10 Box Office Flops That Threw Away Stupid Amounts Of Money

Fancy burning a heap of cash? These films can show you how.

Walt Disney Pictures
Walt Disney Pictures

In a world where Hollywood studios seem to completely misunderstand what it is we want from our movies, there€™s something quite refreshing about a box office flop. If nothing else, they're a sign that films aren't bulletproof and we won€™t just hand over our cash for whatever a studio churns out.

Even when the industry grows each year without fail (thank you cinemas and your increasingly expensive tickets), flops are still rampant, often with greater severity as budgets reach higher and higher. In fact, a lot of films that initially seem to have done well didn't make a profit; to break even a film not only needs to offset its production budget, but also all its marketing, which normally ends up doubling the overall cost.

There is a natural downside to this. The films that flop are the ones that don€™t come with a pre-existing franchise; namely, non-sequels. Everyone moans we get nothing but sequels, but when something new could lose you $100 million you can€™t blame studios going for another G.I. Joe.

Today we take a look at the cream of the crop; the films that took losing a lot of money and turned it into an artform. Here are the ten films that lost their studios completely ridiculous amounts of money (spoiler, Disney don't come out of this well).

All numbers are correct at the time of writing and have been calculated using the standard method (to account for marketing and other expenses the budget is doubled) unless other, more accurate, information was available.


10. The Adventures Of Pluto Nash - $96.4 million

Warner Bros. Pictures
Warner Bros. Pictures

Budget: $100 million Box Office: $7.1 million

Most flops are the films that studios misguidedly think audiences want. So, where better to begin this list than with Eddie Murphy? Breaking out in comedy cop movies (48 Hrs. is a forgotten gem dwarfed against Beverly Hills Cop), the nineties seemed to cement him as a comedy star, where he kept otherwise cynical remakes The Nutty Professor and Dr. Dolittle on the right side of OK.

It€™s a world away from the Murphy we know today, gurning his way through increasingly awful fare; a career descent that began with The Adventures Of Pluto Nash. A sci-fi comedy (a hard mash-up to deliver on), it has a convoluted plot that, for the most part, plods on regardless of the Moon setting. Expecting space-trotting action? Nope, this is the story of nightclub ownership(and is importantly devoid of laughs).

Although the characters survive through an overreliance on bulletproof shirts (c€™mon guys, this isn€™t 1985), nothing could save the film, showing general audiences do have some quality control.

If it wasn€™t for the (relatively) small budget Pluto Nash could have sat much higher on this list; it has the worst percentage return of the whole ten. Starting strong then.

Did it deserve to flop? Oh yes. Even Eddie Murphy didn€™t like it.


9. Stealth - $96.5 million

Columbia Pictures
Columbia Pictures

Budget: $135 million

Box Office: $76.9 million

There€™s something incredibly laughable about watching a box office bomb and discovering an after credits scene. Green Lantern€™s, with Mark Strong€™s Sinestro finding an evil yellow ring (what a coincidence with a name like that) was funny, promising a plot the first film really should have done. But even that€™s pipped to the post by Stealth€™s, notable due to the film€™s massive loss of money and barely sequelable story.

The scene shows that EDI, an A.I. developed to fly stealth aircraft, has survived the film€™s events. Those events you can imagine a screenwriter at one point thinking were genius are anything but. Showing what Hollywood pre-drones thought drone warfare would be like, its €˜realistic€™ science is undermined when EDI is turned evil by lightning. It€™s a dumb film posing as a smart one and thankfully people didn€™t buy it.

Odd, however, for a big summer tentpole was the slight release the film got, appearing in few theatres and dropping from screens faster than most.

Did it deserve to flop? Being directed by Rob Cohen (who left The Fast And The Furious before it got good) and using a poster design every crummy sci-fi does, it came across as the typical bad film.


8. Sahara - $100.3 million

Paramount Pictures
Paramount Pictures

Budget: $160 million Box Office: $119.2 million

Genre comedies are a gamble. But like the guy who wants just one more spin on a fruit machine, Hollywood seem to take that as a sign to put more and more money into a project.

Sahara, an action-comedy starring Matthew McConaughey (pre-awesome critical turnaround) and Penelope Cruz, the film is a National Treasure style lark that sticks close enough to the middle of the road that it€™s surprising to see it on a list like this.

Particularly when you check out that respectable box office (for the time and its scope). Sahara (released within a couple of months of Stealth) didn€™t fail of its own accord, but because Paramount simply sunk too much into their light hearted film that it would be almost impossible to scrape a profit.

