted that in the new WCW, there’d be winners and losers. The refs, accordingly, would not be calling for disqualifications. After Schiavone said this, Mike Awesome defeated Diamond Dallas Page by disqualification. In the very next match, Shane Douglas defeated Lex Luger by disqualification. In the match after that, Scott Steiner defeated Jeff Jarrett by disqualification. Three consecutive matches ended via DQ.
Even if the method here was to knowingly troll the fans - and not brainlessly contradict everything - the idea was stupid.
Ragebait booking only works when the fans are half-certain that the payoff is coming at the biggest show of the year, and WCW’s track record of satisfying fans was comparable to a micro-penised incel.
24. WCW Sold Rey Mysterio, Jr. Masks…
…months and months after he no longer wore one himself.
At SuperBrawl 1999, Rey Mysterio and Konnan lost a Mask Vs. Hair tag team match against Kevin Nash and Scott Hall.
As per the stipulation, and the real-life instruction of Eric Bischoff, Rey was forced to unmask. This is always a moving scene, because the mask is sacred in lucha libre. The loser need not sell; the gravity of the situation is very real, which is why the tradition is so lucrative and longstanding. With Rey, it was different. He didn’t want to do it, but he also didn’t want to lose his spot, or even his job. He was distraught but also visibly hated the ordeal. This was WCW in the first quarter of 1999, too; to put it as generously as possible, there was no guarantee that the promotion would maximise anything.
Rey’s mask obscured his incredibly cherubic face. At his size, he was always an underdog, but with this new look, at a time when size mattered far more than it does nowadays, it was harder to take him seriously. As a result, he was recast as a little brat of a heel, which was a disgrace. Rey was a generational babyface talent forced into the role of prelim bump and feed fodder. This didn’t just kill Rey’s WCW career; WCW lost a potential fortune in merchandise sales because they could not sell the replica masks that proved so popular in WWE that even Vince McMahon relented and pushed him to a level he didn’t want to.
Except, well into 2000, WCW actually did sell replica masks for an unmasked wrestler. By April, they were still collecting dust on merch desks with increasingly shorter lines.
23. Money For Nothing
Lanny Poffo, the brother of Macho Man Randy Savage, was a more than capable midcard wrestler for his era. He excelled at comedy so much that he is one half of Kenny Omega’s favourite match ever.
Years after his prime, he signed a deal with WCW in 1995. This was at the behest of his brother, who had purchased on his behalf the rights to the Gorgeous George gimmick. This was ugly and somewhat shrewd at the same time, in that Poffo peaked as the effeminate Genius character in the WWF. Poffo bleached his hair in preparation for the role. Some online records suggest that he worked a maximum of two dark matches, but this is difficult to verify. Cagematch records an entry of a match on October 14, 1997 before a Saturday Night taping, but literally lists a series of question marks as the opponent. In the October 27, 1997 issue of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Dave Meltzer reported that Poffo defeated ‘L.A.’ on that date.
Beyond that one dark match, for longer than the entire duration of the Attitude Era, Poffo sat at home and collected, per the Death of WCW, $150,000 to never even fly into work - much less wrestle.
This, potentially, is the single dumbest WCW fact ever, but there might be some mitigation, in that Eric Bischoff reckons that Savage was paid $100,000 less to accommodate the deal. But even that is extremely stupid, because it would mean that WCW had a wrestler working for free that could have put the odd guy over at least.
Bear in mind that the title of this article is ‘Crazy WCW Facts (That Get Progressively More Ridiculous). It can’t get more ridiculous than this, can it?
*Mick McCarthy intensifies*
It can.
22. Thursday Slamboree Thursday
By 1999, WCW was failing dismally.
Months and months before Russo turned up, WCW had experimented with dumb authority figure power struggles and a silly, heightened tone. Meanwhile, the WWF was so hot that it barely mattered how awful it was. WCW copied the WWF’s homework and still failed. Many people felt that a back-to-basics approach was necessary. You know, things like sensible long-term storylines, match results that matter, listening to the audience, rewarding wrestlers who actually put in a modicum of effort. With WCW though, the absolute bare minimum was not met so often that the promotion had to get even the most rudimentary business practises correct before anything else.
In denial, WCW ran the TWA Dome in St. Louis, Missouri, drawing just 13,000 paying fans after persuading 30,000 to attend a Nitro in the same building in December 1998. You’d think that WCW might have wanted to push the hell out of the show on TV. Times were bleak. Instead, WCW failed to get the date of the show correct on television. This is the first thing they hammer you with in promo class. The date and the venue is the most important information to stress. Forget that, and you can forget selling any tickets. WCW forgot this; on the go-home edition of Thunder, a graphic was displayed reading ‘Slamboree! TOMORROW, 8PM EST’.
