How Good Was Babyface Roman Reigns Actually?

Analysing all the good and bad from Roman Reigns pre-'Tribal Chief' reinvention.

By Terry Bezer /

WWE.com

The Shield altered WWE's landscape and gave Vince McMahon his most successful act in years, then the 3 members in that 'Hounds Of Justice' trio began to forge their own paths. More than Seth Rollins or Dean Ambrose, Roman Reigns courted the bulk of hysteria and extreme reactions post-Shield. Unfortunately for him and the maniacal billionaire, a lot of that feedback was largely for all of the wrong reasons. 

Advertisement

Following the 'Ruthless Aggression' era and being expected to fill the enormous void left by John Cena's decision to leave wrestling as his full-time job (whilst attempting to conquer Hollywood), Roman Reigns was given the dubious opportunity to lead a billion-dollar global entertainment enterprise into its brave new future. It was a massive task, and an unnecessary one, considering WWE is seen much more as a team effort with retrospect in the wake of McMahon leaving the company.

Join us as we relive the pre-'Tribal Chief' years of Roman to reassess how good he actually was during that period. Was he unfairly criticized, or was the 'Big Dog' incapable of running WWE's yard? Strap yourselves in, because this is not a reappraisal for the faint-hearted.

10. Presence/Look/Presentation

Just take a look at Roman and you'll understand the thinking behind WWE’s head office throwing their full weight behind making him the heir to John Cena as the top guy. He’s big, strong, athletic, and women are kicking off their shoes to try to be with him just at the sight of the muscular Adonis.

Advertisement

However, presentation played a large part in why these early years failed to capitalise on Roman's talents. After The Shield split up, Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose got new entrance music, updated their look and ran with personas that expanded on their work in the group. Meanwhile, Reigns kept everything that worked before, and that was to his detriment. Coming in through the crowd clicked for The Shield because they looked and felt like a SWAT team about to indulge in guerrilla warfare; Roman walking through the crowd alone made it look like he hadn’t let go of the past, whilst his compatriots had moved on without him.

Entrance music was also a big problem with this part of Roman’s career. As the 'Tribal Chief', he has music that demands your attention. From its thumping drum intro, it feels godlike and commands spectacle with its grandiose operatic vocals. It suits his aura, with a main piano melody drenched in drama and punctuated by stabs of powerful, distorted guitars. The Shield’s music is so intrinsically linked to their arrival as a team, because they had such a monumental, landscape-altering impact on WWE. Just giving that music to Reigns meant he had to carry the weight of all of that, and it was too much for any one man to carry, let alone a performer still trying to "find his thing".

Roman's look didn’t receive an update either. See him today, kitted out in the freshest shoes from sneaker culture and his logo looking like wrestling’s Jumpman. Keeping the SWAT team look of The Shield felt silly because the whole point of that look was to make it seem like the members of that group were geared for squad combat. One man in protective gear looks scared.

The biggest problem in keeping the look, music, and feel of The Shield is rooted in ethics, too. The stable worked because they looked, felt and were presented as being anti-establishment, but Roman couldn’t have been more anointed by Vince McMahon if he came out doing the 'Billionaire Strut'. His presentation vs. the reality of the situation were completely incongruous with one another, especially for an audience that felt overly cynical towards Roman.

Cody Rhodes is a great babyface, but he embraces the idea of being "QB1". Roman was given that jersey in this era, but his presentation was supposed to make us believe that he wasn't handed that on a silver platter, and it didn't work for him.

None of this is Roman’s fault. He was pushed in ways that his skillset couldn’t handle yet - WWE let Roman down with all this negligence. The thought behind him was “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it”. Audience reaction from the very beginning should've shown this to be deeply flawed logic.

2/10

9. Promos

Let’s go for the throat on this straight away: There has never been a bigger glow-up in terms of mic work than Roman Reigns. This has to be pointed out, because great mic work often takes time to build as a skill. Whilst Seth and Dean had Tyler Black and Jon Moxley behind them (thus honing their craft on the independents), Roman was far newer to the trials and tribulations of weekly wrestling TV, and it showed in a big way.

Advertisement

In The Shield, those guys did the majority of the talking, but Roman had the cool factor. He spoke monosyllabically, and that fit like a glove next to Ambrose and Rollins foaming at the mouth. When Reigns went solo, WWE was in a very different place than it is today. CM Punk and Daniel Bryan became popular because they were so drastically different from what WWE’s head office believed to be cool.

Roman Reigns was WWE’s anointed one, and being new to the business, he was understandably taking the advice of his superiors and trusting them to guide him on the path to glory. Their writing for him was abysmal.

