10 Great Characters Ruined By Terrible Sequels

Hero-to-zeroes, vanishing love interests, and killers clowns turned to... well, funny clowns...

It Chapter Two Pennywise
Warner Bros.

There are few feelings worse as a film fan than sitting down to the latest instalment of your favourite franchise only to discover that a beloved character has been given the short shrift by the filmmakers.

Sometimes, it’s that a new director has a bold vision for where the series should go which holds no room for old favourites. Sometimes, the studios simply couldn’t be bothered to create a new plot for their sequel, and as such decide to undo the last film’s character development in order to re-tread the same familiar territory as before for lesser results.

Whatever the cause, whilst some sequels do justice to their stars and deepen their character’s believability, just as often follow-ups ruin a much-loved figure in the eyes of the audience. In a lot of cases here, the filmmakers took the coward’s route out and simply killed off inconvenient heroes—a plague particularly common in the horror genre, where villains need to return but heroes are infamously disposable.

In other cases, once likeable heroes are reduced to insufferable jerks or side characters with a part to play are turned into one note jokes—in the worst cases listed here, characters were first ruined and then promptly killed off, a veritable worst of both worlds approach.

Whatever the case, here are ten movie characters whose sequels did them dirty.

10. Lara Jean - To All The Boys: P.S I Still Love You

To all the boys I've loved before still
Netflix

Arriving on our screens in 2018, To All the Boys I Loved Before was a breath of fresh air for fans of the sometimes great, always inconsistent teen rom com subgenre.

Joining the likes of 2010's Easy A, the superb Tina Fey-scripted Mean Girls, and the nineties classic Clueless, the film excelled thanks to its likeable and relatable sweet teen heroine Lara Jean, whose life falls into hilarious disarray when a set of love letters she never intended to send are mailed off to every boy she's ever imagined courting.

Sure, the film may be far-fetched, but Lara Jean's mixture of innocence and whip-smart wit gave her an easy charm. It's one which was unfortunately completely undone in 2020's entirely misjudged sequel.

From its clumsy title to its flat direction, nothing about To All the Boys 2 was a success, but it was Lara Jean's character which suffered worse. Going from a well-meaning over thinker to a self-centred, vindictive antiheroine made her a protagonist impossible to root for, and from cheating on her love interest to leading on some likeable new suitor for weeks, there was little sign of our Lara Jean in this poorly planned follow up.


9. Pennywise - IT Chapter 2

Pennywise The Clown
Bloody Disgusting

Look, there's no doubt that it's hard to make a monster progressively scarier every time they appear onscreen.

The difficulty which many long-running horror franchises have in upping the ante of their antagonists is the reason the later Friday the 13th and Nightmare on Elm Street instalments are infamous for making their villains corny parodies of their earlier selves... And that's saying nothing of (shudder) Seed of Chucky.

But the 2019 adaptation of horror author Stephen King's chilling doorstop It already had its end point in sight when the first film's director signed on to shoot the follow up, so it's hard to understand how the flick managed to fumble the baddie so badly.

But fumble poor Pennywise IT Chapter 2 most certainly did, with the film manifesting the monster as a toothy lumberjack mascot, a puking gurning zombie, and a naked old lady amongst other laughably un-scary incarnations.

Eventually, the first film's terrifying monster was reduced to a gibbering puddle and destroyed by... The power of friendship, in a twist which broke the hearts and overworked funny bones of many formerly fearful fans.


8. Peter Parker - Spider-Man 3

Spiderman 3
Sony Pictures

Whether he's played by Tom Holland, Andrew Garfield, or the OG Tobey Maguire, Peter Parker is a pretty consistent character.

The reliable self insert hero of an iconic comic book premised on the idea of a normal bloke becoming a hero, Peter's character is that of loveable dork who tries to do right by his friends and family whilst admitting he's far from infallible and has as many flaws as any of us.

For the first two films in Evil Dead director Sam Raimi's beloved mid-noughts Spider-Man trilogy, this characterisation shines through to a tee. Nervy, shy, and prone to moments of wit, charm, and bravado as well as real heroism, Maguire's Parker is a believable and likeable hero.

