10 Horrifyingly Underrated Stephen King Adaptations

Unloved and in need of a reappraisal.

Tommyknockers Stephen King
American Broadcasting Company

Check Reddit or an entertainment site for a top ten list of the best Stephen King adaptations ever and the chances are 2017's I.T. has floated to the top. Soon to be usurped by what is shaping up to be a chilling looking sequel. Before that, the usual suspects were The Shawshank Redemption and The Green Mile. All good movies, for sure, but where's all the pulpy goodness?

Stephen King is an author renowned for grimy, scary and gory horror novels. So the best takes on his works should follow the same aesthetic, right? This is where this list comes in.

We're here to celebrate the B-movie brilliance of King's lesser-loved adaptations, ones that got a critical mauling at the time and, in the case of many entries on this upcoming list, some that the author has washed his hands of completely.

These are the movies that take you back to the dimly-lit video sections at the back of your local Spar store, where box art with a ghoul on the cover was enough to make you part with a quid. They may not all be pretty, and some may boast unbelievable special effects (not in the good sense), but by golly these are the King movies that will take you in a ghost train-like journey that's well worth the price of admission.

10. Maximum Overdrive

Maximum Overdrive Stephen King
DEG

What The Critics Said:

The New York Times called this ‘one long car-crunch movie and, come Razzie nomination time, both King and Emilio Estevez received nominations in Worst Director and Actor categories, respectively.

Why It’s Worth A Watch:

King has since advised that he has no recollections of making Maximum Overdrive, so hectic was his cocaine habit at the time the shoot whizzed by in a blur and the finished result was a genre flick deemed a car crash by critics.

But where the plot may be lacking in horsepower – it’s very, very loosely based on Night Shift’s ‘Trucks’ – you’ve got a cracking cameo from King and his wife to kick off proceedings, a creepy ice cream van and lots of vehicle on vehicle smash-ups to break up the plot.

Credit where credit’s due, it’s a near miracle a single reel of film was shot for this movie so for every breakneck turn in plot or iffy performance try and forget the flaws and revel in the carnage.


9. The Mangler

The Mangler
New Line

What The Critics Said:

Variety had the knives out, deeming The Mangler to feature ‘many reels of pointless running around and milking of subplots’.

Why It’s Worth A Watch:

Forget that this is a movie based on a Stephen King short story for just a moment and process the fact this is a movie about a killer laundry press, starring Robert ‘Freddy Krueger’ Englund and directed by The Texas Chainsaw Massacre’s Tobe Hooper.

When announced for release back in 1995, this was a horror lover's dream ensemble and that was before they even knew there was a killer fridge lurking in the movie too.

Even though critics put this one through the wringer, the combination of bonkers premise – Englund and his band of devil worshippers must sacrifice virgins to the machine – good casting and a director adept at piecing together a scare piece or two have seen the film’s stock rise in the noughties. Worth a spin.


8. Firestarter

Stephen King Firestarter
Universal

What The Critics Said:

Roger Ebert doused this one’s flames in his review at the time stating that ‘the most astonishing thing in the movie, however, is how boring it is’.

Why It’s Worth A Watch:

While by no means one of King’s best early novels, Firestarter stood alone as a pretty thrilling girl versus government tale, with the odds tipped in said girl’s favour because she had the ability to go all X-Men on her foes.

Buoyed by a strong performance from Drew Barrymore in her invincible child actor phase (innocent and scarily powerful at the same time), even the most ardent of critics couldn’t argue that the relationship between Barrymore and her on-screen dad (played with affection by David Keith) gives the film a molten core, of sorts. Plus the pyro special effects on display still lend some suspense and wonder to the film’s scenes of action.


7. Needful Things

Needful Things Max Von Sydow
Columbia Pictures

What The Critics Said:

Roger Ebert wasn’t buying Needful Things, saying ‘it’s not funny and it's not scary and it's all sort of depressing" in his 1991 review.

Why It’s Worth A Watch:

King’s slow-burning nineties doorstop novel begins innocently enough – the devil in disguise opens up a cursed artefact store in Castle Rock, slowly infecting the residents with his must-own items – and ends in one of the author’s maddest of finales, where events go all Gangs Of New York on us constant readers.

The film is largely faithful to what was at the time a well-received novel and there’s no denying that Max Von Sydow was something of a casting coup as shady proprietor Leland Gaunt. Chuck an awards-worthy supporting turn from Amanda Plummer into the deal and this stands as a solid adaptation. Better still though, the finale is suitably crazy and that alone is worth a watch.


6. The Langoliers

The Langoliers
ABC

What The Critics Said:

After the show first aired Entertainment Weekly described the miniseries as being ‘an episode of The Twilight Zone stretched out to four hours’. Not exactly high praise.

Why It’s Worth A Watch:

The strongest entry in his Four Past Midnight novella collection got the miniseries treatment back at the tail end of the nineties in what is largely an atmospheric, strongly-acted affair.

The premise is pure King – sleeping passengers on a plane wake up as the lone survivors realising the rest of their awake journey-mates have disappeared – and Fright Night helmer Tom Holland does an expert job of building up the tension as these bewildered travellers touch ground in a deserted airport, discovering something horrifying is afoot.

