10 Films That Made Audiences Dumber
"Dis is nutsen! Oh gooberfish!"
The next time you shout at someone who complains that human beings are getting dumber, have a think on this: between the years 1976 and 1996, our culture included punk rock, Star Wars, Alien, Die Hard and Nirvana.
Between the years 1996 and 2016, our idea of culture included The Spice Girls, The Phantom Menace, Alien Vs Predator: Requiem, A Good Day To Die Hard and Justin Bieber. We gave 11 Oscars to Titanic, told Johnny Depp he could do no wrong playing Captain Jack Sparrow and turned Transformers into a multi-billion dollar franchise.
As a former reality TV star prepares to enter the White House, we must appear to alien visitors like the dinosaurs at the beginning of Armageddon, merrily obsessed by everyday trivialities and unconcerned by that flaming ball in the sky.
When these visitors look back over our culture, desperate for some clue as to how we became extinct, they will conclude that the movies released between 1996 and 2016 were deliberately terrible in order to soften up the masses and make them accept the idea of President Donald Trump. Who subsequently began World War Terminus after being insulted on Twitter.
Here, then, are the 10 films whose only purpose was to lower standards and dull sensations ahead of a full takeover by a pumpkin monster with tiny hands.
10. I, Robot
I know, I know – everybody loves I, Robot and everybody loves Will Smith, especially when he’s running around saying funny stuff in a sci-fi movie.
But consider this: the very best sci-fi uses the future to comment upon the present but I, Robot is content to use the future as an opportunity for product placement.
In the first three minutes, we get gratuitous plugs for JVC, FedEx and “Converse All Stars, vintage 2004”. That’s how it goes for the rest of the film, with particular attention paid to Audi, whose fine automobiles will be the only vehicles gracing American roads in 2035.
Nominated for a special effects Oscar, generally well received by critics and a box office hit to boot, I Robot remains the gold standard of glorified adverts that hoodwinked audiences into believing they were actual movies. The film has nothing at its core except a “message” to buy more stuff so the next time you see a computer generated character standing in front of a billboard, feel free to curse this movie.
9. Terminator Genisys
Imagine the fun that Mystery Science Theatre 3000 could have with a needless sequel that refuses to make sense and whose dialogue lands with a thud every few minutes. Terminator Genisys is such a sequel, a movie so awkwardly contrived and crassly commercial that it deserves to lampooned as ruthlessly as possible.
There’s so much rich material here: the groan-inducing attempts at humour, the characters who keep explaining their motivation to each other and the shameless attempts at fan service. Then there’s the alternate timeline that causes Kyle Reese to experience a live he never lived, where his younger self keeps repeating “Genisys is Skynet.” Erm, what?
Wading through it all is Arnold Schwarzenegger, who by now bears more resemblance to Moonraker-era Roger Moore than the character we saw in The Terminator: all his character does is make dreadful puns, rescue the damsel in distress and smirk for the camera.
8. The Mummy
When The Mummy made $415 million worldwide, it lead to a series of movies inspired by Universal’s classic monster movies made by people who’d clearly never watched them.
The two sequels were bad enough, but when Van Helsing failed to repeat their success, it should’ve torpedoed all future efforts. It didn’t, so we got Dracula Untold and The Wolf Man, which one studio head described as “crappy” and “one of the worst we ever made.”
But here’s the punchline: The Mummy had nothing to do with the 1932 Boris Karloff (or even the sequels with Lon Chaney). It wanted to be Raiders Of The Lost Ark instead, an old-fashioned romp through the desert with a disaster-prone hero, large scale action set pieces and plenty of special effects. All its success proved was that you could ignore the source material, make a generic action movie and still score a smash hit.
A new version of The Mummy, starring Tom Cruise, is due for release in June 2017, so we’ll see.
7. The Day The Earth Stood Still
Based on a story by Harry Bates, Robert Wise’s The Day The Earth Stood Still is one of the landmark science fiction films of the 1950s. Directed by the guy who made Hellraiser: Inferno, this remake casts Keanu Reeves as an alien named Klaatu who visits Earth in a giant sphere.
The original ended with Klaatu leaving Earth after giving the world’s leaders a choice: you can join the other planets in peace or you can extend your violence into space, in which case “this Earth of yours will be reduced to a burned-out cinder.”
Having none of that, the remake dissipates the impact of the story by having Klaatu abandon his plans when Jennifer Connelly and Jaden Smith persuade him that humanity is just swell. Now shut up and watch and these special effects.
As if casting Smith as Connelly’s stepson wasn’t odd enough, the movie also throws in Kathy Bates as the Secretary of Defence and John Cleese (playing it straight) as a Nobel Prize winning physicist. Rumours that Uwe Boll was cast as the US President turned out to be untrue.
6. Freddy Vs Jason
In 2003, a conflict many had predicted for over a decade began as two former allies with competing ideologies engaged in a bitter and bloody feud that left a trail of needless destruction in its wake….but enough about Iraq.
Part of a plot sanctioned by George W Bush to lower expectations, dull sensations and send standards crashing into the basement, Freddy Vs Jason exists for one purpose: to make America forget it was fighting a pointless war. The movie was dreamed up by Karl Rove and Dick Cheney, their faces lit by lightning as they drank champagne from the skulls of children and cackled, “Can you believe that people will be paying to see this?”
