10 Star Wars "Plot-Holes" That Really Aren't
From a certain point of view, they're not mistakes at all!
Pop culture loves a good plot-hole. It is a chance to poke fun at the creators of the media we so enjoy and delude ourselves into thinking that the immensely complex and difficult task of writing for a multi-million dollar project is something any mere mortal can do.
The reality is that writers spend far more time obsessing over their creation than fans do. After all, one of the golden rules of writing is to never insult your reader’s intelligence, a bit of wisdom that, together with the modern virulent hatred for all things expositional, has resulted in writers being rather cagey with their plot details.
As such, what fans will gleefully seize upon as being glaringly obvious mistakes often turn out to have the simplest of explanations, leaving many a fan a bit red in the face.
Star Wars is no different, with the Prequels in particular continuing to be roundly savaged for their apparent plot-holes, mistakes and inconsistencies. However, George Lucas spent decades crafting his world, and as only a few minutes of thought would prove did a better job than most would think.
This is not to say that there are no mistakes – nobody is perfect – but the ‘plot-holes’ on this list are certainly not among them, even if, at times, one must defend the indefensible...
10. Why Did The Jedi Not Sense The Dark Side Around Palpatine?
The Plot-Hole:
The Jedi meet with Palpatine face-to-face yet do not sense that something is off.
But...
Actually, the Jedi did. During the Jedi War Council in Revenge of the Sith Mace Windu states that, “the Dark Side of the Force surrounds the Chancellor,” and none of the Jedi in attendance, among whom are his fellow council members, Yoda and Ki-Adi Mundi, disagree with him. This distrust is nothing new: in Attack of the Clones, Yoda is also clearly suspicious of Palpatine.
But why the inaction?
Again, the War Council provides a clear explanation. Put simply, the Supreme Chancellor is the democratically elected head of the Republic. Apart from the fact that accusing a man subject to such intense scrutiny of being a Sith Lord would be laughable, arresting him without proof would be tantamount to treason.
Worse, as stated by Windu, the Jedi would be compelled to take control of the Senate – in essence, the Republic itself – to ensure an orderly transition of power. From the citizen’s perspective this would leave them at the mercy of an already unpopular, quasi-religious order composed of super-powered individuals.
Palpatine had brilliantly outmanoeuvred the Jedi, placing them in a vice between their commitment to destroying the Sith on the one hand, and their commitment to upholding democracy on the other. Whatever the choice, they lost.
But faced with the threat of a Sith at the helm of the Republic they were forced to act, and tragically Order 66 became inevitable.
9. Why Did Obi-Wan Call Himself 'Old Ben?'
The Plot-Hole:
Why did Obi-Wan Kenobi, while in hiding, use such obvious misdirection as ‘Old Ben Kenobi?’ Also, why hide Luke on Tatooine? Vader is not only native to the planet, but personally met the two people to whom Obi-Wan entrusted Luke.
But...
The usual defence is that Vader did not know that his children were alive. While elegant, this theory is incomplete.
In A New Hope, Tarkin clearly states that “The Jedi are extinct. Their fire has gone out of the Universe. You, my friend (Vader), are all that’s left of their religion.” Ergo, they did not search for Obi-Wan because they believed there was nothing to search for.
But using the surname Kenobi was still a risk, yes? No. Tatooine is an Outer Rim, sparsely-populated, relatively poor, desert planet, with Obi-Wan living in a remote, desolate corner surrounded by hostile Tusken Raiders. Word of a crazy hermit in the hills is hardly going to be considered newsworthy, and certainly won’t be of interest to the galactic elite back on Coruscant.
No, Obi-Wan kept his name in order to maintain a link to his past, one that would, and does, end up convincing Luke to journey with him. Because there can be little doubt that Obi-Wan had more in mind for Luke than the life of moisture farmer...
8. Why Can't Stormtroopers Hit The Broad Side Of A Barn?
The Plot-Hole:
Han and company escape from the Death Star, a battle station station swarming with thousands of trained Stormtroopers.
But...
The widely-accepted response is that the Stormtroopers were ordered to allow the intruders to escape, part of which was to deliberately fudge their aim.
Neat, but nonsense.
