10 Former X-Men Actors Perfect For The MCU

There's still plenty of room in the MCU for these former mutants.

Cyclops James Marsden
20th Century Studios

Major MCU casting announcements always create a buzz but one of the most shocking was the recent report that Evan Peters would be featuring in the Disney+ series WandaVision.

While fans normally wouldn’t be surprised that an actor of his caliber has made it into Kevin Feige’s plans, the fact that Evan Peters played Quicksilver in Fox’s X-Men Universe just a few years ago makes this announcement quite intriguing.

Unlike Peter Dinklage who portrayed Bolivar Trask in X-Men: Days of Future Past before becoming Eitri in Infinity War, Peters was one of the standouts from the current run of X-Men films and his performance was generally lauded over that of Aaron Taylor Johnson’s in Avengers: Age of Ultron.

Could Peters’ casting be a return to his X-Men character, tying both universes together? Possibly, but at this point, who knows which direction Marvel will go with the multiverse moving forward.

But if Feige and company are looking to steal some stars from the X-Men world, there are a few others who deserve the nod that Peters is getting, even if they're still synonymous with Marvel's mutants.

10. Kevin Bacon

X Men First Class Kevin Bacon Sebastian Shaw
20th Century Fox

After the unfavorable reactions to X-Men Origins: Wolverine, X-Men: First Class needed to knock their reboot out of the park. Would an X-Men Origins: Magneto have worked? Possibly, but the strong cast of First Class was able to give the X-Men franchise the mutation it needed to bring back fans.

Placing Kevin Bacon as the movie's antagonist was a great choice, especially pairing him opposite of Michael Fassbender.

Kevin Bacon is a highlight in nearly every movie he's cast in. His ability to play both the flawed hero and sinister villain makes him an excellent choice for an MCU rebirth. Bringing him in as a turncoat character not unlike Jeff Bridges' Obadiah Stane would give the New Avengers a cunning adversary.


9. Edi Gathegi

Darwin X-Men first class
20th Century Fox

With Michael Fassbender, Jennifer Lawrence, James McAvoy, and Nicholas Hoult all commanding screen time, it comes as no surprise that Xavier's supporting X-Men received limited time to shine. Thankfully, the talented Zoe Kravitz will get another go in The Batman, but her fellow recruit Edi Gathegi deserves another superhero spin as well.

With Beast being the only original X-Man featured in First Class, most could already assume walking into the theater that some of this "first class" may not stick around to become official X-Men. Essentially cannon fodder to show Sebastian Shaw's immense power, Gathegi met his end without getting an opportunity to use his powers in combat.

Thankfully, the MCU could give Gathegi an opportunity for poetic revenge by bringing his villainous nature from The Black List into the MCU as Deathlok. Although we've seen one version of the character in Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., many individuals have taken up the Deathlok mantle in the comics, opening up an opportunity for Gathegi to bring him to the big screen.


8. James Marsden

X-Men Cyclops
20th Centutry Fox

With the X-Men heading into the MCU, there's already a huge debate on who should take on Scott Summers. Before we get too far ahead of ourselves, let's not forget that the original Cyclops actor received the short end of the stick.

Marsden was killed off-screen in X-Men: The Last Stand because he was also contracted to star in Superman Returns. Though his cameo in X-Men: Days of Future Past at least gave him a better sendoff, Marsden is a talented actor that could easily carry another leading role as a superhero.

A popular pick for Richard Rider, Marsden plays both the classic good guy and arrogant know-it-all beautifully, and is someone who could fill such a role if Chris Pratt meets his end in Guardians.


7. Alan Cumming

X-Men 2 Nightcrawler
20th Century Studios

Alan Cumming's portrayal of Nighcrawler was one of the highlights of the acclaimed X2: X-Men United, not to mention that his White House scene is one of the most memorable sequences of the entire franchise.

Unfortunately, the heavy makeup involved (and the departure of Bryan Singer from the film) made Cumming reconsider a reprisal for X-Men: The Last Stand. Perhaps the MCU could tempt him back into the superhero world if they promise to limit his time in the makeup chair.

Cumming is an exceptional actor and has the powerful stage presence that Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen have. Who better to bring a Shakespearean sense of drama to the space opera world of the Eternals or Inhumans? Cumming should be a top pick to play alongside Richard Madden and Salma Hayek in a sequel.


6. Ben Foster

Angel X Men The Last Stand
20th Century Studios

Ben Foster isn't the only actor to feature in multiple Marvel movies but he is one of the few to enter in two franchises that aren't within the MCU. Along with Rebecca Romijn, Foster starred in The Punisher with Thomas Jane and John Travolta.

