10 Scariest Horror Movie Mirror Scenes

Nothing is scarier than your own reflection.

Oculus Death
Warner Bros.

It's probably fair to say that horror films are more reliant on cliches than any other genre, but that doesn't necessarily have to be a bad thing.

Even so, there are certainly types of scenes audiences are fed up of seeing - case in point, the hilariously lazy, wildly overused mirror jump scare, where a bathroom mirror is typically slammed shut to reveal a monstrous presence in the reflection.

It's about as moldy and dull as horror tropes get, but every so often, a filmmaker dares to get a little more creative and give the mirror gag a neat makeover.

These 10 films, whether out-and-out genre classics or otherwise pretty terrible movies that got one scene right, all delivered legendary mirror scenes audiences won't ever forget.

From intelligent and stylish reimaginings of the typical mirror gag to films which actually used mirrors as a main prop in their story, these 10 scenes all found ways to do something different and surprising with a classic object from the genre.

The results ranged from intrigue to terror and disgust, along with a greater appreciation for filmmakers who continue to reinvent familiar ideas...

10. Redrum Is Murder - The Shining

The Shining Redrum
Warner Bros.

What would this list possibly be without including Stanley Kubrick's inimitable horror masterwork The Shining?

The unforgettable scene in question is a payoff to young Danny Torrance's (Danny Lloyd) continued utterances of the phrase "Redrum" throughout the film.

After using his mother Wendy's (Shelley Duvall) lipstick to write Redrum on her bathroom door, his increasingly disturbed shouting of the word wakes her up.

While comforting Danny, she looks forward into the mirror to see Danny's scrawlings reflected back at her - Redrum is "Murder" backwards.

It's easy to take such a seemingly simple scare for granted nowadays, but between Lloyd's eerily somnambulant performance and Kubrick's typically exemplary shot selections, he ensures the revelation is absolutely bone-chilling.

The scene isn't merely creepy for creepy's sake, though: it foreshadows an axe-wielding, murderously deranged Jack (Jack Nicholson) coming after mother and son moments later.


9. Helen Returns - Candyman

Trevor Lyle Candyman
TriStar Pictures

You won't find many horror movies more intimately concerned with mirrors as vessels of terror than Candyman - after all, the titular murderous spirit can be summoned by anyone who says his name five times in a mirror.

Though we see this happen several times throughout the movie, the most intense instance occurs right at the end of the film following the death of protagonist Helen Lyle (Virginia Madsen).

Her guilt-riddled husband Trevor (Xander Berkeley), who was having an affair with one of his students, says Helen's name five times in front of the bathroom mirror, in turn summoning Helen's mutilated, hook-handed spirit.

She promptly murders Trevor with her hook, leaving his corpse to be discovered by his student-lover Stacey (Carolyn Lowery).


8. The Jaw Rip - Mirrors

Mirrors Amy Smart
Fox

Alexandre Aja's loose remake of the 2003 South Korean horror film Into the Mirror may not live up to the promise of its setup, but nevertheless delivers one traumatic death scene viewers won't ever forget.

The film revolves around a malevolent force which uses mirrors to attack its victims, and in one mid-film sequence makes short work of protagonist Ben Carson's (Kiefer Sutherland) poor sister Angela (Amy Smart).

While Angela's taking a bath, her reflection in the bathroom mirror begins to tear its own jaw apart, causing the very same thing to happen to the real, incredibly terrified Angela in the bathtub.

It's a nauseatingly violent but exceptionally well-executed sequence, and is sure to leave you creeped out around mirrors for days.


7. Carrie Shatters Her Mirror - Carrie

Carrie Sissy Spacek
United Artists

Not all unsettling mirror scenes need to go the explicitly gory route, though, as proven so expertly by Brian De Palma in his 1976 genre classic Carrie.

In an early scene, Carrie (Sissy Spacek) is abused by her religious zealot of a mother Margaret (Piper Laurie), before heading upstairs to her bedroom.

At this point, an emotionally wrecked Carrie stares at her bedroom mirror, her burgeoning telekinetic powers briefly manifesting and allowing her to explode the mirror into shards of glass in her rage - and then put it back together off-screen.

It's a potent and shockingly unexpected moment, and one elevated by both the extremely Psycho-esque screeching musical score and lingering image of Jesus Christ himself reflected in the mirror's remnants.


6. Evil Ash Attacks - Evil Dead II

Evil Dead 2 Ash
New Line

Sam Raimi put his love of visually creative slapstick comedy to good use throughout Evil Dead II, and perhaps no better than in the film's brilliantly creative mirror scene which introduced audiences to Evil Ash (Bruce Campbell).

As Ash looks at himself in the mirror, his "reflection" reaches through, grabs him and taunts him - "We just cut up our girlfriend with a chainsaw. Does that sound 'fine?'"