It’s difficult to take the film seriously as horror when it’s littered with so many references to Scooby Doo, from an unshaven stoner who owns a vehicle referred to as a “Scooby van” to a Sheriff played by Garry Chalk, who was also the Vice Principal in Scooby Doo: The Mystery Begins. These things are not an accident, people.
5. Lara Croft: Tomb Raider
Academics can debate which decade created “post content” filmmaking, but in 2001 it had a new poster child in the form of Lara Croft: Tomb Raider, which proved that not only could you adapt a video game into a successful movie, you could convince an Oscar winner to take the lead role.
It was a dangerous precedent to set. If a movie this lousy can take $275 million, why bother to create anything good?
Even at 100 minutes, with a lengthy end credits sequence, Tomb Raider has a feeling of sturm und drang that a big summer movie ought not to have. The writing is flat, the direction is lifeless and the supporting cast all look like they’d rather be elsewhere. No movie where Angelina Jolie takes a lot of showers and Daniel Craig is the love interest should be this dispiriting.
Hollywood didn’t draw the line at adapting video games to the screen either, turning toy lines, board games and even the humble Ouija board into franchises. Somewhere in Hollywood there must be a script called Paper Cup: The Motion Picture.
4. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre
Before destroying cinema with his Transformers franchise, Michael Bay established a production company to churn out joyless, oppressive remakes of horror movies. Not content with tearing the guts out of The Hitcher, he later targeted the likes of Friday The 13th, A Nightmare On Elm Street and The Amityville Horror.
First out of the gate, however, was The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, which set the standard for what was to come: soulless, sluggish and determined to get in your face, the movie actually becomes more boring and obnoxious as it goes on. It also helped establish the trend for so-called “torture porn” which gave the world Captivity and Hostel as well as that all-time classic, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning. Then there were the remakes of I Spit On Your Grave, The Last House On The Left, The Hills Have Eyes etc.
Which was missing the point of Tobe Hooper’s original movie: even though the title and poster (which posed the question, “Who will survive and what will be left of them?”) promised all the gore in the world, the movie eschewed blood and guts in favour of claustrophobia, suspense and a nice line in black humour. All of these are absent from the remake, where lopped-off limbs and false scares become the order of the day, as they would in countless films to come.
3. Spice World
Bands like Rage Against The Machine, The Stone Roses and Cypress Hill (among others) meant the early 90s were a vibrant time for music fans, but that all came to an end when The Spice Girls released their debut album and ushered in the era of manufactured, crassly commercial pop sensations.
In 1997, they were busy selling their message of “Girl Power” in Spice World, a movie created for them by the men that controlled their careers. Attempting to do for the Fatuous Five what A Hard Days’ Night did for the Fab Four, the film tries to avoid looking like a glorified promotional video by being “hip” and “funny”, and the results look suspiciously like what would happen if five Barbie dolls came to life and surrounded themselves with embarrassed looking guest stars.
An inexplicable hit, the movie lowered the bar for pop music, musicals, screen acting and film in general, leaving the door wide open for America’s Got Talent, Justin Bieber and other names on the CIA’s Severe Harsh Interrogation Techniques list.
2. Planet Of The Apes
If you need convincing that blockbusters in the early 2000s were churned out for an audience of gurgling test subjects, look no further than Tim Burton’s “reimagining” of Planet Of The Apes. Judging by the level of wit and creativity on display here, a “reimagining” means a rushed and pointless film that throws out the original in favour of a third-rate Twilight Zone episode.
The 1968 original is incredibly subversive, with characters arguing that religious dogma (read “creationism”) should not be substituted for scientific fact, but this movie is having none of that. Instead, Mark Wahlberg runs around, there are some special effects, and Charlton Heston turns up to say “damn them all to hell” (as will you).
So incredibly slipshod in its storytelling that neither Burton nor his cast could explain the plot, Apes ’01 has the distinction of being the only movie in the franchise where nothing is satisfactorily explained, characters and plot points are introduced and discarded at random and the big ‘reveal’ at the climax still leaves viewers scratching their heads.
Does Ape-raham Lincoln have a monument in his honour because he emancipated the apes? Or did he free the human slaves? If you expect answers from Burton’s DVD commentary, you’ll be disappointed.
1. Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace
The most hyped product since Viagra, The Phantom Menace is a dynamic, edge of your seat story about an evil ruler who achieves power via bureaucratic delays and Trade Federation blockades.
The picture has a real shot at being the most mediocre film ever to make a billion dollars, although it achieved a weird hold on the minds of true Star Wars aficionados, who re-watched it in the mistaken belief that they might actually like it this time.
The Phantom Menace has no feel for character, but then the movie was never about people, whether on the screen or in the audience. It was all about shifting product – the toys, the games, the books, clothes, mugs, beach towels etc.
Kudos to George Lucas for pulling off the same trick not once, but twice, but three times before returning to the Indiana Jones franchise for Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull and giving us the term “nuking the fridge”, which Time Magazine defined as “to exhaust a Hollywood franchise with disappointing sequels.”
The movie’s true legacy isn’t it underwhelming sequels, though, but the numbing effect its soullessness had on audiences. The same viewers later flocked to see Pirates Of The Caribbean and Transformers, turning them into multi-billion dollar franchises in the process.