10 Times Captain America Outsmarted Everyone

Fighting Richard Nixon so you don't have to.

Captain America Hiding
Marvel Comics/Alex Ross

In terms of Marvel's superhero roster, Captain America isn't the hero you think of when the topic of smart superheroes comes up. Between Iron Man's technical genius, Mister Fantastic's quasi-omnipotence, and Professor X's psychic knowledge, the star-spangled man comes nowhere near the ranks of heroes you'd expect to be outdoing others.

But being underestimated like this is exactly how Cap manages to outsmart people so often. Nobody expects America's perfect golden boy to be capable of getting the better of them, and he uses this again and again to his own advantage. As such, Steve Rogers has managed to one-up people you'd never expect he could - with the likes of Nick Fury, Maria Hill, and even Iron Man among these ranks. He's no Batman or Bruce Banner, sure, but he's also far smarter than many people think he is - and more than capable of turning any situation in his favour.

While he isn't always the perfect standard of human intelligence, Steve is good at what he does, which is making the world a better place - and he's willing to outdo just about everyone on Earth in order to do so.

10. Discovering Nick Fury Had Wiped His Memory

Nick Fury Captain America Secret War
Marvel Comics

Uncovering that you've had your mind-wiped is a pretty difficult matter regardless of how you look at it. Discovering you've been mind-wiped, working out why, and then confronting the terrifyingly resourceful person who did it is an entirely more difficult matter, and yet Captain America pulls it all off with aplomb at the closing of the Secret War comic.

Steve manages to uncover that he and several other superheroes were recruited by Nick Fury in order to arrest Lucia von Bardas, the prime minister of Latveria - in a plan that actually involved them secretly overthrowing the country, killing untold numbers of Latverians, and then having their memories of the event wiped before any her could get too furious about them not being told about the true awful nature of their mission.

The discovery of this act leaves Fury a full-time war criminal, and in the bad books of the vast majority of the superhero community - who would have otherwise been totally unaware, if not for Cap's uncanny ability to realise when he's had his memory toyed with.


9. Kicking Wolverine Out Of A Plane

Wolverine Captain America
Marvel Comics

Okay, so kicking Wolverine out of a plane admittedly doesn't sound all that impressive at first - as basic hand-eye coordination is a skill which mercifully doesn't involve incredible intelligence.

But Cap's decision to dramatically get rid of the mutant in Avengers vs. X-Men is surprisingly tactical. After taking the human weapon with his team to find Hope Summers, Captain America reveals that he has done so because he doesn't trust Logan to not kill the girl, resulting in a fight that sees Cap order Giant-Man to eject Wolverine forcibly from the plane.

The fact that Steve merely says 'now' to Sharon does suggest that the two had pre-planned this fight, and had intended to leave Wolverine stranded out in the middle of nowhere as a safety precaution from the moment they all boarded the plane. It's maybe not his most honest moment, but there's not many other ways to peacefully get rid of Logan without the X-Men knowing, so it's a smart plan nonetheless.


8. Defeating Himself

Captain America Secret Empire
Marvel Comics

Although the events of Secret Empire sowed a lot of discontent amongst fans - who were understandably a little creeped out at seeing their favorite hero be turned into a Nazi - it was well worth it for the final issue of the series, which sees the true Cap beat his alternate-Hydra self both morally and physically.

While it'd be easy to have made this scene a simple case of the evil Steve Rodgers getting a royal beatdown, it's actually more a case of him being outsmarted, with the heroic Captain America actively setting his doppelganger up to fail. Knowing that just punching his evil counterpart won't truly defeat him, Steve instead lets his evil counterpart try and pick up Mjolnir, which inevitably fails as the Hydra leader isn't worthy of the weapon.

Aware his alternate self is now completely demoralised, Captain America casually picks up Thor's hammer, and absolutely destroys his opponent with it, ending both the fight and one of the more questionable Marvel comics of the recent past.


7. Making Richard Nixon Kill Himself

Captain America Nixon
Marvel Comics

The fact that Captain America is canonically responsible for the suicide of Richard Nixon in the Marvel universe is too surreal to seem true - like a fever dream you had after reading a comic, a history book, and then downing two bottles of cough syrup.

Yet it's also exactly the case in the original run of Captain America, where issue #175 finds our hero discovering the shocking secret identity of the leader of the evil Secret Empire - which is never explicitly stated in the comic, but has been confirmed by writer Steve Engleheart to be Nixon himself, in reaction to the Watergate scandal which was occurring at the time.

While Cap's discovery of this foul secret isn't genius work, he does manage to find out a secret that literally nobody else in the world knows - even if it does lead him to quit being a superhero for an issue or five.


6. Evading Iron Man (And The Entire U.S Government)

Iron Man Captain America Civil War
Marvel Comics

When you have Iron Man, Spider-Man, a cloned Thor and most of the American civil service after you, you'd imagine being able to hide would be quite difficult - especially while trying to carry out covert guerilla operations on the very same people hunting you down.