Apart form being catastrophic for morale, no such order was ever seen to be given nor implied by any line of dialogue. More saliently, according to Stormtrooper radio chatter the majority of the Death Star’s security forces were uncertain of the Rebels’ location, with some completely unaware of what was happening. Hardly the hallmark of a planned tactic.
The true explanation for the Stormtrooper’s abysmal marksmanship is a mite more prosaic.
As stated by Luke the standard issue Stormtrooper helmet is difficult to see out of, and obviously enough, if you can’t see, you can’t aim. More crippling than sloppy ergonomic design is the standard of training on display. Near all of the Stormtroopers, in all three original trilogy films, shoot from the hip. While perfect technique for the average 80’s action hero, attempting the same stunt on a real battlefield will leave you, at best, putting holes in everything but your target, and at worst, dead.
That such poor training is universal among Stormtroopers proves that far from being the galaxy’s elite soldiers they are in fact little more than a uniformed militia. Han and company did not escape because of a clever plan: they escaped because of incompetence.
7. Technology Goes Backwards.
The Plot-Hole:
The Prequel’s technology is more advanced, which does not make sense since the Republic pre-dates the Imperial period.
But...
What needs to be considered is that slick aesthetic design does not necessarily equate to advanced technology: a 50’s-era clunker dressed in a supercar shell is still a 50’s-era clunker.
All of the technology seen in the Prequels, be it droids, view-screens, holograms or shields, is present in the original trilogy. Far from going backwards the Imperial period produced weapons not seen during the Republic era: we see the Super Star Destroyer, planetary ion-cannons, not to mention the Death Stars, the second of which was more advanced than the first. And yes, in our modern era of touch-screens a console bedecked in kindergarten buttons looks archaic, but the fewer the buttons the greater the degree of automation.
The reality is that the meteoric rise of CGI allowed George Lucas to build the fantasy world he had always imagined, and that world was always going to be populated by vehicles and gadgets more intricate, artistic and detailed than anything seen in the original trilogy.
But while the shell of the original trilogy may have regressed into something industrial and Spartan, the underlying technology did not.
6. How Do Ewoks Defeat Stormtroopers?
The Plot-Hole:
How do rotund, furry teddy bears with the waddling gait of a penguin and capable of the most adorable ‘Yub Yub’ speech imaginable manage to take on and trounce the Empire’s best?
But...
Because they are not teddy bears.
Cast your mind back to the home-made traps set for the Imperial walkers. One of these involves the piling up of truly massive logs. The other involves lifting two of said massive logs a good eight meters into the air. Handling loads of this size would require engineering prowess equal to that of the Roman Empire.
Apart from the intelligence and co-ordination involved in constructing these traps, the sheer strength needed to man-handle such immense weights without the use of engines is staggering. And not only do the Ewoks have to lift the trees, but they have to cut them down with stone axes. Recall also that the Ewoks were able to physically overpower the Stormtroopers and bludgeon them to death in spite of protective armour.
The conclusion? Not only is there more than stuffing between those cute ears but under that fur, Ewoks are ripped.
Far from being cute and harmless, Ewoks are badass.
5. Why Are Star Wars Tracking Devices Undetectable?
The Plot-Hole:
In Star Wars trackers cannot be detected, even if they’re thrown onto a spacecraft’s hull. How is this possible in such an advanced universe?
But...
This argument would seem to be watertight. It stands to reason that a tracking device fulfills its purpose by transmitting co-ordinates. Those transmissions, in turn, should be subject to interception. And, they are: in The Empire Strikes Back a Probe Droid’s communication with the Imperial fleet is intercepted, leading to the droid’s destruction.
So why are transmissions from tracking devices the exception?
Out of all six Star Wars films made by George Lucas trackers are only used on two occasions, intriguingly, by the military and the Jedi. Military implies classified and classified implies cutting-edge. Consequently, the technology we are dealing with is not bog-standard radio but something rather more quantum. With the threat of such advanced technology being reverse-engineered it stands to reason that the Empire would ensure that the devices are not detectable.
The risk Tarkin took in allowing the Falcon to escape from the Death Star was thus two-fold: the loss of a valuable intelligence asset in Leia, but also handing the Rebels incredibly sensitive technology. As that Probe Droid on Hoth found out, his caution was entirely justified.
4. Digested Over A Thousand Years?
The Plot-Hole:
Jabba
says that those fed to the Sarlacc will be “slowly digested over a
period of a thousand years.” How then, do its victims stay fresh?
