10 Things The DCEU Wishes It Could've Done Differently
So... why wasn't Joker the villain in Suicide Squad?
The DC Extended Universe has had a rough ride throughout its current seven-film roster, and though things are looking much more positive lately with well-received movies like Aquaman and Shazam, the road Warner Bros. and DC took to get to this point is one littered with mistakes and misfires.
From ill-advised production decisions to poor story choices and some plain bad movies, the DCEU has had a less-than ideal first six years in the wild, but it has shown a lot of potential - and even some flashes of brilliance here and there - all the same.
So, in an effort to mix things up, Warner Bros. has changed course with their DC movie operation in recent years, putting us at the start of a new beginning for the franchise as it moves away from interconnected storytelling and focuses on more standalone adventures.
And so far, things are looking bright for this refreshed DCEU, but even though they're in a good place right now, there are plenty of things that Warner Bros and DC would've liked to have done differently along the way.
10. Changed Wonder Woman's Third Act
Even though Wonder Woman is the most critically-acclaimed movie in the DCEU so far, a lot of fans and pundits agreed that its final act left a lot to be desired.
A loud, explosive fight sequence between Diana Prince and Ares filled with some horribly cheesy boss-battle dialogue, the film's closing third really didn't gel with the rest of the movie, which was otherwise a much smarter and more thoughtful superhero tale. Ares' emergence is easily the weakest part of the film, and it soured the overall experience.
It also dumbed down the movie's thematic weight. Throughout the film, Diana believes that Ares is the big puppet master behind the entirety of World War I, and that by killing him, the war will end. But for a brief moment, this belief is shown to be false, when Diana kills who she thinks is Ares (Ludendorff), and the soldiers below her still carry on with their war-related business.
Wonder Woman is about Diana coming to discover and understand the horrors of the real world, so this was a fitting lesson (that some people are just plain bad, and that war is morally dubious), for the somewhat naive and inexperienced heroine to learn, and a refreshing twist for audiences accustomed to the same old CGI battles closing out their comic-book movies.
Well, scratch that: Ares was behind the whole thing after all, and we got a much shallower Hollywood ending instead.
9. Released Shazam At Christmas Time
Just below Wonder Woman, Shazam is the second-highest rated movie in the DCEU on Rotten Tomatoes, but financially, Billy Batson and his electric alter-ego didn't come close to replicating Diana Prince's huge success.
Worldwide, Shazam made just $364 million by the end of its run. That number wasn't disastrous by any means, but currently, the movie stands as the lowest-grossing DCEU outing by around $300 million, and even with years of inflation (plus increased audience hunger for comic-book movies) to give it a boost, it still failed to top the gross of the 1989 Batman movie. Let that sink in.
However, it might have performed a lot better financially if Warner Bros. had held its release back until Christmas time.
For starters, the movie itself is set at Christmas time, and is heavy on Christmas imagery, as well as Christmas-related themes. It's all about families - even unorthodox ones - sticking together, a perfectly warm, fuzzy message that winter moviegoers would have devoured.
Plus, DC literally just released a movie at Christmas that proved to be a smash hit: Aquaman. With a billion dollars in the bank, it's the DCEU's best financial performer, and benefited from a slow January period that allowed it to rack up repeat viewings. Even with stiff holiday competition in the form of Bumblebee, Spider-Verse and Mary Poppins Returns, Aquaman came out on top, and what's more, it made it look easy.
True, Shazam would have faced even greater competition this December in the form of Star Wars, Jumanji and Frozen, but even if a December 2019 launch for Shazam caused it to make half what Aquaman did, it would still be a bigger financial success than the April 2019 Shazam we did get, and the film's built-in Christmas connections would have only helped it.
8. Had More Batman V Superman In Batman V Superman
In the run-up to release, we all had our own lists of the things we most wanted to see in Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice. We all wanted a great story, sure, and everyone was expecting some Justice League setup, but the one thing that every single person on the planet really wanted to see... was Supes and Bats beating the hell out of each other. We wanted Batman V Superman.
Sadly, one of the most frustrating things about the film was the fact that we only got one short fight scene between the two heroes, before they teamed up to fight a big dumb cave troll - a turn of events that, annoyingly, had been spoiled in the trailers.
The movie sold itself on its title fight (basically every poster had both characters squaring off against one other), but it didn't deliver enough of that action. In reality, the "Batman V Superman" bit only constituted a fraction of the film's runtime, with a litany of subplots involving Lex Luthor, Wonder Woman, Lois Lane, and the upcoming Justice League dominating proceedings instead.
