10 Awards The Golden Globes Got Wrong

With so much talent nominated at last night's awards, it's only natural the HFPA will get it wrong occasionally.

While the Oscars will always be seen as the granddaddy of the movie awards shows, the Golden Globes are usually a little more fun to watch because they doesn't take themselves quite as seriously. They tend to take more adventurous gambles on their hosts, and for the second year in a row, Tina Fey and Amy Poehler cooked up a storm, ripping into Hollywood's elite and cutting them down to size. Some of the highlights of the night include a running gag about Matt Damon being a "garbage man", Matthew McConaughey accepting his award while appearing to be under the influence of...something, Emma Thompson taking to the stage with a martini in hand, Jim Carrey's gag about Shia LaBeouf and Jacqueline Bisset's painfully elongated acceptance speech. But as with any awards show, much of the post-show discussion includes talking about who was snubbed, and who unfairly won an award they absolutely didn't deserve. While most of these winners were deserving nominees, I'm not convinced that any of them should have scooped the win itself, as there were far more fitting choices available. Do you agree with the Globes or not? Let me know in the comments!

10. Best Musical/Comedy Film €“ American Hustle

The Musical/Comedy film category often allows for a lot of so-called "category fraud", though this year the Globes mostly seemed to get it right. However, David. O Russell's American Hustle taking the Globe home was a democratic if rather unoriginal choice, a broad but entertaining, well acted film that was nevertheless inferior to pretty much every other film in the category. What was it up against? Her, Inside Llewyn Davis, Nebraska and The Wolf of Wall Street. While I can appreciate a populist awards show like the Globes not going for Nebraska, the HPFA had three perfectly good picks there, and for my money the Globe should have gone to The Wolf of Wall Street, or failing that, Spike Jonze's Her.

9. Best TV Series (Musical Or Comedy) €“ Brooklyn Nine-Nine

Brooklyn Nine-Nine is, to be fair to, a much better show than I would have imagined it to be in my wildest dreams. That said, is it really better than The Big Bang Theory, Girls, Modern Family and Parks and Recreation? I'll give it the benefit of the doubt with regards to Big Bang and Modern Family, but Girls and Parks and Recreation? Girls may have suffered from winning major awards last year and as such was pushed out of the running, but this year was the first time Parks and Rec had received a Globe nomination for the show itself, and to me it really felt like this was the year for it to win. Awards shows have a habit of falling over themselves to award a new talent or project that comes out of nowhere, and so that may be the reason for Brookyln's win, given that it's a relatively smart, fresh subversion of cop show tropes. Still, there would have been other years for Brooklyn, whereas Parks and Rec is slowly winding down now, so is unlikely to be nominated for this award again. Shame.

8. Best Original Song €“ Mandela: Long Walk To Freedom

This felt like something of a consolation award due to Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom otherwise being a disappointing film as far as awards are concerned. Though the U2 & Danger Mouse song is perfectly acceptable, it's just not the best song in the group, nor is it the second or even the third. Widely anticipated to be the Oscar frontrunner is Let It Go from Disney's Frozen, and Please Mr. Kennedy from Inside Llewyn Davis also has a lot of fans, and yet both went home empty handed. While Mandela's Ordinary Love is fine, it doesn't exactly stick long in the mind like the two aforementioned songs do, so I'm left at odds as to explain how it managed to sneak the win, other than the HPFA wanting Bono to show up at their ceremony.

7. Best Actress (Musical Or Comedy Film) €“ Amy Adams (American Hustle)

One of the most fiercely contested groups at this year's Golden Globes is the Best Actress in a Musical or Comedy field. Though Amy Adams picked up the win for her work in American Hustle, she was up against Julie Delpy (Before Midnight), Greta Gerwig (Frances Ha), Julia Louis-Dreyfus (Enough Said) and Meryl Streep (August: Osage County). Frankly, any one of them could have realistically won, though to me Julie Deply's work was clearly the strongest of the group. The inevitable problem is that Delpy's film just doesn't have the public profile that American Hustle has, and also suffers from having been released so early in the year, whereas Adams' strong work is stuck much more strongly in our minds. It's not one to be too angry about, but the Globes got it wrong anyway.

