10 Most Insufferable Film Sequels Since 2000
"There was too much story for just one movie!"
From Captain
America: The Winter Soldier to Mad Max: Fury Road, there have been some
terrific sequels these last few years, but if you tried counting them on both
hands, you’d still have five fingers too many.
The law of diminishing returns holds true for most franchises, although these days there seems to be an added caveat: not only will one of the sequels disappoint you, it will steal your time and money, insult your intelligence and pummel you with an over the top visual style for two and a half hours. But enough about Batman Vs Superman.
You don’t watch a sequel expecting to see compelling characters, quotable dialogue and white-knuckle action scenes. You watch because the first movie had all of those things, and you’re curious to see how badly they’ve been mangled this time round. Sometimes the filmmakers acquit themselves well, but other times they give you Thor: The Dark World.
Studios come up with all kinds of nonsense to justify making sequels. They had to make it because the audience demanded to know what happened to the characters. They had to make another one because there was so much more of the story to tell, so much rich wonderful story. That’s why there are three Matrix movies instead of just one.
Some franchises improve as they go along, but most wither and die. Here are 10 that withered.
10. The Human Centipede 2 (Full Sequence)
Whatever points director Tom Six wanted to make in The Human Centipede: First Sequence were delivered with brute force, but this sequel has a different agenda. In order to mock the first film’s critics, Six resorts to puerile shock tactics that quickly become tiresome.
According to the BBFC, who initially banned the film, Full Sequence is about a character who is aroused by “the total degradation, humiliation, mutilation, torture and murder of his naked victims.” After using sandpaper to masturbate over a DVD of The Human Centipede, Martin (Laurence Harvey) kidnaps 12 people (none of whom are portrayed sympathetically) in order to make his own “centipede.” As he smashes their teeth and severs their tendons, you could be forgiven for thinking you’re watching some squalid grindhouse movie meant for 42nd Street in the 1970s.
But no – the movie was made to degrade and humiliate a modern crowd, and only serves to prove that our few remaining taboos aren’t worth breaking. Six’s checklist of perversions brings to mind what Kim Newman said about John Waters – he’s really an adolescent boy seeing how far he can go before he’s sent to his room.
9. Spider-Man 3
It’s said that Sam Raimi departed this franchise in a disagreement over the script for Spider-Man 4, but we know better. He walked because the wheels had come off the wagon and everyone except the studio knew it.
Spider-Man 2 left you wondering what would happen to the characters, but this sequel reduces them to pieces on a chessboard. There’s some phoney drama (Peter’s relationship with Mary Jane hits the rocks), a truly bizarre subplot about an alien fungus that turns Peter into a dead ringer for one of South Park’s emo kids and a blah villain in the form of Topher Grace’s Venom, who’s really one villain too many in an overstuffed – yet oddly boring – film.
Also, any movie that uses amnesia as a plot device is really in dire straits creatively. What next – a synthetic reboot that tells the origin story all over again? Oh right. Sorry.
8. The Hangover Part II
When The Hangover made $467 million on a $35 million budget, it became the highest-grossing R-rated comedy of all time. Warner Bros immediately ordered more of the same, and that’s exactly what the filmmakers delivered.
It seems strange that after waking up from a stag party to discover that they’ve lost their friend somewhere in Las Vegas, the same people could wake up from another stag party to discover that they’ve lost another friend somewhere in Thailand, but that’s how it goes sometimes. We would’ve made allowances if this sequel had been as funny and inventive as the first one, but instead it’s repetitive and clunky.
Mike Tyson and Ken Jeong return, and the filmmakers wring as many laughs as possible out of a monkey carrying a severed finger, but it’s too bad that the cast and crew balked at a proposed cameo by Mel Gibson. His alcohol fuelled rants are hilarious.
7. A Good Day To Die Hard
Way to go, Twentieth Century Fox: you took The Greatest Action Movie and gave it a ginger-haired stepchild for its 25th anniversary. Most people would’ve bought a gold watch.
Someone must’ve thought that teaming the director of the Omen remake with the screenwriter of The A-Team would yield great things, but the action is by the numbers, the zingers are forced and even Bruce Willis seems strangely subdued, as if his appearance was due more to a contractual obligation rather than a desire to return to the franchise.
If you remember the Die Hard sequels for anything other than large scale action sequences, it’s probably for McClane’s verbal sparring with the villains, most notably Hans Gruber in the original. A Good Day To Die Hard has none of these things. What it has in abundance is a whole lot of blah: a blah villain, blah dialogue and a blah chase sequence. To make matters worse, Jai Courtenay is in it.
6. Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines
The first Terminator movie without James Cameron, Rise Of The Machines began the trend for frankly rubbish sequels that disappointed audiences and failed to add anything worthwhile to the franchise. Critics can debate whether it’s the worst sequel, but it deserves credit for being the most imitative.
Until near the end, the movie is nothing more than a slavish imitation of T2, which it matches beat for beat. The terminators arrive, they acquire clothes and set off in pursuit of John Connor. Instead of a huge chase through a Los Angeles storm drain, there’s a huge chase through the city’s streets. Instead of going to Cyberdyne to kill Miles Dyson, the characters track down Lieutenant General Brewster, Skynet’s primary creator.
