10 Movies That Were Almost Completely Unrecognisable

They should have gone with the wooden planet.

The road from script to screen is often a tortured one. There will be numerous rewrites, actor changes, problems with the budget or location and a million other issues. Making any movie, even a terrible one, is punishing work. So it€™s no wonder that movies can morph into something almost unrecognisable from their original concept. A script written as a serious drama can turn into a wacky comedy, or an action vehicle written for Tom Cruise can be retooled for Angelina Jolie instead (check out Salt for more information). Case in point: Edgar Wright had been planning Ant-Man for a decade, getting as far as pre-production and casting before €œcreative differences€ with Marvel boiled up. His script was hastily rewritten and a new director brought on-board, and it seems little if any of Wright€™s input will remain. Likewise The Hobbit was originally planned as two movies with Guillermo del Toro helming. He worked for over a year storyboarding and designing sets and creatures, before he eventually left over delays. Peter Jackson came back, and managed to turn a small children€™s book in a series of films with a combined running time of four months. This list will look at some other famous examples of movies that started life as one thing before blossoming - for better or worse - into something else. Most of them probably would have been better off sticking to the original idea.


10. Jurassic Park 3 Was Once A Teen Slasher With Dinosaurs

The plot of the upcoming Jurassic World is such an obvious idea for a sequel it€™s amazing it took so long for the filmmakers to think of it. At one point during development they got so desperate a script was written that featured a SWAT team of human/dinosaur hybrids. Somebody got paid to write that. And taking a step back, Jurassic Park 3 had just as much trouble coming up with a story hook. One plot had a group of teens stranded on Isla Sorna, before a script about Alan Grant investigating pteranodons attacking people on the mainland was settled on. He and some new characters end up crash landing on the island and running into more dino trouble. Sets for this version were built before director Joe Johnston scrapped it. With five weeks to go before filming a feeble rescue plot was stitched together, which explains why Jurassic Park 3 feels like set-pieces in search of a point. And if the showdown with the Spinosaurus is a tad anti-climatic, that€™s because it was supposed to reappear at the end. It would attack the rescuing marines before two T-Rex€™s came along and killed it. This moment would reveal the T-Rex killed earlier was the baby T-Rex from The Lost World. This ending was cut for budget reasons.

9. Smokey IS The Bandit Morphed Into Smokey And The Bandit Part 3

The third instalment in the Smokey And The Bandit series had to come up with something special to overcome Burt Reynolds and Sally Fields declining to return. Jackie Gleason came back as Smokey (aka Sheriff Justice), and the plan was for Gleason to play dual roles. The film was shot under the title Smokey IS The Bandit with Gleason playing Sheriff Justice chasing a new Bandit, who was also played by Gleason. A teaser trailer was released with Gleason hinting at this story, in addition to containing the original title. There is also a publicly picture of Gleason dressed up as the Bandit. But test audiences found the dual role idea horribly confusing, and in a panic the studio reshot scenes with Jerry Reed (Reynolds sidekick in the other movies) as the new Bandit instead. They also snagged Burt for a tiny cameo at the end. These changes did little to help, as bad reviews and poor box office awaited it upon release.

8. Terminator: Salvation Ditched A Super Dark Ending

Terminator: Salvation should have been a triumphant return for The Terminator franchise. The flashy McG was not a popular choice as director, but he convinced people of his passion for the series and managed to snag Christian Bale for John Connor. The signs were good. The original story had death row inmate Marcus awaken post Judgment Day. He meets a young Kyle Reese and they attempt to find John Connor together. Along the way they discover Skynet is actually trying to save mankind before it goes extinct (hence the title Salvation). They built a society of human/machine hybrids, with Marcus already being one. Then Connor finally shows up at the end to destroy this place...and is killed. The resistance decide to preserve his legacy and graft his face onto Marcus to make people think he€™s still alive. They do, and then Marcus turns evil and kills Kyle and the rest of the resistance. End of movie. This script was heavily rewritten when Bale came on with Connor€™s role greatly beefed up, even though he does little of importance. The Skynet saving humanity idea was removed, though a subplot featuring human/machine hybrids was shot but cut out. The original pitch black ending was going to be filmed before it leaked and the internet exploded. It was altered to the rubbish €œHere, have my heart€ climax in the finished product. The planned Salvation trilogy didn€™t happen, and Bale said he€™d never work with McG again. Which was probably entirely reciprocated.

