WWE Backlash 2026: 9 Nightmares That Could Come True
The worst things that could happen in Tampa on WWE's next PLE. Prepare for the Backlash!
Certain things need to happen at Backlash on Saturday night in Tampa, Florida. For example, it's vital that Jacob Fatu looks competitive against Roman Reigns, that Bron Breakker takes his next step, that Danhausen is allowed to do his off-the-wall brand of humour without TKO meddling and more.
WWE is in a bit of a strange place at the moment. WrestleMania 42's second night pulled the nose up after a poorly received opening card, but a string of releases and all of the fallout surrounding those (budget cuts, 2 day pay cut ultimatums etc) has left a sour taste in the mouths of many.
Honestly, it doesn't feel like that's the end. If anything, it seems like those pay cut reports are just the tip of the iceberg. Triple H must be sighing a heavy sigh knowing he'll be asked about all of this at some point, and it's hardly like the product has been on fire creatively either.
Enter the nightmares.
This isn't a positivity-drenched look at the company's next PLE. No, it's a worst of the worst tour through some of the crappiest things that could happen come Backlash. We've got 9 entries spread out across all 5 matches and a heavily-hyped announcement from he-who's-repeatedly-wheeled-out to shift some tickets (apparently) John Cena.
Mascots becoming The Undertaker, a major push stalling badly, more unwanted celebrity influence on WWE's biggest shows, part-time champions going back on their word after 'Mania, stars coming out of retirement for no good reason at all - it's all here.
Being real, if any of this goes down, then it might be WWE and TKO feeling the Backlash...from fans!
9. The Gingerbread Man Pulls An Undertaker!
"I wish you could all be here". That's something iconic announcer Jim Ross used to say regularly during The Undertaker's entrance. He'd bark inspired commentary lines about 'Taker's various rebirths, refer to him as 'The Phenom', 'Deadman' and 'Grim Reaper' of WWE. It all worked, and the character had credibility.
Unfortunately for SmackDown in 2026, the same cannot be said for the Gingerbread Man. That won't stop creative from running with a funeral segment for the mascot gimmick on Friday's 'go home' blue brand TV before Backlash. In theory, this will be WWE's way of saying goodbye to the short-lived character.
Or not.
What if Gingerbread “rises from the dead” in time for Saturday's PLE to cost Sami Zayn his shot at reclaiming the United States Title from Trick Williams? Obviously, that’d be far too comedic, but there are already concerns that Sami and Trick are looking for laughs rather than getting serious with their feud post-WrestleMania.
There'd be no need for GM (hmmm, is that Nick Aldis under the headpiece?! Only joking!) to interfere over the weekend. Saying that, there's honestly no call for the funeral skit in the first place. Last week's SmackDown got a little too deep in the weeds with that silliness - Aldis, Joe Tessitore and others acted like Zayn had literally murdered the mascot live on air.
Please avoid this sort of lame-brained "comedy" during the match, lads. If Gingerbread Man rises from the ashes to put a spanner in the works for Sami, then it means we're all in for even more nonsense afterwards. No thanks.
8. Lil Yachty Turns On Trick
There is another option, and it's similarly chaotic.
Turns only really fly when somebody has a connection with the audience. If people tuning in or buying tickets care about an act, then they'll react accordingly to any alignment changes on camera. If they don't, then they won't, and hanger-on celeb Lil Yachty falls into the latter camp. He's only involved at all due to Trick Williams.
The rapper doesn't have much credit in the bank with the fanbase to speak of. In fact, 99.9% of those checking out WWE's product either don't really know who he is or don't pay much attention to his hype man work on the mic alongside Trick Willy. That's just the way it is. Yachty is a mere prop for Williams at best.
Don't rule out a turn though. Y'know, just for the sake of it. The problem? Not only is Yachty set dressing for Trick's promos, he also isn't somebody that wrestling fans would like to see attached to Sami Zayn. Assuming that was the plan here. Sadly, the biz can't resist a swerve for the sake of a swerve every now and then.
'No-one would see it coming' isn't always the best justification for running with a hard left turn. One can envision fans in Tampa snoozing their way through a Lil Yachty heel move if it's on the cards. Or, perhaps the decision has already been made to quietly move him aside internally.
Questions may be asked as to why Yachty is getting a WWE pay check but New Day aren't, for example.
7. IYO SKY & Asuka Flatter To Deceive
ARGH!
Look, IYO SKY vs. Asuka is looking like one of the better matches on the undercard going into Backlash, but what if it’s a disappointment? Kairi Sane rumours have intensified, but even that might not be enough if the actual match itself struggles to get going. The pressure is truly on for both of these women to tear the roof off the place this weekend.