There's a warning in here about over-promising and under-delivering, but the real issue is that Warner Bros and director Zack Snyder simply didn't understand what most viewers wanted from a movie billed as an epic showdown between two popular superheroes. In hindsight, you have to imagine that the studio regrets not beefing up the hero-on-hero action, especially considering how well Marvel's Civil War - which featured a ton of direct conflict between Cap and Iron Man, with very little filler surrounding that central plot - was received.
In all likelihood, more fight scenes between Batman and Superman would've even improved the film's reception.
7. Made Joker The Villain In Suicide Squad
Suicide Squad was hyped up as the DCEU's version of Guardians Of The Galaxy, but the final product was a bit of a mess. Its editing and pacing were all over the place, its story was unsatisfying, and certain characters were grossly underused. The film had a lot of problems, but arguably its biggest was primary villain Enchantress.
Not only did it make zero sense to put a team consisting of mostly normal humans against a deadly sorceress, but the actual execution of Cara Delevingne's magical baddie was downright awful. Dancing around in a mess of blue lights and smoke, the CGI work here was amateurish, and looked too cartoony when compared to the rest of the film's grittier style.
How different things could have been, then, if Jared Leto's Joker had been the main antagonist instead. This would've pitted the Squad against a villain who actually matched their abilities, given Leto a more interesting role to work with, kept the film feeling more street-level (something different from the world-destroying bad guys seen in the Justice League movies), and given the Joker a story more closely related to the main plot, instead of the random sideshow he was lumped with in the current version.
Even the film's director thinks Joker should have been the villain, which tells you all you need to know.
6. Not Filmed Justice League Immediately After Batman V Superman's Release
The problem with assuming that your movie will be successful is that it might not be successful, something that Warner Bros. discovered in 2016.
When the studio set Justice League to go before cameras literally two weeks after Batman V Superman's release, they were assuming that the latter film would land with a positive splash, both financially and critically, and with the fans. But it didn't.
That might have been fine if they had plenty of time afterwards to assess the situation and understand what went wrong, but with Justice League about to start shooting in literally a fortnight's time, the whole thing turned into a mad scramble to save it from the same fate BvS just suffered, by altering it while the wheels were already turning.
And in the patchwork finished product, you can almost see this mad scramble popping through onto the screen. The movie had clearly been significantly reshot, tons of footage from the trailers had been axed, and it had flashes of a darker film that just wasn't there.
Imagine how different things could have been if Warner Bros. had waited to see the reaction to BvS before barrelling full-steam ahead with its sequel, without any clue as to what audiences may or may not like, and what may or may not work. Justice League might have been a more coherent movie overall, rather than the reactionary and slapdash product it ended up being.
5. Not Announced All Those Movies So Early
Because it's apparently cool to announce a boatload of franchise films years in advance - even when said franchise is not yet an established success - Warner Bros. decided to announce an extensive comic-book movie slate of its own in late 2014.
Featuring two Justice League movies along with standalone Flash, Cyborg and Green Lantern flicks - on top of the likes of BvS and Suicide Squad - the list spanned from 2016 to 2020, a clear sign that the studio was going all-in with its own cinematic universe plans. Or at least, that was the idea.
Instead, thanks to a variety of factors - the underwhelming response to BvS and Suicide Squad, the inability to lock down filmmakers - four of the ten projects they announced disappeared into the void, and have yet to materialise to this day.
As a result, Warner Bros ended up with egg on its face, a ton of internet bashing, and an army of confused and disappointed fans who weren't (and still aren't) quite sure which movies were happening, and whether or not the DCEU even had a future. Not exactly the environment you want to create.
4. Sorted Out Henry Cavill's Moustache
Henry Cavill's moustache became an internet legend throughout the latter half of 2017, but for all the wrong reasons. Well, the mouth blanket itself looked cool, but the splodgy mess it left behind after being digitally removed from the actor's face was... yikes. Just yikes.
With Cavill prohibited from shaving it off and Justice League's visual effects team pressed for time, the filmmakers had to hastily cover up every single hair present on his face in order to blend the film's reshoots with the previously-shot footage, in which Superman was clean shaven.
You've all seen pictures of it by now, along with the social media reactions, the reaction videos, and the memes, but this wasn't a case where the internet turned a non-issue into an issue: all this commotion really was warranted, because for a $300 million dollar blockbuster, the CGI work here was just bad.
