10 More Most Confusing Movie Moments Nobody Understands

The Big Short was still confusing even after Margot Robbie's interjection.

Margot Robbie The Big Short
Paramount Pictures

When done well, movies can have the amazing ability to elicit emotion from an audience. From depression and anxiety, to elation and pure happiness, cinema has the keys to manipulating you into feeling just about anything. Yes, this does include feeling stupid.

Rest assured, this is the same for everybody. If anyone tells you they have never sat in the cinema, even after the credits rolled, and wondered what the hell was going on, they aren't telling you the truth. Hell, some movies are even designed to make you feel that way.

Then of course there are those moments where a story just didn't offer quite as much context as it should have done, or cut to black at the end without the explanation or closure that would have wrapped things up with a neat little bow.

Back in 2015, WhatCulture took a look at Confusing Movie Moments Nobody Understands, but this list will offer 10 more examples, from scenes that seemingly broke the rules already established earlier in the film, to riddles that had no hope of being answered, and even scenes that tried to explain confusing moments themselves, but just made things worse.

10. Why Is A Raven Like A Writing Desk? - Alice In Wonderland

Alice In Wonderland The Mad Hatter
RKO Radio Pictures

The vast majority of movie scenes are supposed to be understood by the audience, though there are some where the point is to create confusion and uncertainty. Then, on another level entirely is Alice in Wonderland, and in particular Ed Wynn's Mad Hatter.

Amidst the bizarre things the character says and does in the film, he poses a riddle to Alice (Kathryn Beaumont). Why is a raven like a writing desk? Before she barely has a chance to ponder the question, things have moved on to fixing the White Rabbit's clock, and an answer is never given.

In Tim Burton's remake from 2010, the riddle is doubled down on, as Alice asks the question back to Johnny Depp's Mad Hatter later in the movie, to which even he admits that he has no idea. If even the one posing the riddle doesn't know the answer, then how is anybody else supposed to understand it?

It was apparently author Lewis Carroll's intention for the riddle to have no answer at all, though after being mobbed by questions about it he provided one in a later edition of his novel. "Because it can produce a few notes, though they are very flat; and it is never put with the wrong end in front." No wonder absolutely no one could make sense of it, but that was also the point.


9. Is Zurg Buzz Lightyear's Father Or Not? - Lightyear

Lightyear Zurg
Pixar

In the long list of sequels and spin-offs that were neither wanted nor asked for, Pixar's Lightyear has to be near the very top. Tim Allen's Buzz Lightyear had appeared in four Toy Story outings, his character had been comprehensively explored and developed, and there was no need to bring to life the in-universe movie that the toy was based on.

The film left plenty of questions unanswered by the end, including why exactly did this Buzz have a different voice to the toy, as here the titular character was voiced by Chris Evans, and what was the story with Zurg (James Brolin)?

In Toy Story 2, it was well established that in Buzz Lightyear's lore, the evil Zurg was actually his father, in what was clearly a play on the infamous Darth Vader/Luke Skywalker twist. Since the toy was based on the movie, surely Lightyear would reflect this, after all, it wouldn't make sense if it didn't would it?

Well, when the reveal came in 2022, it turned out that Zurg wasn't Buzz's father, but instead a different version of Buzz himself from the future. So why on Earth did the toy think the villain was his father?


8. The Layout Of The T-Rex Enclosure - Jurassic Park

Jurassic Park
Universal

There can be no doubt how iconic and influential Jurassic Park has been since its release over 30 years ago, but as excellent as Steven Spielberg's picture is, it is certainly not without its flaws. One such gripe being the enclosure of the Tyrannosaurus Rex.

In one of most memorable scenes in a film stuffed with memorable scenes, the T-Rex can be seen ominously retracting its claw from the now dead electric fence, before bursting through the paddock boundary to confront the likes of Alan Grant (Sam Neill), Ian Malcolm (Jeff Goldblum), and Ellie Sattler (Laura Dern). Then a giant cliff seems to appear from absolutely nowhere.

As the Rex attacked the cars of Jurassic Park's guests, Alan and the children's vehicle got knocked over the side of the cliff, with the task of getting down to the ground safely proving almost deadly. However, the sheer drop appeared to be exactly where the perfectly flat enclosure was just minutes before, leading to confusion as to the exact landscape of Isla Nublar.

