10 Actors Who Played Multiple Marvel Roles
If you fail as Foggy, just be Happy instead.
With at least ten films based on Marvel comics to come in the next two years, the comics giant seems to have decided that the best way to defeat the Distinguished Competition is to swamp the market with their own product. The only flaw with this scheme is that there's only a finite number of actors in Hollywood. Sooner or later they're going to run out of potential cast members, especially if they keep needing a new Punisher every movie.
The solution to this diminishing pool of potential superheroes is clear: simply return to some of the less successful attempts to bring Marvel heroes to the big screen and harvest their casts for actors to give a second chance at heroics in capes and tights. While erstwhile Superman Brandon Routh's downsizing to play The Atom in various crossover TV series may be pretty unique as a DC star doubling up, it now seems pretty much the policy for Marvel.
Where will this end? Former Howard the Duck Chip Zien cropping up as Egghead in the new Ant-Man? Dolph Lundgren's giant Man-Thing? Or Eric Bana abandoning his 2-D performance as Bruce Banner to play 3-D Man?
Let's take a look at ten of the previous Marvel changeovers.
10. Kate Mara
First: Anonymous victim of Tony Stark's charm offensive, simply credited as US Marshal in Iron Man 2.
But Then: Surprisingly pale skinned daughter of a black scientist, Sue Storm, turned completely transparent skinned Invisible Woman in Fantastic Four.
How Did It Work Out?
The sister of The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo had been tipped for big things on the big screen for years, but a first superhero role in little seen family flop Zoom disappeared more completely than her Invisible Woman. A fleeting appearance in Iron Man 2, the weakest movie in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, didn't exactly boost her onto the A-list either.
In a movie in which Scarlett Johansson and Gwyneth Paltrow vie for Tony Stark's attention, Mara's anonymous US Marshal (she doesn't even merit a name) doesn't really register.
Thus far, the main focus of attention on Mara's role as Sue Storm in Josh Trank's youthful Fantastic Four reboot has been the difference in appearance between her and onscreen brother Michael B. Jordan. With her African American House of Cards co-star Reg E. Cathey cast as her father, most discussion of the part has been about whether this racial variation will have an in-world explanation.
At this moment it's hard to see through all this slightly racist furore to get much sense of whether Mara will work as the character.
9. Rebecca Romijn
First: Mutant shapeshifter whose power allows her to be played by other actors, Mystique in X-Men, X-2: X-Men United, X-Men: The Last Stand and X-Men: First Class.
But Then: Tenement squatting Joan, with the ability to nurse the vigilante hero back to life and disappear from the story in The Punisher.
How Did It Work Out?
The only one of Magneto's Brotherhood to outlast the original X-Men film, face-changing Mystique remains Romijn's best known role and one that she would return to on three more occasions. Largely, however, the leggy former model was cast for her ability to look good basically naked and covered in blue body paint.
As a physical performance, Mystique was a good role for Romijn, but didn't offer much to sink her teeth into acting-wise. Her final appearance in the part, in 2011's First Class, was a cameo passing the baton to Jennifer Lawrence, playing a version of Mystique with far more complex, interesting characterisation.
In the meantime she had cropped up in probably the best of the three failing takes on Marvel's skull shirted vigilante The Punisher. Accompanied by fellow mutant Ben Foster (The Last Stand's Angel), Romijn showed up as a tenement dweller mostly just there to nurse Frank Castle back to health. It is unlikely to be as well remembered as her Mystique, even with J-Law taking over.
8. Jon Favreau
First: Daredevil's sidekick in lawyering but not superheroics, Foggy Nelson in Daredevil.
But Then: Iron Man's sidekick in billionaire philanthropy but not superheroics, Happy Hogan in Iron Man, Iron Man 2, and Iron Man 3.
How Did It Work Out?
Swingers star Favreau had already cropped up very briefly in Batman Forever a few years before he appeared alongside another night-time vigilante (and future Bruce Wayne) Ben Affleck in Daredevil.
The part of Matt Murdock's partner in prosecution Foggy Nelson is perhaps now more associated with The Mighty Ducks' Elden Henson in the new Netflix series than Favreau. The Elf director, though, does a decent job in a small role in the better-than-you-remember-it Mark Steven Johnson film, particularly in the superior director's cut which gives Foggy plenty more to do.
