11 MORE WWE Returns That IMMEDIATELY Backfired
None of these shocking or "epic" WWE comebacks worked out as planned.
There are few things in wrestling quite like the rampant social awkwardness of a comeback that just doesn't hit. Spare a thought for workers suffering through those moments, and for creative team members who thought it'd be handshakes, hugs and back pats all round once their carefully-written plan came to fruition in front of the cameras.
Their faces must've been a picture once everyone realised that oh...oh no - *insert return here* just didn't click with fans who bought tickets or those watching en masse at home on TV. Brian Christopher's cringeworthy 2011 comeback is a prime example of this, and so were so-called renaissances for the likes of Shane McMahon, Davey Boy Smith and even Hulk Hogan.
It's time to serve up more of that pain.
Honestly, it sometimes doesn't take long for things to go south. Every pro wrestling comeback is supposed to play before wild cheering/booing, frantic social media chatter and even maybe some mainstream media headlines (depending on the size of the star in question). Then, there are these flubs. They might've received a cheer/boo here or there in the heat of the moment, but things rapidly fizzled out as it became obvious to everybody that dark days lay in wait.
There are some huge names here too. We've got olympians, MMA revolutionaries, multi-time World Champions and even guys who carved out a niche for themselves in the original ECW. What's that old Paul Heyman trope? Maximise someone's strengths and hide their weaknesses? Yeah, well those weaker points were unfortunately laid bare for all to see.
Get ready to cringe hard.
Get over 70% off and three months for free when you sign up to NordVPN here: https://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=704&aff_id=3013&source=WCWREweb
11. King Kong Bundy (1994)
The 'New Generation' had kicked off by 1994. Dynamic in-ring workhorses like Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels were leading the way, but they were ably backed by The Undertaker, Diesel, Razor Ramon and others. Basically, anything other than what conjured up images of Hulk Hogan and the Hulkamania boom of the 1980s was in-fitting with the WWF's fresh direction.
That's why rehiring one of Hulk's biggest foes was a real head-scratcher.
Egg-shaped behemoth King Kong Bundy returned in late '94. He worked his first match for a Wrestling Challenge taping on 30 August, but that actually aired a day after the Superstars match he filmed on 31 August. Then, his first bout on Raw came on the 10 October episode. It wasn't long before Bundy had joined Ted DiBiase’s Million Dollar Corporation, but he looked 100% past his prime.
Even the big guy's squash matches were dull and lacked the oomph a new breed of monster like Diesel had shown when ripping enhancement workers a new one. Later, Bundy's 3 minute showing in the 1995 Royal Rumble was pathetic. Somehow, in spite of looking totally out of sorts since his comeback, the WWF thought he’d be ideal fodder for The Undertaker at WrestleMania XI anyway.
Nothing about this return worked, and it was apparent instantly that Bundy wasn't going to fly in a fresher federation. He linked up with one of the worst factions ever (sorry, 'Million Dollar Man' fans!), wrestled like he was moving through sludge, and his presence continued the agony inflicted on 'Taker during his earliest 'Mania performances.
Bundy's comeback should've been toast as soon as everyone saw his initial flurry of squashes.
10. Rick Rude (1997)
Are you ready? What could scream rebellion more than Rick Rude in a suit and tie looking like the world's most well-chiselled bouncer? Yes, that's a joke. It was confusing to see the 'Ravishing' one tag along next to Shawn Michaels, Triple H and Chyna as they crotch-chopped, shoved bananas/socks/anything else they could think of down their pants, and generally pushed the envelope for what was acceptable in 1997 WWF.
Rude had returned to the fed as an enforcer for the trio's new D-Generation X group on the 11 August '97 episode of Raw. Bizarrely for somebody with such legacy star power and the gift of gab, Rick didn't really actually say much of note on the mic. He never looked right alongside HBK, Trips or Chyna either, but everyone persevered like Rude was some essential piece of the DX act they just couldn't do without.
Eventually, he left due to fallout from the screwjob involving Bret Hart at Survivor Series, but it was a creative mercy killing more than anything else. Michaels pranced and danced, Hunter made countless jokes about his junk, and Chyna was already enough bodyguard muscle for the degenerates. That left Rude, who was called the stable's "insurance policy", looking like someone who had nothing to offer.