The problem, of course, was that like every other WCW pay-per-view ever, Slamboree was taking place on Sunday.
WCW was so stupid that if it was a person, it would forget how to breathe.
21. The Most Insane Quote Ever
Vince Russo’s booking did not make sense. This is the man who booked the New Blood Rising pay-per-view.
At New Blood Rising, Goldberg was written out of a three-way #1 contender’s match via motorcycle accident. This was good news for Kevin Nash, who said that he was “going over” Scott Steiner. As what became an impromptu Nash Vs. Steiner singles match unfolded, the commentary team wondered aloud if it would turn into a shoot. Scott Hudson buried Nash for booking himself to go over Goldberg at Starrcade 1998.
Goldberg eventually hit the ring. It’s important to note here that the match was every worked match you’ve ever seen. That’s because it ended in a worked shoot, which, in addition to making no sense in and of itself, made a pointless mockery of the work.
Goldberg walked out when he refused to “go up” for the powerbomb. The commentators literally pointed this out. That was the story of the match. This summoned an infuriated Vince Russo, who loudly told Goldberg to go along with the script. Goldberg told him to f*ck off. Nash went over Steiner by powerbomb. Once again, it’s impossible to make sense of this, but here goes:
Vince Russo didn’t think wrestling fans enjoyed the wrestling part of wrestling. Instead, wishing to appear smart, Russo wrote for the hardcore fan, who knew how it all worked, under the belief that they preferred the backstage drama of it all. Fake backstage drama thus became the narrative focal point of WCW programming. The problem here - on top of targeting a niche audience and lowering the ceiling for his beloved ratings - is that the hardcore fans thought this meta business was rubbish too, and spent their time mocking it online. WCW, thus, was a product for nobody that made no sense.
Russo still told the New York Times that “There is one word that we start and end every conversation with: logic. Once you lose the logic of the situation, then you lose the realism and you lose the audience”.
What joke can you possibly write about that?
20. Hulk Hogan Was Worse Than Kevin Nash
Hulk Hogan exercised creative control over his WCW run, which naturally pissed the rest of “the boys” off.
Unable to hold himself accountable, since he was a bone-deep narcissist, Hogan hopped on the Mancow radio show in June 1999 to blame everybody else for WCW’s failings. He said he was fed up of hearing “Malenko and the rest of the midgets” whining about being held back.
Maybe Hogan had a semblance of a point here - not that it was wise of him to make it, or that there was any realistic opportunity for the cruisers to prove that they could draw. With the fullness of time, the idea that the cruisers could star in main events was the futile dreaming of a naive aspirational hipster. Malenko was particularly uncharismatic, too. If you’re Hulk Hogan, you probably are balking at the idea that the Rock’s momentum could be stopped, if only Dean Malenko could headline Slamboree in a 25 minute match against Blitzkrieg. Astonishingly, though, Hogan also buried Goldberg.
Hogan downplayed Goldberg’s accomplishments in the business, saying that anybody could win “20,000” matches in a row. What a stupid and petulant comment to make. If it was that easy, WCW could have handed anybody an undefeated streak every time business needed a shot in the arm.
It’s not as if Hogan did many jobs, especially when his character was failing badly as 1995 rolled into 1996. By Hogan’s logic, Uncensored 1996 should have got him more over than ever. The show was in fact so poorly received that even Hogan had to resort to turning heel.
19. The Commentary Was EVEN WORSE In A Different Language
The WCW commentary team was often ridiculed, across its various incarnations, but come on. They had an impossible job, especially towards the end.
Bobby Heenan - whose ideas were waved away by Eric Bischoff - by his own admission checked out within weeks. He spent six years in WCW. Tony Schiavone’s job as lead commentator was to make sense of the storylines, so of course his credibility was shot to death by firing squad. Larry Zbysko was a sardonic arse. Mike Tenay was informative and emerged from the circus with his integrity intact. Dusty Rhodes was at least delightfully insane. Eric Bischoff just wanted to be on the show, and wasn’t worthy of his place until he joined the New World Order, at which point his smugness actually worked. Stevie Ray was a goof. Scott Hudson actually tried. Steve McMichael was a spotlight hog, but a big personality. Mark Madden was an intensely unlikeable presence, much too off-putting and witless even to play the heel colour role. Was the commentary better in German?
Nein!