We know much more about how Sahara flopped than others on this list (although rampant speculation is still fun) thanks to Clive Cussler, who wrote the book on which the film is based. Suing the producer after his €œabsolute control€ ended up meaning nothing not only showed some major nefarious dealing, but led to the revealing some otherwise confidential documents. Turns out some of the budget was left aside for bribing Moroccan officials. Money well spent.

Did it deserve to flop? The film itself didn€™t, but Paramount needed to learn the folly of throwing money around like it€™s going out of fashion.


7. Jack The Giant Slayer - $101.1 million

Warner Bros. Pictures
Warner Bros. Pictures

Budget: $185 million Box Office: $197.7 million

Thank goodness Bryan Singer is returning to the X-World for this year€™s Days Of Future Past. Since he left pre-production of The Last Stand his career has been undirected, with no development in sight; Superman Returns and Valkyrie weren't bad per se (ignore what the fans screech about the former), but they were unfitting of the director of The Usual Suspects.

Jack The Giant Slayer was a different beast. A gritty re-imagining of the beanstalk fairy tale, it personified a film thrown together from what€™s worked in the past; a plucky up-and-coming actor playing a plucky blank slate hero, Bill Nighy under lots of CGI, a kooky world wrapped in a fake-looking computerised sheen, Ewan McGregor as a sword wielding knight, a well known story reduced to an action spectacle.

Well those things don't a success make, although you feel given the film€™s release in the purgatory between Oscar fare and blockbuster season Warner Bros. knew they were onto a loser.

Did it deserve to flop? The film itself wasn€™t god-awful, but the sub-genre of re-imagined fairy tales is. Seeing one of them fail spectacularly (Hansel And Gretel: Witch Hunters made a sizable profit thanks to international markets) finally tells studios we€™re not buying it.


6. Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within - $102.4 million

Columbia Pictures
Columbia Pictures

Budget: $115 million Box Office: $85.1 million

The only film based on a video game on this list, Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within, in a turn that seems made up, didn€™t flop because of the obvious reason.

Directed by Hironobu Sakaguchi, the man who created the enduring game series, this isn€™t the usual blatant cash grab that has ruined the medium as a source of cinematic inspiration. Neither based off a particular game nor spawning an adaptation, this was a labour of love, evident by the amount of effort put into making lead character Aki look as real as possible (it makes James Cameron€™s efforts with the Navi positively lazy).

The box office poison all comes out of what make the project so intriguing. Of course unable to escape the video game movie stigma, the obsessive animation (which impresses thirteen years on) sent the budget skywards and Sakaguchi showed he wasn€™t as masterful at telling a story on the big screen. The film was actually OK, but audiences had a buffet of reasons to not check it out.

Did it deserve to flop? With its envelope pushing effects and by the simple fact it isn€™t terrible, not really.


5. John Carter - $108.6 million

Walt Disney Pictures
Walt Disney Pictures

Budget: $250 million Box Office: $282.8 million

If you€™re going to throw a quarter of a billion dollars at someone to make a tentpole picture based on risky (read: no fan base) material you could do a lot worse than the director of two of the biggest animated films of all time. Unfortunately for Andrew Stanton, his brush with the live-action blockbuster led him to run back to Pixar with his tail between his legs to needlessly sequalise another of their classics.

John Carter (originally Of Mars, but that was dropped because audiences don€™t like Mars but love bland names) tells the story of a civil war soldier magically transported to the red planet, where he develops superpowers. If that sounds a little archaic it€™s because it is. Based off the Edgar Rice Burroughs novels from the early 20th Century, repurposed into a 2012 blockbuster makes the idea look derivative, but that's only due to the series€™ subsequent influence. Disney ignored that in their marketing, however, instead presenting it as an Avatar rip-off.

John Carter wanted to be the new Star Wars, but in doing so betrayed the indie ideology that allowed it (or the first one at least) to end up such a hit. So in the end Disney went €œf**k it€ and just bought Star Wars instead.

Did it deserve to flop? It€™s surprising Stanton churned out something so generic, putting extra stock in the €˜movie by committee€™ idea, but that doesn't defend the film. As a non-franchise (hundred-year-old books don€™t count) movie it€™s sad to see it turn out bad, but a film this messy doesn't deserve a profit.


4. R.I.P.D. - $114.8 million

Universal Pictures
Universal Pictures

Budget: $130 million Box Office: $78.3 million

What exactly made R.I.P.D. such a flop? It€™s a comedy-action-sci-fi film, which is a subtle theme of this list, but what made it burn so much more than its contemporaries? Just as its genre is one too many, the film was just too many X-meets-Y.

