10 Hit Horror Movies That DIDN'T Get Sequels
Stand alone scary movies that didn't spawn an entire franchise of sequels, prequels, and crossovers.
Traditionally, horror movies spawn more sequels than any other genre. Almost every classic has not just a sequel, but a franchise.
What often makes a horror film into a franchise is having an iconic baddie that makes the film brandable. Without Michael Myers there wouldn’t be eleven films in the Halloween franchise. Freddy Krueger led to six A Nightmare on Elm Street sequels, just as Jason Voorhies led to nine Friday the 13th sequels. That was before Freddy vs Jason and the subsequent reboots of both originals.
In the 70s and 80s, we got franchises borne out of The Exorcist, Alien, Jaws, The Omen, Texas Chainsaw Massacre, The Evil Dead. The 90s gave us Ghostface and the Scream franchise. The noughties gave us Jigsaw and the ongoing Saw franchise. Even, somehow, The Human Centipede managed second and third installments.
With that one in mind, it's astonishing that some of the most successful horrors ever didn't get a single second go, let alone a whole series of them...
10. The Cabin In The Woods (2012)
We begin with a film that did for cabin-in-the-woods style horrors what Scream did for slashers, and then some. Grossing $66.5 million from a $30 million budget and receiving huge critical acclaim, this irreverent parody of a horror sub-genre has enough scares and gags for mainstream moviegoers, whilst keeping the horror buffs satiated with its metafictive allusions to other horror movies and, further still, what horror movies are in our society.
After arriving in a cabin in the woods a group of teens are attacked by Evil Dead-esque ghouls, before it is revealed that beneath the cabin is an underground facility that houses an entire zoo of movie monsters. These monsters are used in other recognisable horror movie locales to sacrifice teenagers and appease the evil Gods “The Ancient Ones”, a.k.a. us the viewers.
It’s a clever and incredibly fun premise and it opens up a huge world of monsters and Gods and in terms of franchising, you could parody so many subgenres in a similar way - The Haunted Mansion, The Murderous Inbred Family, The Torture Porn Dungeon. But whether you could say anything more about the function of horror movies that isn’t already said by Joss Whedon in this original is doubtful. Even worse would be unleashing a slew of Epic Movie style sequels.
Whedon must have known this himself. To make sure there would be no sequel or franchising of the film, it ends with a gigantic monstrous hand destroying the entire world. Fair enough, Joss.
9. The Witch (2015)
The two most common time periods for horror films to be set in are 1) modern day, and 2) Gothic Victorian England. So The Witch being set in early 17th century New England is immediately interesting, and gives the simple story of a witch in the woods an eerie authenticity.
Robert Eggers’ debut is a wonderfully frightening tale of a possession and paranoia. Critical reception was very positive, and it even grossed over ten times its $4 million budget. The film ends just as our protagonist Thomasin (Anya Taylor Joy) joins a coven of witches, so it would make perfect sense for a sequel to pick up where this film finishes. Further installments could take place hundreds of years later, with the coven tormenting families throughout history.
But there’s a sense of dread that lingers after The Witch ends. WItchcraft feels real. Thomasin’s manic, cackling ascension above the trees is scarier not a glorious rebirth but a terrible death. With that in mind, maybe The Witch is best left with the final image of Thomasin rising into the night sky as its chilling end.
8. The Thing (1982)
John Carpenter's Lovecraftian cosmic horror is so sequel-worthy that the fact that it has no sequel barely seems possible. There is a follow-up, but it actually ended up being a prequel.
On an isolated research lab in the Antarctic, Kurt Russell and a group of other scientists are under siege from a shape-shifting alien that assimilates and imitates other organisms. What follows is an hour and a half of paranoia, mistrust, and outrageously gory body-horror special effects.
It's perfect franchise material because not only does the film end on a massive cliffhanger where even we viewers don't know who is human or Thing, but the shape-shifting nature of the alien means that it can look like anyone or any-Thing. It's a gift for filmmakers because it gives them license to tell any sort of story they like, and then fill it with whatever fantastically gruesome special effects they can imagine.
And just think of the scope that could be covered in a franchise. How many of these Things have already infiltrated our society? In sequels do we find out that the Things have covertly taken over the upper echelons of society like in They Live? Can we trust any Antarctic dogs??
Despite making a $4.6 million box office profit, initial critical response was negative, perhaps explaining its lack of sequel. Such a shame considering it is nowadays rightfully regarded as a horror classic.