When Foster came into the X-verse, he seemed a good fit for Warren Worthington III but sadly was left without much to do. It would have been great to see him transform into Archangel or at least do something more than fly and flex for a few scenes.

After two runs in the Marvel Universe, Foster deserves a character he can sink his teeth into. Bringing Trevor Fitzroy onto the silver screen would give him a chance to let his charisma shine and bring a lesser known X-Men villain into a mutant-filled MCU.


5. Ellen Page

Kitty Pryde x men shadowcat
Fox

While it was unsurprising the Kitty Pryde wasn't given much to do in the X-Men franchise, it was disappointing to see Ellen Page not get the opportunity to travel back in time for X-Men: Days of Future Past.

Page has come a long way since her go as Kitty Pryde. With the MCU setting a priority on diverse casting, pairing her up with Tessa Thompson in New Asgard would be a great start. Bringing her in as a member of New Asgard or even adding her into flashbacks while exploring Thompson's past as a Valkyrie would be an easy addition.

She's also grown as an actress and could easily fall into a mentor role of either a new team of Young Avengers, a new group of Mutants (perhaps even the New Mutants should that film suddenly be tied to the MCU) or any number of younger characters that may need a patient, caring figure that Page can portray.


4. Shawn Ashmore

Iceman Bobby Drake
20th Century Fox

Although he was an original X-Men, the X-Men film series was wise to keep him young and immature to grow alongside Rogue, Colossus, and Kitty Pryde. By the time X-Men: Days of Future Past rolled around, he was able to complete his arc and do the character justice.

While he may be fine without returning to the superhero genre, there is a unique way that he and his twin brother Aaron Ashmore could be used in the MCU. Should the Secret Wars story line or another Skull-focused tale be in the cards, why not take advantage of these two actors?

Obviously, CGI and stunt doubles can effortlessly be injected into any movie, so much so that a character like Multiple Man would have no trouble making it onto the screen. But using real twins has the potential to make any scene feel much more organic.

The slight differences in their facial features and mannerisms would subtly distract audiences and help them naturally feel that something is not right. With audience so used to special effects trickery, it would be refreshing to play the "body snatcher" trope without relying on a crutch.


3. Will.i.am

John Wraith Kestrel Will I Am
Fox

All things considered, the cast of X-Men Origins: Wolverine had more ups than downs. One of the bigger names on the cast list was musician Will.i.am who, despite limited acting credits, was actually a solid addition to the group.

Will.i.am had a natural chemistry with Hugh Jackman and stood out in all the right ways. Will.i.am rarely acts, and when he does, it's typically for voiceover roles. If he wanted to, he wouldn't be the only musician that's made a cameo in the MCU.

From Rob Zombie to Miley Cyrus, the MCU has shown that it has room for musicians from any genre. While he may not want a significant role, he could pop in for voice over work without much effort. If the MCU wanted to wink at the audience a bit, they could have Deadpool recognize will.i.am (in voice or in person) and call him out.


2. Alexandra Shipp

Xmen Apocalypse Storm Powers
Fox

Alexandra Shipp was a badass Storm who unfortunately got very little opportunity to be a badass Storm.

Another talented actress pushed to the sidelines in X-Men, Shipp is a rising star who could certainly cement herself as a strong presence in the MCU. While she would be a great Storm to pair alongside Chadwick Boseman's Black Panther (and in an alternate reality, would have given a fantastic performance with Michael B. Jordan), it's extremely unlikely she'll be considered for the role.

However, that doesn't mean there's not room for her in another corner of the MCU. Of course, everyone hopes that the MCU Netflix series can finally tie into the MCU proper and bring that impressive cast to the mainstream, but if not, Shipp should reboot one of the show's roles.


1. Jessica Chastain

Jessica Chastain Dark Phoenix
Fox

So much mystery surrounded the role of Jessica Chastain in Dark Phoenix, particularly because such a talented dramatic actress could instantly turn one of the X-Men's villains into one of the highlights of the franchise.

Unfortunately, her talents were relegated to the emotionless Vuk.

Interstellar, Zero Dark Thirty, Molly's Game, Miss Sloane...watch her filmography and you'll see that she has so much potential to become an MCU mainstay if given the opportunity.

Chastain is a strong performer who deserves a stage to showcase her abilities on. Playing another X-Men character like Lilandra or Deathbird would be a fantastic casting.


Watch Next


The Impossible X-Men Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know Marvel's Mutants?

How tall is Wolverine
Marvel Comics

1. How Tall Is Wolverine?

Contributor

Nick Dauk hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.