Justice League already had a lot of bad press in the run-up to its release, and "moustache-gate" only caused it to become the butt of even more jokes. The visual effects artists weren't really at fault here, since they simply weren't given enough time to pull off such a complex job, but regardless, Warner Bros., the production crew, and even Cavill himself must have been quite embarrassed at how this one turned out.
3. Not Tried To Replicate The Marvel Formula
When The Avengers shocked the world by becoming the third-highest grossing film of all time during the summer of 2012, it was inevitable that Hollywood would stop, notice, and attempt to replicate that astounding success. Cinematic universes were the new hot thing, and in that, Warner Bros. saw an opportunity.
The following year they released Man Of Steel, which was littered with references to a wider, interconnected DC universe, including nods to LexCorp, Wayne Enterprises, and Supergirl. It was clear that the groundwork for a shared universe was being laid, and sure enough, BvS was officially unveiled at 2013's San Diego Comic-Con.
But the decision to launch headfirst into a cinematic universe of their own didn't exactly work out the way Warner Bros intended. BvS was bogged down by heaps and heaps of heavy-handed universe-building (Wonder Woman being emailed some snazzy Justice League graphics... really?), and this was one of the reasons why the film felt bloated and poorly-paced. The cinematic universe took precedence over a good story.
They've since abandoned this angle for the most part, and funnily enough, when you look at the DCEU today, it's the complete opposite of the MCU. Marvel's most successful movies are their gigantic team-up events like Endgame and Civil War, while DC's most lauded efforts have been Wonder Woman, Aquaman, and Shazam - standalone stories that are basically devoid of universe-building.
Had the DCEU adopted this strategy from day one - y'know, actually focusing on making good movies, rather than building a franchise - maybe it would've been on this current hot streak from the start.
2. Injected More Levity Into Those Earlier Films
Partly thanks to the success of Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy, DC is now viewed as the "dark and gritty" to Marvel's light-hearted fun.
Annoyingly, this perception even seems to exist when the characters themselves might not fit with that tone. We got two films featuring Superman that had the character just moping around for the majority of the runtime, and even Batman had been made darker than he normally was, with Batfleck murdering practically anyone unfortunate enough to be caught in his path.
There's absolutely nothing wrong with grounded and gritty storytelling in superhero movies, but the DCEU's mistake was injecting this tone into the very characters themselves, and not providing enough levity to balance things out. Cavill's Superman in particular has been heavily criticized for his general pessimism and sadness, which Warner Bros responded to by rebooting him into a much more colourful figure in Justice League's third act, garnering a more positive response in the process.
They've also rebooted the tone of their entire operation, with Shazam bordering on a full-on comedy, and Aquaman one of the lighter, brighter superhero movies in recent years. And overall, this reboot has been a huge success.
Both those movies (and Wonder Woman) have a fine blend of action, drama, and laughs, without leaning too heavily in one direction or the other. If the DCEU had done this from the very beginning - instead of turning up the grittiness dial to eleven - maybe the response to those earlier movies would've been much more favourable.
1. Found Their Own Version Of The MCU's Kevin Feige
The overseer of the MCU and a god to superhero film lovers the world over, Kevin Feige has been a producer on everything from Iron Man to Avengers: Endgame, and is the guy who makes all the big decisions over at Marvel Studios.
One of the most impressive things about the empire that he's built is the fact that we never hear about any behind-the-scenes troubles on any MCU films, a feat that the MCU can almost take ownership of within the franchise space. Feige clearly takes the time to choose the correct collaborators, trusts them to do their jobs, and has a carefully thought-out plan. Basically, he's a competent leader with an exciting vision.
Compare this to the DCEU, which, for the majority of its lifecycle, has been a hotbed of bad press, failed projects, and odd creative decisions. Directors come and go more often than Tony Stark upgrades his suit, random movies like Deathstroke and Deadshot are outed and then never heard from again, nobody knew if Ben Affleck was Batman for a good year-and-a-half, and we still don't know if Henry Cavill is still Superman. The DCEU needs a Kevin Feige, and it's needed one for quite some time.
Fortunately, positive steps were made in this direction when Walter Hamada was appointed as DC Films' president in January 2018, and things have definitely been looking up ever since.
But the damage the brand suffered as a result of BvS, Suicide Squad and Justice League - and all the offscreen issues surrounding them - will be tough to wipe out, and a lot of that damage could've been avoided if the early DCEU actually had someone who could confidently steer the ship in the right direction, as opposed to the mosh pit of executives and filmmakers that it was for so many years.
-
What else do you think the DCEU could have done differently? Let us know in the comments section!
Watch Next
DCEU Quiz: How Well Do You Remember Aquaman?