10 Intrusions From The Cthulhu Mythos Into Cinema

Mouth Of MadnessThough he is described by many as the father of modern horror fiction, H.P. Lovecraft is still a figure who is somewhat absent from horror in the cinematic mainstream. That said, this obscurity could be something of a blessing, particularly as modern horror seems to be stuck in a rut of ultimately uninspired rehashing of the Amityville and Exorcist tropes with a brief respite in some tawdry attempt to imitate Rob Zombie's innovative re-imagining of Halloween. True horror aficionados had something to get genuinely excited about when it was announced that Guillermo del Toro would be adapting At The Mountains of Madness for the big screen. Sadly this project fell through and we are left with only a few preliminary sketches, a screenplay and our own twisted imaginations with which we might attempt to imagine what this film may have been like. Scratch below the surface, root around the digital equivalent of the budget aisles and bargain bins however and you will find a plethora of movies that are either somewhat direct translations of Lovecraft's works to the silver screen or influenced both directly or indirectly by Providence's most distinguished gentleman. What is presented to you here is just a brief selection, a springboard if you will. This by no means a charting from best to worst, nor have I included every film initially considered for this list. You see, half the fun of Lovecraftian cinema is watching a film feeling that dawning sense of the weird, then discovering, like some doomed Lovecraftian protagonist, it's connection to the mythos at large. Therefore this list is by no means comprehensive and because it is an appetizer of sorts in may include films that aren't immediately obvious as Lovecraftian. These will serve therefore as an initiation of sorts to those new to the master, not least the film that deserves this lists honorary mention...

Honorary Mention - Lovecraft Fear of the Unknown

Fear Poster 21 Lovecraft's work is still ultimately best enjoyed in it's original prose form and his life is almost as weird as his fiction. This documentary combines a discussion and exploration of both and is by no means a dry affair. Directors who have adapted his works, writers who have been influenced by him and even Lovecraftian scholars all passionately contribute to this film. Interview segments mix with biographical photography and artistic works to paint a comprehensive picture that will hopefully enable any new viewer to begin your own exploration into the Cthulhu mythos in all it's various mediums. Nor does that exclude those familiar with the man and his masterpieces being rich enough to yield warm infinite returns and curious introductions to the work of others.

10. Cast A Deadly Spell

Cast A Deadly Spell In a certain sense Lovecraft's works are invested with an element of biography and many of his protagonists are thinly veiled masks of their creator. This has lead many to speculate whether certain other elements of his works are entirely fictitious as well. With that sense of blurring between fact and fiction in mind we come to the first of this lists movies to actually feature a fictionalised version of Lovecraft himself as a protagonist. Beyond this and the inclusion of various mythos elements the links are somewhat tenuous. The beauty of this movie however lies in their use and the movies overall execution. The movie's narrative is essentially detective mystery in the noir style, the Lovecraftian twist beyond it's protagonist's name is the setting. Echoing the author's staunch atheism the character is alone in his rejection of magic in a world filled with the magical and supernatural. Cast a Deadly Spell is also the first film in our list to feature horror stalwart; David Warner. Warner appears alongside Clancy Brown, Fred Ward and a young Julianne Moore in a film that, like Lovecraft, has a dedicated cult following but is deserving of so much more.

9. Necronomicon

Necronomicon Our next film not only features David Warner once more but also features H.P. Lovecraft himself as a protagonist again, played by another horror icon and Lovecraft regular; Jeffrey Combs. Named after that infamous grimoire, this movie weaves three loose adaptations of Lovecraftian tales around a speculative tale about the true nature of Lovecraft's inspiration. For the newcomer these adaptations €“though loose €“ distil essential notions and themes not only from their respective tales but also from the Mythos as a whole, hopefully planting the seed of further interest. For those familiar with the Mythos, they provide entertaining and jaunty romps through seemingly familiar territory but with enough deviation from the original texts as to delight and entertain. No one tale is greater than the other, and each director infuses their own essence of the macabre allowing the shorts and the wraparound to stand in their own right.

8. In The Mouth Of Madness

Mouth Of Madness Staying with the theme of horror authors and unearthly inspiration we arrive at our first entry from the works of John Carpenter. In The Mouth of Madness is in fact the final movie in his apocalypse trilogy and, of the three, possibly the most profoundly disturbing. Though perhaps not outwardly Lovecraftian; In The Mouth of Madness absolute drips with the slime of a thousand unearthly tentacles. The initial premise is a classic Lovecraftian trope. Mundane investigator begins a case which; through progressively transgressive events and distortions of time and space warps his very mind and the actual fabric of reality itself. Carpenter cleverly interweaves these notions with tropes of other genres of horror creating an actual psychological effect in the audience far more profound and ultimately more sinister than the Wachowski brothers could ever philosophically posit, particularly in the first time viewer. Like many movies in this list experienced audiences will yield a sense of knowing humour that reinforces the mythos world-view.

7. Mystery Of The Necronomicon

Mystery Of The Necronomicon Some might argue that a piece of Hentai has no place in this list. However one could easily counter argue that the very ambience and action of a lot of Hentai approaches a state similar to that we can expect when Lovecraft's eponymous Old One's return.
"The time would be easy to know, for then mankind will have become as the Great Old Ones; free and wild and beyond good and evil, with laws and morals thrown aside and all men shouting and killing and revelling in joy."
In addition to the transgressive sexual and physical acts this hypothetical proposition evokes; Mystery of the Necronomicon does actually frame itself around a particularly Lovecraftian tale of investigation, mayhem, magic and forbidden tomes. One really cannot expect less from the creative team behind the original Urotsukidoji: Legend of the Overfiend.