7. Robin Hood Used To Be CSI: Nottingham

Ridley Scott and Russell Crowe reteamed for the tepid Robin Hood, a gritty new take on the legend. This version began development as a script called Nottingham, where the Sheriff of Nottingham was investigating murders apparently committed by Robin Hood. It turns out Robin has been framed, and the film would climax with an epic battle scene. In addition to making the Sheriff the protagonist he would also have been involved in a love triangle with Lady Marion and Robin, and he investigated the crimes using historically accurate Twelfth Century crime scene techniques. Despite signing on for Nottingham Scott didn€™t actually like the script that much. He instead developed a new story where the Sheriff and Robin Hood are the same person, with Robin seeing the real Sheriff die early on and taking on his identity. Shortly before filming Scott fell out of love with that concept and eventually settled on doing a traditional take on the character. The film did decent box office but planned sequels were scrapped.

6. The Island Of Dr. Moreau Cut Out Human / Mutant Sex

This 1996 version of the famous book originated as a low budget horror by director Richard Stanley, and would have been a twisted affair featuring people having sex with animal hybrids. This changed when Marlon Brando was cast and it became a much bigger movie. Stanley€™s script was subsequently rewritten to remove the dark elements and make it a glossy thriller. Then Val Kilmer was cast as the hero, only to demand his role be cut by 40% because he didn€™t want to work that much. Kilmer was also a temperamental jerk on set, throwing tantrums constantly. Then Brando showed up painted white and wearing an ice bucket on his head, just because. With tensions running high Stanley was fired after a few days, as the studio felt he couldn€™t control the mess. He later disguised himself as a creature extra to spy on filming. John Frankenheimer took over and ordered more rewrites, and was generally hated by everyone. A lead actor quit and was replaced. The lead actress tried to flee, only to be caught at the airport and dragged back. The final film was a bizarre mess and a huge flop, and is best remembered for inspiring the character of Mini-Me from the Austin Powers series.

5. Jaws 2 Was A Violent, Depressing Thriller

A sequel to Jaws stood no chance of being as good, but Jaws 2 gave it a decent try. Spielberg and Richard Dreyfuss, having experienced the shoot from hell on Jaws, wanted no part. A few ideas were thrown around, including a prequel based on Quint€™s chilling USS Indianapolis speech. But eventually the shoot began under director John D. Hancock, who also wrote the screenplay. This version was set four years after Jaws, with Amity economically destroyed after the shark attacks. The tourists stopped coming (understandably), and businesses and houses are boarded up. Then the mayor makes a deal with a developer (and the mob) to build a casino to revitalise the Island. Just when things start looking up, another shark arrives. Hancock€™s take would have been darker and more violent than the final version, but conflicts with executives saw he didn€™t last long. The studio head wanted a bigger role for his wife, who played Chief Brody€™s other half but Hancock refused. He also fired an actress from a small role, who turned out to an executive€™s girlfriend. These conflicts combined with unhappiness over Hancock€™s footage led to him being dismissed after a month. His footage was scrapped, a new director was wheeled in and Jaws 2 was retooled to be happier in tone. Hancock€™s footage has never been revealed, but the eerie shot of a fin rising out of the water near the start is said to be the only shot of his used.

