10 Star Trek Episodes That Paid Off WAY Later

Star Trek knows how to tease and deliver, even if it takes a little longer than expected.

Star Trek Bruce Maddox
Paramount

Long-running franchises often live and die on the attention paid to fan service. While fan service would not be the only reason that a story can pay off years later, we as audiences are seeing more and more callbacks to early episodes of Star Trek as Discovery, Lower Decks and Prodigy continue on. Star Trek: Picard is effectively a sequel to The Next Generation, so it is arguably one giant callback itself.

Yet how many episodes pay-off in both unexpected and fresh ways? There are times when it is clearly deliberate - The Neutral Zone was always meant to tease the arrival of the Borg - and then there are those times when new writers pick up on threads and take them in different directions.

This list will encompass a bit of both - the intentional and the unintentional - episodes that paid off way later down the line. With new episodes dropping weekly between the newer series, there is already enough material for several of these lists.

Let the reader beware: there will CLEARLY be spoilers ahead, so you are now warned!

10. The Measure Of A Man

Star Trek The Measure of a Man
CBS

Coming in The Next Generation's second season, The Measure of a Man is considered by many audience members, including this author, to be the first truly great episode of the series. It is Star Trek firing on all cylinders - a bottle show that defines not only the importance of Data to the Enterprise, but affirms the right to life and liberty for all androids going forward.

The episode featured several follow-ups in The Next Generation's run, including The Offspring and Data's Day, but it would actually form the basis of two storylines in subsequent series.

The first comes in Star Trek: Voyager. The seventh season episode Author, Author is effectively a copy and paste of this episode, dealing instead with the Doctor's rights as owner of his creative output. In this case, it is a poor follow-up. The advocate of the day definitively declines to rule on the Doctor's status as a sentient being, which is both a deliberate nod to Data's trial, but a bit of a cop-out at the episode's end.

The direct payoff, however, is Bruce Maddox's appearance in Star Trek: Picard. He was badly affected by the synthetic lifeform ban following the attack on Mars, yet he created, with Alton Soong, a new race of androids based on Data's neurons. The inclusion of his character makes this a bittersweet continuation, particularly as neither Data nor Maddox live to see the ban overturned.


9. Dark Page

Star Trek Dark Page
CBS

The Next Generation's seventh season felt like something of a victory lap, as the show was coming to the end of its run. Star Trek: Generations was on the horizon, which gave the showrunners a chance to revisit some of the recurring characters, to give them a bit of closure. Lwaxana Troi, having been introduced back in the first season and popping up periodically, returns in what turned out to be her most heart-wrenching story.

For it is in this episode that the audience learns that Deanna Troi was not an only child. When she was a baby, the Trois went on a family picnic. While there, Kestra Troi, Lwaxana's firstborn, slipped into a pond and drowned. The event was blocked from her mind, though after years and much heavy telepathic activity, those walls came down and the truth was revealed.

Deanna was faced with the choice to resent her mother for keeping this information from her, or to accept this and attempt to move on. In Star Trek: Picard, Nepenthe shows the return of Deanna - and introduces the audience to her daughter, Kestra. We also learn that, like her mother, Deanna lost a child as well.

It is a bittersweet return for the character, but one heightened by the earlier revelations.


8. Sins Of The Father

Star Trek Kurn
CBS

Another third season episode of The Next Generation that had ramifications for years to come, Sins of the Father introduces the audience to Kurn, the second son of Mogh, and Worf's younger brother. Played by Tony Todd is his pre-Candyman era, this Klingon warrior became the audience's gateway into the wider machinations of the Klingon Empire.

This episode set the scene for much of what followed with the Empire, arguably only truly coming to a close with Deep Space Nine's seventh-season episode Tacking Into The Wind. Here, Worf accepts discommendation from the Klingons, agreeing to a lie - that his father, rather than Duras's father, sold out Khitomer to the Romulans - which sets the stage for Duras to make a bid for Chancellor.