But...
The answer is obvious – they don’t. Slow digestion does not equate to slow death: snakes such as Pythons and Anacondas can take weeks to digest a meal, but this does not mean that the meal is still breathing – otherwise it could bite. Instead their digestive system has evolved to function in this manner.
In the case of the aforementioned snakes death comes by suffocation. In the case of the Sarlacc, the victims likely loose consciousness due to the extremely toxic environment then... drown, in acid. Horrible death? Yes. Conscious while you’re turned to goop? No.
So, rather than spouting facts Jabba is insulting his victims, something very much in character for the slug.
There is no plot-hole here, only simple biology and a great deal of hubris.
3. How Is Luke Able To Pilot An X-wing
The Plot-Hole:
How is Luke, a farmboy, able to pilot a starfighter as advanced as an X-wing?
But...
The explanation is a touch esoteric, but it's there all the same. In a deleted scene from A New Hope it is revealed that Luke flew the T-16 Skyhopper, a spacecraft used, according to lore, as a trainer for the the X-wing. The model Luke is playing with in the garage on Tatooine? That is a T-16. The spacecraft visible in the background? The very T-16 in which Luke bulls-eyed Womp Rats in Beggar’s Canyon. Clearly, Luke's statement that he "is not such a bad pilot" is no idle boast.
Consider also that experienced pilots – including the pilot in command of the strike against the Death Star – not only allows Luke to fly the X-wing, but to fly it in combat as part of his squadron, something he would not due if if Luke was clueless.
As for Luke’s convenient combat prowess? With his marksmanship and piloting skills having been established, only one thing remains to be explained – his lack of nerves. But when you remember that only hours before Luke faced down an entire Death Star’s worth of Stormtroopers, four TIE Fighters, never mind the sight of the dreaded battle station itself, one can safely say that the jitters were no longer a problem.
2. Why Did That One Trade Federation Transport Not Shoot Qui-Gon Jinn?
The Plot-Hole:
Qui-Gon Jinn is seen fleeing from an armed Trade Federation transport. Only a few minutes ago we saw them try to kill Jinn. So why doesn’t it open fire?
But...
To solve the mystery we need do nothing more than look at the context. All military operations are time-critical and the battle droids aboard the transport were needed to pacify any resistance on the part of the Naboo. Having witnessed the futility of pitting a squad of battle droids against a Jedi, and unable to halt the entire invasion to deal with a single Jedi, there was simply no point in engaging Jinn.
But they did not need to. A force of battle droids riding STAPs (Singe Trooper Aerial Platform) had already been dispatched to deal with the Jedi. That they were ineffective might come as no surprise to the viewer but having seen the success of heavy weapons like Droidekas the Trade Federation would have backed their chances...wrongly, as it turned out.
Silly though the plot-hole may seem the scene is pivotal: if Jinn died at this early juncture then Jar Jar Binks is never recruited, Obi-Wan never arrives in Theed City in time to save the Queen, never meets Anakin, who then is never trained, never fathers Luke, and never becomes Darth Vader.
Quite literally, no Qui-Gon Jinn, no Star Wars.
1. Parsecs: Unit Of Time Or Distance?
The Pot-Hole:
By having Han imply that completing the Kessel Run in 12 Parsecs is fast, George Lucas clearly confused a unit of measurement with a unit of time.
But...
Not necessarily. In the DVD commentary for A New Hope, Lucas states that the Millennium Falcon is fitted with an advanced navigation computer. This allows Han to calculate the most efficient route through the Run, thus justifying the use of a measurement of distance.
Eyeballs will roll, yes, but Lucas is onto something. When navigating through a forest, for example, the most efficient route through the obstacle will naturally translate to the quickest transit. Complete the transit in one hundred meters as opposed to your competitors’ best of one hundred and twenty and you would, in fact, take less time.
In this context the unit of distance does equate to a unit of time.
The confusion arises because Lucas has never clarified what the ‘Kessel’ in ‘Kessel Run’ refers to. An asteroid field? A globular cluster? Horrendously convoluted space lanes? We do not know but, if any of these scenarios are correct, the 12 parsec boast makes perfect sense.
Watch Next
Star Wars Quiz: Who Said It - Anakin Or Luke?