How strange.
The company were only looking for something for Rick to do other than wrestle, and the "insurance policy" tag was a nod towards the reasons why he couldn't work matches (Rude had a lucrative Lloyds Of London earner), but surely he could've done anything other than rock up as the corporate odd man out in an anti-authority faction?!
9. Jeff Jarrett (1997)
Armageddon could strike and Jeff Jarrett would not only survive but launch the MWWF (Mutant Wasteland Wrestling Federation) like he's in Fallout. He's one of wrestling's ever-presents. Just when you think 'Double J' is history, up he pops to remind everyone that there's life in the old dog yet. Typically, he does a lot of the same stuff, but Jeff fancied trying on something a bit different in 1997.
He re-debuted on the 20 October Raw in a shoot-style promo segment that saw him lambast WCW and Eric Bischoff for his year long run in the company. He'd previously walked out on the WWF in 1996, but had returned and vowed to become a headache to Vince McMahon. The promo was far from terrible, but it still missed its mark.
Fans just didn't see the cartoonish Jarrett as a main event tier worker, and that wasn't going to change even though he was blasting everyone from McMahon and Bret Hart to Shawn Michaels and Steve Austin. His shooting didn’t work; people didn't see Jeff on par with the stars he was verbally cutting down over the live mic.
McMahon's face behind the commentary desk said it all. The boss wore an expression that screamed: 'This is tanking before my very eyes'. Within months, Jarrett had joined the going nowhere NWA revival (which was presented as a stable on WWF television), and he was right back in the lower card mix all over again.
If this was a bid to elevate him to headline status as a straight shooter, then it had failed in a few short minutes.
8. Christian (2009)
You've really got to wonder what they were playing at here.
Christian bolted from WWE in 2005 because he figured he'd never be taken seriously or given the chance to be a top guy. His TNA run peaked then faded, but it did prove one thing: Christian Cage could be an excellent addition to the upper card mix if WWE gave him a go at that level. When he re-signed in early-2009, there was much merriment. The buzz didn't last long.
He debuted on the 10 February 2009 ECW. Announcer Todd Grisham infamously seemed less-than-enthused (“It’s…it’s Christian!”), and Jack Swagger’s gawping sell mid-ring was a bit crap too. The biggest problem was which brand Christian had been dumped on though. Most fans figured he'd play a role in the ongoing Edge vs. Jeff Hardy feud, but it was Matt who turned on Jeff instead to launch into one of the worst brother vs. brother stories going.
Thankfully, WWE would correct their mistake by putting Christian on Raw by 2010, and he had World Title success, but the ECW surprise backfired. This was supposed to achieve 2 things. Firstly, it'd beef up the star power on the third brand. Second, in Vince McMahon's mind this was where Christian belonged. He got that one wrong, didn't he?
Audiences responded in kind by treating Christian like a bigger deal than anything else on ECW, largely because...he was. He'd more than earned a crack at the World Title scenes on Raw or SmackDown, so this slap in the face blew up in McMahon's face. You can't stop talent!
7. Kurt Angle (2017)
This writer was over in Orlando for WrestleMania 33 when news spread that Kurt Angle's much-anticipated WWE comeback was a lock. Then, on the post-'Mania edition of Raw, Angle was introduced as the brand new GM for Monday nights, and all was well in the world again. That 3 April 2017 announcement seemed to fit, and the role would also give Kurt plenty of time to get healthy for some big time money matches.
Yeah, about that.
By his own admission, Angle was struggling to physically live up to the billing around that time. His body had seized up badly, and he just wasn't capable of performing at the high level necessary for heavily-hyped featured matches in WWE. Thus, his GM gig trundled along for a while before the ultimate sin was committed: WWE installed Jason Jordan as Kurt's kayfabe son, and the fanbase was not amused.
That sudden and unrealistic nonsense started in July, but the bloom came off the rose for Angle pretty early. There were highlights over the coming years before he retired in 2019 (such as a stunning mixed tag match with Ronda Rousey vs. Triple H and Stephanie McMahon at WrestleMania 34), but they were few and far between. Overall, Kurt's GM saga and meagre amount of matches failed to satisfy the way people had hoped.