This leads to Civil War when the Duras Sisters fight Gowron for leadership. That in turn leads to the destruction of the Enterprise-D, as the Duras Sisters manage to overcome the Galaxy-class ship. Worf is then reassigned to Deep Space Nine, leading to his meeting with Martok and eventual fight to the death with Gowron.

The saga of the final days of this era of the Klingon Empire begins with the arrival of Kurn.


7. The Price

Star Trek The Price
CBS

The Price introduces several elements to the franchise, including the Barzan race and their Wormhole, the Delta Quadrant and its extreme distance, and of course the characters of Arridor and Kol. The episode itself is relatively light fare, appearing somewhat as a love story for Deanna Troi more than anything. However, this episode would have far-reaching ramifications for the franchise.

For example, Arridor and Kol are stranded in the Delta Quadrant by the episode's end. Star Trek: Voyager would pick up on this storyline in their third season episode False Profits. Actor Dan Shor returned as Arridor, though Kol was recast, now played by Leslie Jordan. The episode establishes the Ferengi as false gods on a pre-warp planet, using their advanced technology to gain power.

However, that is not the only element from The Price to come back. Star Trek: Discovery, in its second season, introduced the character of Nahn, a Barzan security officer serving aboard the Enterprise, and later the Discovery. This informs us that not only had first contact between the Federation and Barzan people occurred more than 100 years before the events of The Price, but that Nahn must have impressed someone at Starfleet, as she would have needed sponsorship to gain entry to the Academy. Barzan was not a member world by The Price.


6. Elementary, Dear Data

Star Trek Elementary Dear Data
CBS

Elementary, Dear Data is almost as pure a comedy episode as it's possible to get - while the ship is still in very real danger. Daniel Davis delivers a stellar performance as Professor Moriarty, while Diana Muldaur is excellent as Dr. Pulaski as well. However, the best moment of the episode probably must go to Worf's sudden jump as Picard pops his top hat.

However, this episode makes this list with the shortest payoff time, with only four seasons between it and Ship In A Bottle, but with the largest behind-the-scenes reason for the delay. When this episode was in production, the producers believed that Sherlock Holmes was in the public domain. After the episode aired, the estate of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle got in touch to inform them that this was not the case and that they would need recompense for any future depictions of the characters.

This killed the plans for rapid sequels and left Moriarty in cybernetic limbo. By the time that Ship In A Bottle was produced, the delay was actually noted on-screen, along with a reference to Pulaski, though not by name. This would be the final reference to her character to date.


5. The Infinite Vulcan

Star Trek The Infinite Vulcan
CBS

The Animated Series is, quite frankly, the bastard stepchild of Star Trek. It will generally be found at the bottom of many rankings, though this is hardly a fair assessment. There are story ideas as strong as many of The Original Series, while it is the execution of those ideas that probably gives the most pause.

However, Star Trek: Lower Decks has been striving to bring it back into the audience's mind. For example, alien races like the Vendorians and Aurelians, along with characters like Arex and M'Ress, have all made cameos in some form or another. The episode Kayshon, His Eyes Open features the darkest callback in Star Trek: Lower Decks.

The Infinite Vulcan introduces a giant, cloned Spock. He is created by the human Dr. Stavos Keniclius 5, a remnant of the Eugenics Wars, who is attempting to find the perfect specimen. Giant Spock is left on the planet Phylos in an attempt to cure the Phylosians of their sterility. Fast forward to Kayshon, His Eyes Open and that same Giant Spock makes a cameo - as a skeleton, adorned in a ripped uniform, hanging from the ceiling. Grim.


4. Space Seed

Star Trek Space Seed
Paramount

Ok, no, this isn't just going to talk about Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, although that did come sixteen years after the release of Ricardo Montalban's first appearance in Star Trek. While Khan will generally still consistently be referred to as the greatest villain in the franchise, it is the Eugenics Wars that are introduced in this episode that takes point.

The rise of the Supermen and the wars to defeat them would return many times throughout Trek history. In Deep Space Nine, Dr. Bashir is revealed to have undergone genetic resequencing as a child, which leads to a tribunal, and an evocation of Khan's name. Though Bashir is spared the legal ramifications, he later helps to treat others who are like him, yet not so fortunate.

