10 Stephen King Movie Adaptations That Stephen King Hated
The King does not hail these movies.
Stephen King has always maintained a healthy “The book is the book, the film is the film” attitude when it comes to adaptations of his work. If a movie turns out great like The Shawshank Redemption, The Dead Zone, Misery or Stand By Me, that’s great. If they turn out awful – hi there, Sleepwalkers and Cell – that’s not going to affect his books any.
Despite being one of the most adapted authors ever he’s been lucky with the amount of quality movies based on his work, and being a gentleman he rarely comments on the crappy ones. That said he’s also quite honest and if a weak movie based on his works rubs him the wrong way, he won’t be expressing his opinion.
Listed here are some of the King movies that don’t have his personal stamp of approval, and some he’s outright disowned; in most cases, it’s hard to disagree.
10. The Children Of The Corn Sequels (All Of Them)
Children Of The Corn was a King short story from the 1970s, a creepy tale about a cult of children who murder any grown-ups who wander into their town. The original movie is far from great, but it’s an effective horror movie that even King enjoyed.
How the hell it managed to spawn another nine movies (and counting!) is a mystery. They’re all pretty bad and feature variations on the same plot; a cast of bland teens come into town and the murderous kids sacrifice them to “He Who Walks Between The Rows." The only notable thing about these sequels is the number of future name actresses to emerge from them; Charlize Theron made her debut in part three, Naomi Watts took the lead in four and Eva Mendes appears in part five.
They’re basically shelf fillers trading on King’s good name, and he told Deadline "I could do without all the Children Of The Corn sequels." The director of a TV movie remake of the original tried to get him involved again, only to receive a letter from King’s lawyer stating he’d wanted nothing to do with it.
9. Dreamcatcher
Dreamcatcher was the first book King wrote after his horrible road accident in 1999, and it was written mainly through a haze of painkillers. He’s since admitted the book is a mess for this reason, and he's not too fond of it.
This didn’t stop Warner Bros snapping up for a big budget feature, and they assembled an impressive cast for it, including Morgan Freeman, Damian Lewis, Tom Jane and Timothy Olyphant. Unfortunately, the whole enterprise was a disaster of conflicting tones, horrible CGI monsters that are literally pieces of s*** and jaw-droppingly poor ending.
Weirdly enough, King seemed to give the impression he liked Dreamcatcher during an interview for the DVD, but has since conceded it’s terrible, bluntly calling it a “train wreck” in a 2007 interview with Time.
8. The Lawnmower Man
Stephen King movies were reaching epidemic proportions by 1992, and The Lawnmower Man proudly displayed posters with the master’s name on them. The issue there was that it bore such little resemblance to his story, he ended up suing New Line Cinema to remove his name from it.
King’s short story has a man hiring a mysterious guy to mow his lawn, who turns out to be a goat man who eats grass and worships Pan; in the end, he sacrifices the man to his god. It’s utterly bonkers, but the movie has a hunky professor – played by pre-Bond Pierce Brosnon – making a mentally disabled lawnmower man smarter through VR experiments. He soon evolves into a new lifeform who is intent on becoming a cyberspace god, so Brosnan has to stop him.
Outside of some character names and a lawnmower, the movie has nothing to do with the story at all. King doesn’t even recognise it as an adaption of his work, and when New Line dragged their feet removing his name he sued them again.
7. A Return To Salem's Lot
A Return To Salem’s Lot is a sequel to the acclaimed 1979 miniseries, and boy is it weird. It finds an author and his family trapped in Salem’s Lot, and forced by the vampires to write their history. The film was written and directed by b-movie legend Larry Cohen, and he infuses it with lots of quirky touches.
It’s not scary in the least, though, and is quite dull for the most part. The film is pretty obscure now and while the cover proudly states it’s based on characters created by Stephen King, the author himself had nothing - and wanted nothing - to do with it.
During a Time interview he also lumped it in with the Children Of The Corn sequels as something he could do without.
6. Needful Things
Needful Things was a darkly comic horror novel from King, and tells the story of the demonic owner of an antique shop, where customers usually end up paying with their souls. It’s a parody of pointless consumerism, and while it wasn’t acclaimed it might be one of his most underrated books.