Then come 2007's muddled, over-complicated Spider-Man 3, he becomes... Whatever that Venom dance scene was meant to be.

Suddenly aggressively goofy and cartoonishly un-self-aware, Parker becomes a swaggering self parody when he dons the Venom suit. Obviously the symbiote is intended to change his personality, but instead the suit seems to make him utterly insane, and once he's back to himself the damage has been done and there's no un-seeing Maguire's floppy Fall Out Boy do.


7. Emmett - Legally Blonde 2

Legally Blonde Emmett
MGM

When the charming Reese Witherspoon vehicle Legally Blonde arrived in cinemas the film was a smash success and there's denying that the story of Elle Woods deserved all the acclaim heaped at its feet.

Following a light-hearted but razor-sharp sorority sister who becomes a lawyer despite the expectations of everyone around her, the film has a funny script and features one of Witherspoon's best-loved comic turns. It also benefits from the presence of Idiocracy star Luke Wilson as Elle's competent, supportive love interest Emmett.

A laidback charmer, Wilson makes a perfect foil for Woods, with his tentative flirtations balancing her bombastic presence.

So how does he fare in the sequel?

Who knows!

Emmett is inexplicably made a complete non-entity in the film's follow up, the less-loved Red White and Blonde. Outside of an opening and closing scene appearance which seem to exist solely to reassure fans that yes, he does still exist, Emmett is absent throughout the action. It's a poor choice which drags an already flawed sequel down further.


6. Holly McClane - Die Hard 4.0

Die Hard Holly McClane/Bonnie Bedelia
20th Century Fox

Remember the simple pleasures of the first Die Hard movie way back in 1988, when our hero John McClane could simply arrive at a Christmas party and outwit countless well armed not-actually-terrorists?

Before entire cities were taken hostage, before trips to Russia and a convoluted subplot featuring Kevin Smith, the first Die Hard was a tense white knuckle thrill ride which introduced to both no nonsense hero McClane and his smart, self sufficient love interest Holly.

From the moment she drops his name to get ahead in business to the second she has to let go off a company-gifted Rolex to ensure her survival, Holly is the blueprint for love interests who refuse to be damsels in distress and instead take a proactive role in the plot... even if she does end up taking back said name and losing said all-important Rolex in the name of family.

So where is she in 2007's abominable Die Hard 4.0?

Why, where else would the woman who tearfully embraced John and proudly took his name at the close of the first film.

She's nowhere to be seen, having divorced him offscreen at some point.

Inspiring stuff.


5. Oz - American Wedding

Oz American Pie
Universal Pictures

Played to perfection by the underrated Chris Klein, American Pie’s Oz is the quintessential all-American love interest. A likeable jock who takes up choir in order to win over Mena Suvari’s quiet new girl only to end up really falling for her (and choir), Oz is the most socially successful of the series’ largely awkward protagonists.

Despite this, the initially glib character may be well meaning but he still needs to learn honesty and vulnerability. By the second film in the series he’s a more sincere and mature character, and one viewers are invested in the future of.

Which make it all the more surreal when he is inexplicably absent from American Wedding, the disappointing third instalment of the series.

Sure, Oz may return in the next film, 2012’s return to form American Reunion. But what was the point of that unexplained absence, particularly when even the character’s actor doesn’t seem to know why Oz was left out of proceedings?


4. Alan - Hangover III

The Hangover 3 Iii
Warner Bros.

Comedy franchises often run into trouble when the characters they rely on mining laughs out of need to up their own inherent absurdity every time they appear in a new outing. Even characters whose surroundings are as surreal as they are struggle with this—look at the less loved later outings of Ron Burgundy, Derek Zoolander, and Austin Powers for proof of silly comedy’s strict adherence with the law of diminishing returns.

For Todd Philip’s blockbuster franchise The Hangover, meanwhile, the trouble runs even deeper, as the comedy comes from the larger-than-life Alan inhabiting a relatively realistic world wherein his antics are met with confusion and shock.

Whilst the first film was able to deploy Alan for huge laughs throughout its slender runtime, the sequel struggled to make it believable that the Wolf Pack would ever reunite with him for another crazy adventure. The third instalment in the franchise, however, saw the film’s writer derail the character himself, with Alan becoming a psychotically troubled figure who thinks nothing of accidentally decapitating a giraffe and causing a freeway pile up.

