3. The Creature (Frankenstein) vs. Dracula
That's right, I'm going all classic horror characters on your asses right now. For the record, the version of the Creature that I'm going by is the original character from the novel, who is intelligent and considers himself a version of Adam and has no discernible neck bolts. If you've seen the Frankenstein play with Benedict Cumberbatch and Jonny Lee Miller, more along the lines of that character. And Dracula is pretty much just traditional Dracula. So now that we've gotten that out of the way, let's begin. While Dracula definitely has the edge when it comes to longevity and a limited number of ways to be killed, the Creature is actually quite a master strategist. He tracks down Frankenstein, who is himself not exactly a schlub in the mental department. No word on if the Creature is human enough to be swayed by Dracula's brand of hypnosis, but that would come into play heavily here.
Who Would Win: I have to go with the Creature. His intellect combined with the brute strength that the character has always been known for is more than enough to take out Dracula, who's basically a really old dandy that's been going after easy prey for centuries.