Reportedly, the original script for the movie detailed that the car was dragged several meters before being pushed over the cliff, meaning that the two moments took place at different locations. However, within the walls of the final cut, this is not shown or explained, leaving a huge question mark dangling over the scene.


7. Walking Across The Bottom Of The Ocean - Pirates Of The Caribbean: The Curse Of The Black Pearl

Jack Sparrow Will Turner Pirates Of The Caribbean
Buena Vista Pictures Distribution

The Pirates of the Caribbean is a franchise that has been built on the ridiculous and often simply unbelievable exploits and adventures of Captain Jack Sparrow. As the movies kept coming, the set pieces became more bombastic and eccentric, as at one point the famed pirate even knew where a man would step a good five minutes before he even entered the room.

One of the strangest things he ever did, however, came in his very first appearance and was part of the first time he stole the hearts of the world as the lovable pirate rascal.

Jack had a plan to commandeer the royal fleet's grandest ship, the Interceptor, but to do so he needed to essentially sneak up to it. He and Will Turner grabbed a rowing boat, and using a pocket of air trapped within the boat were able to walk across the floor of the ocean without suffocating.

Though not something the typical movie-goer will have a strong knowledge of to hand, the laws of physics say that creating this kind of air bubble under the water is possible, but what raises more questions is the pure weight and pressure needed to stop the boat from rising back to the surface.

Jack Sparrow achieved many unbelievable feats, but non quite so unbelievable as this.


6. Gisele's Return - Fast X

Fast X Gisele
Universal

With each and every entry of the Fast and Furious franchise the impressive cast list only grows bigger and more impressive. The likes of Brie Larson, Jason Momoa, and Charlize Theron have graced Vin Diesel's film series over the years, but Fast X looked to the past for a couple of its biggest stars.

The post-credit sting brought Dwayne Johnson's Luke Hobbs back to the proceedings for the first time since Hobbs and Shaw in 2019, but this wasn't the only returning character. Gal Gadot reprised her role as Gisele, showing her face in the film series for the first time in over a decade.

The issue with Gisele returning is that she perished the last time she was seen. The Fast and the Furious has brought characters back from the dead before, but with Gal Gadot there was literally not so much as an attempt for an explanation, leaving everyone in the dark.

This is a franchise that has earned itself a reputation for leaning into the ridiculous, pushing the suspension of disbelief to the absolute limit, but dead characters returning to life with no explanation is too far for even in this universe.


5. The Rules Of Rollerball - Rollerball

rollerball 1975
MGM

Typically, in any dystopian story there has to be a huge amount of world building and exposition to set the scene of a world very different to what the audience has seen before. Rollerball however, chose to go a different route, and offered very little explanation for anything at all.

The James Caan-led 1975 movie is based in such a world where the game of Rollerball has been designed as something of an oppressive tool, to demonstrate the futility of individual effort against the Energy Corporation. Naturally, when Caan's Jonathan E got so good at the game that he achieved something of a legendary status across the world, he had to be stopped.

The narrative largely surrounds the conspiracy to kick Jonathan out of the game, without ever truly delving into the specifics of the rules themselves. There are hints of roller derby in there, but with several players on motorcycles in what is essentially just a bloodbath. Even Jonathan Houseman's Mr. Bartholomew, Chairman of the villainous Energy Corporation describes the rules as odd, and that's before they change later in the movie.

There are three games of Rollerball shown throughout the film, with E's Houston taking on Madrid, Tokyo, and finally New York, which gives a lot of screen time to a game that the writing has gone to surprisingly little effort to explain.

Not that it stops any of those scenes from being very, very cool, though.


4. Two Different German Soldiers - Saving Private Ryan

Saving Private Ryan Adam Goldberg
Paramount

Saving Private Ryan offers audiences an immersive, unparalleled view of the horrors of war. Surrendering soldiers were shot dead, others were deliberately left to burn rather than being put out of their misery, and children were left behind for the greater good.