As such, Roman's promo ability in his early years felt like a man reading from a bad script. Not just a bad script; at times, it was one so cataclysmically awful that people still remember individual lines. Hearing Reigns call Rollins a “sniveling little suck-up sellout full of sufferin' succotash” made him look childish and foolish to such an extent that it’s a delivery that will follow him forever. Similarly, calling Sheamus a “tater tot” was immature and couldn't be further from the "cinema" he produces today.

Then, John Cena took him apart in August 2017 in such devastating fashion that he froze completely and looked like Papa Doc at the end of Eminem’s 8 Mile movie. It’s all stuff that would never happen to your 'Tribal Chief'.

Listen to Roman today. Everything he says oozes cool, and his delivery is emotional yet controlled. The 'OTC' is a believable character with historical relevance due to his family ties and contemporary cool. Conversely, the 'Big Dog' felt like they’d given Reigns a pair of John Cena’s old shoes and expected him to walk in them.

Reigns admitted all of these problems on an episode of Logan Paul’s podcast: “If someone gives me something to say today and I don’t want to say it, I ain’t saying it. 10 years ago, if someone’s giving me a script and Vince is telling me to say something and it’s highlighted, then you gonna say it". That's Roman’s direct quote, and lord did WWE give him some crappy stories, promos, catchphrases and nicknames in those early years.

2/10

8. In-Ring Ability

Roman is exactly what WWE wants from its superstars in the ring. This is a company that demands its own in-house brand of wrestling, so much so that when outsiders join the company it takes them a period of time to adjust. If you watch Jacob Fatu when he arrived in WWE compared to his work now, then you can see that evolution happening in real time.

Advertisement

Reigns was born into WWE’s system as a pro wrestler. His moves are exciting and built for 2K video games and WrestleMania main events. If this seems like a knock on his art in any way, it isn’t. He is literally the perfect WWE superstar when it comes to the work he does in the ring.

All of his iconic moves were forged during this part of his career and in his time at FCW, NXT, and as part of The Shield. As the 'Tribal Chief', his spear feels a lot more impactful, his power over his emotions means the pacing of his matches is better, and he sells everything with the cinematic feel that he has made his forte. That doesn't detract from the fact that Roman has always been able to go in the ring. He’s an incredible athlete, and his signature moves and finishers are perfect for a man his size.

The “OOOOH-AAAAAH!” before hitting his spear is the definition of iconic. He may not sell cocking his fist like it’s a pump-action shotgun, and punching the ground like he’s Goku about to go Super Saiyan as much these days, but these are essential elements that make him the perfect WWE wrestler. Selling this in NJPW or AEW might not have the same effect, but in WWE, where your in-ring work is designed to make you seem like a larger-than-life superhero, Roman Reigns is one of the standout talents of his generation.

8/10

7. Time’s Test

One of the reasons why this babyface run didn’t work is that it came in an era directly after fans had witnessed John Cena being forced down their throats for over a decade. Although John gets called the "GOAT" and has a string of moments and matches that are sold as core memories to fans retrospectively, wrestling fans who only had WWE as a viable weekly TV show were sick and tired of the Hulk Hogan-esque approach that had been served to them. When Vince tried to promote Roman in the same way, fans rebelled.

Advertisement

McMahon was so far past his creative best by the time he was booking Reigns as his lead babyface that Reigns became the poster child for how much the old boss had lost his mojo. It’s why Paul Heyman, with his contemporary pop culture references and mindset, was so vital towards revitalising this character and showing Roman who he was capable of being.

The 'Big Dog' would be eaten alive if faced the 'Tribal Chief'. When the kingpin of the 'Island Of Relevancy' pointed out that WWE works for him during a SmackDown encounter with Brock Lesnar, it was done with the power of a thousand men. This went beyond Reigns trying to sell himself as a powerful force during these years. When CM Punk aimed barbs at Roman on Colt Cabana’s podcast, pointing out that he was WWE's newly anointed golden boy to an audience that wanted the anti-Roman in Daniel Bryan, it set him back years because he couldn’t and didn’t defend himself.

Reigns was able to stand up against Punk’s heaviest artillery, eyeball-to-eyeball, on the road to WrestleMania 42. That direct comparison shows how far he has come since those early years. He was a timid boy back then, and he is a mountain of a man today

Look at Oba Femi in 2026, too. The machine is so behind him that he has (allegedly) retired Brock at 'Mania mere weeks after arriving on WWE’s main roster. He's being pushed to the moon, and nobody has a problem with it because he has his own unique, unquestionable vibe, and WWE's creative (no matter what you might think of it) isn't as insulting towards the audience as it was under McMahon. The 2014/15 Roman didn't have half the required aura to fill the spot he was being asked to, and he was hampered by just about everything WWE gave him.