Ryan Reynolds as Ryan Reynolds-meets-Rooster Cogburn in Supernatural-meets-Men In Black story of everyday world-meets-its near destruction. Based on a comic book. The trailer showed a cool concept with no plot to back it up and it also did poorly with audiences (even some people liked Transformers) leading to awful word of mouth. It€™s too much for it to not fail.

The issue here is thinking a comic book, rather than beloved superhero, is a big box office draw. Taking a little known concept and Hollywood-ing it up isn€™t going to work because in a saturated market bringing a couple of fans with you doesn€™t hold water.

Did it deserve to flop? Jeff Bridges will always be fun, but it€™s so unimaginative it€™s not surprising audiences were turned off.


3. The Lone Ranger - $119.7 million

Walt Disney Pictures
Walt Disney Pictures

Budget: $250 million Box Office: $260 million

Although The Fifth Estate,the Benedict Cumberbatch-helmed story of Wikileaks,was the least profitable film of 2013 by percentages, at the base line The Lone Ranger comes out on top. Gore Verbinski€™s rejuvenation of the radio series none of the target audience was old enough to remember wound up losing Disney $100 million, which came as a surprise to no one.

Westerns are a tricky genre nowadays. You need a strong director, gritty realism and a focus. The Lone Ranger had none of those, but what buried it was the press. Taking over five years to make it to the screen it defined a troubled production and the press were quick to label it a flop well before release. In fact, the film arrived in some international territories with the big loss as the only selling point. Slap that on the poster.

Disney, you can imagine, were a bit upset their western wasn€™t a new Pirates Of The Caribbean, but don€™t expect this to have a massive impact on the Mouse House; they were also behind Iron Man 3, the year€™s biggest hit.

Did it deserve to flop? Actually no. The Lone Ranger wasn€™t the train wreck of quality Verbinski€™s overblown Pirates sequels led us to believe. It was long (what isn€™t) and used Johnny Depp doing a silly voice too much, but was an average film in a summer of poor ones.


2. The 13th Warrior - $129.2 million

Buena Vista Pictures
Buena Vista Pictures

Budget: $100 million Box Office: $61.7 million

The only film on this list from before the new millennium (just), it€™d be easy to chalk up The 13th Warrior€™s failure down to coming out hot on the heels of The Sixth Sense, a film that was only beaten by the unmatchable hype of Star Wars Episode I. But to do that gives the film too much of a free pass.

As Keanu Reeves in 47 Ronin recently reaffirmed, American takes on a certainly non-American story are a shaky proposition. Doomed to look pandering in the native setting and alien to US audiences, there€™s minimal appeal. And why you'd make things worse by thinking Antonio Banderas was a suitable Arab is beyond me. But to blame that still gives the film too much of a free pass.

The production was an utter mess. Based on a book by Michael €˜Jurassic Park€™ Crichton (one of the film€™s main selling points), the writer ended up taking over from original director John McTiernan after test audiences hated the film and the budget subsequently spiraled. Oh troubled productions, you strike again.

Did it deserve to flop? No matter how poor the film, it marked a then-low-point in John McTiernan€™s career. If it had done a little better maybe we could have avoided Rollerball (a film that could have made the list if it weren€™t for its more sensible budget).


1. Mars Needs Moms - $130.5 million

Walt Disney Pictures
Walt Disney Pictures

Budget: $150 million Box Office: $39 million

John Carter and The Lone Ranger just too mainstream for you? Want a more hipster-flop? Well Mars Needs Moms was losing Disney copious amounts of money before it was cool.

Produced by Robert Zemeckis and made using his beloved motion capture, it was an odd film that couldn't commit to either side of its sci-fi-comedy genre (you again?) and got so many things wrong it€™s amazing it made the little amount it did.

The animation goes for realistic but can€™t get out of the €˜uncanny valley€™ Final Fantasy brushed with ten years before. The story is in concept knockabout (Martians need to steal Moms for their €œmomness€) but is treated with a straight face, following the path of any other blockbuster. And, a couple of years after Avatar, its big push of 3D came just as we were becoming disenfranchised with the tech. It all adds up to a film that lacks any major appeal.

The flop was high profile, with effects slowly seeping into cinemas. John Carter lost its Of Mars (because the film obviously only flopped because of that association) and motion capture now needs to be pushed by the likes of Steven Spielberg and Peter Jackson to make it close to the multiplexes.

Did it deserve to flop? Its quality is exactly why it flopped. Thanks to Twitter reducing the time word of mouth takes to spread, everyone knew it was an iffy movie and pundits knew it had failed long before the executives did.

Which upcoming films could displace some of these entries? Which film didn€™t deserve to lose so much money? Head down to the comments and have your say.


Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.