One of the biggest decisions Captain Miller (Tom Hanks) made in and around this was to let the German soldier who killed Giovanni Ribisi's Medic Wade go. Almost his entire team wanted the surrendering prisoner dead, but as Miller explained it, with every life he took he felt further from home, and so in spite of the fact he just killed a member of the team, he walked free.

During the big final battle at the bridge, Private Mellish (Adam Goldberg) was ultimately killed by a German soldier who looked strikingly similar to the man Miller let walk free. This has led to a common misconception that the two were the same man in what would have been arguably the most heartbreaking and ironic twist in the story.

However, in spite of the parallels of the two scenes, in that Mellish's killer lets Corporal Upham (Jeremy Davies) walk away, after Upham was the only other one campaigning for Wade's killer to be spared, these are two completely separate men, and other than being German soldiers have nothing else in the movie to connect them.


3. Steve's Return - Avengers: Endgame

Avengers: Endgame old Captain America Steve Rogers
Disney

For the most part, Avengers: Endgame was a phenomenal final chapter in the Infinity Saga, and a perfect send-off for the Marvel Cinematic Universe as the world knew it. There were however a handful of flaws that stood out, one of the biggest of which was Steve Rogers' (Chris Evans) arc.

After going back in time to return the Infinity Stones to where they were initially taken from, which in itself raised certain questions, Steve Rogers didn't come back as expected. Instead, he chose to live his life in the past with Hayley Atwell's Peggy Carter. His older version had been sat on a bench the entire time just waiting to be spotted by Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) and Bucky Barnes (Sebastian Stan).

This didn't make sense based on the way time travel was presented earlier in the film. As Mark Ruffalo's Hulk explained it, going back in time wouldn't alter that same timeline, but would instead cause a new branch of reality. That is why nothing they did in the past could change the present, but instead would create a totally new and separate timeline.

Going by that theory, when Steve went back in time he kick-started a new reality for him and Peggy to live in. So how did he return to his original timeline from his new one? This shouldn't have been possible, and yet there he sat, handing his shield over to Sam just to disappear again.


2. Inversion - Tenet

Tenet Inverted Fight Scene
Warner Bros.

Christopher Nolan has a history of producing ambiguous projects, from Memento and Interstellar to Inception. Even the ending to his acclaimed Dark Knight trilogy left the fate of Bruce Wayne open to interpretation. Tenet however, feels on another level entirely even from the most confusing of the rest of Nolan's back catalogue.

It's the kind of film that isn't necessarily supposed to make sense on first viewing, but even after seeing John David Washington and Robert Pattinson fight backwards several times, the concept of inversion remains a frustrating mystery.

Tenet became infamous when it released in 2020, widely being regarded as one of the most confusing movies ever. Vague explanations were offered throughout, but the kind that didn't exactly help. When the protagonist is told outright not to try and understand things, it doesn't give much hope that anyone watching will have a chance.

It does feel that this is intentional rather than an oversight from the acclaimed writer and director, as audiences are all but told that the concept of inversion isn't supposed to be understood, but this arguably makes it a much bigger risk to deliberately base a story around something no one will understand.


1. Financial Jargon - The Big Short

Margot Robbie The Big Short
Paramount Pictures

The Big Short tells the story of how the American financial crisis in 2007 was caused by the downfall of the housing market, and how nobody saw it coming except for a handful of people. Outside the likes of Michael Burry (Christian Bale), Jared Vennett (Ryan Gosling), and Mark Baum (Steve Carell), there were few people who understood the principles behind why the housing market was going to fall.

By the very definition of the narrative, there was a lot of exposition needed for the aspects of the financial and mortgage worlds that the typical layman in the cinema just wouldn't understand.

The movie was self-aware enough that the technical jargon would go over the heads of most and addressed it wonderfully. Not only was it referenced by Ryan Gosling's Jared in a voiceover, but he also introduced Margot Robbie sipping champagne in a bubble bath to explain everything before telling the audience to f*ck off.

As entertaining as this deviation from the story was, however, even after Robbie's explanation it was still very difficult to follow without a deeper knowledge of the housing market and mortgage rates. There were similar scenes in which aspects of the financial world were explained by celebrity chef Anthony Bourdain, economist Richard Thaler, and Selena Gomez, but again, things still weren't much clearer.


Watch Next


Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.