3/10

6. Cultural Significance

In a business that plays on nostalgia in such a meaningful and deliberate way, there’s a reason why you never see video packages put together that showcase the early history of Roman Reigns. This is a man who has headlined more WrestleManias than anybody in history, but WWE purposefully keeps Roman’s past locked away in a fashion they do not for stars like John Cena or even CM Punk. That's 'cause this period of Roman’s career is so far beneath the stories he crafts and the feuds he inhabits today that it would be to his detriment to put his past in front of a modern audience.

Advertisement

The Shield will be remembered forever. The 'Tribal Chief’s' 1,316-day title reign and telling one of the best long-running stories in wrestling with The Bloodline changed the fortunes of WWE at a time when the company’s credibility was on its knees. The truth is that nothing that happened between these duelling eras will make it into Roman’s overall highlights package.

Again, we have to point towards the state WWE was in during these years.

All 3 of The Shield have gone on to have immense moments and feuds away from McMahon-led creative. Imagine Jon Moxley giving a fig about a potted plant as the head of the 'Death Riders'? Compare Seth Rollins righteous anger towards CM Punk and compare that to his nonsense around 'The Fiend' or under The Authority. The babyface period of Reigns’ career will not leave a cultural footprint for any positive reason, and that is as much to do with his brilliance on either side of these years as it is the playground slop he was having to serve up back then.

The only reason he had cultural significance during those years? He was put in 'Mania headline slots and had WWE Championship reigns. His runs with the United States and Intercontinental Championships did nothing to elevate the status or significance of those belts. You can’t be irrelevant when you’re the guy WWE is pinning their hopes on, despite how futile that felt during this era.

4/10

5. Rivalries

Reigns’ first feud after the breakup of The Shield was with Randy Orton. It was during this rivalry that the writing was on the wall that Roman was being catapulted to the top of WWE, but he never really looked comfortable on his own. That was a problem - everyone put into a feud with Reigns was trying to make him look like Superman, but these were largely seasoned veterans at the top of their craft.

Advertisement

Brock Lesnar is the person most associated with Reigns in this period, as they headlined 2 WrestleManias and a SummerSlam together, but they never had any spark. Lesnar is a man who lets his actions do the talking. Paul Heyman is arguably the best talker in wrestling history and therefore created a chasm between himself and Reigns’ mic ability. Whilst a Seth Rollins’ cash-in saved Lesnar and Reigns' decent 'Mania 31 main event, both men were roundly booed and rejected by the crowd when headlining 34 in New Orleans years later.

If Cena had been the blueprint for the vast majority of Reigns’ push to little avail, then WWE went the Steve Austin route for Roman in 2016. Vince, alongside Stephanie and Triple H, conspired to try to stack the deck against him in an attempt to get fans to rally behind their new hero. They made him defend the WWE Title in the Royal Rumble and put him at #1 before crowning Hunter as the new champion at the end of the night.

This all felt futile too, as nobody could believe that Roman wasn’t a corporately-appointed stooge who was going to (and did) emerge victorious against Triple H at 'Mania 32. The idea that this man with 10/10 good looks and a family lineage in the business (who'd been rammed down fans' throats for almost 2 years straight) was somehow “one against all” was impossible to buy.

The only saving grace for Roman from this entire saga was his feud with Rollins. It always feels personal between the pair, and their feuds had more engagement from fans than Reigns had mustered up to this point. Rollins had the fan support in their 2016 feud, despite being booked as the heel, but WWE refused to turn Reigns into a villain and see if it would work. It was a misfire, but at least moments like Rollins winning the WWE title from Roman at Money In The Bank 2016 and during his WrestleMania 31 cash-in gave them a history that they can still use to this day.

Roman created great matches during these years with AJ Styles, Braun Strowman and as part of 2 separate Shield reunions, but none of these feuds helped change fans’ opinions on Reigns.

5/10

4. Moments

If this all comes across a little harsh, then cast your minds back to Roman’s first Royal Rumble victory in 2015. The Rock is a man who is very aware of his public popularity, and he looked like he’d rather be anywhere else as choruses of boos showered the ring and he raised his cousin’s hand in victory. This was a sentiment felt throughout the world too, as Roman was arguably the worst-received Rumble winner of all time.

Advertisement

Some of that was down to Daniel Bryan being the fans’ favourite, but Reigns was also becoming public enemy numero uno due to how fast he was being pushed. This win came just 7 months after the break-up of The Shield, and Reigns had been a huge fan favourite just 12 months earlier when he eliminated 8 men and finished the match as runner-up to an enormous, positive fan reaction.

It would get worse.

Not only did Reigns have to suffer being a grown man calling himself the 'Big Dog', but this was used against him literally when Dolph Ziggler, Bobby Roode and Baron Corbin handcuffed him to a ring post and poured dog food all over him. Vince McMahon’s fingerprints are all over this hot garbage, but it’s Roman Reigns who has to suffer this image being out in the public for the rest of his life.