This culminates in one of the most ‘eh?’ finales King has ever imagined (CG meatballs!) but somehow it all works. Props should also go to towering thesp David Morse, who anchors this series.


5. Silver Bullet

Silver Bullet Werewolf
Paramount Pictures

What The Critics Said:

The Chicago Tribune’s Rick Kogan thought this was an absolute howler, describing the film as a ‘limp retelling of the werewolf legend that is about as frightening as a rubbery Richard Nixon Mask.' Woof.

Why It’s Worth A Watch:

Ripped from one of King’s lesser-known novellas (The Cycle Of The Werewolf) Silver Bullet is a Corey Haim vehicle with far more bite than you’d expect.

Sure, the werewolf looked a bit ropey at the time and can now just about get away with looking kitsch to a contemporary audience, but it’s the slow build up and eighties nostalgia beats that make this a perfect Halloween movie, where we watch events unfold from the perspective of Haim’s bike- riding tween as the inhabitants of Tankers Mill start getting picked-off in pretty grim ways.

Look out for a mostly ad-libbed, bonkers but brilliant turn from Gary Busey, too. Rick was wrong.


4. Pet Sematary Two

pet sematary 2
Paramount

What The Critics Said:

Writing for the LA Times, Kevin Thomas put this sequel to sleep by dubbing it to be ‘not nearly as scary as the 1989 original’. The box office wasn’t much kinder, with the film scraping in $17 million compared to the monster $57 million haul of its predecessor.

Why It’s Worth A Watch:

This one deserves to threaten the upper tier of this list as critics - unfairly - treated it like a neglected mutt when it was released in 1992.

Not only does it build on the lore (slightly) of the original, you've got Edward Furlong brooding in the lead role, a killer husky, director Mary Lambert hurling crazed slow motion action scenes at us and enough skinned bunnies and diced kittens to put you off your kibbles.

Ballistic, occasionally brilliant and backed by what you could only assume was a deliberately disjointed soundtrack, this sequel deserves some attention.


3. Cujo

Cujo dog
Warner Bros.

What The Critics Said:

‘This screen adaptation of Stephen King’s Cujo emerges as a dull, uneventful entry in the horror genre’. Not our words, these are the words of Variety magazine.

Why It’s Worth A Watch:

Any book about a rabid St Bernard rampaging around on a sweltering summer’s day was never going to be dull, so by that logic a film based on this premise couldn’t be bad, right? Right, because Cujo is one of those rare beasts, a film set solely in the day time but still brimming with menace and suspense.

Any illusions that the film will be a by the numbers, dog picks off residents of a sleepy town one by one are soon shattered when film turns on its snout, as mum Donna (Dee Wallace earning her scream queen credentials in this role) and her son are trapped in a car, overheating and being circled by the deranged pooch. It’s here the film bounds towards its climax, albeit a more family-friendly one than the book.


2. The Tommyknockers

The Tommyknockers
ABC

What The Critics Said:

Veteran Variety (them again) critic Tony Scott didn’t get on board with this miniseries, deeming the writing to be ‘pedestrian’ and ‘the characters obvious’ in his 1993 review.

Why It’s Worth A Watch:

The Tommyknockers remains King’s strongest foray into sci-fi, melding the best of the genre with an involving plot (a buried alien vessel in the woods sees the inhabitants of Haven, Maine go a bit Invasion Of The Bodysnatchers) and a very personal subtext, with the film being an interpretation of his withdrawal from drugs.

The miniseries sticks close to the source material, with events unravelling at a gentile pace, relying on a sequence of shocking moments to heighten the paranoia spreading through the town.

The series soars thanks to a driven, almost possessed performance from Marg Helgenberger and the ever-reliable Jimmy Smits. The eponymous space baddies still scrub up pretty well, too, and we challenge you not to feel some emotion at that finale.


1. Children Of The Corn

children of the corn
New World Pictures

What The Critics Said:

In a one star review, Roger Ebert hacked the movie apart, concluding his piece by saying ‘the only thing moving behind the rows is the audience, fleeing to the exits.' Ouch.

Why It’s Worth A Watch:

Starting life as a slow-growing kernel in Penthouse magazine before sprouting into readers’ affections as one of the best entries in King's Night Shift collection, Children Of The Corn was always begging to make the cut on the big screen.

Despite taking a couple of mostly welcome deviations from the source material – kudos to the creation of narrative-driving kid protagonists Job and Sarah, a big boo to a tamer finale – the film is a taut examination of a couple’s strained relationship, as they are thrust into the isolation of ghost town Gatlin, Nebraska, pitted against a group of youngsters fresh from raiding their dead daddies’ toolsheds.

Headed up by John Franklin’s sneering little cult leader Isaac, it’s the kids that make the film so unnerving with director Fritz Kiersch dialling up the tension until their reveal sees events hurtle towards the cornfields at a scary pace. Unfairly disregarded by outlander critics of the time, the film has a deserved cult following.

Got any unloved King adaptations to include? Feel that Hearts In Atlantis has been mugged off slightly? Comment below.


In this post: 
Stephen-King
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Shaun is a former contributor for a number of Future Publishing titles and more recently worked as a staffer at Imagine Publishing. He can now be found banking in the daytime and writing a variety of articles for What Culture, namely around his favourite topics of film, retro gaming, music, TV and, when he's feeling clever, literature.