The film may not have been a break-out success, but the same couldn't be said for Favreau's next turn as a chubby assistant to a crimson suited crime-fighter. Tony Stark's driver Happy Hogan may not be the most thrilling role in the MCU, but he gets his moments to shine thanks to his director: himself.
Still enjoying an executive producer credit on both Avengers films, Favreau is undoubtedly someone who has benefited greatly from switching from non-MCU Marvel pictures to Marvel's own productions.
7. Vincent D'Onofrio
First: Alien cockroach wearing a human corpse and bent on world domination, Edgar in Men In Black.
But Then: Grumpy gangland kingpin bent on Hell's Kitchen domination, Wilson Fisk in Daredevil.
How Did It Work Out?
Often forgotten as a movie based on a Marvel property, Men In Black's source, Lowell Cunningham's The Men In Black comic, was originally published by Malibu Comics but acquired by Marvel in 1994, while the film adaptation was in development.
The original 1997 film remains comfortably the best in the trilogy and a lot of that is down to its superior choice of villain. D'Onofrio's slapstick, rubber faced performance as a decomposing corpse worn by an alien bug is definitely a large part of what made the film so successful.
The Full Metal Jacket star's range is evident from his role in Netflix's Daredevil, which has a very different kind of physicality in a character that is awkward in an Aspergers-esque fashion. (In contrast, Men In Black co-star Tommy Lee Jones stuck very much to grizzled, humourless mentor type in his transfer to the MCU in Captain America).
Both villains are memorable roles for D'Onofrio, but it is perhaps the more nuanced Fisk that is the more intriguing, a character that fans will be keen to see more of.
6. Tim Blake Nelson
First: Tumour faced sequel-bait scientist Samuel Sterns in The Incredible Hulk.
But Then: Tunnel exploring sequel-bait scientist Harvey Elder in Fantastic Four.
How Did It Work Out?
It's pretty much par for the course now in the world of developing super-franchises to spend almost as much time in your origin story setting up the sequel as telling the current story. Of course the result of this can be a movie that is unsatisfying enough on its own ever to merit that sequel and a plot full of loose ends, (There's no possibility of ever seeing Green Lantern's Sinestro unleashing his full sinister side).
Nelson's Samuel Sterns (who becomes villain The Leader in the comics) is one of the MCU's biggest loose ends, left partially transformed by the Hulk serum at the end of The Incredible Hulk.
Given the MCU is unlikely ever to pick The Leader plot up again, it makes sense for Nelson to jump ship to the Fox Marvel Universe. The only thing is, there's every possibility that the exact same thing might happen to him here.
Cast in Fantastic Four as scientist Harvey Elder (who becomes villain Mole Man in the comics), in a movie in which Dr Doom is the principle villain, there is every possibility that Nelson will once again be waiting for a sequel for his moment to shine.
5. Ray Stevenson
First: Vengeful vigilante Frank Castle in Punisher: War Zone.
But Then: Burly boozy warrior Volstagg in Thor and Thor: The Dark World.
How Did It Work Out?
Separate from the mainstream MCU, but still owned by Marvel Studios, Marvel Knights (like its print namesake) attempted to tell more adult and less mainstream stories. Punisher: War Zone was the first of these and its failure (along with Marvel Knights' only other production Ghost Rider: Spirit Of Vengeance) basically put an end to the whole project.
With Marvel's partner Lionsgate having final cut (rather than director Lexi Alexander), the final film was an uninspiring mess and Stevenson in the title role failed to dislodge the memory of the previous movie's more popular Thomas Jane (who returned in slick fan-film short Dirty Laundry).
While his second Marvel movie saw him dropping from the lead to a relatively minor comic relief sidekick (although at least he gets more screen time than the other two of the Warriors Three), Stevenson seems more at home as the mirthful Volstagg in Thor than he did as the humourless Punisher. Sure to return for Ragnarok in 2017, his is a reliable if unspectacular role within the MCU.
4. Nicolas Cage
978653First: Flaming skulled soul harvesting stunt rider Johnny Blaze in Ghost Rider and Ghost Rider: Spirit Of Vengeance.
But Then: Batman suited vigilante with erratic syntax, Damon Macready (Big Daddy), in Kick-Ass.
How Did It Work Out?
For a self-confessed comic book geek who named himself after a Marvel character (Powerman Luke Cage, soon to be seen on Netflix), it shouldn't really come as a surprise that Cage has played more than one Marvel hero. (Although naming his son Kal-El never led to the fulfilment of a long cherished desire to play Superman).