7. Drag Me To Hell (2009)
Sam Raimi, creator of The Evil Dead, Evil Dead 2, and Army of Darkness, is no stranger to a horror franchise. When Drag Me to Hell made $90.8 million at the box office from a $30 million budget and was hailed as a modern horror classic by the critics, Rami and his producers must’ve been tempted to get a sequel penned pronto.
The whole point of a curse is that it continues to cause havoc until it is broken. And a good horror film curse should be tough to break, otherwise where’s the horror? In Drag Me to Hell, loan officer Christine Brown (Alison Lohman) suffers a gypsy’s curse after denying an elderly European woman a mortgage extension.
What follows is a series of typically-Rami grotesque and unfortunate events, culminating in Christine being literally dragged to hell by a hilarious pair of flaming hands. Not only has she failed to break the curse, but as the credits roll, we audience members know that she has unwittingly passed it on to her boyfriend by leaving him with her hexed button.
It’s a real surprise that the story of this cursed button was not followed up on. Raimi has the mainstream clout to bring in an audience, and the film’s campy tone keeps the appeal broader than that of contemporaneous torture porn films. Drag Me to Hell 2 could see Christine return from Hell to either torment or aid her cursed boyfriend.
Or maybe the spooky button finds its way onto the jumper of another unlucky loan officer (or another profession that Rami deems deserving of cursing to Hell!).
6. It Follows (2014)
Continuing with the theme of tough curses to crack, It Follows manifests its curse in truly terrifying fashion. The curse is a vague It. All It does is slowly Follow you. It can take the form of any person that could be nearby. When it catches up with you it kills you, then pursues the person who passed the curse on to them. And the curse is passed on by having sex.
It Follows made over ten times its $2 million budget and the critics loved it, but it doesn’t have a horror-movie posterboy like Freddy or Pinhead to stick on any franchise branding. The changeable nature of the threat means it could symbolise anything.
The most obvious reading may be that it is a parable for the dangers of unsafe sex. But there’s more going on in It Follows. When and where is it taking place? Why are there no adults apart from those that appear as a manifestation of the curse? Will It ever stop Following?
These questions could all be answered in It Follows 2 and beyond, but that doesn’t mean they should be. The film’s dreamlike ambiguity is what makes it so nightmarish. The curse is all the more terrifying for these unanswered questions. It Follows is an unexplainable, unstoppable evil.
Naturally, some discussion of a sequel HAS happened, but we're no closer yet.
5. Get Out (2017)
With a budget of just $4.5 million that went on to draw $255.5 million at the box office, Get Out is arguably the biggest horror hit of the decade. Not only was it a commercial success, but the critics heaped praise after parise upon Jordan Peele’s directorial debut.
Get Out has a very typical structure for a horror film. Our hero is brought to an isolated cabin (or family mansion) in the woods and must eventually survive its horrors and try to escape. But what makes it so different and appealing to a wider audience is, aside from its successful use of humour, is how brazenly it tackles the theme of racism.
Many horror films have used their ghoulies as metaphors for a bigger social commentary, be it mindless consumerism in Dawn of the Dead, or Godzilla destroying Tokyo with the force of a nuclear bomb. There is no such metaphor in Get Out: uur heroes and victims are black and all the white characters are racist and range from totally psychopathic, complicit in the madness, or just casually prejudiced in the case of an early traffic cop.
And this is why the film was such a breath of fresh air on its release and managed to find a huge audience. The film ends with our hero Chris (Daniel Kaluuya) escaping the burning family house, as his wounded girlfriend-turned-captor (Allison Williams) lays in her own blood watching him leave. With both our main hero surviving and our villain not quite dying, the door was certainly left open for Get Out 2.
But what about the many other rich white folk that arrive at the Armitage house for the auction? Unlike the family, the threat of these characters and their desire for black bodies as hosts is still alive and well in the world of Get Out. When the roots of such an insidious evil run so deep, how many sequels would it take for Chris to defeat the foe of white racism? The grim reality is too many to count.
4. Oculus (2013)
Sometimes a horror franchise doesn’t need to be built on a monster or masked killer, but something more innocuous. Making almost nine times its $5 million budget at the box office, Oculus is a clever chiller where a brother and sister try to figure out once and for all if an eerie mirror is responsible for the violent deaths of their parents.
