10 Comedians Who Pulled Out Awesome Acting Performances
Warning: The following list contains an assortment of strange, seemingly random acting roles from talented comedians. The author of this article recognizes the fact that some of these performances make him look like a hipster that is purposely excluding classic roles by comedian-turned-actors, but that is not the case. He would like it to be made clear that these choices are based entirely on his own personal preference. Also, yeah, he may be a bit of a hipster. Thank you for your time. For whatever reason, it's always interesting to see comedians, more specifically stand-ups, acting in films. But why? Maybe it's because we're all innocent little boys and girls at heart, and we love having the opportunity to yell out "Hey! I saw them on a stage telling jokes! And now they're in this movie!" while enjoying a nice flick with our friends. Or, perhaps it's something else entirely, I don't know. What I do know is that incredible acting performances from comedians are becoming more and more common these days, and that is extremely beneficial for the world of stand-up, as well as the magical lands of film and television. Of course, some of these roles are more famous than others. An example would be Robin Williams in Good Will Hunting, but for the sake of making this an interesting list, some of my picks will be lesser recognized film and television performances. Don't worry, though, they're all awesome. Enjoy the article, and write some words for me to read in the comments sections. 10. Seth Rogen - 50/50
It's pretty much a widely known fact at this point, but in case you aren't privy, the always hilarious Seth Rogen got his start in the entertainment industry via stand-up comedy. Beginning when he was just 12 years old, a young Rogen would perform around Canada, and he somehow managed to get paid for it. This eventually led to him auditioning for (and getting a part in) Freaks and Geeks, and the rest, as they say, is history. The actor now has a fantastic catalogue of comedy films, and to be honest, there are a plethora of other movies I could have chosen for Rogen. I ended up settling on 50/50. Now, yes, Rogen basically plays an exaggerated version of himself in the movie, but something about the role sticks out. Perhaps it has to do with the heavy emotional aspect of the film, and just how relieving it was to have comic relief throughout. Without Rogen's character, this film would essentially be a drama, and not nearly as good as it turned out.9. Mike Birbiglia - Sleepwalk With Me
The brilliant Sleepwalk With Me marked the first time I was truly exposed to the genius that is Mike Birbiglia. This is a movie that, quite literally, grabs your attention right off the bat, and doesn't let it go until the end of the film. However, it wasn't until a friend of mine urged me to check out Birbiglia's stand-up, that I fully realized how phenomenal of a job he actually did (shout out to Amanda for that. I've been writing here long enough to give shout-outs, right?). In the film, Bigbigs plays an exaggerated version of himself, before he was an established comic. And, wow, the dude spectacular at playing a bad comic, as great as he is in reality. As far as I know, Mike had no formal acting training, just experience as apart of an improv troupe, and obviously his stand-up/one man show act. This makes it even more impressive. Mark my words, Mike Birbiglia will be a well-respected actor in a few years time.
8. Garry Shandling - The Larry Sanders Show
I'm not sure if it's considered cheating to include a TV show, but whatevs, I have to. The Larry Sanders Show is one of the greatest pieces of entertainment ever, and, of course, a lot of that has to do with Garry Shandling. Shandling, whose career started by writing for sitcoms, turned to stand-up in the late 70s, due to his frustration with the formula of said sitcoms. Along the way, Shandling decided to break that boring sitcom formula by creating It's Garry Shandling's Show for Showtime. The series starred Garry as himself, and it constantly broke the fourth wall, which made it one of the most insanely awesome things I've seen. It ran for four seasons, and when it was over, Shandling headed over to HBO, for another series (also known as, his masterpiece). This series turned out to be The Larry Sanders Show. Starring Shandling as the title character, Larry Sanders was a talk show host, and the actual show revolved around Larry's talk show, as well as his hilarious personal life. Make sense? Granted, Mr. Shandling wasn't trying to show everyone how good of an actor he was, but he did have chops, and he managed to create an iconic character.
7. Louis C.K. - Louie
I've written about Louie in the past, so those of you who are huge fans of that article, basically know my opinion of the series. Hint: I very much like it. Louis C.K., the guy that made me a fan of stand-up, stars as an exaggerated version of himself, living the life of a comedian and a father. It's a simple show really, but like nothing you've seen before. It's surreal, yet real, it's edgy, funny, dramatic, it's everything you'd expect from C.K. And, despite past performances in bad movies, Louis is actually a pretty great actor. His performances are nuanced, subtle, and often poignant. Granted, he's playing himself, which might not be too challenging, but it's still an interesting take on his own life. Since the show became popular, he's been getting more work, including a role in Woody Allen's next film. In other words, he's doing something right.