Described by the San Francisco Chronicle as “flat”, Rise Of The Machines is so underwhelming that it persuaded the makers of Terminator Salvation to ditch the formula (and the humour) in favour of a grim, gritty war movie. So if you hate that movie – and if you hate Salvation, you must really hate Genisys – don’t forget that this is where the rot first set in.
5. Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull
From the script to the casting, there’s just something about this sequel that causes it to miss the mark on every level. It was a bad sign when Sean Connery refused to reprise his role as Henry Jones Snr, but even less reassuring was the casting of Shia LaBeouf. Then there were the aliens.
While it was perfectly fine for The X-Files Movie to climax with a flying saucer breaking free and hurtling into space, it wasn’t something you expected to see in a franchise whose previous instalments rekindled the spirit of Saturday matinee serials. It felt like Lucas and Spielberg had turned into characters from Jurassic Park, pulling it off not because they should but because they could.
Throw in an overblown action sequence where Indy survives an atomic blast by jumping into a lead-lined fridge, and you’ve got a film so desperate to take your money that it will literally resort to anything. The scene even gave rise to the term “nuking the fridge”, which Time Magazine defined as “to exhaust a Hollywood franchise with disappointing sequels.”
4. Halloween II
Whatever your opinion of Rob Zombie’s Halloween, the first 40 minutes were just that – Halloween filtered through the mind of the man who made House Of 1000 Corpses. What happened next was unthinkable - he made the same movie, only without any thrills or sympathetic characters.
The only expectation for this sequel was that it’d be like the 1981 sequel and take place in a dimly-lit hospital full of idiot victims. For 20 minutes, Zombie goes that route, then he says it was all a dream which frankly is a cheat.
It seems that Michael Myers got up and walked away after being shot point blank in the last movie, and he’s spent 2 years talking to his mother’s ghost in a barn. That’s enough to drive anyone crazy, so when Halloween rolls around he stalks another bunch of stereotypes that have “dead meat” written on their foreheads. Then he kills them. Needless to say, originality is not on the menu here.
3. X-Men: The Last Stand
No matter how outrageous Magneto’s schemes became in Bryan Singer’s movies (and what’s more outrageous than attempting to transform world leaders into mutants?), his motives are grounded in his disgust at animalistic, hypocritical human beings. Throw in some talk about the persecution of outsiders, in a movie directed by an openly gay filmmaker, and you have a pulp fiction raised to its highest level.
Without it, you’ve got an old man in a dorky-looking helmet, which pretty much sums up what X-Men: The Last Stand did to the franchise.
Trashing all the good work done in the previous films in favour of special effects and overheated drama, The Last Stand has no reason to exist, so the subsequent movies just pretend it doesn’t. Even Vinnie Jones registered his displeasure at the movie, claiming the original script was junked before filming began.
If that’s true, it explains the narrative’s slung-together feel. A movie where so many important characters bite the dust (or do they?) should have more impact, but this is just a long, limp farce from beginning to end. Then again, what were you expecting from the director of Rush Hour and Red Dragon?
2. Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen
Even for a movie made in conjunction with a toy manufacturer, Revenge Of The Fallen is outstanding in its attempt to cater to an audience of remarkably low intelligence, and it’s terrifying to try to envision what kind of crowd Michael Bay and his focus group must’ve had in mind. Did they look at pictures of Cletus The Slack Jawed Yokel and say, “Like that, only dumber”?
Aimed at people who’d lose a game of Tic-Tac-Toe to a chicken, this sequel is all razzle-dazzle and loud bangs, and when things aren’t blowing up, viewer interest is maintained by a constant stream of “hilarious” jokes. For a PG-13 movie, some are quite risqué, but mostly they’re just perplexing: dogs start humping on the living room couch, Sam’s mom gets high and goes crazy, a Decepticon rubs itself up against Megan Fox’s leg etc etc.
Special mention must be made of Skids and Mudflap, a pair of “comic relief” Autobots that perform what could loosely be termed “urban humour.” Speaking in voices somewhere between Pam Grier and Jar Jar Binks, these clods exist to deliver such unforgettable dialogue as “Boogy boogy boogy boo” and remind us that Hollywood still loves dialect humour.
1. Book Of Shadows: Blair Witch 2
In order to research a book called Blair Witch: Hysteria Or History, 2 aspiring scribes take the inaugural Blair Witch Hunt accompanied by a Goth in a bad make-up job and a gratuitous nudity-loving Wiccan. They go into the woods to tell Heather Donahue jokes and mock the first movie, which turns out to be a really bad idea. Before long, they’re seeing ghosts and having weird dreams/ hallucinations that cause them to act in ways that make Donahue’s Razzie-winning performance look subtle.
There was absolutely no need to make a sequel to The Blair Witch Project, never mind this rushed, barely coherent fiasco. That said, the movie does have some unintentional laughs. For reasons hard to determine, one of the characters undergoes a breakdown that consists of her waving her arms, raising her voice and walking backwards very quickly. She also starts talking backwards, which prompts a shocked colleague to observe, “She’s lost her f*****g mind!”
Apparently they’ve brought something back from the woods, possibly a spirit that causes bad acting and narrative incoherence as well as blackouts, during which everybody commits a murder they don’t remember. Just like the protagonist in L Ron Hubbard’s novel Fear, in fact. But that’s probably a coincidence.