Cage, who has a Ghost Rider tattoo that the film had to cover up, lobbied strongly for the part of Johnny Blaze and performed the role with his trademark lack of restraint. The films, though, were dull and unimaginative.
The Wild At Heart star's oddball performance style was a far better fit for Matthew Vaughn's off-the-wall take on Mark Millar's Kick-Ass (published by Marvel's creator-led Icon Imprint). Playing cop-turned-vigilante Big Daddy, Cage turned in a bizarre performance that entertainingly aped Adam West's classic Batman.
The film lost a bit of its spark after Big Daddy's demise and Cage's presence was certainly one of the many things missed in the misjudged sequel.
3. Evan Peters & Aaron Taylor-Johnson
First: Comic book geeks Dave Lizewski and Todd Haynes turned comic book heroes Kick-Ass and Ass-Kicker in Kick-Ass (and Kick-Ass 2 for Taylor-Johnson).
But Then: Bratty youngster Pietro (or Peter) Maximoff turned heroic super-speedster Quicksilver in X-Men: Days Of Future Past (for Peters), and Captain America: The Winter Soldier and Avengers: Age of Ultron (for Taylor-Johnson).
How Did It Work Out?
One of the quirks of the film rights to Marvel properties existing in multiple different hands is that we can end up with two different takes on the same character if they happen to be, say, a mutant and an Avenger. That's why former Kick-Ass co-stars Taylor-Johnson and Peters found themselves on opposite ends of a scrap over the character of Magneto's son Quicksilver between Fox's X-Men series and Marvel Studios' Avengers.
Taylor-Johnson had been obviously the bigger star beforehand, enjoying the lead role in the subversive, creative Kick-Ass, while Peters supporting part was recast before he could suit up as the derivative Ass-Kicker in the pointless sequel. As Quicksilver, however, their roles were reversed. While Taylor-Johnson proved literally nothing more than disposable in this summer's Avengers, Peters' brief role in Days Of Future Past was the standout sequence of the movie. There are not immediate plans for either version of the character to return in their respective sequels, however.
2. Ryan Reynolds
First: Wisecracking, gun-toting loudmouth Hannibal King in Blade: Trinity.
But Then: Wisecracking, blade swinging loudmouth Wade Wilson in X-Men Origins: Wolverine, and a revamped version of the same character in Deadpool.
How Did It Work Out?
For a long time a charismatic star searching for a franchise in which his charisma wouldn't just spill over into annoyance, Reynolds probably took the supporting roles in both the Blade threequel and X-Men prequel on the hope of a spin-off.
Both movies were terrible, however, and no follow-ups were forthcoming. Reynolds, playing very much to brash and cocky type, was at least one of the better things about both (at least until they sewed his mouth up and chopped his head off in Wolverine).
While a mooted Deadpool spin-off never really got off the ground, Reynolds had a string of huge blockbuster failures. Now, however, he's finally been given the chance to return to the character in what could be his last chance at headlining a franchise.
Early reports from the Tim Miller directed film suggest that it hews far closer to the darkly humorous, self aware character that comic book fans know and love. Could Reynolds have finally found a leading role to suit him? And could it be a part that he's already essentially failed in?
1. Chris Evans
First: Cocky firestarter Johnny Storm AKA The Human Torch in Fantastic Four and Fantastic Four: Rise Of The Silver Surfer
But Then: Earnest all-American super soldier Steve Rogers in Captain America: The First Avenger, The Avengers, Thor: The Dark World, Captain America: The Winter Soldier, and Avengers: Age Of Ultron
How Did It Work Out?
With The Losers (based on the DC Vertigo comic), TMNT (based on the Mirage Studios comic), Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World (based on the Oni Press comic), and Snowpiercer (based on the Casterman comic), Evans basically owes his whole career to comic book adaptations.
It's Marvel, however, that have given him by far the two biggest roles that he has yet played.
In Tim Story's bland Fantastic Four flicks Evans' Johnny Storm stood out as one of the few roles with a bit of personality and energy, but it is the superficially duller Captain America that Evans will likely be forever associated with.
The boy scout-ish do-gooder may not have the instant appeal of Iron Man, Thor, or even Evans' Human Torch, but unlike the latter Cap's old fashioned notion of heroism has allowed him to feature in a succession of Marvel's more interesting movies - from the wartime derring-do of The First Avenger to the 70s style conspiracy thriller The Winter Soldier.
And that's before we even get to a Civil War.