3 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (21 Nov - Results & Review)

AJ Lee and Becky Lynch are in for WarGames; WWE wastes a bloody Cody Rhodes moment.

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

The lineups for every team involved in both WarGames matches on next weekend's Survivor Series 2025 PLE are now complete. WWE tidied things up during a double shot taping for SmackDown in Denver on Friday night. Violence is always expected to play a part in WarGames bouts, so it was interesting that Triple H saw fit to deliver then instantly squash that idea during the show.

Advertisement

In retrospect, maybe one angle involving Cody Rhodes and Drew McIntyre should've been left on the cutting room floor. It didn't do much to sell the latter as a rampant force who's going to take some babyfaces out for good come Survivors and the double cage main event. Put it this way: Minor details matter when it comes to build for WarGames.

On the women's side, both AJ Lee and Becky Lynch signed on for some PLE fun of their own, and SmackDown kept the John Cena tournament stuff ticking along. There was a shock result in the brackets to report on, but the main event (which looked excellent on paper) was a complete disappointment. Sorry, but it was.

Advertisement

Back on a more positive note, Ilja Dragunov's United States Title 'Open Challenge' segment improved on last week's offering, and there was a fun tag-team sprint that may/may not take Axiom's unmasking further.

In times of peace, prepare for war. Apparently, Trips and his writers didn't prepare much of anything for this year's WarGames. Oh well, at least the matches will be watchable once things get going, eh?

Advertisement

Here's all the good and bad from Friday's penultimate lead-in.

Advertisement

Downs...

4. This Still Doesn’t Make Sense

WWE

WWE bust out some old-school graphics for a "Traditional Survivor Series Elimination Match" that'll actually take place on next week's edition of SmackDown instead of on the PLE named after such bouts. Make it make sense. Team Sami vs. Team MFT will likely be the featured match on Friday's TV, and it could eat up a fair chunk of time across the 2 hour show.

Advertisement

Sami Zayn, Motor City Machine Guns, Rey Fenix and Shinsuke Nakamura were only trying their best when they appeared in a backstage promo to hype all of this, but the scenario feels so hollow. If Triple H doesn't think these elimination matches are worth much, then just don't do them at all. Running them at half speed on TV rather than at Survivor Series is a weird choice.

Straight away, it makes Sami's squad and Solo Sikoa's side feel less than.

Advertisement

No, not everybody can make it onto PLE cards, but this is a literal Survivor Series match that's been shunted from the lineup that only has 4 matches (both WarGames, John Cena vs. Dominik Mysterio and Stephanie Vaquer vs. Nikki Bella) to shout about thus far. Another will be added, but...why not the elimination one?!

Nobody would be complaining as much if the WarGames matches ruled, but build for both has been tepid at best and they're just sort of chucked together for the sake of it. It's mad that Hunter refuses to 'book around a calendar' with the elimination stuff but is willing to do it for WarGames.

Advertisement

Good luck to Sami, Solo and peers. They're gonna need it.

3. New Members Won’t Save Women’s WarGames

WWE.com

Rhea Ripley introduced AJ Lee as the final member of the babyface squad, then it became clear that Becky Lynch is the final member on the heel side when she attacked to close out SmackDown. Yeah, this whole deal was rushed - the credits were rolling on Friday's episode when Becky shook Asuka’s hand. Did they lose time somewhere in the night? Did somebody go long in-ring, or something?

Advertisement

The side story of mistrust between Rhea and Charlotte Flair seems ultimately pointless looking back now they're content to be all buddy buddy, and there’s still such a thrown together air to everything. That’s true on the men’s side too, being fair. Nah, yours truly hasn't been digging the build to this year’s Survivor Series, can’t lie. There's absolutely no need for either of the top billed matches to take place inside the double cage.

At this rate, a return to more standard elimination fare in 2025 might've been the better call.

Advertisement

There isn't much meat on the bone for the women's match. Only AJ and Becky feel like true enemies in this thing, and they'll have to do a lot of the heavy lifting come next weekend. Let's be real, WWE fans in San Diego aren't exactly going to rocket out of their seats if Lash Legend and Nia Jax go face to face with Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss.

This match would be perfectly serviceable as an elimination tag at most. Again, the WarGames concept should be held back for ultra-violent blood feuds or rivalries where everybody has to the settle the score in a vicious, stunt-filled brawl. That doesn't fit what's being presented here.

Advertisement

2. So…Why Do The Bus Attack Angle?

WWE.com

SmackDown kicked off with lots of empty words involving The Vision and The Usos, then the latter called out Cody Rhodes to help even the numbers. Cody’s music played, but he was nowhere to be seen. Uh oh! Drew McIntyre had attacked him on his bus and left him bloodied/battered, so Jimmy and Jey rushed to the scene, then McIntyre drove past shouting at them.

Advertisement

Corey Graves pointing out that Drew didn’t step foot in the building so technically didn’t violate WWE’s suspension fell a little flat. He was there inside the ring last week, but yeah - get what they were going for. The real story was his violent ambush anyway. It smacked of The Rock kicking lumps out of Cody and gave this show a hot open and could’ve been epic, but then...Rhodes showed up less than an hour later to destroy Bronson Reed’s path in the John Cena tourney and cut a fiery babyface promo.

You've really got to wonder what the point of this bus attack stuff was then. It only served to make McIntyre look mediocre, because he couldn’t take Cody out for longer than 60 minutes then sped off thinking he'd done his dirty work to weaken the babyface WarGames team. Hmm. A vicious heel's inability to cripple the hero? That doesn't bode well for Survivor Series.

Advertisement

If anything, there should've been more mileage squeezed out of whether or not Cody would even make it to the PLE. Nick Aldis should've been having panic attacks about it all night, and WWE could've stretched that into next week. Let things breathe a little, guys.

