Casting HBO's Justice League Dark

Which actors should play the likes of Constantine, Zatanna and... Detective Chimp?!

Daniel Craig John Constantine
20th Century Studios

It's been nine years since Justice League Dark debuted in the comics, and around half a decade since word first emerged that they'd be getting adapted to the big screen. Their long awaited adaptation is finally coming now however, this time curtesy of HBO and JJ Abram's Bad Robot.

It may not exactly be a Guillermo del Toro film, but good for them, I say. They are a great bunch of characters and giving them an HBO show would be a suitable use of Warner Bros' money.

That is if they get the right cast, of course.

Now, I have no experience in the performing arts (unless we're counting primary school plays), but comics are something I have a... passing knowledge on, giving me all the authority I need to tell the big wig executives over at WarnerMedia (or however the funding for these things work) who they should be spending their millions on for this particular venture.

HBO is known as a source of quality entertainment, able to attract big names, so getting the actors on this list wouldn't be impossible for them - it would simply be a matter of whether or not they wanted to listen to my (admittedly genius) suggestions.

Okay, genius might be a tad hyperbolic, but I'll let you decide that for yourself...

10. Shade, The Changing Man - Rupert Grint

Shade the Changing Man Rupert Grint
DC Comics/Sony Pictures Television

Due to the nature of Shade's powers, numerous actors will likely be needed for the character. However, seeing as his default look is a white male with shaggy red hair, there is an obvious choice as to who should be the first to play him: Rupert Grint.

Grint is not suitable simply because of his hair though, he has proven himself to be a fairly versatile actor since his days as Ron Weasely. For a couple of examples - in Amazon's adaptation of The ABC Murders Grint played the hard-boiled Inspector Crone, and in Snatch he was a not-so-smooth gangster.

The point is, Grint is able embody a variety of different personas, something which would be vital if the choice were made to have him voice Shade even whilst he's in his other forms. If not, he would simply be limited to playing the character's default version well.


9. Tim Hunter - Kit Connor

Kit Connor Rocketman
DC Comics/Paramount Pictures

Tim Hunter is DC's Harry Potter type: he's a young British kid with glasses who can do magic and has a big ol' destiny to fulfil. If you want a couple more similarities, he has a pet owl and even wears a yellow & red scarf on occasion. Hunter did debut before Potter, but the success of the Potter franchise somewhat dwarfs that fact nowadays.

Regardless of that, Hunter will likely show up in Justice League Dark - his destiny may even end up being the central narrative drive of the series. So, who should play him?

Well, if DC want a Harry Potter then they should do what the Potter films did and cast an unknown (or a relative unknown, in this case). That unknown should be Kit Connor, who played a young Elton John in Rocketman, among other roles.

He has the talent, appearance, and accent necessary for the role, all that's left is to give it to him.


8. I, Vampire - Luke Evans

i Vampire Luke Evans
DC Comics/Universal Pictures

The role of a sexy, British vampire sounds like one tailor-made for Robert Pattinson. Unfortunately, he is already playing DC's *checks notes* biggest and best role, so this one falls to Luke Evans.

Evans is quite the looker and has a chest deserving of the shirtless performance I, Vampire would provide him with. While he has superbly played quite a few morally ambiguous arseholes in the past, Evans is also no stranger to playing the hero, as evidenced by The Hobbit, which saw him play the reluctant hero Bard, and Robot Chicken, in which he voiced comedically-charged versions of James Bond and Wolverine.

On top of all that, if the show is written well, then this might make-up for the other time he played a vampire...


7. Detective Chimp - Tom Hollander

Detective Chimp Tom Hollander
DC Comics/BBC

Detective Chimp was not a member of the original Justice League Dark, but subsequently became one in the version created under DC's New Justice banner.

Upon his introduction in the 2018 series, the character is bitter and a drunk. He saw a lot of friends die during Dark Nights: Metal and has been entrusted with a responsibility he did not want, hence those aforementioned qualities.

These are qualities that were perfectly reflected by Tom Hollander in The Night Manager, a role that actually won him the BAFTA for best supporting actor. Get Hollander to channel that performance for Detective Chimp and DC has an excellent representation of the character as he was presented in the Justice League Dark books.


6. Jason Blood/Etrigan - Michael Sheen/David Tennant

Jason Blood Etrigan
Warner Bros./Amazon

The Jason Blood/Etrigan dynamic is not quite as disparate as the Bruce Banner/Hulk one, so the choice to have Michael Sheen and David Tennant respectively play the two sides of the character wouldn't exactly be for the purpose of having them be the opposites they were in Good Omens.

The association with those two characters would certainly help to illustrate the differences between Blood and Etrigan though.