Star Trek: Enterprise would go further. In the three-part story centering on the Augments and Arik Soong, genetic resequencing is again brought into play. Here though, a group of these augmented humans goes on a rampage, proving to be at least equal to Starfleet's best along the way. This augmentation is acquired by the Klingons, leading to a full circle moment in Star Trek.

The augmentation virus that infects the entire Klingon race erases their head ridges, leading to the smooth-headed Klingons best remembered from The Original Series. Though it took forty years to get there, Khan and the events of Space Seed end up retroactively explaining the change in the Klingons overall.


3. The Tholian Web

Star Trek The Tholian Web
CBS Media Ventures

The Tholian Web hails from The Original Series' oft-maligned third season. The budget for the show had been slashed as it went into its final year, with the initial production of The Tholian Web requiring some creative ideas to make work. A new Constitution-class model was created, rechristened the USS Defiant, and given a green hue for all of its scenes. As well as this, the Tholian web-spinners were introduced.

Both the Defiant and the Tholians would return in the fourth season of Star Trek: Enterprise. Here, it is explained that once the ship vanishes, it reappears in the Mirror Universe. Captured by the mirror-Tholians, they are attempting to strip it for parts. However, the ship is taken by the Terran Empire, leading to some fairly big headaches for the Tholian Assembly.

The two-parter In A Mirror, Darkly is one of the best stories in Enterprise, coming right at the end of its final season. It ties a nice bow on the story of the Defiant, though it would be mentioned again in Star Trek: Discovery. It also goes a way to explaining how the Terran Empire remained as strong as it was for so long, with the infusion of future technology.


2. The City On The Edge Of Forever

Star Trek The Guardian Of Forever
CBS

The Guardian of Forever was introduced at the end of the Original Series' first season in the episode The City On The Edge Of Forever. It would return in the Animated Series episode Yesteryear. In both cases, it is a stable method of temporal travel, though it clearly has a mind of its own.

Altering the timeline is referred to as one of the greatest headaches for Starfleet, or simply as 'Tuesday' for James T. Kirk. However, this entry is less about Kirk as, ironically, it is he who ensures the stability of the timeline after his encounter with the device. Rather, it is Starfleet themselves, and others who engaged in the Temporal Cold War, who would come to abuse the artifact.

Star Trek: Discovery's third season two-parter, Terra Firma, sees the return of the Guardian to the franchise. This time, it appears initially in a different form. Carl, as it likes to be called, is presented as a man who speaks in riddles, holding a copy of the Star Dispatch, prophecizing Georgiou's death. This leads to the jaw-dropping reveal of the Guardian, realized in 21st-century graphics, rendered beautifully for the modern day.


1. The Cage

Star Trek The Cage
CBS Media Ventures

Quite frankly, of all entries on this list, The Cage is the one that began paying off from the moment it was created. However, as it was not officially aired until twenty years after its filming, not many people actually knew that. The introduction of Star Trek, the Enterprise, and of course Mr Spock, cannot be overstated. All of the ingredients for what Star Trek would become are present in this first hour.

However, it would be 2009 before Christopher Pike would be reimagined, appearing in the JJ Abrams film, played by Bruce Greenwood. While Sean Kenney had played the character in The Menagerie, that came at a time when not many audience members truly understood who Pike was. The character would return again, played this time by Anson Mount, for Star Trek: Discovery's second season.

The episode If Memory Serves features a convention-breaking moment, opening with clips from the original pilot, showing both Jeffery Hunter and Anson Mount, one after the other. The episode also sees the return of Vina, played in archive footage by Susan Oliver, and new footage by Melissa George.

The success of Mount's take on the character has directly led to a new series of Star Trek - this time called Strange New Worlds. Sixty years later, The Cage is continuing to deliver on its promise of a brighter future, helping to green light more and more content for the modern audience.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Star Trek
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"