Asuka is a seriously respected veteran who routinely gives rivals everything she has, and SKY has blossomed from Damage CTRL villain into a genuinely likeable babyface who shares the same star power Rhea Ripley exhibits, which is impressive. Together, owing somewhat to the tenure of their story on WWE TV, Asuka and IYO should deliver the goods.
Things don't always pan out that way, unfortunately. Sometimes, there's a little gremlin inside that ring with workers, and it makes sure that nothing goes to plan. That's a wretched thought, not least when considering that Triple H might be calling up Kairi for a one off appearance post-release so she can help tie a bow on this plot line.
That moment (Sane surely sticking it to Asuka for all of the verbal abuse and poor treatment lately) will only resonate if it comes as the apex of a hotly-contested match that has everyone on the edge of their seats. If Asuka vs. SKY is meandering and boring before Kairi's music hits/she runs in, then it won't land quite as well.
Here's hoping these women have their game faces on in Tampa. The show might need them.
6. Bron Breakker’s Push Stalls
Some online seem to have a problem with Bron Breakker pinching his nose and doing his best impression of Seth Rollins, but WWE's scriptwriters haven't gone too far in that direction. In other words, this rivalry isn't quite as comedic as Sami Zayn vs. Trick Williams seems to be, and that's a major plus. It really, really, really doesn't need OTT comedy.
It does, however, need Breakker to come out on the winning end at Backlash.
Nah, there's no harm in losing to someone like Seth normally, but this feels like a crucial period in Bron’s development. WWE either go all in on him or they go 50/50 and he cools off. Hopefully, Triple H has learned his lessons with that sort of thing - he need only look at Oba Femi and Jacob Fatu for both sides of the coin.
Oba is on fire after beating Brock Lesnar, and an 'Open Challenge' gimmick on Raw is already working well to make him look like a proper beast. Meanwhile, Fatu's aura evaporated once he became United States Champion and started feuding with Solo Sikoa. The 'Samoan Werewolf' is only just started to heat back up in 2026.
'The Game' doesn't need that issue with Breakker. Stalling his push just so Rollins can grab an unnecessary PLE win would be foolish. Hell, have Bronson Reed return and help his Vision stablemate beat their former leader. Then, Seth has a reason to get to a steel cage bout (or something similar) on Saturday Night's Main Event or Clash In Italy later this month.
5. Too Many Moving Parts Wreck The Main
Speaking of Fatu, here's another point: His main event vs. Roman Reigns at Backlash should be 1v1 without endless urn-ins (a trope of The Bloodline era and Roman's 'Tribal Chief' matches; more so when he was heel) and that sort of thing. Jimmy and Jey Uso, Solo Sikoa and Talla Tonga could all get involved in the match.
That actually sounds pretty likely.
It’d be fine to have a run-in from someone, but not everybody, and not Solo with Talla. Being a bit harsh (probably), they shouldn’t be this high up the card at the moment. The MFTs group WWE put around Sikoa was a flop, as evidenced by the fact that guys like JC Mateo and Tonga Loa have been cut from the roster without warning.
Solo has personality, but not as a vicious heel badass. Talla is really finding his feet as an act around here too, and he doesn't feel anywhere close to the level of Reigns, Jacob or even The Usos right now. Arguably, he only reaches that point by interacting with them, but no - Fatu should be handling Roman on his own, especially after mauling almost everyone else en route to this PLE.
If this writer was going to pick one act to interfere, it'd be The Usos. They're the only ones that actually make sense, and recent bouts like Jacob vs. Solo on SmackDown prove that there isn't much juice to that program anyway.
Keep it simple, please. The bout is a routine title defence for Reigns but can still elevate Jacob. Let's focus on that rather than lazy run-in after run-in.
4. It’s Roman’s Last Match For Months
Win or lose, there are no guarantees that Roman Reigns will be on television much after Backlash. Currently, he's scheduled to miss a big chunk of time in June, but could miss out on the 23 May edition of Saturday Night's Main Event and the special Clash In Italy PLE right at the end of the month too.
That's a bit of a bummer to think about, eh? Roman himself said post-‘Mania that he’d be around more often as World Champ, so what if that turns out to be false and he’s gone again after this? Worse, what if he'll be sitting at home or working out in his own private gym with the belt sitting in storage?
It won't sit well if Raw goes back to having a part-time champion again. The comments Reigns made to fans during the WrestleMania wrap up show suggest that even he's aware of how crap it is to have the 'A' show linger without a head champ for too long. If that's the case, then...don't do it.