Evil Ash then attempts to strangle his regular self, before Ash steps back and realises that he's actually throttling himself.

The scene was achieved through an ingenious array of practical trickery, namely an over-the-shoulder body double for Bruce Campbell and sneaky set changes between cuts.

The end result is basically completely seamless, and serves as a testament to the resourceful solutions so often rustled up on low-budget genre productions.


5. Freddy's Final Scare - A Nightmare On Elm Street (2010)

A Nightmare On Elm Street Nancy 2010
Warner Bros.

2010's A Nightmare on Elm Street remake may be a pretty lousy movie for the most part, but it has two things going for it - Jackie Earle Haley's solid performance as Freddy Krueger, and a brilliantly gnarly ending involving a mirror.

If Wes Craven's 1984 original has any one flaw, it's surely the laughable sequel-baiting ending, in which a ridiculous-looking blow-up doll was used to double for Nancy's (Heather Langenkamp) mother Marge (Ronee Blakley) when she's pulled through a window by Freddy (Robert Englund).

But this is the single aspect of the film the remake actually improves, ending instead with Nancy's (Rooney Mara) mother Gwen (Connie Britton) being stabbed through a mirror by Freddy, who then drags her corpse back into the mirror before it magically repairs itself. The End.

Despite the film's many missteps, it's a genuinely unsettling visual and far less silly-looking than how the '84 original wrapped up, even with the slightly iffy CGI gore.


4. Kaylie's Death - Oculus

Oculus Death
Warner Bros.

Mike Flanagan's Oculus is another entry into the small subset of horror movies centered around mirrors as haunted objects, in this case an antique mirror capable of generating hallucinations.

Rather than conclude with sibling protagonists Kaylie (Karen Gillan) and Tim (Brenton Thwaites) finding a way to destroy the mirror, Oculus opts instead for a grim ending in which the mirror tricks the pair of them.

Tim is duped into releasing a kill switch he and Kaylie had set up to destroy the mirror with a giant anchor. To Tim, the room appears to be empty, but in fact, Kaylie is standing directly in front of the mirror when he hits the switch.

The mirror meanwhile makes Kaylie hallucinate a vision of her late mother (Katee Sackhoff), leaving her helpless as she's impaled by the swinging anchor, leading the police to arrest Tim for her apparent murder.

The mirror wins, yet despite the film's critical and commercial success, a sequel has bafflingly never materialised.


3. Death Reflection - Peeping Tom

Peeping Tom
Optimum Releasing

A deeper cut now with Michael Powell's legendary 1960 psychological horror film Peeping Tom, which revolves around deranged serial killer Mark Lewis (Carl Boehm), whose voyeuristic kink involves filming the various murders he commits.

His method of killing? Stabbing them with a blade concealed within the camera's tripod leg, but at film's end Mark reveals his pièce de résistance - a mirror mounted to the camera, forcing his victims to see their own deaths and in turn allowing him to capture their traumatised reactions.

In one of the film's many chilling images, we see the distorted reflection of his friend Helen (Anna Massey) as he places the blade to her throat.

Thankfully, though, he stops short of stabbing her, moments before the police intervene and Mark ends up taking his own life with the blade.


2. The Face Peel Nightmare - Poltergeist

Poltergeist Face
MGM

Poltergeist is already one of the most atmospheric and unsettling studio horror films of the '80s without even getting into its all-timer scene involving a mirror.

The decidedly-not-PG scene included in this bafflingly PG-rated movie involves Marty (Martin Casella) experiencing a horrifying hallucination in front of the bathroom mirror.

He notices a small cut on his face and begins to pick at it, but ends up ripping his entire face off, his flesh plopping into the sink and eventually revealing the skeletal remains beneath, before he thankfully snaps out of it.

Considering how totally unexpected and revoltingly gory the scene is, it's basically the most inspired and effective use of a mirror in horror movie history, if understandably traumatising for any youngsters in the audience.


1. Dracula Has No Reflection - Dracula (1931)

Dracula 1931
Universal

But we saved the deepest of all cuts for last by going back almost an entire century for one of the most intelligently and slyly creepy uses of a mirror in the genre's rich history.

We're talking of course about Tod Browning's 1931 Dracula, and specifically the iconic scene where John Harker (David Manners) opens his cigarette box, whereby the mirrored lid reveals that Count Dracula (Bela Lugosi) doesn't have a reflection.

This is of particular concern to Professor Van Helsing (Edward Van Sloan), who attempts to confront Dracula about it, only for the Count to smash the cigarette box and insist he has an intense dislike of mirrors. Quite.

Sometimes the simplest flourishes are the best ones, and though this might seem completely basic by contemporary standards, it does a fantastic job of illustrating Dracula's otherworldliness in practical, efficient, and downright eerie terms.

Almost 100 years on, the scene's lost none of its ominous power.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Oculus
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.