Comments like, 'His TNA run was better than this' started to appear on socials. The penny had dropped that Angle would never be back to his best in-ring again, and that was that. WWE had hoped to give Kurt enough time to get prepped when making him GM, but all they did was dilute somebody who should've been a special attraction by having him make matches every week.
6. Batista (2014)
He walks alone, don't you know? Admittedly, Batista's return on the 20 January 2014 episode of Raw did get plenty of cheers, but the goodwill didn't go the distance through WrestleMania season as planned. By 26 January and the Royal Rumble show, WWE fans had soured on 'Big Dave' big time. He was booed heavily for winning the 30-man match.
Most of the scorching heat stemmed from the fact that Batista wasn't Daniel Bryan. How dare he. People had made it clear who they desperately wanted WWE to push from the 2014 Rumble to 'Mania XXX, and it wasn't the 'Animal'. Batista spotted the hatred coming his way early, and he got fairly salty about the way fans had treated him after the fact.
In fairness, it cannot have felt good.
He was making his first WWE appearances in years, and they were being utterly rejected by an audience he figured would be delighted to see him. Again, they were, at least until it became obvious during his first promo that he'd be the top priority heading into the Rumble pay-per-view. That ticked the fanbase off, 'cause it was a sure sign that bosses just weren't listening to their demands.
Some may call it childish (Batista surely would've back in ye olde 2K14), but the people had spoken. They soured on their comeback king as soon as it became clear that he'd be winning the Rumble and headlining the biggest show of the entire year. That was Bryan's spot, gosh darn it.
That peer pressure forced WWE to alter their booking. Any plans for Batista vs. Randy Orton to go one on one were shelved, and Daniel closed WrestleMania covered in gold and confetti instead.
5. Brock Lesnar (2025)
WWE had to know that there'd be significant backlash once Brock Lesnar returned to action at SummerSlam 2025. After all, Lesnar had been mentioned in the ongoing legal issues involving Vince McMahon and ex-WWE employee Janel Grant, and that had stopped the promotion from using him from at the 2024 Royal Rumble. His last match before that was a loss to Cody Rhodes at SummerSlam 2023.
The company steered clear of Lesnar chat as much as possible following this, but he eventually launched a comeback by attacking John Cena following the main event at SummerSlam 2025. Yes, he was on the sidelines for 2 solid years. As expected, many expressed their disgust with WWE for bringing Brock back into the fold, and Cena himself even distanced himself from the decision making by claiming that he wasn't handpicking his retirement tour opponents.
Not all of them, at least.
Lesnar then embarked on a mini-comeback tour that included a rubbish in-ring skit with R-Truth on the 12 September SmackDown and a match with Cena (one reminiscent of their SummerSlam 2014 squash) at the Wrestlepalooza show on 20 September. Since then, Brock has been back under wraps, and it remains to be seen what's coming next.
Was the aggro worth it? Bringing Lesnar back in was always going to be controversial, and there have been reports that several behind the scenes at WWE weren't too comfortable with it. Management may reason that he's too big a star to keep on ice forever, but they had to realise that they'd receive a ton of flak for using Brock again.
4. Shane Douglas (1995)
Bright-eyed young rookie Shane Douglas had a fairly brief run in the WWF between 1990-1991, then he went off to make a name for himself in both WCW and ECW. His ascent in the latter promotion was more noteworthy, so it felt like a coup when the WWF signed Shane up again in 1995. They had a 'Franchise' on their hands, but they fumbled him badly.
Shane re-debuted as Dean Douglas on the 29 July edition of Superstars, and…it sucked immediately. His “Report Card” segments were as painful as the sound of nails screeching down a chalkboard. In truth, Douglas never really got going and clashed with members of The Kliq backstage, so he was gone by the end of the year. It was crystal clear from the off that this reinvention just wasn't going to click.
So to speak.
Douglas looked uncomfortable in his new guise, and he lacked the threat he'd been cultivating as a workhorse pro wrestler who could technically bamboozle enemies one minute then brawl with them the next. His raspy attitude in promos was replaced with a sneering approach that might as well have yelled "HE'S A MIDCARDER" right in your face.
There was nothing to really pin your hopes on with Dean. He didn't help himself by falling foul of Shawn Michaels, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall and others (Yokozuna reportedly yelled at him for missing matches due to injury), but one of the most glaring issues with Douglas in the WWF 2.0 was that his new gimmick was hokey trash. It was never rising above Intercontinental Title level at best.