This would have to be considered poor contingency planning from WWE if Roman does bolt from screens yet again, and everyone's tired of those 'Roman Reigns Returns' graphics that the promotion oh-so-loves. They're tedious. Keep him around, because he'll help the flagship.
If he doesn't want to work SNME, then booking something for Clash In Italy is a real must. Maybe a rematch with Fatu could be on the cards, or Roman could bang heads with another one-off challenger. Just don't vanish, my 'Tribal Chief'!
3. Danhausen’s Partner Is A Popcorn Fart Celeb
A FartHausen, you might say!
Danhausen's surprise tag-team partner to fend off The Miz and Kit Wilson probably has to be someone like CM Punk at this point. The Punker has nothing else going on at Backlash, and he’s pals with Danhausen away from the ring anyway, so there’d be immediate chemistry that WWE fans might enjoy.
One thing's for sure: It absolutely can’t be ESPN’s Stephen A. Smith, or someone like that. Dan put a curse on Smith, so it wouldn't be outwith the realms of possibility for him to call on a corrupted version of the anchor to fight alongside him here. If that happens, then someone in the creative squad or on TKO's end has been playing a wee bit too much WWE 2K26 and diving into Community Creations.
Seriously though, whilst Smith is a celebrity he isn't over with wrestling fans. People worldwide (especially) would be scratching their heads and wondering why they should care about this guy at all. He isn't even Pat McAfee or Jelly Roll, both of whom have shown they can get physical when the need arises.
Danhausen is doing some sweet stuff in WWE, and he definitely doesn't need some celeb influence weighing him down. Oh yes, CM Punk could be the only viable option to come out and have his spooky little buddy's back. It'd be a slide for Punk after headlining 'Mania, but he'd find a way to make it work.
PunkHausen is the way to go. Not Stephen SmithHausen. Never Stephen SmithHausen.
2. John Cena’s Announcement Flops
The year is 2046, and WWE/TKO just called on John Cena to throw on a suit and announce the attendance for WrestleMania. Or announce that he's veeeeeery happy to be here and can't wait to see the superstars do their thing. Or announce that Club WWE plans to give everyone 0.1% off their next merchandise purchase.
You get the gist.
Eyebrows were raised when word spread that Cena will be back to host Backlash. Firstly, 'B' tier PLEs like this don't typically have hosts. Second, WWE is hyping his appearance up big style by teasing that he'll deliver a "history-making" announcement on the show. Let's be straight up about something: It better be good.
A WWE Draft or Club WWE announcement would flatten the live crowd and lead to an angry mob on socials whilst watching at home. Fingers crossed that TKO aren't stupid enough to fly Cena to Tampa just for that sort of thing. After all, his preview of what's coming at Backlash is setting anticipation levels at a fever pitch, and knowingly so.
If Cena did that (with WWE's blessing), then announced a Draft that the company will forget about within a few weeks anyway, then he'll be booed out of the building. Here's hoping this isn't a case of TKO booking John into an impossible situation here, because he doesn't deserve to be jeered for playing the role of corporate messenger.
He really doesn't. 'Mania's fare (Bianca Belair pregnancy announcement and Danhausen merriment considered) was passable, but Backlash wouldn't be if he couldn't back up some seriously bold claims going into the show.
1. Or he’s CenaHausen!
Could things get even worse? They bloody well could, you know.
Listen, this is unlikely, but Cena did interact with everyone else involved in the tag match at WrestleMania 42. So, what if he puts on some face paints to become Danhausen’s special guest partner vs. The Miz and Kit Wilson?! That would kinda dump all over his retirement match vs. Gunther last December, but this is wrestling and stuff like that happens occasionally.
Promoters rarely look back the way for too long. Only forwards. If someone higher up (whether on Triple H's creative team or within TKO's power structure) believes that Cena teaming with Danhausen would give the spooky little merch seller a rub that'd shift even more t-shirts, then there's always a chance it could happen.
They'd have to hurl a big load of cash at John, sure, but that could be arranged. Besides, if he got a cut of any "CenaHausen" shirts, then he'd probably be happy. Back on the negative side, it'd be a huge slap in the face to anyone who cried when he smiled then tapped out to Gunther in Washington right before Christmas.
Cena's retirement is too fresh for this sort of comedy comeback spot. It'd be even more insulting if the gag was that it wasn't actually John - "it was CenaHausen". It's a nope from this fan.
What other nightmares could come true at WWE Backlash 2026? For more wrestling, check out 10 Way Too Early Card Predictions For WWE WrestleMania 43 and WWE Backlash 2026: 10 Things That NEED To Happen!