To be fair, it might have been most of the time, but at Starrcade 1999, in a rarity, the German commentary team was in attendance live. They were joined by a comedian, Tom Gerhardt, who was famous in the early ‘90s for a routine in which he’d dress up as a giant penis and pretend to jizz on the audience. If Art Donovan and Bubba The Love Sponge were spliced together, Gerhardt would be the resulting abomination: he mocked Disco Inferno as “gay”, complimented the “nice t*ts” of Madusa, and basically said that wrestling was fake and that he could beat all the wrestlers up, including Chris Benoit, standing up when Benoit issued his open challenge.
18. HOW Many Pole Matches?
The exact number of On A Pole matches booked by Vince Russo is difficult to gauge, because late-period WCW is so dumb that it makes people weigh up the philosophical difference between a metal pole and a forklift.
The number is likely 12; other Pole matches took place before and after Russo’s three stints with the company. If you combine Russo’s three actually short-lived stints with WCW, the total amount of months over which he had control is less than a year, somewhere between nine to ten. Ergo, Russo booked On A Pole matches at a rate over one per month. The real staggering stat here is that Russo, in his first full month in charge, November 1999, booked three Pole matches - which isn’t too far off one per week.
Eddie Guerrero Vs. Perry Saturn ‘Key On A Pole’ (November 1, 1999); El Dandy Vs. Silver King Vs. Villano IV Vs. Psicosis Vs. Juventud Guerrera ‘Five-Way Pinata On A Pole (November 15); Dean Malenko Vs. Chris Benoit ‘Flag On A Pole’ (November 22).
WCW presented five episodes of Nitro in November 1999. A Pole match happened 60% of the time. On the other two Mondays, Russo booked three hardcore matches on November 8, and on November 29, he booked two steel cage matches.
The real crux here is that you could very credible argue that just one ‘On A Pole’ match was too many, because the match type is so stunningly boring and has yielded exactly zero worthy matches that anybody cared about.
There is no drama in climbing a pole because you only need to climb the top turnbuckle to reach the item atop it. In WCW especially, through its pioneering cruiserweight division, fans were used to watching the wrestlers climb to that position at will.
17. WCW Was Ass
Vince Russo will tell you, until he’s in the goddamn grave, that Standards & Practices ruined what he was trying to do with WCW. That meddling department of Warner kept getting in the way of his ratings-winning ideas, like rampant misogyny and non-stop homophobia.
In the spring of 2000, Standards & Practices brought the hammer down again, insisting that WCW could not air the word “ass” on its programming. That was a pain in the ass. What was up their ass? It was hardly the C-word, although Russo almost certainly wanted to call a piece of ass that at some point. Standards and Practices could shove their fake morality up their ass, bro. This was ass-backwards, bro. This ain’t the 1950s anymore, come on. Get your head out of your ass and get with the times. Russo was busting his ass trying to kick the WWF’s ass, and this is the thanks he got? Why were they on his ass so much? They could kiss his ass, for all he cared.
On the June 13 episode of WCW Thunder, the banned word was uttered no less than 11 times after Russo was explicitly told to knock it off. An errant ass is acceptable, because the word was so entrenched in trash-talk slang at that point, and the average pro wrestler was too dumb and jacked up from performing in front of a live crowd to remember the edict, but 11 is taking the piss a bit, no?
It’s not as if WCW enjoyed a healthy relationship with their paymasters at this point.
16. Can’t Do Right For Doing Wrong
WCW was so ridiculous, so phenomenally cursed, that the promotion literally couldn’t do right for doing wrong.
The history of the promotion is infested with examples of horrendous communication. On countless occasions, WCW failed to inform viewers of the rules to certain matches. And failed to communicate properly with its partners.
In one infamous example of WCW’s problem in this area, a widely-known fact that isn’t even the subject of this entry, the liaison to pay-per-view providers neglected to inform carriers that Halloween Havoc 1998 was scheduled to last longer than the usual three hours; this resulted in 25% of paying fans missing the main event between WCW World champion Goldberg and Diamond Dallas Page. Because so many fans opted for a refund instead of a free replay, since WCW aired the main event on Nitro for free, the Wrestling Observer Newsletter’s Dave Meltzer estimated that WCW lost out on close to $1 million dollars in revenue.
Along similar lines, WCW for years simply did not tell viewers when certain episodes of TV were set to be pre-empted. This was just par for the course. Either nobody cared, somebody forgot, or nobody knew whose responsibility it was. Not sure what’s worse.
WCW resolved to get it right ahead of the October 5, 2000 Nitro. This episode was meant to start 35 minutes later than the usual 8PM slot. That is because it was meant to be pre-empted by a NASCAR race. WCW stressed that the programme would begin at 8:35PM.
Unfortunately for WCW, the one bloody time that the promotion actually did the right thing, they were wrong. Nitro hadn’t been preempted after all.