1. Main Event Doesn’t Cut It

WWE.com

Mark it down. This is the second week in a row that SmackDown’s main event has been lacking.

Advertisement

Penta vs. Finn Bálor as part of the ongoing quest to wrestle John Cena's last match looked rock solid on paper, but it never really got going. It’s like all they had was a 2 minute closing stretch and that was it. Honestly, any self-respecting wrestling fan would hate to say guys of this quality ever go through the motions, but they ran damn close to it on Friday night. The live crowd picked up on that and felt muted as a result too.

No, there isn't much to shout about with this one. It's tough to recommend, and that sucks when you realise the calibre of worker between those ropes. Also, not that Triple H particularly cares about this sort of stuff, but WWE booked 2 Raw guys in the SmackDown main event. Remember this next time they hype up a Draft and make a lot of noise about how the rosters on major shows are "separate".

Advertisement

There was a crystal clear moment when the ref told Bálor and Penta to go home. That's when the pace quickened. Sure, this is nothing new for TV matches, but it felt like nothing else other than that 2 minute drill actually happened. Penta winning makes sense, at least, and putting him against Solo Sikoa in the tournament feels like a legitimately fresh outcome.

Here's hoping they serve up something better than Penta and Finn did. Man, it's actually a shocker how lukewarm their match turned out to be.

Advertisement

Ups...

3. Fraxiom & DIY Maximise Their Minutes

WWE.com

It's a tough position to be in when you’ve got nothing really going on in terms of a feud. Thus, this was a cold tag match, but Fraxiom and DIY managed to heat everyone up by putting on a fast-paced clinic. They weren't hanging around to feel sorry for themselves. Personally, this guy isn't too sure he likes the whole unmasking Axiom thing, but it gave Candice LeRae something to do at ringside and handed the heels a much-needed win.

Advertisement

Nathan Frazer covered Axiom up with a towel afterwards anyway, so maybe they can get something out of this by booking some revenge for the babyfaces. It's either that or the former A-Kid is about to ditch his hood for good, grow out his hair and match Frazer's look so they're like mirror images of one another. The third option is having Axiom bitch and moan about Nathan never being there for him and going the split route.

That'd take a bit more thought, probably.

Advertisement

If you're in the mood for a zippy tag bout that doesn't overstay any welcomes and manages to skirt the fine line between spot, spot, spot without making the referee look like a chump, then DIY vs. Fraxiom is the match for you. It's the kind of thing you might see more often on AEW Dynamite, albeit with better officiating.

Finally, it's cool to see Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa get the win. Interesting that they came out individually to their own music though. Is a split incoming for DIY? Or, was Triple H simply trying out something new for the pair? Only time will tell.

Advertisement

2. Nice To See Melo Getting Spotlight

WWE.com

Carmelo Hayes' match vs. Bronson Reed seemed like a mismatch going in, but Hayes surprisingly worked real well in the underdog babyface role. There’s something here, especially if Hayes can show the same kind of fire vs. Gunther deeper in the tournament. Look, he’s surely never winning that one, but Triple H has to realise it’s high time Melo was given some consistency on the main roster.

Advertisement

He won via countout when the WarGames teams started brawling then Cody Rhodes attacked Reed behind the ref’s back. It was a tidy finish despite the fact that Cody’s run in trampled all over the point of Drew attacking him earlier. That was nothing to do with Melo and Reed though. They had a job to do for a good 10 minutes or so before all of the run-ins, and they did it well.

Bronson's power based heat building sections work a treat. He understands when to keep the tempo up and when to slow down so he can make mean faces at fans in the front row. At ringside, Paul Heyman barks encouragement like he's turning the clock back to his NWA/WCW days and managing the Dangerous Alliance. It's a nice blend, and they complement one another well.

Advertisement

Denver was right there for Hayes too, and he needed that support. Any aspiring babyface is only as strong as the reactions they're getting, after all. Yep, this was a really decent outing for this pair. It's one they can be proud of. Now, it's time for Carmelo to lean into that spitfire baby role as he tangles with chop machine Gunther.

Say a prayer for his chest.

Advertisement

1. US Title Open Challenge = Back On Track

WWE.com

Last week’s Ilja Dragunov vs. Axiom match was oddly lacklustre, but this was more like it.

Advertisement

JD McDonagh was in the house to lend moral support to Judgment Day stablemate Finn Bálor in his John Cena tournament match, so he answered the ‘Open Challenge’. Why not? These dudes wrestled a lot on the independent scene pre-WWE, and it showed. They also had a couple of NXT bouts in their back pockets, so chemistry was never going to be an issue.

As usual, Ilja’s selling was on point, and McDonagh worked well in the one-off challenger spot. Excellent stuff here. Of course, it’d be nice to see Dragunov get a PLE match at some point, because his hard work on TV richly deserves that kind of platform. If nothing else, at least he's guaranteed plenty of minutes on SmackDown every week as United States Champ.

Advertisement

Admittedly, there was a pretty silly spot that saw McDonagh seemingly being content with taking a countout, but that…wouldn’t have given him the US Title. Fair play to Michael Cole and Corey Graves on commentary for pointing that out rather than no-selling it. This avoidable brain fart didn’t kill the match though. There was enough great action elsewhere to compensate.

A near fall following JD's sweet moonsault was wonderful and tricked the live crowd into thinking they might see a title switch in their hometown. Some of the smiling/laughing faces in the front few rows suggested that they felt foolish for believing that was going to happen. You never know, Denver. You just never know.

Advertisement

Top match.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 11 MORE WWE Returns That IMMEDIATELY Backfired and 25 Things You Didn't Know About John Cena!

Advertisement