6. Larry David - Whatever Works
Remember earlier, when I said I wanted to include lesser known roles? This is one of them. Everyone knows David for Curb Your Enthusiasm, and it's easily his best work, but it wasn't until Woody Allen's Whatever Works that the actor got the chance to show his range. To be honest, I didn't know the film existed until recently, and I think that may be the case for a lot of people. I mean, the idea of a Woody Allen film with Larry David in the lead is irresistible. And, while the film isn't nearly as good as it could have been, it's certainly something to see. David plays Boris, a man who can only be described as unpleasant. You know, one of those characters that are really fun to watch, but you'd hate to know them in person? That's Boris. The final product is a sweet comedy from Allen, and it proves that Larry David can carry a film, given the right role. Basically, anything other than that awful Three Stooges movie. So yeah, I recommend Whatever Works, despite some critics disliking the film.
5. Jay Mohr - Jerry Maguire
If you're a fan of film, and not so much comedy, you probably think Jay Mohr hasn't been relevant since the nineties. You'd be mistaken, people. Mohr is one of the best stand-up comedians ever, and he also runs a successful (and hilarious) podcast. But who knows where he would be today if it weren't for Jerry Maguire. Cameron Crowe's uber-popular 1996 film features Jay Mohr as Bob Sugar, a sleazy sports agent, and the enemy of Tom Cruise's protagonist. The performance isn't Oscar-worthy or anything, but it's a lot of fun, and it was a great opportunity for the young comic. Mohr went on to be a great actor, appearing in some notable films over the years, including a Clint Eastwood flick, and recurring roles on a number of television series', including Suburgatory. He's a talented man.
4. David Cross - Arrested Development
Another comedian (and former roommate of Louis C.K.), David Cross has a cult following in the comedy world. From his days working on Mr. Show with Bob Odenkirk, to his three comedy albums, David Cross is a legend in the industry. But his best work, and probably what you'd recognize him most for, is his supporting role in Arrested Development. In the series, Cross plays Tobias Funke, the never-nude, possibly gay, definitely idiotic, brother-in-law of Michael Bluth, the series' protagonist. For me, Cross is the highlight of the show, and he absolutely garners the most laughs. His habit to misunderstand his own statements, often become some of the most memorable moments of the show. Even more impressive, unlike some of my other choices, Cross is playing a character that is strikingly different from his actually personality. Those sketch comedy classes in college must have really paid off.
3. Woody Allen - Broadway Danny Rose
Here we go with more Woody Allen, though this time around, the actor in question is Allen himself. The prolific filmmaker, who often stars in his own films, and who occasionally pops up in other people's movies, was a comic early on in his career, and to this day is considered one of the most influential stand-up comedians of his time. In fact, it was actually the act that helped him to develop the signature neurotic personality we all know and love. This is on full display in, more or less, every Woody role, and although the popular picks here would probably be Annie Hall or Manhattan, I'm going with my favorite Woody Allen film, Broadway Danny Rose. In this one, Woody plays a somewhat pathetic talent manager with a heart of gold. Danny gets into a hilariously dangerous situation because of his biggest client, and he (accompanied by Mia Farrow) spends the movie trying to figure out a way to get out of it. It sounds simple, and it is, but Allen creates an endlessly lovable character, and an equally lovable film. He doesn't act much anymore, but hopefully the man has a few more great performances left in him.
2. Jim Carrey - Man On The Moon
Out of all stand-up comics turned actors, Jim Carrey may be the most successful. He's a household name, and he's been in some of the most popular comedies of the past twenty years. There are multiple performances that could take this spot, but to me, Carrey's best acting was as Andy Kaufman in Man on the Moon. What's funny about this pick, is that Carrey, a comedian, is portraying Kaufman, another comedian. And he does so excellently. The Golden Globe winning performance captured all of Kaufman's weirdness, and didn't at all feel like Jim Carrey imitating Andy Kaufman. The film is streaming on Netflix, and if you have it, I definitely recommend giving it a watch. It's a work of art. Well, all films are, but this one is good. Take my word for it.
1. Bill Murray - Rushmore
Ever since Bill Murray met Wes Anderson, his career got a makeover. I didn't grow up with the Murray of the eighties and nineties, and I generally avoid those silly comedies (sorry, fans of those movies), so the cynical, indie William Murray of now is all I know. And it started with Rushmore. Already one of the greatest films of all-time, Murray turns in a great supporting performance alongside young Jason Schwartzman. The actor plays Herman Blume, a generally unhappy man who is in love with the same woman as the protagonist. The acting is brilliant, and it's fun to see a comedian portray such a miserable character. Don't get me wrong, though, the film is still hilarious, full of witty and dry humor. It also managed to spark a working relationship with between Wes and Bill. Since this film, Murray has been in every Wes Anderson movie.