Sheen would work as Blood as he would be able to convey the idea of him being a good guy, while also portraying how the character can also seem rather menacing (just look at him in Apostle for instance).

Going back to Good Omens, Tennant would simply be fun as Etrigan - he may not look the part, but then again, there aren't many actors that look like massive, yellow demons.


5. Deadman - Nicholas Hoult

Deadman Nicholas Hoult
DC Comics/Warner Bros.

Starting with the obvious: Nicholas Hoult would work so well visually as Deadman. He has the right build, doesn't have long hair (meaning it wouldn't look weird to see him without any), and can pull off the white make-up look, as proven by Mad Max: Fury Road.

Performance-wise it's a similar story. Hoult is known for playing more timid characters, though he got far enough in the runnings to play Batman to show that branding him in such a way might be unfair.

In short, he looks the part and can play the part well, what more convincing does one require? I mean, it's not like he'll be making more X-Men movies anytime soon.


4. Doctor Fate - Tommy Flanagan

Doctor Fate Tommy Flanagan
DC Comics/HBO

The version of Doctor Fate that will appear in Justice League Dark will most likely be Kent Nelson, who discovered the helmet of Nabu back in the 1920s and went on to co-found the Justice Society of America. Nelson is a good guy, Nabu often is not, however, and has a tendency to possess Nelson via the helmet. As such, the good Doctor often straddles the line between hero and villain.

Tommy Flanagan, of Sons of Anarchy and, much more recently, Westworld fame would straddle this line expertly.

His characters are usually not very nice people, yet it is that assumption of villainy that would make his Doctor Fate so interesting - audiences would never quite be sure if it were Nabu or Nelson in control. The Justice League Dark is more a team of anti-heroes than heroes anyhow.


3. Swamp Thing - Clancy Brown

Swamp Thing Clancy Brown
DC Comics/Quantic Dream

If DC doesn't do the sensible thing and fold the DC Universe Swamp Thing into their HBO-verse, then Clancy Brown would make for a terrific replacement.

The actor is no stranger to the superhero arena - having voiced Surtur in Thor: Ragnarok, played Frank Castle's old CO in The Punisher, not to mention having voiced the fan-favourite version of Lex Luthor from Superman: The Animated Series and Justice League Unlimited. Across these roles and more, Brown has demonstrated his voice talent, the element that is arguably the most important when it comes to a character like Swamp Thing, who could be entirely computer-generated.

If DC opt for the practical route that they have done previously with the character, then Brown is no stranger to prosthetics, as seen in The Mandalorian. If a full-body Swamp Thing costume would be too much of a step-up though, then they can just have someone else in the suit and add Brown's dialogue in post.


2. Zatanna - Eva Green

Zatanna Eva Green
DC Comics/Showtime

Zatanna may end up being the most important character in HBO's Justice League Dark. She is the one most likely to form the League, seeing as she is one of the few characters who is definitely a hero, and is the character with the biggest ties to the original team.

Because of these features, someone who would be able to play a Zatanna in more of a mentor capacity while still maintaining her badassery would be necessary. Eva Green fits that bill.

For years, the actor has been touted as the one to play The Witcher's Yennefer - for the confidence and gravity she brings to her roles, as well as due her looks, of course. That role is now obviously out of her hands, but if she were to bring these qualities to Zatanna then fans of the DC hero would be given a wonderful on-screen interpretation.


1. Constantine - Daniel Craig

Constantine Daniel Craig
DC Comics/Sony Pictures

Constantine is a tough character to cast. Matt Ryan has kind of already given fans a definitive take, so trying to find anyone to match, let alone surpass, such a performance is quite the challenge. I previously suggested David Tennant as a slightly left-field choice to play the Hellblazer; yet, I now feel that Daniel Craig may pose a better chance at dethroning Ryan.

Craig's Bond, while still the slick operator he always has been, is a far more morally ambiguous hero than his predecessors - he's not all that nice and can be quite cruel at times. Put that alongside some of Craig's other performances such as his tattooed & incredibly blonde crook from Logan Lucky or his smooth-talking drug dealer from Layer Cake and you have yourself one heckuva Constantine.

The man is even from Liverpool, meaning he should be able to nail the accent. Plus, the thought of a Craig-played Constantine alongside a Green-portrayed Zatanna is a bloody nice one, if I do say so myself.


Watch Next


DC Comics Quiz: How Well Do You Know John Constantine?

John Constantine Hellblazer Original Sins
DC Comics

1. Alan Moore Based Constantine's Look On Which Artist?

Contributor
Contributor

Lover of film and comics, and (according to a comment on this very website) a pulsating sack of worthless nothing!