4. Prometheus Used To Be A Straight Forward Alien Prequel

Prometheus saw Ridley Scott return to the sci-fi genre after a long gap and also kinda, sorta return to the Alien series. It starred out as a direct prequel to Alien, and went into development under the title Alien: Engineers. In the script the characters land on planet LV-426 where they uncover the history of the Engineers and face new versions of the Alien, including a boneless albino creature. It also had a twist on the famous chestbuster scene, where the Alien bursts out of an impregnated character during sex. But as development rode on it started to break away from that script. Scott was also tired of the Alien, feeling the design had been done to death. He had the script rewritten by Damon Lindelof (Lost, Star Trek) who retained the basic story but removed the Aliens and reworked characters, motivations and settings. The resulting film met a mixed reaction. The main complaints were the patchy story, dumb or unlikable characters and the tone shifting between philosophical musing and b-movie silliness.

3. World War Z Used To Have A Giant Battle In Russia

Brad Pitt€™s zombie blockbuster had some well publicised problems during production, and reports had it that Pitt and the director didn€™t get along. In World War Z Pitt is a UN Investigator trying to find a cure to a zombie epidemic. In the released film he escapes Jerusalem on a plane in act two and crash lands in Wales. The last act is a siege movie in a medical centre as he and some doctors make a breakthrough. But this final stretch is a replacement for a more epic finale set in Russia. As originally shot the plane lands in Russia, where Pitt is forced into the Army to help fight the zombies. Months pass and he leads his own kick-ass zombie slaying team. There is one final large scale zombie battle before he finally gets to ring his wife to check in. It turns out she€™s had to prostitute herself to a soldier (Matthew Fox) to keep their children safe. The soldier warns Pitt not to come back. The movie ends with him on a boat heading to America to save his family. Cue sequel hook! This dark ending didn€™t test well. Damon Lindelof was brought in (again), and he thought the final battle was too much and the movie needed to scale back. The studio agreed and a new, happier conclusion was decided upon. The film got average reviews but ultimately earned some big bucks.

2. Alien 3 Used To Feature A Wooden Planet Full Of Monks

Alien 3 had a legendarily troubled shoot, with first time director David Fincher nearly breaking down over the pressure he was put under. But it was a mess long before he arrived. A ton of scripts were written, some not even featuring Ripley as Sigourney Weaver was reluctant to return. There was a space prison, a space farm and a teaser trailer even hinted it would be set on earth. The producers wanted to find something unique, and felt they found it in director Vincent Ward€™s idea. His Alien 3 was set on a wooden planet, where an order of monks who have rejected technology and modern society live. Ripley€™s escape pod crash lands, and Hicks and Newt die on impact. Also onboard is an Alien, who wastes no time slaying himself some tasty monks. They blame Ripley for this, believing she brought the devil with her. She teams up with a nice monk to survive. Pre-production got underway and sets were built, before internal conflicts made things unravel fast. The producers thought it was too expensive to do the wooden planet and wanted something cheaper, and they demanded other story changes too. These arguments led to Ward leaving and Fincher coming on. A fast rewrite changed the monks to prisoners and the wood planet became a prison. The final film had a mixed reception, and Fincher himself has disowned it.

1. Exorcist: The Beginning Scrapped An Entire Movie And Started Again

In the normal course of events a film changes direction either before or during the shoot. In the rare case of Exorcist: The Beginning, it changed direction AFTER an entire movie had been shot. It got off to a bad start when original director John Frankenheimer died before production, and star Liam Neeson dropped out. New helmer Paul Schrader then shot and edited a complete version, setting out to make a gore free psychological thriller. But when he showed it to investors, they were furious. It was too slow and talky in their eyes and was bound to fail. Instead of simply reshooting and adding in some gore and jump scares they decided to start fresh. Renny Harlin (Die Hard 2) was hired to shoot a brand new version, with Stellan Skarsgard remaining as the lead actor. This didn€™t help, as Harlin€™s version bombed and was criticised for the amount of excessive gore and terrible CGI effects. In an ironic twist the studio ended up releasing Schrader€™s version on DVD in an attempt to recoup some money. It didn€™t get great reviews either though. Can you think of any other movies that radically changed direction during production? Share your choices in the comments tread below.

In this post: 
Robin Hood
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Handsome. Charismatic. Intelligent. Noble. Witty. I'm none of these things, but I'm a half decent writer, I guess.