All of this is exactly why Captain America should get significantly more credit than he does for managing to keep out of the clutches of his many pursuers during the events of Civil War - even if many of his teammates aren't as lucky. Cap goes as far as to don a mustachioed disguise for a portion of the comic, launching into some spy-film level antics in order to avoid those who would do anything to catch him.

Although ultimately Steve gives himself up to Tony and the government, it's only after he realises he's hurting the people he sought to protect - meaning he could have gone on playing cat-and-mouse with some of the smartest people in the world for longer, had he had reason to.


5. Trusting Bucky

Captain America Bucky Barnes Winter Soldier
Marvel Comics

A decision so smart, so emotional, and so perfect that it demanded a film adaptation, Cap's decision to trust Bucky Barnes not to kill him in The Winter Soldier storyline is actually one of his smartest moves the hero has made to date.

The idea of Bucky's conditioning and mind-control is a two-pronged beast - in that Cap's enemies win if the hero dies, but they also win if he decides to kill one of his oldest friends. Rogers, however, knows his long-time ally better than the people who kept him captive, and predicts that reminding him of his old life will distract Bucky for just long enough that Steve can cancel out his brainwashing with the Cosmic Cube - as it does.

Making plans that involve essentially just hoping not to be shot at doesn't sound all that smart, but Cap's plan manages to create a scenario that never could have been expected, with Barnes being freed from his mind-control after countless years.


4. Outsmarting Maria Hill To Create The New Avengers

New Avengers Maria Hill Captain America
Marvel Comics

There are very, very few times in comic history that someone gets to outsmart Maria Hill. There are even fewer that involve getting to do so without any unfair shenanigans involved - so few that it would appear the only time this actually happens is in the case of the New Avengers, where Captain America manages history's greatest dunk on the S.H.I.E.L.D operative.

Because after Steve has put this motley crew together, he is accosted by Hill, who is attempting to shut down the new Avengers before they can even begin. What the S.H.I.E.L.D director has missed, however, is that Cap has what is called a 'Full Champion License' issued to him by the government - meaning he can legally create a superhero team without anyone else's approval.

This leads to an absolutely beautiful moment where the eternally over-prepared Maria is forced to sheepishly explain that, actually, she wasn't aware of that, and that there is actually nothing whatsoever she can do about the new team. With superheroes being tied up by bureaucracy one too many times, the catharsis of this moment is undeniably glorious.


3. Out-Thinking An Omega-Level Mutant

Captain America Quentin Quire
Marvel Comics

Quentin Quire is a curious character, because you simply can't predict his actions - changing from sassy sulking teen to terrifying apocalyptic powerhouse in the blink of an eye. He's also one of Earth's most powerful telepaths, which makes conflict with him a good way to get your brain turned to mush - for anyone but Captain America, of course.

As when Quentin tries to enter Cap's mind, he comes face to face with none other than America's most iconic shield. It's symbolic of the hero's focus, and is particularly effective against Quire, as he can't use his mind powers on someone whose mind he cannot actually access. With Steve actively challenging Kid Omega to enter his mind, it can be seen that this is a skill the hero has purposefully built in order to one-up anyone with powers involving the mind - because, unless said telepath can break-in, they can't really beat him.

It's a risky gambit, but one that proves solidly effective on countering Quentin's terrifying mind-powers - even if it doesn't convince him to work with Captain America as was initially intended.


2. Preparing For His Own Assassination

Captain America Tony Stark
Marvel Comics

Captain America's assassination was one of the most major events of the character's recent history, drawing serious emotions from countless fans. While Steve's funeral was especially sad, there was one moment that came as an especially unexpected punch - when it is revealed that Cap left instructions for Iron Man, detailing what he would like to happen should he be killed.

The letter asks that Iron Man look after Bucky - likely because America anticipated that the man would go after whoever was responsible for his death -and requests that Captain America 'live on' - with the hero's mantle being given to another worthy individual in order to carry on the "First" Avenger's work.

The idea of replacing Cap can be seen to actually outsmart Steve's murderers, as their aim - to kill Captain America - fails so long as someone else takes up the role.


1. Discovering The Illuminati (Twice)

Captain America Avengers
Marvel Comics

Steve Rogers has an exceedingly bad history with being mindwiped - one that's only soothed by the fact that he always finds out what memories have gone missing, and he always busts the ass of whoever is responsible.

This formula extends even to his own teammates, it turns out, as when Cap discovers that he has been brainwashed to forget that The Illuminati has been rebuilt - a seriously sketchy secret superhero team, and a nightmare for anyone with a lisp - he immediately begins scheming of how to take the group down, all the while acting like he can remember nothing.

With this in mind, Steve forms the Mighty Avengers, and violently confronts Iron Man about his secret cult-like club. While nobody wins this fight - as the appearance of the time crystal instead leads to timeline shenanigans - there's a pretty good chance that Captain America actually would have won, had the battle continued to the end.


Watch Next


Marvel Vs DC Quiz: Captain America Or Superman - Who Said It?

Captain America Avengers Endgame
Marvel Studios

1. You’re Going To Change The World.

Contributor
Contributor

I like my comics like I like my coffee - in huge, unquestionably unhealthy doses.