6. From Beyond

From Beyond Continuing our kinky theme we have Stuart Gordon's adaptation of the shorty story of the same name. This film also marks the return of Jeffrey Combs, along side Gordon and Yuzna, into our list, but, it is by no means his, and their, last appearance. The original tale though one of Lovecraft's shortest may well actually represent the very quintessence of the Mythos. Demonstrating Lovecraft's uncanny knowledge of that murky area between magic and the sciences, From Beyond posited a machine that stimulates an individual's pineal gland, opening up to them wondrous and horrifying new vistas of reality. The movie adaptation, extending the narrative; by adding in characters and events, manages to distil this essence almost perfectly. This movie also stands out as an outstanding example of pre CGI ingenuity in special effects. Subdued Lovecraftian meditations on the narrow perception of reality and dreaming play out along side giant monster effects and a certain slick Eighties sleaze. Finally in true Lovecraftian fashion the ending provokes horror in the uninitiated but amusement in the seasoned viewer.

5. The Dunwich Horror

The Dunwich Horror I've chosen the 1970 version over the more recent TV movie simply because of it's infinite superiority. Whereas both deviate in places from the original narrative the earlier version has a soft subtlety over the later version's wild and overgenerous attempts to weave in a wider Mythos narrative. Sandra Dee stars alongside an incredibly serious Ed Begley and a somewhat devilish Dean Stockwell. Her character; Nancy Wagner, and subsequent casting possibly an attempt to widen the movie's potential audience. Nancy, by serving as the audience's main companion to Wilbur Whateley rather than the unattached factual narrative of the original short tale, generates a certain sympathy with the character. The story flirts with potentially romantic notions in direct contrast to Wilbur's increasingly odd behaviour. The dream sequence is a particular favourite of mine, perhaps meant to invoke the horror of a world in the thrall of the Old Ones, it instead plays out like a psychedelic daydream. The attempt to bring Wilbur's twin, though a somewhat humorous effect now, is a sterling effort from the days before computer generated imagery.

4. Call Of Cthulhu

Call Of Cthulu Until now most of these films have been adaptations or loose translations for the big screen. Call of Cthulhu differs in that it is almost a direct translation of the story to the screen. There are some changes but only if you really look for them. The other quality that makes this film stand out from many others, is the manner in which it was produced. The HP Lovecraft Historical Society chose to make this film as though it were an artefact of the 1920's; when the original story itself was published. Rather than being detrimental this adds to the movie's merit, particularly the nostalgic whimsy of certain prop pieces and special effects, also, the way in which mood is dictated almost exclusively by music. Normally fan movies are painfully self indulgent affairs, however the HPLHS treat their subject with the right amount of creative passion and reverence so as not to spoil their own work.

3. Re-Animator

Re Animator Many attempts to bring Lovecraft to the big screen transpose his stories to the modern era, sometimes to their own detriment. With Jeffrey Combs, Brian Yuzna and Stuart Gordon's third entry, and Barbara Crampton's second entry, in our list this is not the case. There is a strange irony at play when the story that Lovecraft himself, and scholars of his work, consider to be his worst actually forms the basis of one of the best and most favoured of Lovecraft movies. The film also retains a certain sense of macabre humour, which is interesting considering the original prose work was serialised in a humour magazine. Combs' utterly serious Herbert West is a source of much of the humour, with the deadpan delivery of lines such as "I gave him life," which adds a certain relish to this film's obviously morbid proceedings.

2. John Carpenter's The Thing

the thing Sadly without Del Toro's At The Mountains Of Madness the closest we will ever get to a cinematic treatment of that story is the first movie in Carpenter's Apocalypse Trilogy. Though not directly a Lovecraft story and in fact a remake of an entirely separate tale; The Thing actually plays out very like the first few chapters of At The Mountains of Madness. Whereas Lovecraft's tale comes to deal with a formless creature; the Shoggoth, Carpenter takes that amorphousness one step further making it a shape shifter with a gift for mimicry. Once again this film is a testament to the pre CGI days of special effects, and if the recent prequel serves to prove anything it is this; when it comes to a movie like The Thing CGI really doesn't cut the mustard compared to prosthetics and animatronics when portraying the disturbingly horrific and utterly alien.

1. The Whisperer In Darkness

The Whisperer In Darkness Though this list is in no way a charting from worst to best, each film selected being as good as the others, the second effort by the HPLHS is definitely one of the best adaptations of a Lovecraft tale for the cinematic medium. Again created €“ or shot €“ in Mythoscope so as to appear as an artefact from a by gone era, The Whisperer in Darkness perfectly evokes the sensibilities of the dawning horror and sci-fi creature features of the 1930's. Adhering to the original tale's plot structure almost completely, this adaptation is a testament to the ingenuity of the creative team. Lovecraft's tale actually ends in the second act which as a movie would be disastrous, however a third act is created which plays out most satisfactorily finishing on a twist worthy of the master himself.

Contributor
Contributor

David is grateful not only for the opportunity WhatCulture! has given him but also for the tens of thousands of views that you have given him. Particularly, when he still considers his efforts as somewhat clumsy and amateurish. Like H.P. Lovecraft, David will probably never be happy with his own work. Still this doesn't stop him studying E-Prime, Game Theory, Tantra, Magic, Media Analysis & Criticism along with many other things outside of his top secret day to day job and writing for WhatCulture! All of this in a no doubt conceited effort to improve not only his writing but also himself as a person.