The movie version featured a perfectly cast Max Von Sydow as the show’s owner, and a gruff Ed Harris as the town sheriff trying to stop him. The movie has a minor cult around it, but it was neither a critical nor commercial hit, though an extended three-hour television cut received better reviews.
King isn’t a fan, stating in an interview for Lilja’s Library that it was a real "disappointment" to him. While it’s hardly the worst movie based on his books, it’s not an underrated classic either.
5. The Running Man
The Running Man was written by King under his pseudonym Richard Bachman, and he apparently wrote it in a week-long binge. It’s a grim story, with a desperate man agreeing to take part in a sadistic game show where he’s stalked across America by lethal hunters.
It was eventually adapted in 1987 as an Arnold Schwarzenegger movie, where he’s a wrongfully accused convict forced to take part in a glossy game show against themed hunters. It’s profoundly camp and silly, but boy is it a lot of fun in the right mindset and a few beers.
It completely misses the point of the book, of course, and lacks the ruthlessly bleak ending. For this reason King isn’t a fan, and he complained in his memoir On Writing about how it turned the book’s protagonist into a pumped-up superhero, which is the exact opposite of Ben Richards in the book.
4. Graveyard Shift
Graveyard Shift was an early short story King sold to a magazine, and while it’s gruesome fun it's hardly his best work. The plot finds a group of textile plant workers trying to clear out the army of rats underneath the building, only to discover there are giant mutant rats waiting for them underneath.
The movie version came around in 1990 when studios would have paid top dollar for anything with King’s name on it. The film is a cheerless, mean-spirited affair with unlikable characters and a slack pace, though it does pick up a tad in the last act. Plus b movie favourite Brad Dourif’s turn as an unhinged exterminator is also good fun.
Don’t expect King to sign your DVD copy, though, since he’s not fond of it. He remarked in an interview with Deadline it was "Just kind of a quick exploitation picture." Since it’s about killer rats, that’s not much of a surprise though.
3. The Shining
King has made no secret of his loathing of Stanley Kubrick’s version of The Shining, stating it’s the first adaptation he remembers outright hating. He feels Kubrick made numerous missteps, and that the director’s own coldness robbed the movie of emotion.
He thinks Jack Nicholson was miscast and that his character has no arc, since he starts kind of crazy and just gets crazier from there. He also told The Paris Review that he finds the character of Wendy offensive to women and that "She's basically a scream machine."
King is also baffled by the praise lavished on the movie and was so outraged by the many changes that he produced a mini-series remake in 1997. Fan reaction was mixed, to put it nicely.
King also dismissed the many theories and conspiracies that people read into Kubrick’s version, and said of the documentary Room 237 stating “I've never had much patience for academic !*$%.”
2. Firestarter
Firestarter tells the story of a young girl with the power to start fires with her mind. She and her father go on the run from a secret government unit to survive, leading to a rather fiery showdown. It’s a cracking read, and the rights to make a film were quickly snapped up.
John Carpenter was supposed to helm it, but he was fired after the failure of The Thing; ironically, he ended up directing Christine instead. The resulting Firestarter film isn’t too bad, with great performances by Drew Barrymore and George C Scott, plus a catchy synth score by Tangerine Dream.
King wouldn’t agree with that assessment, and after seeing a rough cut declared it “One of the worst of the bunch” out of the adaptations he'd seen, and dubbed it “flavourless.” He and director Mark Lester later traded barbs over these comments, though King told Cinefantastique he feels Firestarter’s producer is the one to blame for its failings.
1. Maximum Overdrive
In the now infamous trailer for King’s directorial debut Maximum Overdrive, the man himself tells viewers that many filmmakers had adapted his work, but “...if you want something done right, you oughta do it yourself.” A bold claim, considering by that stage he’d been adapted by Brian De Palma, Tobe Hooper, David Cronenberg and John Carpenter.
It turns out he actually wasn’t the best choice to helm a King movie since he had no experience directing, and was high as a kite throughout the entire shoot. He set out to make a silly horror movie with over the top acting and gore, but for a movie with killer trucks, it’s dull for long stretches and the campiness is just plain annoying.
His slapstick humour falls flat, and Emilio Estevez does not make for a convincing tough guy. It’s awful, basically, and King has since admitted in an interview for the book Hollywood's Stephen King he was "coked out of his mind" throughout production. He's also called it the worst adaptation of his work to date. He hasn’t directed since, which is for the best based on this evidence.