Bigger action rarely equates to bigger laughs when it comes to comedy, and the threequel failed Alan for much the same reason it failed to impress fans and critics—the absurdity was too incredulous and the stakes seemed non-existent as a result.


3. Cotton Weary - Scream 3

Scream 2 Cotton Weary Liev Schreiber
Dimension Films

A Nightmare on Elm Street helmer Wes Craven reinvigorated the flagging slasher subgenre in the mid-nineties with his clever, meta Scream series, the first horror flicks to discuss their own genre within the film itself (well, there’s always Rolfe Kanesky’s debut There’s Nothing Out There, but that’s a debate for another day). The films combined horror and self-referential comedy with verve and panache, and outside of offing poor Randy the second in the series was almost as well-loved as the first.

However cracks began to appear when screenwriter Kevin Williamson departed the third film in order to focus on other projects and Ehren Kruger was drafted in as a replacement—you know, Ehren Kruger of The Ring 2 fame?

As expected, the third film was a disaster, and this was never more obvious than in its woeful mistreatment of the Cotton Weary character.

A stoic, soft-spoken figure ably portrayed by Leiv Schreiber, Cotton goes from suspect to unlikely anti-hero in Scream 2. However, by the opening scene of the third instalment he’s an insufferable, philandering talk show host capitalising on his fame, a move which is clearly designed to make his demise less tragic but instead makes the character retroactively seem sleazy and means said death carries no emotional weight.


2. Dr Stephanie Woods - Lethal Weapon 3

Dr Stephanie Woods Lethal Weapon
Warner Bros.

There's less to say about Dr. Stephanie Woods, the resident psychiatrist/ mental health evaluation officer of Lethal Weapon’s precinct, than most of the characters on this list. That said, that’s part of what makes her an important and impressive figure—at first.

In the first film of the franchise we’re introduced to the unflappably cool, morally righteous, and suicidally depressed Martin Riggs. His fragile mental state is made clear via some tearful breakdowns and a few scenes he shares with Dr. Woods, a psychiatrist who doubts his suitability for active patrol. Woods is level-headed, professional, and her diagnosis of Riggs makes it clear that, as cool as he is, he’s a dangerous man with serious issues.

So far, so R-rated action movie appropriate.

However by the film’s second sequel, Riggs’ mental health is doing a lot better and our antihero is far more stable. Cause for celebration, right? Er…

The movie still needs to convince us he’s a loose cannon, but we see him sitting back enjoying family barbeques, meaning the formerly competent Dr. Woods must become an over-involved, wishy washy parody of the worst excesses of new age touchy-feely pseudo-psychiatry, doing both her earlier iterations and the franchise’s dark, gritty tone a disservice in the process.


1. Lou - Hot Tub Time Machine 2

Hot Tub Time Machine 2
Paramount Pictures

We could really pick any character from the original Hot Tub Time Machine for this entry, as Grosse Point Blank scribe Steve Pink’s 2010 hit featured a quartet with better chemistry than The Hangover trio and each of them was done a distinct disservice by this dire sequel released in 2015.

The most obvious candidate for inclusion is Adam, the world weary protagonist central to the first film’s proceedings who is jettisoned entirely in the sequel due to actor John Cusack’s famous (and in this instance very wise) “no sequels” stance.

However, the character most mishandled by this sequel is undoubtedly the first film’s stand out Lou.

Played in a break out turn by former Daily Show correspondent Robb Corddry, Lou is an insufferable lech who of course becomes the film’s most human and likeable figure through a painful and humiliating redemption arc—never has the phrase “he’s an ***hole, but he’s our ***hole” rang more true.

By the time the second film begins, however, any trace of character development has been surgically removed and Lou is as nasty, self-centred, and mean-spirited as ever before. However, without the calming influence of Cusack’s Adam and the dire circumstances which made his unlikeability tragic, there’s nowhere but downhill for the character to go, resulting in a flick which is best erased from canon by fans of the original instalment.


Watch Next


Contributor

Cathal Gunning hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.