3. Bret Hart (2010)
Some things just happen far too late to be effective. Case in point: Bret Hart feuding with Vince McMahon in 2010. This was almost a full 13 years after their infamous 'Montreal Screwjob' altercation at Survivor Series 1997 (you might have heard of it!), and that was too long. By 2010, Hart was a shadow of his former self.
He returned on the 4 January Raw as a guest host and publicly patched things up with Shawn Michaels. He tried to do the same with Vince McMahon, then Vince hoofed him in the balls to build towards an eventual match between the pair at WrestleMania XXVI. This was all newsworthy, of course, but Bret lacked the same fire he’d had during his first run in the company.
Physically, he was a spent force after struggling through numerous health problems from 2000 onwards, but his promos were also too passive and nondescript to really punch through the rekindled feud with McMahon. Further, the actual match itself at ‘Mania was atrocious. Bret couldn't bump, so Vince was almost turned babyface by default because he took such a kicking from the entire Hart clan on the night.
The stupidity didn't stop there. WWE decided that the best follow up plan for one of the worst 'Mania showings ever was to put the United States Title on Bret. Naturally, his reign didn't last too long (how could it?!), but that's besides the point - it didn't need to happen in the first place.
It was clear from his re-introductory promo on the 4 January flagship that the fires had gone out.
2. The Ultimate Warrior (1996)
Some have said that jobbing to The Ultimate Warrior in short order at WrestleMania XII was part of Triple H's punishment for being involved in the 'Curtain Call'. That's factually all wrong. That incident didn't happen until 19 May, and 'Mania XII was on 31 March. So, either someone could predict the future and was punishing Hunter ahead of time, or his loss had nothing to do with hugging Shawn Michaels, Diesel and Razor Ramon.
Nah, the WWF simply needed someone on the midcard to stare at the lights for Warrior during his comeback. Trips had nothing better to do, so he was chosen for that spot. Here's the thing: Federation fans were happy to see a star the magnitude of Warrior return at first, but they'd swiftly grow bored of his stale act.
Post-Triple H squash, Warrior moved onto a truly odd feud with Goldust. He was gone by July amidst backstage drama with Vince McMahon after no-showing several live events, so this reprise proved to be a complete waste of everybody's time and energy. Again though, Warrior’s dated presentation was also totally at odds with the ‘New Generation’ style of ’96. He wasn't quite King Kong Bundy, but there was only so long fans were going to pop for his style when placed next to HBK or Bret Hart main events.
Warrior clashed with the WWF over his comic books too. There was a lot going on backstage. His ego, general disinterest in putting a shift in, and thoughts he was a fish out of water all combined to make his comeback a disaster almost straight away.
1. Ronda Rousey (2022)
Speaking of somebody who was a "fish out of water".
Few can claim to have had a better debut match than Ronda Rousey. Her mixed tag with Kurt Angle vs. Triple H and Stephanie McMahon at 'Mania 34 should be held aloft as one of the best of its kind, but it was all downhill between the ropes from that point on. Ronda would barely even come close to matching the cyborg-esque skills she displayed in New Orleans across multiple WWE spells.
She'd left WWE by 2019, but returned as #28 in the 2022 women’s Royal Rumble and won the match to snag a WrestleMania title bout. On the next TV, Ronda then challenged Charlotte Flair. The problem? Nobody really wanted babyface Rousey. Her prior WWE stint had ended with a botch at ‘Mania 35, and she’d been known to badmouth fans online. The former UFC star never seemed to grasp the idea that she might be booed in a worked business and had really thin skin, which was fascinating for somebody who'd previously been punched in the face for a living.
History repeated itself, and Ronda got boo boo faced when heat poured in. She was one of the least likeable babyfaces in recent memory as soon as she returned in 2022. Like, it was immediate. People could see right through her smiles and high fives, and everyone seemed to be anticipating another online meltdown.
It's remarkable to say this considering her importance to women's MMA and sport overall, but WWE's female ranks are way better off without 'Rowdy' Ronda.
What other WWE returns backfired almost immediately? For more wrestling, check out 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2006 and 10 WCW Fates Worse Than Death!