Kaylie (Karen Gillan) is certain that a 17th century mirror is imbued with a supernatural evil which causes all of its owners to die in horrific fashion. Its structure follows two interweaving timelines, past and present, which gradually melt into one grisly climax.
The film ends with Tim (Brenton Thwaites) being arrested for the apparent murder of his sister, mirroring (get it?) his arrest as a child for the murder of his father. As Tim shouts protests of “It wasn’t me, it was the mirror!” whilst the evil spectres of his family look on, you can practically smell a sequel in the air. Surely the mirror won’t stop its bloodlust until it has claimed Tim and any other unlucky owners?
An Oculus 2 would surely involve Tim trying to finally destroy the mirror, be it from prison or the outside world. Maybe it’s only after more mirror-owning families have torn each other apart that someone seeks the help of an initially-reluctant Tim to break both the mirror and the cycle of death.
And of course, you’ve got the option of prequels. The mirror has had plenty of other unfortunate owners throughout its history if the producers fancy throwing some period costumes into the mix.
3. The Babadook (2014)
If the familial threat of Oculus wasn’t quite enough for you, then next up we have Australian indie smash The Babadook. After receiving a terrifying children’s book on her doorstep a single mother slowly descends into madness and tries to kill her young son.
The Babadook works so well as a piece of cinema because at its core it is a touching and painful story about a widowed mother and her child dealing with shared grief. But it could also work so well as a franchise because this emotional theme is manifested as an instantly recognisable boogeyman. Without sounding too cynical, The Babadook is a highly brandable character. The top hat. The coat. The claws. Even the name. One day we’ll be seeing as many fancy dress Babadooks at Halloween parties as Ghostfaces or Freddy Kruegers.
But here’s hoping The Babadook doesn’t get given sequels just for the sake of cashing in on the eponymous ghoul. Any continuation to the story needs to make sure that it is fuelled by the relationship between Amelia (Essie Davies) and her son Samuel (Noah Wiseman). Perhaps Amelia tries to overcome her grief and find a new partner? Maybe an older Samuel poses new challenges to this single mother?
The Babadook ends with Amelia literally taming her mania and learning to live with it. To a movie producer however, no beast can stay tamed forever. Especially when it made almost four times its $2 million budget at box office.
2. Let The Right One In (2004)
From the murky swamps of the bloodsucking Twilight franchise emerged this lo-fi Scandanvian masterpiece, which is arguably the best vampire film ever made.
Oskar (Kåre Hedebrant) is a bullied 12-year-old boy who meets Eli (Lina Leandersson) at the play area on his housing estate. Eli looks to be a similar age to Oskar but is in fact a much older vampire. They develop a friendship which becomes the beginnings of a pre-teen romance. All the while Eli drinks the blood of the locals and eventually dismembers and murders Oskar’s tormentors. The film ends with Oskar leaving his hometown on a train with Eli hidden in the trunk. Its an ending that suggests the pair will move on to a new town together and that their relationship will intensify.
In a sequel, there’s the option of turning Oskar into a fellow vamp, but more likely Oskar would become an older helper to Eli just like Håkan (Per Ragnar) was before his grisly end. You could even have the relatives of the butchered bullies try to track down Oskar for vengeance. And there’s always the question in vampire lore of where are the other vampires?
It’s tough to decide how welcome a sequel would be. The original grossed $11.2 million from a $4.5 million budget, leading to the American remake Let Me In which turned out to be a pleasant surprise. There is no doubt so much that could be done to further the story of Oskar and Eli, it’s just that something so beautiful needs to be handled with care.
1. The Sixth Sense (1999)
Topping the list is a film that had a huge impact on pop culture when it was released. Think of how often “I see dead people” has been parodied. Try and remember a time when people watched this film not knowing that Bruce Willis was a ghost all along. It made Hayley Joel Osment an overnight star and grossed an eye-watering $672.8 million at the box office.
And yet The Sixth Sense never became franchised. Producers could have used Cole Sear’s (Osment) ability to see and hear the dead to make any ghost film they wanted, safe in the knowledge that Osment and the quality of the original would draw.
But Hollywood showed more interest in writer/director M. Night Shyamalan than The Sixth Sense as a franchise, and it would be a succession of Shyamalan mystery/horror films such as Unbreakable, Signs, and The Village that appeared off the back of The Sixth Sense’s glory.
It’s probably too late to try and give The Sixth Sense a sequel now that Osment is all grown up, but it’s a film whose cultural impact will stand the test of time on its own.