6. Best Foreign Language Film €“ The Great Beauty

The Best Foreign Language Film category is one that the Golden Globes and the Oscars always seem to have trouble getting right, and this year was no exception. Though Paolo Sorrentino's regal drama The Great Beauty is certainly a fine nominee, it's not a particularly deserving winner when it's sharing the field with Palme D'or winner Blue is the Warmest Colour, widely acclaimed Oscar frontrunner The Hunt, The Past, and Hayao Miyazaki's "final" Studio Ghibli film, The Wind Rises. It's a genuine surprise that the Globes didn't take the opportunity to give the award to Blue is the Warmest Colour, given that it wasn't eligible for the equivalent award at the Oscars, as it would have been a striking jab at the Academy's often silly qualification guidelines (that the film must be released in its native country by the end of September).

5. Best Supporting Actor (Series, Miniseries Or TV Film) €“ Jon Voight (Ray Donovan)

This one is truly baffling given that a) Ray Donovan has had relatively mixed reviews since it started and b) there are 3 other nominees in the category who are far more deserving. It's fair to say that this might be a case of the HFPA old guard picking one of their old familiars, but with a slew of performances as good as Rob Lowe (Behind the Candelabra), Aaron Paul (Breaking Bad) and Corey Stoll (House of Cards), it's a real shocker and a disservice. More to the point, it was Aaron Paul's single Golden Globe nomination throughout his entire run on Breaking Bad, and would have been a very welcome summation award for his years of work. Paul's always worked in the shadow of Bryan Cranston, who has picked up countless awards left and right, so this would have been a nice moment, one that was sadly not to be for reasons unknown.

4. Best Original Score €“ All Is Lost

The Best Original Score category wasn't particularly strong this year, though the clear stand-outs were Hans Zimmer's work on 12 Years A Slave, and Steven Price's on Gravity. Fine though Alex Ebert's work on All Is Lost was, did it really deserve to topple the far more memorable, epic work done by Zimmer and Price in particular? I'm not convinced. It's fair to say that Zimmer's re-use of the same leitmotifs he used in Inception probably worked against him here, but the searing Gravity score should have easily sewn this one up. The only thing I can think of is that the HPFA found the electronic elements of the score not to their liking, and so opted for something a little more traditional with Ebert's admittedly strong work. Still, at least Mandela and The Book Thief didn't win.

3. Best Actor (TV Musical Or Comedy) €“ Andy Samberg (Brooklyn Nine-Nine)

It was a great night for the Brooklyn Nine-Nine crew, as Andy Samberg delivered one of the night's biggest shocks by scooping the Best Actor in a Musical or Comedy TV award. The big three in terms of competition were Jason Bateman (Arrested Development), Michael J. Fox (The Michael J. Fox show) and Jim Parsons (The Big Bang Theory), though each had a reason to lose to Samberg. Both Bateman and Parsons have won for their respective roles before, while Fox was simply glad to be nominated due to the mixed reception the show has received. As mentioned, awards shows love championing on-the-up talent, and this was their tip of the hat to Samberg. Who was the most deserving? For me, it would unquestionably be Bateman, who really poured himself into the new season of Arrested Development, and a thumbs up for that work would also be a tacit approval of Netflix's revolutionary TV delivery system (something they got anyway with Robin Wright's win for House of Cards).

2. Best Supporting Actress (Musical Or Comedy Film) €“ Jennifer Lawrence (American Hustle)

Jennifer Lawrence is very much the "it" girl of the moment, with one Academy Award win to her name already, and worldwide fan adoration due to the success of The Hunger Games franchise. Though her performance in American Hustle was rabble-rousing and very entertaining, was it really the best of the bunch? The two it was particularly bested by in my opinion were Lupita Nyong'o (12 Years A Slave) and June Squibb (Nebraska), though I frankly wasn't surprised that the HPFA went for Hollywood's darling instead. I just hope this doesn't help set a precedent for the Academy Awards, because I can't get on-board with Lawrence being a back-to-back Oscar winner for two performances that were certainly good, but not great by any means (unpopular an opinion as that may be).

1. Best Drama Film €“ 12 Years A Slave

12 Years A Slave was a brilliantly gruelling drama about American slavery, and it is for sure the frontrunner to take Best Picture at the Oscars, but is it the best film of the five nominated here? Close, but no cigar. While it easily bests films like Captain Phillips, Philomena and Rush, it is thoroughly outdone in my opinion by Gravity. Yet as we all know, sci-fi films rarely do well at awards shows not specifically tailored to sci-fi, and so it had to settle for a Best Director win for Alfonso Cuarón, which was inevitable by sheer force of will. Is 12 Years probably the most awards-friendly film of the five? Despite its grim subject matter, I would hazard to say yes, because it is a card-carrying "prestige" film, yet that doesn't mean it's the best film, or more specifically, that it should have beaten Gravity for the gong. What do you think? Did I miss any epic snubs? Sound off in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.