On a more positive note, Reigns became only the 2nd man to beat The Undertaker at WrestleMania 33 in a match that he did exceptionally well to carry considering how far 'Taker was past his best in 2017. This was eclipsed by Roman opening Raw the following night and being greeted by over 7 minutes of building-shaking boos and chants of “go away” and “you suck”.

His one line, “This is my yard now” is the first time he channeled the future cool of the 'Chief', but it really is a testament to how fans felt about Roman during these years that the hate directed his way was so unforgettably toxic.

4/10

3. Range

Behold yet another area in which WWE let Reigns down with their stubborn and tone-deaf booking.

Advertisement

There was such a tidal wave of hate for Roman that the smart move was surely to turn him heel and see what he could do. Allowing him to harness that anger from fans and do something with it creatively, instead of forcing a character that was never going to pass in a way that was turning fans off, would've been cool. Y'know, letting him show that he was worthy of WWE investing so much of their hope in him instead of just trying different things that had worked in the past in the vague hopes that it might resonate with fans once more.

He wasn’t given this opportunity. WWE would move him into the US Championship scene and take him out of the main event when the Universal title was first introduced to center things around NXT callups Kevin Owens and Finn Bàlor, but this was only ever temporary. Roman was pushed to the moon as a babyface once more.

This feels all the more tragic when we see what Reigns is capable of today. Whether babyface or heel, he's as good a performer as any wrestling company could wish to have as their top guy. Fans saw this when he stepped away for 5 months as COVID took the world off its axis, then came back to begin the run of a lifetime that finally made him everything WWE believed he could be.

The sad reality is that these years were wasted by Vince, a stubborn old man who treated his audience with contempt and believed they were far stupider and easier to manipulate than they actually are. 

3/10

2. Drawing Power

The years that Roman Reigns was pushed as a babyface were criticized by fans in a way that changed the landscape of pro wrestling forever. The rise of the Bullet Club and NJPW happened here, and the indy scene became hotter than ever as fans looked elsewhere after being disenfranchised by Vince McMahon using Roman Reigns as his latest Hulk Hogan.

Advertisement

The world screamed at WWE’s owner that they were ready for something new, so much so that CM Punk left and openly criticized the promotion for preparing the rocket that they were so obviously going to strap Reigns to, then Cody Rhodes and The Elite convinced a billionaire to start AEW. This all happened because McMahon was trying to recreate the past, and Roman Reigns was the poor guy taking bullets for this outlook.

These were not great box office years for WWE, and Roman was the man who had been entrusted to continue the legacy of the generational babyfaces that came before him. It didn’t work. At all. Hell, John Cena even came back and cut a scathing promo on Reigns in 2017, bemoaning that he had to keep coming back to work for Vince because Reigns didn’t have what it takes to draw the same kind of business that he did.

Daniel Bryan had a moment in these years, in spite of McMahon and his cronies, before they went back to trying their outdated formula with Reigns after The Shield split. WrestleMania filled stadiums with Reigns headlining them, but those stadiums were never behind him. It's a testament to Roman’s resilience and talent that those same fans now put their index finger to the heavens in acknowledgment of his greatness.

It's harder to turn negativity around than it is to get to the top and stay there. Nevertheless, these years are not remembered with any fondness, whether financially or creatively.

4/10

1. Conclusion

The babyface period of Roman Reigns’ career should not be given a revisionist history to make it seem as though it was better than it was. It was a fairly awful run in front of an audience who rejected him as the poster child for what Vince wanted his WWE to be. To indulge in “this era was good because…” rewrites would be to taint the incredible, generational work that the man himself has put in to go from this level of poor performance and immense, genuinely hateful public scrutiny to being not only the biggest WWE superstar of this era, but a man in the conversation to be the greatest WWE superstar of all time.

Advertisement

When Reigns is at the bottom of the 9th of his career, these years will matter, but not because of their quality. To come through the very worst years of McMahon’s creative, to be smeared in dog food and booed by stadiums of people in the main event of WrestleMania as a babyface? It would have buried lesser men. Hell, it would have buried nearly everybody but Roman Reigns.

If you had shown fans of this era footage of thousands of people all over the globe standing to attention and raising their hands to the sky in acknowledgment of Roman's greatness and undeniable aura now, they would never have believed it was real.

With the exception of his bitter feud with Seth Rollins, which proved to be his true undoing at WrestleMania 40, and building the foundations of his in-ring ability (which have also seen a massive improvement following this period), these years are best kept away from the lineage of the 'Tribal Chief's' story. When all is said and done, Roman will go down as one of the greats, but only a sliver of these years will make it into his greatest hits montage.

Of all the achievements Reigns has achieved and will go on to achieve, overcoming this period will always rank among his greatest accomplishments. Believe that.

4/10

Advertisement